Fourth-order quantum master equations reveal that spin-phonon decoherence undercuts long magnetization relaxation times in single-molecule magnets
Alessandro Lunghi · 2025
Read Fourth-order quantum master equations reveal that spin-phonon decoherence undercuts long magnetization relaxation times in single-molecule magnets by Alessandro Lunghi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-20716.txt.
Introduction
Alessandro Lunghi computes how lattice vibrations steal the coherence of a single molecule magnet, using fourth order quantum master equations. His 2025 paper extends the equations to cover coherence terms and two phonon processes together, fully from first principles. The test molecule is a champion of slow forgetting, with magnetization lasting near seconds at liquid nitrogen temperature.
The catch is coherence. While the magnetization direction persists, the quantum superposition between its states dies in under ten nanoseconds. A new two phonon dephasing route does the damage. Lunghi's result draws a line the field must respect: a magnet can remember its pole for seconds yet forget its phase almost at once, which caps its use as a quantum bit.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alessandro Lunghi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-20716
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Fourth-order quantum master equations reveal that spin-phonon decoherence undercuts long magnetization relaxation times in single-molecule magnets Alessandro Lunghi Abstract Spin-phonon interaction is known to drive magnetic relaxation in solid-state systems, but little evidence is available on how it affects coherence time. Here we extend fourth-order quantum master equations to account for coherence terms and describe the full effect of up to two-phonon processes on spin dynamics. We numerically implement this method fully ab initio for a single-molecule magnet with large magnetization blocking temperature and show that while strong axial magnetic anisotropy ensures slow magnetic relaxation approaching seconds at 77 K, the superposition of Kramers doublets is coherent for less than 10 ns due to a novel two-phonon pure dephasing mechanism. Introduction. Magnetic relaxation studies have been conducted across vastly different length scales, ranging from bulk magnets to nanoparticles, molecules, and single atoms adsorbed on surfaces Gambardella et al. 2003 ; Donati et al. 2016 ; Sessoli et al. 1993 , showing that the effect of spin-phonon interaction is strongly inhibited when the magnetization experiences a reversal energy barrier introduced by magnetic uniaxial anisotropy. The study of single-molecule magnets (SMMs) has particularly enjoyed large attention in recent years thanks to the possibility of chemically tailoring said magnetic anisotropy, and record-breaking long magnetization relaxation times, \tau , have been achieved for coordination compounds based on Dy 3+ ions with large effective total magnetic moment J=15/2 and magnetization reversal barriers exceeding 2000 K Goodwin et al. 2017 ; Guo et al. 2018 ; Emerson-King et al. 2025 . The application of SMMs in quantum information science has also been pursued due to several advantageous properties of this physical platform with respect to others, including chemical and physical tunability, synthetic reproducibility, and more Atzori and Sessoli 2019 ; Gaita-Ariño et al. 2019 . Early prototypes of SMMs based on clusters of 3d ions had indeed shown that Rabi oscillations and quantum gates can be driven at cryogenic temperatures where relaxation time, T_{1} , is long enough, leaving spin-spin dipolar interactions to limit coherence time, T_{2} , in such conditions Hill et al. 2003 ; Ardavan et al. 2007 ; Schlegel et al. 2008 . However, dipolar contributions to T_{2} can be mitigated by deuteration or using proton-free environments Zadrozny et al. 2015 , effectively making spin relaxation the hard limit for T_{2} at all temperatures. More recently, spin coherence in 4f ions Pedersen et al. 2016 ; Shiddiq et al. 2016 , isotropic spin-1/2 3d ions Bader et al. 2014 ; Zadrozny et al. 2015 ; Atzori et al. 2016 and organic radicals Schäfter et al. 2023 ; Gorgon et al. 2023 has also been explored, with qualitatively similar phenomenology. SMMs with ultra-slow magnetic relaxation are an intriguing candidate for quantum applications, but the limit of T_{2} posed by spin-phonon coupling in these systems remains unknown, as no experimental or theoretical evidence is available. Quantum master equations. Here we address this knowledge gap by tapping into the increasingly successful field of ab initio spin dynamics. This method has already provided unique insights into the spin-phonon relaxation of magnetic molecules, ranging from isotropic spin-1/2 systems Mariano et al. 2025 up to strongly correlated 3d metal Lunghi 2022 ; Mondal et al. 2025 or lanthanide complexes Goodwin et al. 2017 ; Briganti et al. 2021 , and solid-state paramagnetic defects Mondal and Lunghi 2023 ; Cambria et al. 2023 . A theory of spin-phonon relaxation up to two-phonon contributions has so far been developed Lunghi 2022 ; Mariano et al. 2025 . However, while second-order contributions have been fully unravelled Lunghi and Sanvito 2019 ; Lunghi and Sanvito 2020 , fourth-order contributions, key to describe low-temperature spin dynamics in SMMs Briganti et al. 2021 , have so far been determined only for the population terms of the density matrix Lunghi 2022 . In addition to precluding gaining insights on coherence times at low temperature, this limitation has been shown to potentially lead to catastrophic results in the case of spectral degeneracies able to couple the time evolution of population and coherence terms of the density matrix Lunghi 2022 . In order to access coherence time over the full temperature range, we here set out to derive a 4th-order propagator in Lindblad form able to describe the time evolution of the entire spin density matrix. Let us start by describing the system Hamiltonian \hat{H}=\hat{H}_{s}+\hat{H}_{ph}+\hat{H}_{sph}\>, (1) where \hat{H}_{s} is the spin Hamiltonian, and \hat{H}_{ph} is the phonon Hamiltonian, which we assume to be harmonic, \hat{H}_{ph}=\sum_{\alpha}\hbar\omega_{\alpha}(\hat{n}_{\alpha}+\frac{1}{2})\>, (2) where \hbar\omega_{\alpha} is the \alpha -phonon quantum energy and \hat{n}_{\alpha}=a^{\dagger}_{\alpha}a_{\alpha} is the number operator written in terms of creation and annihilation operators. Finally, the third term in Eq. 1 is the spin-phonon interactions, which in the weak-coupling linear regime reads \hat{H}_{sph}=\sum_{\alpha}\left(\frac{\partial\hat{H}_{s}}{\partial q_{\alpha}}\right)q_{\alpha}\>, (3) where q_{\alpha}=2^{-1/2}\left(a^{\dagger}_{\alpha}+a_{\alpha}\right) are the phonons’ atomic displacements. The time evolution of the spin system under the influence of a weakly coupled phonon bath is here tackled with time-local quantum master equations Timm 2011 , \frac{d\hat{\rho}(t)}{dt}=\hat{\hat{R}}(t,t_{0})\>\hat{\rho}(t)\xrightarrow{t_{0}\rightarrow-\infty}\hat{\hat{R}}\>\hat{\rho}(t) (4) where \hat{\hat{R}} is a super-operator describing the effect of the phonon bath over the dynamics of the reduced spin density operator \hat{\rho}(t) expressed in the interaction picture. As depicted in Eq. 4 , the superoperator \hat{\hat{R}} becomes time independent in the Markovian limit, i.e. long times after the system has been initialized at t_{0} . The latter approximation is well justified for molecular crystals as phonons relax to equilibrium on much faster timescales than spin Albino et al. 2021 ; Nabi et al. 2023 . In order to make Eq. 4 tractable, the super-operator \hat{\hat{R}} is often expanded perturbatively, \hat{\hat{R}}=\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\hat{\hat{R}}^{(2n)} . Recently, the regularized T-matrix approach Timm 2011 has been used to determine an explicit expression of \hat{\hat{R}}^{(2)} and \hat{\hat{R}}^{(4)} under the Markov and secular approximations Lunghi and Sanvito 2019 ; Lunghi 2022 . By expressing all operators in the eigenspace of \hat{H}_{s} , the population terms of \hat{\hat{R}}^{(2)} read R^{(2)}_{bb,aa}=\frac{2\pi}{\hbar^{2}}\sum_{\alpha}|V_{ba}^{\alpha}|^{2}G^{(2)}(\omega,\omega_{\alpha})\>, (5) where V_{ba}^{\alpha}=\langle b|\partial\hat{H}_{s}/\partial Q_{\alpha}|a\rangle , and \hbar\omega=\hbar\omega_{ba}=E_{b}-E_{a} . G^{(2)} reads G^{(2)}(\omega,\omega_{\alpha})=\delta(\omega-\omega_{\alpha})\bar{n}_{\alpha}+\delta(\omega+\omega_{\alpha})(\bar{n}_{\alpha}+1)\>, (6) where \bar{n}_{\alpha}=(e^{\hbar\omega_{\alpha}/\mathrm{k_{B}}T}-1)^{-1} is the Bose-Einstein distribution accounting for the thermal population of phonons, \mathrm{k_{B}} is the Boltzmann constant, and the Dirac delta functions enforce energy conservation during the absorption and emission of phonons by the spin system, respectively. There are three possible two-phonon contributions to \hat{\hat{R}}^{(4)} , double phonon emission, double phonon absorption and simultaneous emission-absorption. For the absorption of phonon \alpha and emission of phonon \beta , R^{(4)}_{bb,aa} is R^{(4)}_{bb,aa}=\frac{2\pi}{\hbar^{2}}\sum_{\alpha>\beta}\left|T^{\alpha\beta,+}_{ba}+T^{\beta\alpha,-}_{ba}\right|^{2}G^{(4)}(\omega,\omega_{\alpha},\omega_{\beta})\>, (7) where the terms T^{\alpha\beta,\pm}_{ba}=\sum_{c}\frac{V_{bc}^{\alpha}V_{ca}^{\beta}}{E_{c}-E_{a}\pm\hbar\omega_{\beta}} (8) describe the contribution of virtual transitions to excited spin states |c\rangle , and G^{(4)} reads G^{(4)}(\omega,\omega_{\alpha},\omega_{\beta})=\delta(\omega-\omega_{\alpha}+\omega_{\beta})\hat{n}_{\alpha}(\hat{n}_{\beta}+1). (9) In order to extend these results to the description of the full reduced spin density matrix, we recall the fundamental theorem by Lindblad Lindblad 1976 that determines that any process described by a Markovian semi-group leads to a generalized and universal form of quantum master equations, which expressed in the eigenbasis of \hat{H}_{s} read \frac{d\hat{\rho}_{ab,cd}(t)}{dt}=\sum_{\kappa}\gamma_{\kappa}\left[L_{db}^{\kappa}L_{ac}^{\kappa}-\frac{1}{2}\sum_{j}\delta_{bd}L_{jc}^{\kappa}L_{aj}^{\kappa}-\frac{1}{2}\sum_{j}\delta_{ac}L_{jb}^{\kappa}L_{dj}^{\kappa}\right]\hat{\rho}_{cd}(t)\>, (10) where the jump operators \hat{L}_{\kappa} represent the effect of the bath on the reduced density matrix operator, and \gamma_{\kappa} are positive weights determining the relative efficiency of different \kappa bath contributions. A one-to-one map between Eq. 10 and R^{(2n)}_{ab,cd} , order by order, emerges. For instance, under the secular approximation, i.e. R_{ab,cd}=0 unless \omega_{bd}=\omega_{ac}=\omega , the second-order jump operators