Approximate solutions to the shrinking core model and their interpretation
Cristian Moreno-Pulido, Rachael Olwande, Tim Myers, Francesc Font · 2025
Read Approximate solutions to the shrinking core model and their interpretation by Cristian Moreno-Pulido, Rachael Olwande, Tim Myers, Francesc Font (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-21042.txt.
Introduction
Cristian Moreno-Pulido and co-authors revisit, in twenty twenty-five, the shrinking core model of a solid particle reacting with a surrounding fluid. The model tracks a shrinking unreacted core as reaction eats inward. They re-derive it from the underlying physics and scale it carefully. That exposes limits of the common pseudo-steady-state shortcut, above all when fluid and solid densities are close, as in liquid-solid systems. A perturbation method then yields better approximate solutions. A small-time solution captures early transient behavior.
A semi-implicit numerical scheme solves the full model to benchmark the approximations. The perturbation solution is much more accurate than the shortcut, especially when diffusion limits the rate. They also give a cheap fitting recipe that merges both approximations to estimate physical parameters from data.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cristian Moreno-Pulido, Rachael Olwande, Tim Myers, Francesc Font |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-21042
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Approximate solutions to the shrinking core model and their interpretation Cristian Moreno-Pulido, Rachael Olwande, Tim Myers, Francesc Font Abstract The shrinking core model (SCM) describes the reaction of a solid particle with a surrounding fluid. In this work, we revisit the SCM by deriving it from the underlying physical processes and performing a careful non-dimensionalisation, which highlights the limitations of the commonly used pseudo-steady-state approximation, particularly in liquid-solid systems where fluid and solid densities are comparable. To address these limitations, we derive approximate analytical solutions using a perturbation method that improves upon the pseudo-steady-state model. We also obtain a small-time solution capturing early transient behaviour. A semi-implicit finite difference scheme is implemented to solve the full model numerically and benchmark the analytical approximations. We demonstrate that the perturbation solution provides significantly improved accuracy over the pseudo-steady-state model, especially in diffusion-limited regimes. Finally, we propose a simple fitting procedure combining the perturbation with the early-time solutions to estimate physical parameters from experimental data at minimal computational cost. 1 Introduction The shrinking core model (SCM) is an idealised mathematical model developed to describe the reaction between a solid particle and a surrounding reactant fluid. The reaction occurs at a sharp interface that moves inward into the solid interior as the fluid diffuses through the growing, inert, porous, product layer. It is a classic model that has been applied to a multitude of physical problems, including: oxidation [ 1 ] , corrosion [ 2 ] , mineral leaching [ 3 ] , anaerobic digestion [ 4 ] , combustion [ 5 ] , dehydration [ 6 ] , hydrolysis [ 7 ] , catalyst regeneration [ 8 ] , smelting [ 9 ] , glass fiber diffusion [ 10 ] , in the capture of environmental contaminants and calcination (for example through batch adsorption [ 11 ] ). The present study is motivated by analysis of hydrogen storage in metal hydrides [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 ] , however, in the following we leave the analysis general such that it may describe liquid or gas interactions with a solid core. Mathematical modelling of the SCM is generally based on the pseudo-steady state (PSS) approximation. The physical basis for the PSS is that the conversion process is much slower than the diffusion of mass to the reaction front. Mathematically this permits the neglect of the time derivative in the concentration diffusion equation, hence the concentration satisfies a steady-state equation. However, since the boundary is actually slowly moving, it is not a true steady-state, as the time-dependent boundary position is present in the solution. The PSS is a well-known approximation applied in a variety of fields, such as phase change, enzyme kinetics, lubrication theory (where the time derivative is dropped from the Navier-Stokes equations) or the related thin film theory, see [ 19 , 20 , 21 ] for example. The problem studied in the present paper is analogous to a spherically symmetric one-phase change (Stefan problem) with a variable phase change temperature. This has been studied extensively in the analysis of nanoscale melting and nanocrystal growth [ 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 ] . The classical SCM is often attributed to Yagi and Kunii [ 5 ] and is described in detail in [ 27 , 28 , 29 ] . The applicability of the PSS has been questioned by a number of authors. Levenspiel [ 28 ] states that his analysis is based on the assumption that the surrounding fluid is a gas, but goes on to assert that it is equally applicable to a liquid. Wen [ 30 ] clearly states that the PSS is valid for most solid-gas reaction systems but not for solid-liquid systems, unless the liquid reactant concentration is very low. Lidell [ 31 ] focusses on reminding readers of the approximations and limits of the original models, which appear to have been lost over time and, in particular, on the range of applicability of the PSS assumption. They summarise Wen’s result [ 30 ] stating that the non-dimensional coefficient of the time derivative in the diffusion equation must be less than 0.1 (which leads to errors of the order 10%) to avoid erroneous results (in the following we will derive a similar limitation). A key result is that they point out the different system behaviour at small times (something we will also discuss later in this paper). There are clearly situations where the non-dimensional coefficient of the time derivative in the diffusion equation is not negligible, for example at early times (hence the different behaviour mentioned in [ 31 ] ) or with liquid-solid systems. In these cases some form of correction must be sought. One attempt was provided by Theofanous and Lim [ 32 ] . After changing all the variables in the problem, they integrate the heat equation twice to determine an integral equation for the concentration. This permits a solution to be obtained by repeated integration (the idea being that with each further integration the solution becomes more accurate). However, the method requires an initial solution which their approach does not provide, hence they apply a PSS approximation. To make for a simpler solution form they have imposed constant concentration at either boundary which results in a linear concentration. When this is placed into the integral formulation a cubic equation is obtained (their 2nd order solution). Replacing this back into the integral the 3rd order, obviously, is a quintic. The process could be carried further following a standard iterative procedure but at the quintic stage the algebra is already becoming very cumbersome. However, there is no proof that this iterative method converges on the correct solution. Moreover, the constant concentration boundary condition corresponds to the diffusion dominated case described in Levenspiel [ 28 ] but the diffusion-controlled PSS is a cubic equation: their starting choice corresponds to the kinetic-controlled limit (we will demonstrate this more clearly in subsequent sections). The solution in [ 32 ] involving the sum of their first and second order approximations, which is a cubic, may then be viewed as a somewhat inconsistent approximation to the standard model involving both kinetic and diffusion mechanisms - their governing equations neglect the kinetic reaction but their starting solution is equivalent to the kinetic solution. Liddell [ 31 ] states that the full cubic form may be obtained through elementary calculus. A review of different solid-state kinetic models can be found in [ 33 ] , where a plethora of different models are briefly mathematically motivated and classified into one of the following categories: nucleation, geometrical contraction, diffusion, and those models described by the order of the underlying chemical reaction. A critical evaluation of the SCM can be found in [ 34 ] . In [ 34 ] , the model is extended to multiple particles, and the authors investigate the role of the particle size distribution and the effects of neglecting it. The main conclusion is that if the distribution is wide, with a large variance, the kinetic equations can be affected in a non-negligible way, as supported by experimental data. The interplay between multiple evolving particles is well-documented in