Finding Uncommon Ground: A Human-Centered Model for Extrospective Explanations
Laura Spillner, Nima Zargham, Mihai Pomarlan, Robert Porzel, Rainer Malaka · 2025
Read Finding Uncommon Ground: A Human-Centered Model for Extrospective Explanations by Laura Spillner, Nima Zargham, Mihai Pomarlan, Robert Porzel, Rainer Malaka (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-21571.txt.
Introduction
Laura Spillner and co-authors present a 2025 paper on a human-centred way for AI systems to explain themselves. Most explanations expose a model's inner workings, which suits engineers but not everyday users. What a person needs depends on who they are, what they already know, and the moment they are in.
Their model gives the agent a worldview that doubles as a living memory of past talks with the same user. From that memory the agent judges which facts are likely to matter and which are already common ground. The title's twist is the point: good explanation finds the uncommon ground, the part the user does not yet share.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Laura Spillner, Nima Zargham, Mihai Pomarlan, Robert Porzel, Rainer Malaka |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-21571
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Finding Uncommon Ground: A Human-Centered Model for Extrospective Explanations Laura Spillner, Nima Zargham, Mihai Pomarlan, Robert Porzel, Rainer Malaka Abstract The need for explanations in AI has, by and large, been driven by the desire to increase the transparency of black-box machine learning models. However, such explanations, which focus on the internal mechanisms that lead to a specific output, are often unsuitable for non-experts. To facilitate a human-centered perspective on AI explanations, agents need to focus on individuals and their preferences as well as the context in which the explanations are given. This paper proposes a personalized approach to explanation, where the agent tailors the information provided to the user based on what is most likely pertinent to them. We propose a model of the agent’s worldview that also serves as a personal and dynamic memory of its previous interactions with the same user, based on which the artificial agent can estimate what part of its knowledge is most likely new information to the user. Figure 1: In domains such as household robotics, human users interact with AI agents repeatedly over time. When the two disagree, helpful and succinct explanations of the AI’s behavior should be tailored to the user based on its memory of their previous interactions. 1 Introduction One major motivation of explainable artificial intelligence (XAI) is the desire to make the predictions of black-box machine learning (ML) models more transparent Barredo Arrieta et al. 2020 . Adadi and Berrada conducted a survey of the XAI literature and created an overview of common XAI methods - all of the methods presented range over the internal mechanisms of a ML model Adadi and Berrada 2018 , which we will refer to as introspective explanations. More recently, there has been an increasing need to explain AI behavior to non-expert users of AI systems. Therefore it has been proposed that XAI needs to focus more on end-users as the recipients of the explanations Xu 2019 ; Liao et al. 2020 and on how XAI methods can be evaluated from a human-centered point of view Norkute 2020 . This sheds a different light on estimating the quality of an explanation and how it can be tailored adequately to the given user. This view is supported by the argument made by several researchers in the field that explanation should be understood as interactive conversations Miller et al. 2017 ; Feldhus et al. 2022 . The usefulness of explanations can depend on the context in which they are given, including the situation and the user, as pointed out in several recent studies Conati et al. 2022 ; Graefe et al. 2022 ; Norkute 2020 . To foster a human-centered approach to XAI, individuals and their preferences should be considered by appropriate user models. These can encompass, e.g., a level of education, cultural background, familiarity and interest in technology, perception of the agent, mood, and social settings Zargham et al. 2022b . To accommodate these factors, personalization of AI explanations might be crucial Conati et al. 2022 ; Graefe et al. 2022 . This is particularly relevant in domains where users interact with the same artificial agent over a long period, such as smart home devices, robots in household and care domains, and other personal AI applications. If users ask for explanations because they expected different AI behavior, there must be some disagreement between users and AI in their respective beliefs and knowledge, which is what we call their uncommon ground . Explanations should allow the user to realize where the uncommon ground is. In error cases, this can empower users to correct the AI’s behavior for future interactions; in other situations, it can enable them to see that they are missing important knowledge themselves. To facilitate this, explanations by the AI should reflect its experience from previous interactions with the same user. Personalization can improve user satisfaction Wolters et al. 2009 ; Zargham et al. 2022a by using user models created with direct or indirect user input, i.e., user entry or automated systems that adapt to user behavior Mobasher et al. 2000 . Although direct user inputs can have advantages, an agent that is not properly configured may be less acceptable Braun et al. 2019 , thus personalization through indirect adaptation might be preferential Zimmermann et al. 2005 . We argue that it is thus necessary to consider how to generate extrospective explanations: explanations that are given with respect not only to the system itself but also take into account what the system knows about the user’s expectations and draw on experience from earlier interactions. This extrospective perspective on XAI is at the heart of our work, as we focus on domains where users interact with smart software, intelligent devices, and autonomous agents/robots repeatedly over time, e.g., smart home device [citation redacted] and household robotics [citation redacted]. This, in a sense, entails that users have their ‘own’ personalized AI. As Alizadeh et al. point out, explanations in the context of repeated interactions have not been studied as much Alizadeh and Pins 2022 . Therefore, we seek to examine this challenging problem systematically. 2 Explanations in Context To evaluate explanations, it makes sense first to consider why there is a need for an explanation from the user’s side. We argue that in domains such as household robotics, where non-expert users commonly interact with AI systems that they generally trust, if a user asks for an explanation in a specific situation, this will likely be because the AI’s behavior or recommendation differed from the user’s expectation - meaning the need for explanation is motivated by the user’s surprise . The XAI literature commonly differentiates between global and local explanations: Global explanations aim to make the overall workings of a (black-box) AI model transparent Adadi and Berrada 2018 ; Barredo Arrieta et al. 2020 , e.g., through global feature importance or approximation. Here the question is about “how” the model works Liao et al. 2020 . Local explanations try to explain a specific instance of model prediction or agent behavior Adadi and Berrada 2018 ; Barredo Arrieta et al. 2020 , e.g., through local feature importance or salience. Here the question is about “why” the model arrived at this prediction Liao et al. 2020 . Global explanations are independent of any particular prediction. Regarding local explanations, we can further categorize explanation requests based on whether or not the user expected a different AI prediction. When users ask for a local explanation for one specific prediction, often the reason is that they expected a different outcome in this instance. Liao et al. surveyed AI practitioners and developed a taxonomy of questions that users ask of XAI systems Liao et al. 2020 . They identified several situations and goals, ranging from users wanting to increase their confidence in their own decision to trying to debug or improve the AI system. Both global and local explanations can be useful in cases where one wants to better understand how a model works, what its prediction is based on, or make its workings transparent for ethical purposes. This is often the goal of researchers or developers but was also a common need by other practitioners surveyed by Liao et al. However, as