Superconducting flux concentrator coils for levitation of particles in the Meissner state

Robert Smit, Martijn Janse, Eli van der Bent, Thijmen de Jong, Kier Heeck, Jaimy Plugge, Tjerk Oosterkamp, Bas Hensen · 2025

Read Superconducting flux concentrator coils for levitation of particles in the Meissner state by Robert Smit, Martijn Janse, Eli van der Bent, Thijmen de Jong, Kier Heeck, Jaimy Plugge, Tjerk Oosterkamp, Bas Hensen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-20795.txt.

Introduction

Robert Smit and co-authors build coils that can float a small superconducting particle in mid air, held by magnetism alone. Such floating gives a stage to test quantum rules with heavy objects, but the trap is weak, so the particle shakes slowly and picks up noise.

Their coils use cores that squeeze magnetic flux into a tiny space, which makes a steep trap. A pair of coils in a set layout did hold a particle aloft. Yet the motion died fast, since flux got trapped in the cores past a field limit. Sensors made from diamond defects mapped the leftover field, and the authors weigh fixes.

Catalog record

CREATORRobert Smit, Martijn Janse, Eli van der Bent, Thijmen de Jong, Kier Heeck, Jaimy Plugge, Tjerk Oosterkamp, Bas Hensen
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-20795

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Superconducting flux concentrator coils for levitation of particles in the Meissner state Robert Smit, Martijn Janse, Eli van der Bent, Thijmen de Jong, Kier Heeck, Jaimy Plugge, Tjerk Oosterkamp, Bas Hensen Abstract Magnetic levitation of superconductors is a promising platform to study quantum mechanics in the large-mass limit. One major limitation is the weak trapping potential, which results in low vibrational eigenfrequencies and increased susceptibility to low-frequency noise. While generating strong magnetic fields is relatively straightforward, creating a tightly confined harmonic potential — essentially achieving a large magnetic field gradient — remains a significant challenge. In this work, we demonstrate a potential solution using superconducting cores that concentrate magnetic flux into arbitrarily small volumes. We show the ability to trap superconducting particles using an anti-Helmholtz coil configuration incorporating these cores. However, we observe rapid damping of the levitated particle motion due to flux trapping within the cores, occurring once the lower critical field is exceeded locally. To investigate this mechanism, we employ diamond NV center magnetometry and detect substantial remanent fields persisting after high-current operation of the coils. Finally, we discuss possible strategies to mitigate this effect and improve the levitation properties. I Introduction The levitation of particles is a powerful and widely employed technique for isolating objects from their environment, thereby minimizing dissipative interactions Gonzalez-Ballestero et al. 2021 . The achievement of a long-lived and large-mass motional quantum state would be a milestone towards addressing fundamental questions in physics, including those concerning wave function collapse models Vinante et al. 2019 and the interplay between quantum mechanics with gravity Bose et al. 2017 ; Bose et al. 2025 . Beyond theoretical implications, levitated particles also serve as highly sensitive platforms for detecting gravitational forces Fuchs et al. 2024 , torques Ahn et al. 2020 , and even individual nuclear decay events Wang et al. 2024 . The current state-of-the-art in particle levitation is the optical tweezer, which has realized significant milestones over the past decade Ashkin 1970 ; Chu et al. 1986 . A particular achievement is the cooling of the motion of a levitating silica nanoparticle to the quantum ground state, first along a single vibrational mode Delić et al. 2020 ; Tebbenjohanns et al. 2021 and later in two modes simultaneously Piotrowski et al. 2023 . Despite these achievements, optical traps inherently suffer from heating via photon absorption Millen et al. 2014 and scattering Jain et al. 2016 , a limitation that becomes increasingly severe for larger, more massive particles, particularly for those approaching the 1 \mu m scale, where gravitational effects are expected to become relevant Bose et al. 2017 . Alternative levitation techniques, based on electric and magnetic fields, offer potential pathways to circumvent these limitations. According to Earnshaw’s theorem, stable levitation of charged or magnetic objects using static fields alone is impossible, necessitating dynamic potentials such as the rotating saddle potential in electric Paul 1990 and magnetic Paul traps Perdriat et al. 2023 ; Janse et al. 2024 . However, static magnetic levitation is achievable for diamagnetic particles that acquire an induced dipole in an applied magnetic field Simon and Geim 2000 ; Hsu et al. 2016 . Superconducting particles represent an ideal diamagnetic system, perfectly repelling external magnetic fields by the Meissner effect Hofer and Aspelmeyer 2019 . Magnetic confinement of such particles has been demonstrated using anti-Helmholtz coil configurations with both superconducting wire loops Hofer et al. 2023 and planar on-chip coils Gutierrez Latorre et al. 2023 . However, the achievable eigenfrequencies of motion within a magnetic trap remain significantly lower than those possible in optical traps. A clear route to increasing them involves higher coil currents, but this approach introduces substantial technical difficulties when operating in a millikelvin environment, more so when including vibration isolation systems Hofer et al. 2023 . In this work, we explore an alternative strategy: we employ superconducting flux concentrators to locally enhance the magnetic field gradient, thereby enabling stable levitation of superconducting particles without resorting to impractically large currents. Furthermore, we investigate potential dissipation mechanisms by incorporating nitrogen-vacancy (NV) center defects as nanoscale magnetic field sensors. Through this study we provide both a promising route towards enhanced magnetic levitation systems and a detailed characterization of the associated technical challenges. II Results II.1 The flux concentrator trap The earliest demonstrations of magnetic flux focusing or concentration involved coils wrapped around electrically conductive materials. These flux concentrators were originally developed to produce high transient magnetic fields Furth et al. 1957 or to generate strong localized fields in a confined region Brechna et al. 1965 . In our flux concentrator configuration, illustrated in Figure 1 a, the magnetic field produced by an outer coil induces circulating eddy currents within the core. By introducing a slit into the core, extending to its center, the induced current is forced to navigate around a narrow central path, resulting in a locally enhanced magnetic field. The absence of resistive losses and the perfect diamagnetic shielding inherent to superconductors make them highly efficient flux concentrators, a capability demonstrated using a range of superconducting materials Kiyoshi et al. 2009 ; Zhang et al. 2011 . While flux concentrators can dramatically increase local field strengths, the enhancement persists only until the applied field approaches the critical current of the superconducting core. For levitation applications, however, the field strength itself is less critical than the achievable magnetic field gradient. Notably, superconducting flux concentrators have recently been proposed as a means of generating large field gradients suitable for diamagnetic levitation Takahashi et al. 2020 . Beyond generating concentrated fields, similar designs have been applied to efficiently collect magnetic flux from localized areas, particularly in scanning magnetic susceptibility measurements, where they are coupled to SQUID sensors Xiang et al. 2023 . Figure 1: Flux concentration to enhance trap stiffness for Meissner levitation in anti-Helmholtz configuration . (a) Two coils (orange) create a quadrupole magnetic field (blue lines) resulting in a harmonic confinement potential (black line) for a superconducting particle (red dot). When the core enters its superconducting state from T<T_{\text{c}} onward, the magnetic field flux lines of the coil are concentrated in the slit due to the Meissner effect, enhancing the magnetic field gradient and thus the stiffness of the trapping potential. (b) Equivalently, a current ( I_{\text{coil}} ) through the outer wound coil induces an equal shielding current that revolves around an inner loop, leading to local concentration of the magnetic field. The dimensions of the cores in the experiments are l_{1} = 4.5 mm, l_{2} = 0.45 mm, r_{1} = 6.57 mm and r_{2} = 0.2 mm. (c) A set of these identical coils, placed in anti-Helmholtz configuration. The spacer is a PEEK plate with the superconducting particle inside. (d)-(e) The simulated potential minimum of the magnetic field for projections on the YZ and XZ axis, according to the axes system shown in panel (b). The simulations correspond to an applied current of 1 A through both coils. In this work, we employ machined niobium cores with dimensions listed in the caption of Figure 1 . The system can be effectively modeled as two separate coils: the outer drive coil and the inner induced current loop within the superconducting core. Assuming that the formula for idealized long solenoids

Read the complete text