Empathy in Explanation
Katherine M. Collins [email protected], Kartik Chandra [email protected], Adrian Weller [email protected], Jonathan Ragan-Kelley [email protected], Joshua B. Tenenbaum [email protected] · 2025
Read Empathy in Explanation by Katherine M. Collins [email protected], Kartik Chandra [email protected], Adrian Weller [email protected], Jonathan Ragan-Kelley [email protected], Joshua B. Tenenbaum [email protected] (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-21081.txt.
Introduction
Katherine Collins and co-authors model empathy inside explanations in a 2025 paper. Explaining is a social act: a questioner asks why, and an explainer answers with the listener in mind. Emotion, they argue, shapes which true answer a good explainer chooses.
Their computational framework lets a simulated explainer weigh a listener's feelings, especially regret, when framing a cause. Tested on how a doctor might explain a diagnosis, the model matched human intuitions about tactful explanations. Stripping the emotion away made predictions worse. The result suggests people really do reason about feelings when they explain, and machines that explain should too.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Katherine M. Collins [email protected], Kartik Chandra [email protected], Adrian Weller [email protected], Jonathan Ragan-Kelley [email protected], Joshua B. Tenenbaum [email protected] |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-21081
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Empathy in Explanation Katherine M. Collins [email protected], Kartik Chandra [email protected], Adrian Weller [email protected], Jonathan Ragan-Kelley [email protected], Joshua B. Tenenbaum [email protected] Abstract Why do we give the explanations we do? Recent work has suggested that we should think of explanation as a kind of cooperative social interaction, between a why-question-asker and an explainer. Here, we apply this perspective to consider the role that emotion plays in this social interaction. We develop a computational framework for modeling explainers who consider the emotional impact an explanation might have on a listener. We test our framework by using it to model human intuitions about how a doctor might explain to a patient why they have a disease, taking into account the patient’s propensity for regret. Our model predicts human intuitions well, better than emotion-agnostic ablations, suggesting that people do indeed reason about emotion when giving explanations. Introduction Why do we answer “why” questions the way we do? A long line of work on explanation (see Lombrozo (2006) ; Lombrozo (2012) ; Miller (2019) , for reviews) has shown that good explanations are contrastive ( Lipton (1990) ; Riveiro & Thill (2021) ) , selective ( Lombrozo (2007) ; Gerstenberg & Icard (2020) ; Poesia Reis e Silva & Goodman (2022) ) , and causal ( Josephson & Josephson (1996) ; Hilton (1996) ; McClure (2002) ) in nature. However, recent work has argued that explanations are also social in nature: our intuitions about explanation are contextual, depending on the mental states of both the explainer and the listener ( Harding et al. (2025) ) . For example, Kirfel et al. (2024) show that explanations are sensitive to the explainer’s assessment of the listener’s goals: good explanations help the listener make good interventions. Similarly, Chandra, Chen et al. (2024) show that explanations are sensitive to the explainer’s assessment of the listener’s beliefs: good explanations infer and address the misconceptions that led to the “why?” question in the first place. In this paper, we extend this argument by studying another type of mental state that may be relevant to the social dynamics of explanation: emotions . Explanations can create a wide variety of affective reactions, because many emotion concepts are closely related to notions of causality. For example, an explanation that attributes causal responsibility to a listener’s actions can cause that listener to feel regret, guilt, or pride—while an alternate explanation that absolves the listener from responsibility might cause that listener to feel relief instead. Hence, if explanations are indeed subject to the principles of cooperative social interaction, we should expect cooperative explainers to take the listener’s emotional response into account when crafting an explanation. In this paper, we test this prediction by studying human intuitions about explanation in an emotionally-charged doctor-patient communication setting. In our experiment, a patient with a terminal disease asks their doctor what caused the disease. Participants in our experiment are tasked with playing the role of the doctor and giving an explanation. Specifically, they choose whether to communicate that the disease was caused by the patient’s lifestyle choices (e.g. excessive drinking), an external factor beyond their control (e.g. a virus), or both. We asked whether participants would expect the doctor to adjust their explanation to minimize the extent to which the patient regrets their past actions. We modeled participants’ judgments on this task using a variety of computational models, which instantiate competing hypotheses about what role (if any) emotion may play in explanation. We built on Chandra, Chen et al. (2024) ’s framework for modeling explanation as a type of rational communication that follows Gricean maxims ( Grice (1975) ; Sumers et al. (2023) ; Frank & Goodman (2012) ; Goodman & Frank (2016) ) , extending their framework to account for the emotional impact an explanation might have on the listener. Specifically, we introduced a new emotion-sensitive term in the explainer’s utility function, which is grounded in recent work on Bayesian models of emotion appraisal ( Houlihan et al. (2023) ) and intervention ( Chen et al. (2024) ) . In the population we studied, we found an even split between participants who considered the patient’s regret when giving explanations, and participants who preferred to be forthcoming with all information. Our regret-sensitive model predicted both subgroups’ intuitions well ( r^{2}=0.87 and r^{2}=0.97 , respectively). Critically, for the former subgroup, our model was more predictive than an alternate model that ablated the regret term ( r^{2}=0.58 ), suggesting that some people indeed take emotion into consideration when giving explanations. Review of computational framework Our computational framework extends Chandra, Chen et al. (2024) ’s framework of explanation as rational communication. Under this framework, an explainer (Alice) can be modeled as inferring and intervening on the question-asker’s (Bob’s) mental model of the situation at hand. Concretely, this framework assumes that the question-asker asks a “why?” question when faced with an event e that leads to an expectation violation under Bob’s current mental model of the world, i.e. when Pr(e\mid m_{\text{asker}})\ll 1 under mental model m_{\text{asker}} . The explainer infers m_{\text{asker}} from the question asked, and then chooses an explanation u (“utterance”) among a space of candidate explanations by softmax over Alice’s utility V : that is, \Pr(u)\propto\exp(\beta\cdot V(u)) . The explainer’s utility V is decomposed into two key terms: 1. An understanding term , which measures the degree to which the question-asker’s expectation violation would be resolved by updating Bob’s mental model according to the information in u , i.e. \Pr(e\mid\text{update}(m_{\text{asker}},u)) . If this probability is high, then Bob’s expectation-violation has been resolved. 2. A social term , which measures additional social considerations that may be in play during an explanation-interaction. For the social term, Chandra, Chen et al. (2024) specifically considered the phenomenon of “mansplaining”: offering redundant or obvious information in an explanation could embarrass the question-asker by implying that the explainer Alice thinks that the question-asker Bob is ignorant. Here, we generalize the social term to more broadly consider the role of the question-asker Bob’s affective response to the explainer Alice’s explanation. We model possible emotional costs in terms of appraisal variables ( Moors (2014) ; Frijda (1986) ; Houlihan et al. (2023) ; Lazarus (1991) ) , which are computed with respect to the question-asker Bob’s updated mental model upon hearing the explanation u . In the next section, we show how this framework can be applied in the setting of our experiment, in order to model how explainers take the emotion of regret into account when giving explanations. Experiment Setting Figure 1: Schematic representation of our experimental paradigm. A disease is caused by two possible factors. The doctor knows the patient’s test results and temperament, and decides what information to communicate in the explanation. To study the role of emotion in explanation, we considered a domain where both informativity and emotional response are at stake in explanation: medical communication. In our experiments, a doctor explains to a patient why they have a disease (Figure 1 ). We considered fatal diseases with two potential causes: • A virus , which patients have no control over contracting, and whose presence can only be detected by a blood test conducted by a doctor. • Excessive alcohol consumption in youth, which patients did