Extremal AdS Black Holes as Fluids: A Matrix Large-Charge EFT Approach

Eunwoo Lee · 2025

Read Extremal AdS Black Holes as Fluids: A Matrix Large-Charge EFT Approach by Eunwoo Lee (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-21240.txt.

Introduction

Eunwoo Lee recast the physics of near-frozen, spinning black holes in 2025 as the flow of an unusual fluid, using a matrix version of a large-charge theory. Extremal black holes in anti-de Sitter space sit at zero temperature with huge charge. The large-charge approach treats such states with an effective field theory; Lee's step promotes its scalar field to a matrix, multiplying the light modes enormously.

A mean-field solution then gives rigidly rotating fluid states, solved from self-consistency equations. Their energy, spin, and charge densities match exactly the thermodynamics and surface stress of a zero-temperature conformal fluid, in the comparison reported. A mode count explains the large entropy, and the fluid picture maps onto the black hole by the fluid-gravity link. Comments extend to supersymmetric holes outside the usual fluid regime. Readers get a dictionary: black hole weather, written as fluid flow.

Catalog record

CREATOREunwoo Lee
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-21240

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Extremal AdS Black Holes as Fluids: A Matrix Large-Charge EFT Approach Eunwoo Lee Abstract We develop a simple, yet powerful, matrix-valued large‑charge EFT that captures the thermodynamic behavior of rotating extremal large-charge AdS black holes. We introduce a minimal “matrix EFT” by promoting the complex scalar in large charge EFT to a complex N × N N\times N adjoint scalar, whose 𝒪 ⁡ ( N 2 ) \mathcal{O}(N^{2}) modes contribute at zero temperature. Employing a mean‑field approximation, we solve the self‑consistency equations and obtain explicit rigidly rotating fluid solutions. We demonstrate that their energy, angular momenta, and charge densities exactly reproduce the thermodynamics and boundary stress tensor of zero‑temperature conformal fluids. A microscopic mode‑counting further accounts for the 𝒪 ⁡ ( N 2 ) \mathcal{O}(N^{2}) entropy. Via the fluid/gravity correspondence, this fluid describes an extremal AdS black hole in large charge limit. We also comment on supersymmetric BPS black holes, which fall outside the usual hydrodynamic regime but nevertheless exhibit simple, universal behavior in the large angular momentum limit. In this regime, their non-linear charge–spin relations simplify to form reminiscent of our extremal fluid solutions at large angular momentum limit. 1 Introduction Large black holes in AdS exhibit universal thermodynamic behavior. This universality can be effectively described by conformal fluid dynamics on the boundary of AdS spacetime (see, e.g., Policastro:2002se ; Janik:2005zt ; Son:2007vk ; Bhattacharyya:2007vjd ; Hubeny:2011hd and references therein). In particular, the authors of Bhattacharyya:2007vs demonstrated that large rotating AdS black holes can be mapped to stationary solutions of relativistic conformal fluid dynamics on the boundary sphere. The stationary configuration corresponds to a rigidly rotating conformal fluid, and that both the thermodynamic properties and the boundary stress-energy tensor of the black holes are accurately captured by the behavior of this fluid solution. Quite remarkably, this fluid/gravity correspondence holds not only for finite temperature black holes but also extends to certain extremal, non-supersymmetric configurations if a black hole carries large charge Q . On the other hand, the large charge effective field theory (EFT) provides a systematic low-energy description of CFTs in sectors of fixed, large global charge Q Hellerman:2015nra ; Alvarez-Gaume:2016vff ; Loukas:2016ckj ; Loukas:2017lof ; Hellerman:2017efx ; Hellerman:2017veg ; Hellerman:2017sur ; Monin:2016jmo ; Jafferis:2017zna ; Bourget:2018obm ; Hellerman:2018xpi ; Cuomo:2019ejv ; Badel:2019khk ; Cuomo:2022kio ; Cuomo:2023mxg ; Badel:2022fya ; Dondi:2024vua ; Choi:2025tql ; Watanabe:2025mnc . In this framework, the Goldstone mode of the spontaneously broken global symmetry dominates the low-energy dynamics, and the effective action is organized as a controlled expansion in inverse powers of Q . The large charge EFT successfully captures the ground state structure, energy spectrum, and correlation functions within this fixed-charge sector. The Wilsonian effective action describing the sector of a conformal field theory on S^{d-1}\times\mathbb{R} with large fixed U(1) charge Q can be written, to leading order, as \displaystyle\mathcal{L}=c|\partial\chi|^{d}+\text{subleading}, (1) where \chi is the Goldstone mode associated with the spontaneously broken global U(1) symmetry, and c is a dimensionless constant. Alternatively, this EFT can be equivalently formulated as a linear sigma model with the following Wilsonian action: \displaystyle\mathcal{L}=-\partial^{\mu}\varphi\partial_{\mu}\varphi^{*}-m_{d}^{2}\varphi\varphi^{*}-\lambda|\varphi|^{2d/(d-2)}+\text{subleading}, (2) where \varphi is a complex scalar field charged under the global U(1) symmetry and m_{d} is the conformal mass in d dimension. At leading order, both descriptions are equivalent. This can be seen by parameterizing \varphi=v\,e^{i\chi} and integrating out the radial mode v . Substituting this back into the action yields the nonlinear Goldstone action ( 1 ), up to corrections suppressed in the large-charge expansion Hellerman:2015nra . Recent studies have shown that the ground state of the EFT ( 1 ) at large charge Q and large angular momentum J , in the regime 1\ll Q\ll J\ll Q^{(d-1)/(d-2)} , is well-approximated by a rigidly rotating fluid configuration Cuomo:2017vzg ; Cuomo:2019ejv ; Choi:2025tql . In this limit, the stress-energy tensor takes the same functional form as that of a zero-temperature conformal fluid undergoing rigid rotation Choi:2025tql . 1 1 1 We note that the stationary fluid description for extremal black holes is also valid only in 1\ll Q\ll J\ll Q^{(d-1)/(d-2)} . For J\lesssim Q , rigid rotation is not the relevant configuration. For instance, when J\lesssim Q^{1/(d-1)} , the dynamics is dominated by low-energy phonon excitations on top of a homogeneous superfluid background. Also, the fluid solution cannot reach J\gtrsim Q^{(d-1)/(d-2)} . We elaborate on this correspondence in Section 2 . This fluid-like behavior in the large-charge sector naturally raises several questions. • Does there exist a universal hydrodynamic description applicable to the large-charge regime of conformal field theories? • Is there a deeper correspondence between the large-charge ground state and the fluid dynamics of large-charge AdS extremal black holes? • In particular, can extremal AdS black holes be understood as rigidly rotating, zero-temperature fluids that are dual to the ground states of large-charge effective field theories? In a related context, the authors of Loukas:2018zjh proposed a tentative correspondence, which they referred to as the AdS/EFT correspondence. They suggested that the ground state of the large-charge EFT at large Q may provide an effective description of extremal Reissner–Nordström black holes in AdS. Nevertheless, the correspondence has not been understood completely because it is believed that the superfluid ground state described by the large charge EFT seems to be nearly unique, representing a low-entropy configuration dominated by a single macroscopic condensate. In contrast, the extremal AdS black hole, even at zero temperature, possesses a macroscopic degeneracy with an entropy that scales as \mathcal{O}(N^{2}) . Namely, the EFT action itself does not encode large numbers of microscopic degrees of freedom necessary to account for the vast entropy of the black hole. The large charge EFT does provide a description of the energy and stress tensor but does not capture the full microstate structure responsible for the black hole’s entropy. In this paper, we propose that extremal AdS black holes can be understood as large-charge ground states of a “matrix” version of the large charge EFT, where \mathcal{O}(N^{2}) number of nearly degenerate modes are condensed. 2 2 2 Here, we are considering the classically extremal black hole. We are not taking into account quantum effects such as those governed by the Schwarzian mode Iliesiu:2020qvm . Therefore entropy remains finite and nonvanishing at the zero temperature. We comment on this briefly in 3.3.1 . As a concrete example, we introduce a simple—but sufficiently general—extension of the large‑charge EFT by promoting the original U(1) ‑charged complex scalar to a complex N\times N adjoint matrix. In d=4 , our model is governed by the Lagrangian \displaystyle\mathcal{L}\;=\;-\Tr\Bigl(\partial^{\mu}X\,\partial_{\mu}\bar{X}+m_{4}^{2}\,X\bar{X}\Bigr)-V_{4}(X,\bar{X})\,, (3) where X(\bar{X})=\Phi_{1}\pm i\Phi_{2} , with \Phi_{1} and \Phi_{2} being N\times N Hermitian matrices. A potential V_{4}(X,\bar{X}) is chosen to be quartic in X,\bar{X} , such as V_{4}\sim\lambda\,\Tr\bigl(X\bar{X}X\bar{X}\bigr)~\text{or}~\lambda\,\bigl[\Tr(X\bar X)\bigr]^{2}, so as to preserve classical conformal invariance and the global U(1)\times SU(N) symmetry. Although SU(N) appears here as a global symmetry, one may weakly gauge it to project onto SU(N) singlet states without affecting the large‑charge, large‑spin dynamics. We return to this point in Section 3 . In this paper, we analyze ( 3 ) whose equation of motion is \!(-\partial_{t}^{2}+\nabla^{2})X=\frac{\partial V}{\partial\bar{X}} . We employ a self‑consistent mean-field approximation, \frac{\partial V}{\partial\bar{X}}\approx CX , reducing the equation of motion to the linear form (-\partial_{t}^{2}+\nabla^{2})X=CX . If we impose J_{1}=J_{2} for simplicity, the SO(4) symmetry ensures

Read the complete text