Thermodynamic Constraints on the Emergence of Intersubjectivity in Quantum Systems
Alessandro Candeloro, Tiago Debarba, Felix C. Binder · 2025
Read Thermodynamic Constraints on the Emergence of Intersubjectivity in Quantum Systems by Alessandro Candeloro, Tiago Debarba, Felix C. Binder (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-20736.txt.
Introduction
Perfect quantum measurement would take endless resources, since the laws of heat forbid preparing a pointer in a fully erased, pure state. Alessandro Candeloro, Tiago Debarba, and Felix Binder explore what that limit means when several observers measure the same system, in this 2025 paper. The key question is whether the observers can agree on the outcome and each recover the true odds.
With ideal tools, agreement and faithful odds imply each other, but finite resources constrain each one apart. The authors prove a no-go result for perfect agreement of this kind and give a way to measure the shortfall. The bounds they derive depend only on the starting state of the surroundings. Cooling or coarse-graining can still bring observers close to the ideal.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alessandro Candeloro, Tiago Debarba, Felix C. Binder |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 115 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-20736
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Thermodynamic Constraints on the Emergence of Intersubjectivity in Quantum Systems Alessandro Candeloro, Tiago Debarba, Felix C. Binder Abstract Ideal quantum measurement requires divergent thermodynamic resources. This is a consequence of the third law of thermodynamics, which prohibits the preparation of the measurement pointer in a fully erased, pure state required for the acquisition of perfect, noiseless measurement information. In this work, we investigate the consequences of finite resources in the emergence of intersubjectivity as a model for measurement processes with multiple observers. Here, intersubjectivity refers to a condition in which observers agree on the observed outcome (agreement), and their local random variables exactly reproduce the original random variable for the system observable (probability reproducibility). While agreement and reproducibility are mutually implied in the case of ideal measurement, finite thermodynamic resources constrain each of them. Starting from the third law of thermodynamics, we derive how the achievability of ideal intersubjectivity is affected by restricted thermodynamic resources. Specifically, we establish a no-go theorem concerning perfect intersubjectivity and present a deviation metric to account for the influence of limited resources. We further present attainable bounds for the agreement and bias that are exclusively dependent on the initial state of the environment. In addition, we show that either by cooling or coarse-graining, we can approximate ideal intersubjectivity even with finite resources. This work bridges quantum thermodynamics and the emergence of classicality in the form of intersubjectivity. I Introduction In quantum mechanics, measurement of any system has to be understood not only as a dynamical mechanism but also as a fundamental principle: the associated probabilities are dictated by the Born Rule, and textbook projective measurement is postulated to result in a pure quantum state. This scenario has recently attracted attention due to the discrepancy between idealised projective measurements and the third law of thermodynamics Guryanova et al. 2020 ; Debarba et al. 2024 ; Mohammady and Miyadera 2023 ; Mohammady and Buscemi 2025 . Specifically, while the measurement postulate of quantum mechanics suggests that measurement leaves the system in a pure state, the third law of thermodynamics dictates the inherent impossibility of realising such a pure state in practice Taranto et al. 2023 . Thermodynamics is primarily concerned with macroscopic systems consisting of multiple constituent parts and their interactions. For this reason, thermodynamic considerations are essential for modelling measurement and the transition from quantum to classical. The first foundational efforts to explore such a quantum-to-classical transition involved the study of decoherence Zurek 1991 ; Zurek 2002 ; Joos et al. 2003 ; Schlosshauer 2004 ; Schlosshauer 2007 ; Schlosshauer 2019 . Over time, the framework of quantum Darwinism emerged from decoherence theory, shifting the discourse towards the view that measurement and the quantum-to-classical transition correspond to redundant, broadcasted information encoded in environmental macrofractions Zurek 2003 ; Zurek 2009 ; Zurek 2022 . These concepts have recently found a more structured framework in operational objectivity and Spectrum Broadcast Structures (SBS) Horodecki et al. 2015 ; Korbicz 2021 . This structure responds to the fact that quantum Darwinism, while ubiquitous Brandão et al. 2015 , does not per se imply agreement about measurement outcomes among observers due to quantum discord Modi et al. 2012 ; Zwolak and Zurek 2013 , resulting in the introduction of Strong Quantum Darwinism Le and Olaya-Castro 2019 ; Feller et al. 2021 ; Le and Olaya-Castro 2021 . These developments have provided a formalised approach to understanding the quantum-to-classical transition in terms of a specific state structure, where the salient features can be captured in terms of information broadcasting and almost perfect distinguishability of branch states Touil et al. 2024 . Figure 1: Multiple macroscopic observers \mathcal{P}_{j} monitor a central quantum system S in order to extract information about a specific central observable. The presence of a thermal environment at temperature T hinders the emergence of ideal intersubjectivity. Nonetheless, the framework developed thus far faces some limitations. First, it does not describe measurement as a process, but just as a target state, if not solely in entropic terms. Furthermore, the discussion is usually limited to projective measurement, implicitly omitting destructive measurement as a possibility. For this reason, in this article, we adopt a broader notion of objectivity known as intersubjectivity Ozawa 2019 . This can be understood as the minimal scenario for information broadcasting with multipartite agreement: multiple environments access local subsystems to extract information about the system’s initial state. In this framework, additional properties, such as non-disturbance of the system or the environment, are not generally required. Only the broadcasting of information is essential Debarba et al. 2024 . This approach thereby generalises the usual notion of ideal projective measurement and measurement schemes Busch et al. 2016 , by naturally including multipartite systems as environments. The interplay between quantum measurement and thermodynamics has been extensively studied – in particular, the thermodynamic cost of acquiring information through measurement Sagawa and Ueda 2009 ; Jacobs 2012 ; Faist et al. 2015 ; Deffner et al. 2016 ; Abdelkhalek et al. 2016 ; Kammerlander and Anders 2016 ; Linpeng et al. 2022 ; Xuereb et al. 2024 , and the resulting implication that limited thermodynamic resources constrain the precision with which quantum measurements can be performed Guryanova et al. 2020 ; Debarba et al. 2019 ; Mohammady 2023 ; Panda et al. 2023 ; Mohammady and Buscemi 2025 . In this context, the measurement process has been modeled as a thermal engine, whose efficiency can be directly compared to the precision of the measurement Elouard and Jordan 2018 ; Latune and Elouard 2025 . Within the framework of Quantum Darwinism, the role of environmental mixedness Zwolak et al. 2009 , the compatibility between equilibrium states and Spectrum Broadcast Structures (SBS) Le et al. 2021 , measurement as a phase transition Allahverdyan et al. 2013 , the emergence of objectivity as a classical limit of information broadcasting Debarba et al. 2024 , and the formation of SBS through equilibration processes Schwarzhans et al. 2023 ; Engineer et al. 2024 ; de Melo et al. 2024 have been analysed. In this work, we apply these thermodynamic considerations to characterise the emergence of intersubjectivity in a thermodynamically consistent manner (see Fig. 1 for illustration). This is motivated by the observation that there is a conflict between ideal projective measurements and the third law of thermodynamics Guryanova et al. 2020 : while the measurement postulate predicts a pure post-measurement state, the third law forbids the creation of a pure – or rank-reduced – state with finite resources. Moreover, thermodynamics limits the ability to create the redundancies necessary to broadcast information encoded in a quantum system Debarba et al. 2024 . We investigate the constraints imposed by the third law of thermodynamics, and quantify the extent to which information can be broadcast and how consensus about observed outcomes can be achieved when available thermodynamic resources are finite. Our results thereby address the thermodynamic cost of building the type of correlations that result in intersubjectivity, adding to the broader understanding of the thermodynamic value of correlations Huber et al. 2015 ; Bruschi et al. 2015 ; Bakhshinezhad et al. 2019 ; Piccione et al. 2020 ; Piccione et al. 2021 ; Krisnanda et al. 2022 ; Lipka-Bartosik et al. 2024