Agent-Based Exploration of Recommendation Systems in Misinformation Propagation

Lise Jakobsen, Anna Johanne Holden Jacobsen, Önder Gürcan, Özlem Özgöbek · 2025

Read Agent-Based Exploration of Recommendation Systems in Misinformation Propagation by Lise Jakobsen, Anna Johanne Holden Jacobsen, Önder Gürcan, Özlem Özgöbek (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-21724.txt.

Introduction

Jakobsen and three co-authors present a study from twenty twenty-five on how feed rules spread false claims online. They built a fake social network in a computer model. Its users include normal people, bots, and big accounts that sway others. The model then ran four ways of picking what each user sees next. One way pushed what is most popular, and one way picked posts at random as a base case.

The popular-first rule spread false claims the most by far. Two rules that match posts to user taste held back false claims better. One of those rules did better than past studies had found. The authors say feed design shapes what false claims reach people. Their model offers a safe way to test rules first.

Catalog record

CREATORLise Jakobsen, Anna Johanne Holden Jacobsen, Önder Gürcan, Özlem Özgöbek
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-21724

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Agent-Based Exploration of Recommendation Systems in Misinformation Propagation Lise Jakobsen, Anna Johanne Holden Jacobsen, Önder Gürcan, Özlem Özgöbek Abstract This study uses agent-based modeling to examine the impact of various recommendation algorithms on the propagation of misinformation on online social networks. We simulate a synthetic environment consisting of heterogeneous agents, including regular users, bots, and influencers, interacting through a social network with recommendation systems. We evaluate four recommendation strategies: popularity-based, collaborative filtering, and content-based filtering, along with a random baseline. Our results show that popularity-driven algorithms significantly amplify misinformation, while item-based collaborative filtering and content-based approaches are more effective in limiting exposure to fake content. Item-based collaborative filtering was found to perform better than previously reported in related literature. These findings highlight the role of algorithm design in shaping online information exposure and show that agent-based modeling can be used to gain realistic insight into how misinformation spreads. 1 Introduction The significant presence of social media today has made it a primary source of information, which has revolutionized the way individuals consume and interact with content and news [ 1 ] . However, this digital transformation has also facilitated the rapid spread of misinformation, a phenomenon with severe implications for public discourse, democracy, and social trust [ 2 ] . Misinformation can alter the balance of authenticity of the news ecosystem, exposing people to equal amounts of true and fake news, making it more difficult for consumers to differentiate which news is trustworthy and which is not [ 3 ] . Misinformation on social media is often propagated by malicious users and bots, both of which play significant roles in amplifying false information [ 4 , 5 ] . Social media platforms are unable to control what users post until these actors have already broken the community guidelines. Misinformation is further shown to be reinforced through social media’s use of recommendation systems [ 6 ] . Even though the platforms can not control the malicious user behavior, they can control how the recommendation algorithms (RAs) curate the user news feeds and therefore have a great influence on what users are exposed to [ 7 ] . Recommendation systems are designed to enhance user experience by personalizing content selection to user preferences. While useful for dealing with content churn and enhancing user experience in social media and news domains, this personalization can inadvertently promote the formation of filter bubbles and echo chambers, where users are repeatedly exposed to similar viewpoints [ 8 ] . Currently, there is limited focus within recommendation systems on identifying, restricting, or correcting misinformation content. The consequences of failing to address the role of RAs in misinformation propagation are prominent [ 6 ] . Beyond the immediate societal harms, such as increased polarization and erosion of trust in institutions, the unchecked spread of misinformation undermines the credibility of digital platforms themselves. As these systems continue to influence public opinion on critical issues, from elections to public health, there is an ethical incentive for researchers to develop solutions that help mitigate the propagation of misinformation in recommendation systems. Looking into how the different RAs affect the flow of misinformation online is therefore important to evaluate new approaches for mitigation. Previous research focusing on the effect of RAs on the spread of misinformation provides a good baseline [ 9 , 6 ] . Our approach differentiates itself with the use of agent-based modeling (ABM), in which we simulate a social network with realistic features and investigate how recommendation systems affect the spread of misinformation on social networks. Based on this observation, in this study, we focus on the extent to which different RAs affect misinformation spread. We also investigate how agent-based modeling can help us gain realistic insight into how misinformation spreads in a social network that employs RAs. The contributions of our study are as follows: • Developed a detailed agent-based model 1 1 1 The source code will be made publicly available if the paper is accepted. that simulates a social network with heterogeneous agents, including regular users, bots, influencers. The model is implemented using Python, the Mesa framework, and the LensKit library for recommender systems - —building on best - practice guidelines for re - implementable ABMs [ 10 ] . • Compared how various recommendation strategies— popularity-based, collaborative filtering, content-based, and random—affect misinformation spread. • Integrated temporal dynamics and feedback loops in the simulation to realistically model evolving misinformation spread and algorithmic influence over time. • Applied evaluation metrics like infection rate, Misinformation Ratio Difference (MRD), and Misinformation Count (MC) to quantify the effects of different algorithms on misinformation dissemination. • Found that item-based collaborative filtering performed better than expected, limiting misinformation spread, contrary to previous studies. The rest of the paper is organized as follows: Section 2 reviews background and related work; Section 3 describes the simulation framework and evaluation metrics; Section 4 presents and analyzes the results; Section 5 discusses implications, prior work, and limitations; and Section 6 concludes with future research directions. 2 Background and Related work 2.1 Agent-Based Modeling (ABM) ABM offers a framework for analyzing the complex interactions between users, algorithms, and information flow on social media platforms [ 7 , 11 ] . Unlike static models, ABM simulates autonomous agents with behaviors that are governed by simple rules, and where interactions give an understanding of complex system-level dynamics. Many agent-based models are based on epidemiological diffusion frameworks, such as the SIR (Susceptible-Infected-Recovered) model, which effectively captures the viral nature of information spread in networks [ 12 ] . Several studies simulate misinformation spread using epidemiological diffusion models such as SIR due to its ability to mimic viral behavior in networks. These models serve as the foundation for more complex agent-based approaches used in recent research [ 13 ] These foundational models are extended in ABM by embedding cognitive, social, and algorithmic components into each agent’s behavior. Agents can be influenced by their preferences, social neighbors, previous experiences, or exposure to content, making ABM particularly suitable for simulating phenomena such as misinformation cascades, opinion shifts, and the emergence of echo chambers. Recent studies have used ABM to investigate how misinformation spreads and how recommendation systems could contribute to or mitigate such spread [ 7 , 14 , 15 ] . In our work, we build on these insights to model not only individual user behavior but also the dynamic feedback loops introduced by different recommendation strategies and evolving network structures. 2.2 Recommendation Algorithms and Misinformation Recommendation systems are technologies designed to suggest relevant content to users based on their preferences, behaviors, or interactions [ 16 ] . The risk of recommendation systems amplifying the spread of misinformation has been highlighted in several studies. Pathak et al. [ 6 ] demonstrated how RAs, particularly those based on popularity and networks, are particularly likely to recommend misleading content. One key concern is the feedback loop between user behavior and the algorithm. If users engage with misinformation, the RAs interpret it as positive feedback and then continue to promote similar content. Over time, this dynamic leads to the emergence of filter bubbles and echo chambers, where users are increasingly exposed to information that confirms their existing beliefs. This was further explored by Lunardi

Read the complete text