Phase structure of below-threshold harmonics in aligned molecules: a few-level model system

Samuel Schöpa 1, Falk-Erik Wiechmann 1,2, Franziska Fennel 1,2, Dieter Bauer 1,2 · 2025

Read Phase structure of below-threshold harmonics in aligned molecules: a few-level model system by Samuel Schöpa 1, Falk-Erik Wiechmann 1,2, Franziska Fennel 1,2, Dieter Bauer 1,2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-20829.txt.

Introduction

Schöpa and co-authors use stripped-down model systems to explain odd phase behavior in light emitted by aligned molecules. When a strong laser drives molecules, they emit harmonics, and the harmonics below the ionization threshold carry a puzzling phase pattern. A simple two-level system turns out to reproduce the key effect on its own.

In that model, harmonics below the gap between the two dressed states flip their phase by pi from one odd order to the next. Above the gap, the phase instead stays constant. The team then stacks two such systems at right angles in a four-level model. There, lower harmonics follow the driving field's polarization while higher ones mirror it. Real aligned molecules with dipoles pointing along crossing directions, they predict, should show the same split behavior.

Catalog record

CREATORSamuel Schöpa 1, Falk-Erik Wiechmann 1,2, Franziska Fennel 1,2, Dieter Bauer 1,2
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE15 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-20829

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Phase structure of below-threshold harmonics in aligned molecules: a few-level model system Preprint: APS/123-QED Samuel Schöpa 1, Falk-Erik Wiechmann 1,2, Franziska Fennel 1,2, Dieter Bauer 1,2 Abstract We utilize few-level model systems to analyze the polarization and phase properties of below-threshold harmonics (BTH) in aligned molecules. In a two-level system (TLS), we find that the phase of emitted harmonics undergoes a distinct change. For harmonics with photon energies below the transition between the dominant field-dressed states, the phase alternates by π \pi between successive odd harmonic orders but remains constant above. Exploiting this behavior, we construct a four-level model composed of two uncoupled TLS subsystems aligned along orthogonal directions. We demonstrate that with selected transition frequencies lower-order harmonics follow the polarization of the linearly polarized driving field while higher-order harmonics exhibit a mirrored polarization. The model predicts that aligned systems with orthogonal transition dipoles may show analogous phase and polarization features in the BTH regime. The mechanisms underlying below-threshold harmonics (BTH) in high-harmonic generation (HHG) from molecules driven by short, intense laser pulses differ fundamentally from those responsible for the generation of higher-order (plateau) harmonics. In the gas phase, the latter typically involve a single active electron undergoing tunnel ionization, followed by quasi-free propagation and recombination with the parent ion Kulander et al. 1993 ; Corkum 1993 . In contrast, below-threshold, non-perturbative harmonics are produced by bound electrons, and the relevant processes are governed by the time-dependent populations of the electronic states in the molecule and the related time-dependent dipole induced by the electrons. Compared to above-threshold harmonic orders, the properties of the generated lower orders in molecules are much more target sensitive, as the geometric structure of the ion configuration and the many interacting electrons determine the electronic structure and the dipole transition matrix elements. Its sensitivity to electronic structure might make BTH a valuable tool for high-harmonic spectroscopy Soifer et al. 2010 ; Dong et al. 2015 ; Xiong et al. 2017 ; Li et al. 2020 while their potential for VUV frequency comb generation Yost et al. 2009 ; Zhu et al. 2021 ; Xiong et al. 2017 has further expanded their relevance. As a result, interest in this regime has grown significantly in recent years. The superposition of multiple microscopic contributions, such as laser-driven continuum like motion and bound-bound transitions Yost et al. 2009 ; Xiong et al. 2017 , makes BTH spectra exceptionally difficult to interpret and analyze. While most studies apply semi-classical analyses to model BTH Xiong et al. 2017 , these approaches obscure the role of discrete electronic transitions for polarization properties of the emitted harmonics. To isolate and understand these contributions, we turn to few-level model systems where specific transitions, dipole orientations, and resonances can be precisely controlled. Such simplified models offer a framework to investigate the mechanisms responsible for the complex polarizations of BTH from aligned molecules. Despite the simplicity of few-level models, they cannot be solved analytically beyond certain edge cases like the rotating-wave approximation or approximate treatments using Floquet-Green formalisms Martinez 2005 although such approaches have also revealed nontrivial harmonic phase behavior. For example, emitted plateau harmonics exhibit abrupt \pi phase jumps at specific Rabi frequencies Gauthey et al. 1997 . These investigations were carried out in a parameter regime with extremely high field strengths where most population transfers between the adiabatic states occur at very distinct times. In such cases analogies to the three-step model can be drawn Figueira De Morisson Faria and Rotter 2002 . To relate the TLS to BTH in molecular systems, we will investigate the dependence of the harmonic phase in a TLS at more moderate field-strengths and from there construct the most simple system that can create a very anisotropic response to differently oriented linearly polarized laser fields. That is, by combining two decoupled two level systems, we can create a HHG target that will have a ’counter-rotating’ polarization dependence and can emit harmonics that are linearly polarized and orthogonal to the driving polarization. We start by investigating a TLS with the field-free Hamiltonian \hat{H}_{0}=\begin{pmatrix}-\omega_{10}/2&0\\ 0&\omega_{10}/2\end{pmatrix} (1) with the transition frequency \omega_{10}=0.1 to model a system with one bound-bound transition and no continuum involved. There is only a single transition in x -direction, simplifying the interaction part to \hat{H}_{1}(t)=\begin{pmatrix}0&E_{x}(t)d\\ E_{x}(t)d&0\end{pmatrix}. (2) The total Hamiltonian reads \hat{H}=\hat{H}_{0}+\hat{H}_{1}(t) with d=-1.5 and the 60-cycle electric field E_{x}(t)=E_{0}~\text{env}(t)\cos(\omega_{L}t), (3) with a Gaussian envelope smoothly brought to zero at the edges using a Tukey window. To investigate the electron dynamics we solve the time-dependent Schrödinger equation (TDSE) i\frac{d}{dt}\textbf{C}(t)=(\hat{H}_{0}+\hat{H}_{1}(t))\textbf{C}(t) (4) for the vector \textbf{C}(t) with the populations in the basis of field-free orbitals, i.e., \ket{\Psi(t)}=C_{0}(t)\ket{\Psi_{0}(0)}+C_{1}(t)\ket{\Psi_{1}(0)} . The TDSE is solved numerically using an explicit Runge-Kutta method of order 5(4) to obtain the time-dependent dipole D(t)=d(C_{0}^{*}(t)C_{1}(t)+C_{1}^{*}(t)C_{0}(t)) . The harmonic spectrum is calculated via the Fourier-transform of the dipole acceleration H(\omega)=\omega^{4}||\tilde{D}(\omega)||^{2}=\omega^{4}||\mathcal{F}\{D(t)\cdot\text{hann}(t)\}||^{2}, (5) with a hanning window. Figure 1: High-harmonic spectrum of a TLS for different field-strengths. We are interested in the phase of the harmonic that a bound-bound transition would contribute to the HHG spectrum. As for very strong driving this TLS does not resemble any physical system, we choose moderate laser parameters such that there is no plateau yet. Figure 1 shows harmonic spectra for \omega_{L}=\omega_{10}/7.5 and different E_{0} . We observe odd harmonic orders as well as non-harmonic spectral features due to resonances. Concerning the phase of the emitted harmonics, we do not observe a dependence of the phase of the harmonics on the field strength in our parameter range, in contrast to observations from Gauthey et al. Gauthey et al. 1997 . This is not unexpected, as the jumps in the phase in Gauthey et al. 1997 can be associated with avoided crossings of Floquet states. Our system is in a parameter range where the variation of the electric field is too small to meaningfully change the Floquet states. Figure 2: Spectral internsity as a function of the ratio between transition energy and laser frequency and harmonic order. What we do observe, however, is a dependence on the frequency of the driving field. In Fig. 2 , the harmonic yield is plotted for E_{0}=0.015 as a function of the ratio between the transition frequency \omega_{10} and the laser frequency \omega_{L} on the horizontal, and the harmonic order on the vertical axis. This plot shows several features: At \omega_{10}/\omega_{L}=1 , we see the typical features of a TLS driven in resonance. The side-peaks around the fundamental are the Mollow-triplet, split apart by the Rabi-frequency \Omega=d\cdot E_{0} . For small deviations from \omega_{10}/\omega_{L}=1 these satellite peaks move according to the change in the generalized Rabi frequency \sqrt{\Omega^{2}+(\omega_{L}-\omega_{10})^{2}} , consistent with predictions by the rotating wave approximation, which holds in this domain where |\omega_{L}-\omega_{10}|\ll|\omega_{L}+\omega_{10}| . Outside strict resonance, non-harmonic spectral features appear due to coupling between Floquet states. The primary resonance manifests with satellite peaks spaced by integer multiples of 2\omega_{L} , reflecting transitions involving adjacent Floquet quasi-energy states Chu and Telnov 2004 . We observe harmonic orders up to the 17th. In Fig. 2 , these harmonics appear as horizontal lines. As \omega_{10}/\omega_{L} increases, higher-order harmonics are progressively enhanced, consistent with Gaarde and Schafer 2001 . Whenever \omega_{10}/\omega_{L} approximately matches an odd integer (with an energy shift due to field-dressing)

Read the complete text