Tightness of Chekanov’s bound on displacement energy for some Lagrangian knots

David Keren Yaar · 2025

Read Tightness of Chekanov’s bound on displacement energy for some Lagrangian knots by David Keren Yaar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-21282.txt.

Introduction

How much push it takes to move a shape inside a space, without stretching it, is a deep measure in geometry. A classic theorem ties that cost to the size of the smallest disk the shape can bound. David Keren Yaar tests whether that classic bound is sharp, in a 2025 paper. He works with two families of donut-like shapes that sit in special balanced positions.

For both families, the push cost and the least disk area come out exactly equal, so the bound cannot be tightened there. Comparing how the two numbers behave as shapes vary also yields a case where the cost stands strictly above the bound. As a bonus, the math gives a fresh proof that one family holds endless truly distinct shapes, a fact earlier shown by other means.

Catalog record

CREATORDavid Keren Yaar
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-21282

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Tightness of Chekanov’s bound on displacement energy for some Lagrangian knots David Keren Yaar Abstract By a classical theorem of Chekanov, the displacement energy, e e , of a Lagrangian submanifold is bounded from below by the minimal area of pseudo-holomorphic disks with boundary on the Lagrangian, ℏ \hbar . We compute e e and ℏ \hbar for displaceable Chekanov tori in ℂ ​ P n \mathbb{C}P^{n} , and for an infinite family of exotic tori in ℂ 3 \mathbb{C}^{3} constructed by Brendel. In these families, e = ℏ e=\hbar . We compare continuity properties of e e and ℏ \hbar on the space of Lagrangians. This provides an example (suggested by Fukaya, Oh, Ohta, and Ono) where e > ℏ e>\hbar . Our calculations have further applications such as a new proof, inspired by work of Auroux, that Brendel’s family of exotic tori consists of infinitely many distinct Lagrangians. 1 1 footnotetext: Mathematics Subject Classification (2020). 53D12; 53D20. 1 1 footnotetext: Keywords. Displacement energy, J -holomorphic disks, Lagrangian tori, Chekanov torus. 1 Introduction Let (M,\omega) be a symplectic manifold and L\subset M be a closed embedded Lagrangian submanifold. In the present note, we compare the following two fundamental notions in symplectic geometry, which quantify the size of L , through concrete examples. The first notion is Hofer’s displacement energy. Denote the Hofer norm by \lVert H\rVert\coloneqq\int_{0}^{1}\max_{M}H_{t}-\min_{M}H_{t}dt where H\colon[0,1]\times M\to\mathbb{R} is a normalized Hamiltonian. We denote by \phi^{H}_{1} the time-one map of the Hamiltonian flow. We refer to [ Pol01 ] for details. Definition 1 . The displacement energy of L is given by e(L)\coloneqq\inf\left\{{\lVert H\rVert}\,\middle|\,{\phi^{H}_{1}(L)\cap L=\emptyset}\right\}. In case no Hamiltonian displaces L from itself and e(L)=\infty , L is called non-displaceable . From now on, we assume that M is geometrically bounded in the sense of [ Che98 ] . The second notion we consider is the minimal symplectic area of a pseudo-holomorphic disk with boundary on L , as introduced by Chekanov in [ Che98 ] . Definition 2 . Denote by \mathcal{J}_{\omega} the space of \omega -tame almost complex structures. Set {\hbar_{D}}(L,J)\coloneqq\inf\left\{{\int_{D}u^{*}\omega}\,\middle|\,{u\colon(B^{2},\partial B)\to(M,L)\text{, non-const. $J$-holo.}}\right\}, and {\hbar_{D}}(L)\coloneqq\sup_{J\in\mathcal{J}_{\omega}}{\hbar_{D}}(L,J). (1) Define \hbar_{S}(M)>0 similarly with areas of pseudo-holomorphic spheres in M instead of disks. Define \hbar(L)\coloneqq\min\{{\hbar_{D}}(L),\hbar_{S}(M)\} . As a warm-up, we consider e and \hbar as functions on the space of closed Lagrangians of M , endowed with the C^{\infty} topology. In Section 2 , we prove opposed semi-continuity properties for both invariants. For instance, our calculations make use of the lower semi-continuity of \hbar , see Proposition 2.2 . Chekanov’s work [ Che98 ] used ideas from Lagrangian intersection Floer theory to prove the following inequality, referred to as Chekanov’s bound on displacement energy in the title, \hbar(L)\leq e(L). (2) We observe that in many elementary examples, either • L is non-displaceable, in which case ( 2 ) is obvious, or • \hbar(L)=e(L) . Examples exhibiting one of the two options include many toric fibers and the simplest Lagrangian knot 1 1 1 Also called an exotic torus, a Lagrangian knot is a Lagrangian torus that is not symplectomorphic to a standard torus (the product torus in \mathbb{C}^{n} or, more generally, a regular toric fiber in a toric symplectic manifold). , which is the well-known monotone Chekanov torus. For instance, a product torus T(a)\coloneqq\bigtimes_{i}S^{1}(a_{i})\subset\mathbb{C}^{n} has \hbar(T(a))=e(T(a))=\min_{i}a_{i}\eqqcolon\underline{a}. Here, S^{1}(b)\coloneqq\partial B^{2}(b) , where B^{2n}(\pi r^{2})\subset\mathbb{C}^{n} is the closed ball with radius r>0 . On the other hand, the Clifford torus in complex projective space \mathbb{C}P^{n} is non-displaceable. The following proposition gives a sufficient condition for a Lagrangian torus to have e=\hbar . Definition 3 . A Lagrangian torus L\subset M^{2n} has property (CS) if there is a Darboux chart \varphi\colon B^{2n}(A)\to M with L=\varphi(T(a)) such that \underline{a}+\sum_{i}a_{i}<A and \underline{a}<\lambda_{S}(\varphi)\coloneqq\sup\left\{{\hbar_{S}(M,J)}\,\middle|\,{J\in\mathcal{J}_{\omega},\,J|_{\operatorname{im}\varphi}=\varphi_{*}J_{0}}\right\}. Proposition ( [ CS16 , Proposition 2.1] , [ Bre25 , Proposition 1.14] ) . If L=\varphi(T(a))\subset M is a Lagrangian torus with property (CS), then \hbar(L)=e(L)=\underline{a}. In light of Chekanov’s bound ( 2 ) and the proposition above, it is natural to ask the following question. Question 1 . Is there a closed Lagrangian L such that \hbar(L)<e(L)<\infty? Property (CS) was interpreted in [ Bre25 , Remark 1.20] as characterizing standard tori in (not necessarily toric) symplectic manifolds. Thus, exotic Lagrangian tori are natural candidates to examine in relation to Question 1 . The zoo of Lagrangian tori. Both families of Lagrangians we consider are based on the Chekanov torus. Thus, we start with a brief review of the construction of Chekanov torus in \mathbb{C}^{2} via symplectic reduction, see also [ EP97 , CS10 , Bre22 ] . Recall the standard toric moment map \mu(z_{1},z_{2})=(\pi\lvert z_{1}\rvert^{2},\pi\lvert z_{2}\rvert^{2}) of \mathbb{C}^{2} , having (\mathbb{R}_{\geq 0})^{2} as its image. The autonomous Hamiltonian given by \mathcal{C}\coloneqq\mu_{1}-\mu_{2} , generates the 1 -periodic Hamiltonian flow t\in\mathbb{R},\quad(z_{1},z_{2})\mapsto(e^{2\pi it}z_{1},e^{-2\pi it}z_{2}). We obtain a Hamiltonian S^{1} -action on \mathbb{C}^{2} having the origin as its single fixed point. The level set \mathcal{C}^{-1}(0)=\{\lvert z_{1}\rvert=\lvert z_{2}\rvert\} is invariant under this S^{1} -action. After removing the origin and taking the quotient of this action, we obtain a reduced space symplectomorphic to the standard punctured plane \mathbb{C}^{*}\coloneqq\mathbb{C}\setminus\{0\} . Let a>0 . While the product torus T(a,a)\subset\{\lvert z_{1}\rvert=\lvert z_{2}\rvert\neq 0\} projects to the circle S^{1}(a)\subset\mathbb{C}^{*} , the Chekanov torus T^{2}_{\text{Ch}}(a)\subset\mathbb{C}^{2} is obtained by lifting a null-homotopic curve bounding area a in \mathbb{C}^{*} . The Chekanov torus is a monotone Lagrangian knot that first appeared in [ Che96 ] . \mu(\mathcal{C}^{-1}(0)) Figure 1 : The segment is the image of T^{2}_{\text{Ch}} under \mu in (\mathbb{R}_{\geq 0})^{2} . Chekanov tori in \mathbb{C}P^{n} . Let n\geq 2 . The Chekanov torus has a straightforward generalization to higher dimensions, given for example in [ Bre23 ] . Denote the standard toric moment map by \mu\colon\mathbb{C}^{n}\to(\mathbb{R}_{\geq 0})^{n} . Then the moment map \mathcal{C}=(\mu_{1}-\mu_{2},\dotsc,\mu_{1}-\mu_{n})\colon\mathbb{C}^{n}\to\mathbb{R}^{n-1} (3) generates a T^{n-1} -action on \mathbb{C}^{n} . Again, performing symplectic reduction on \mathcal{C}^{-1}(\vec{0})\setminus\{0\} , gives a punctured plane. Lift a contractible curve enclosing area a>0 in the punctured plane, to obtain a monotone Lagrangian knot T^{n}_{\text{Ch}}(a)\subset\mathbb{C}^{n} . Chekanov tori can be embedded into closed symplectic manifolds by Darboux charts. In favorable situations, this gives rise to a family, parameterized by small enough a , of Lagrangian knots, only one of which is monotone. For instance, Chekanov tori in S^{2}\times S^{2} are a primary subject of interest. They appear in a one-parameter family consisting of • a non-displaceable monotone member [ CS10 , OU16 ] , • a one-parameter subfamily of non-displaceable non-monotone members [ FOOO12 ] , and • another one-parameter subfamily of displaceable non-monotone members [ Lou24 ] . Figure 2 : A one-parameter family consisting of non-displaceable members on the left and displaceable members on the right. The dot corresponds to the monotone member. For a<\frac{\pi}{n} , one can fit T^{n}_{\text{Ch}}(a) into B^{2n}(\pi) . We work with the Fubini-Study symplectic form \omega_{\text{FS}} on \mathbb{C}P^{n} , scaled such that \int_{\mathbb{C}P^{1}}\omega_{\text{FS}}=\pi . Let \varphi\colon B^{2n}(\pi)\to\mathbb{C}P^{n} be the Darboux chart to the complement of a hyperplane in the complex projective space. Define T^{n}_{\text{PrCh}}(a)\coloneqq\varphi(T^{n}_{\text{Ch}}(a))\subset\mathbb{C}P^{n}. The Lagrangian T^{n}_{\text{PrCh}}(a) is monotone only for a=\frac{\pi}{n+1} . We show that it is displaceable for 0<a<\frac{\pi}{n+1} , see Proposition 3.2 . We call the displaceable ones small Chekanov tori . Note that monotone Chekanov tori in a broader class of compact toric symplectic manifolds

Read the complete text