Lattice study of scattering phase shifts for D ​ D ∗ DD^{*} and B ​ B ∗ BB^{*} systems using twisted boundary conditions: search for bound state formation

Masato Nagatsuka, Shoichi Sasaki · 2025

Read Lattice study of scattering phase shifts for D ​ D ∗ DD^{*} and B ​ B ∗ BB^{*} systems using twisted boundary conditions: search for bound state formation by Masato Nagatsuka, Shoichi Sasaki (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-20712.txt.

Introduction

Some particles seem to be pairs of heavy mesons stuck together, and physicists want to know which of these bound states truly exist. Masato Nagatsuka and Shoichi Sasaki use lattice simulations to study how two mesons, DD* and BB*, scatter off each other. They apply Lüscher's finite-size method with twisted boundary conditions, which let them scan scattering at many momenta rather than a few fixed points. The twisting also mixes wave types, giving access to P-wave results that are otherwise hard to reach.

The simulations use three pion masses and an action designed to limit errors for heavy quarks. For the charmed system, the work follows up the known Tcc+ state seen just below threshold at the LHCb experiment. For the bottom system, the results point to a shallow bound state with binding energy around 100 keV at the physical pion mass.

Catalog record

CREATORMasato Nagatsuka, Shoichi Sasaki
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE77 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-20712

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Lattice study of scattering phase shifts for D ​ D ∗ DD^{*} and B ​ B ∗ BB^{*} systems using twisted boundary conditions: search for bound state formation Masato Nagatsuka, Shoichi Sasaki Abstract We investigate the S S - and P P -wave phase shifts for the D ​ D ∗ DD^{\ast} and B ​ B ∗ BB^{\ast} scatterings using Lüscher’s finite-size method under twisted boundary conditions to search for doubly charmed tetraquaks, T c ​ c + T_{cc}^{+} , and doubly bottomed tetraquarks, T b ​ b − T_{bb}^{-} as the hadronic bound states. The T c ​ c + T_{cc}^{+} state was observed as a peak just bellow the D ​ D ∗ DD^{*} threshold by LHCb Collaboration, while the T b ​ b − T_{bb}^{-} state is a theoretically predicted tetraquark state having heavier quark flavors b ​ b ​ u ¯ ​ d ¯ bb\bar{u}\bar{d} . Lüscher’s finite-size method is one of the well established methods for calculating the scattering phase shifts between two hadrons in lattice QCD simulations. Several studies have used simulations under the periodic boundary condition to determine the scattering phase shifts at a few discrete momenta for the D ​ D ∗ DD^{*} system. However, the scattering phase shift has not been investigated for the B ​ B ∗ BB^{*} system. In this study, S S - and P P -wave scattering phase shifts for the D ​ D ∗ DD^{*} and B ​ B ∗ BB^{*} systems in both I = 0 I=0 and I = 1 I=1 channels under several types of partially twisted boundary conditions. The use of the partially twisted boundary conditions enables us to obtain the scattering phase shift at any momentum by continuously varying the twisting angle. It also allows us to easily access the P P -wave scattering phase shifts through the mixing of S S - and P P -waves, which is induced by the imposed boundary conditions. The 2+1 flavor PACS-CS gauge ensembles at m π = 295 m_{\pi}=295 , 411 and 569 MeV are used. For charm and bottom quarks, the relativistic heavy quark action is adopted to reduce the lattice discretization artifacts due to the heavy quark mass. We discuss the emergence of a shallow bound state with a binding energy of 𝒪 ⁡ ( 100 ) \mathcal{O}(100) keV at the physical pion mass in the B ​ B ∗ BB^{*} system, which has the quantum number I ⁡ ( J P ) = 0 ​ ( 1 + ) I(J^{P})=0(1^{+}) . pacs 11.15.Ha, 12.38.-t 12.38.Gc I Introduction After the discovery of the exotic meson X (3872) in 2003 Belle:2003nnu , many hidden-heavy exotic hadrons were reported, and these hadrons have been studied extensively over the past several decades. However, the presence of quark-antiquark annihilation makes theoretical analyses of most exotic mesons quite challenging. From a theoretical perspective, therefore, the existence of exotic hadrons without quark-antiquark annihilation is highly desirable. The experimental observation of the S=+1 baryon resonance, called the \Theta^{+}(1540) resonance LEPS:2003wug , was the first candidate for a genuine exotic pentaquark state classified as a uudd\bar{s} state, and triggered many lattice QCD calculations Sasaki:2003gi ; Csikor:2003ng ; Sasaki:2004vz . However, subsequent experiments have not confirmed the existence of the \Theta^{+}(1540) state Liu:2014yva . The doubly charmed tetraquark T_{cc}^{+} , which has the explicit exotic flavor cc\bar{u}\bar{d} and isospin I(J^{P})=0(1^{+}) , was discovered by the LHCb Collaboration in 2021 LHCb:2021vvq ; LHCb:2021auc . The T_{cc}^{+} state was found to be about 360 keV below the D^{0}D^{*+} threshold with a decay width of 48 keV LHCb:2021auc . The doubly bottomed tetraquark T_{bb}^{-} can be obtained by replacing the charm quarks with bottom quarks as a theoretical analogue of the T_{cc}^{+} . The properties of T_{cc}^{+} and T_{bb}^{-} have been studied within the same framework using phenomenological methods since 1980s Carlson:1987hh ; Manohar:1992nd and there are many recent updates Meng:2020knc ; Noh:2021lqs ; Dong:2021bvy ; Deng:2021gnb ; Kim:2022mpa ; Maiani:2022qze ; Praszalowicz:2022sqx ; Dai:2022ulk ; Ortega:2022efc ; Dai:2023kwv ; Feijoo:2023sfe ; Ren:2023pip ; Sakai:2023syt ; Wu:2024zbx . The bb\bar{u}\bar{d} channel is typically considered to have a single bound state with a binding energy ranging from \mathcal{O}(1) MeV to \mathcal{O}(100) MeV. Furthermore, an exact few-body calculation suggests that there may be two bound states in this channel Meng:2020knc . The DD^{\ast} scattering has been widely studied in lattice QCD simulations to identify the T_{cc}^{+} state as a shallow bound state. The S -wave scattering phase shifts for the I(J^{P})=0(1^{+}) channel have been calculated using Lüscher’s finite-size method Padmanath:2022cvl ; Collins:2024sfi ; Chen:2022vpo and the HAL QCD method Ikeda:2013vwa ; Lyu:2023xro , while there are a few calculations for the I(J^{P})=1(1^{+}) channel Chen:2022vpo ; Meng:2024kkp . Although both methods are well-established approaches for obtaining the scattering phase shifts, the conclusion regarding the T_{cc}^{+} from lattice QCD remains controversial due to the left-hand cut of DD\pi just below the DD^{*} threshold, which could give rise to the singularity in the DD^{*} scattering amplitude as discussed in Ref. Du:2023hlu . Some studies circumvent the issue by incorporating the DD\pi scattering, as demonstrated in Refs. Dawid:2024dgy ; Hansen:2024ffk . The authors of Refs. Collins:2024sfi ; Meng:2024kkp attempt to extract the singular behavior by assuming that the left-hand cut originates from one-pion exchange. An alternative approach involves extracting S - and P -wave scattering phase shifts based on chiral effective field theory Meng:2023bmz . In this study, however, we will extract the detailed scattering phase shifts of the S - and P -wave scattering near the threshold using twisted boundary conditions, which, in principle, can provide scattering phase shifts at arbitrary energies. There are some lattice studies for the doubly bottomed tetraquark using the NRQCD action, which show the existence of a deeply bound state with a binding energy of \mathcal{O}(100)~\mathrm{MeV} in the I(J^{P})=0(1^{+}) channel Francis:2016hui ; Junnarkar:2018twb ; Leskovec:2019ioa ; Mohanta:2020eed ; Hudspith:2023loy ; Aoki:2023nzp ; Alexandrou:2024iwi ; Tripathy:2025vao . Unlike most model calculations, which predicted a wide range of binding energies from \mathcal{O}(1) to \mathcal{O}(100) MeV, these lattice calculations consistently predict strong binding of B and B^{\ast} mesons in the bb\bar{u}\bar{d} system. While the presence of a deep energy level from threshold is sufficient for identifying a deep bound state, the identification of shallow bound states is better served by using Lüscher’s finite-size method to probe the peculiar behavior of the scattering phase shifts in the vicinity of threshold. As summarized in a recent review of lattice QCD calculations for the heavy tetraquark states Francis:2024fwf , the identification of a deep bound state has only been discussed in the BB^{\ast} channel. However, the search for shallow bound states, as is done in the DD^{\ast} channel, has never been discussed. The finite-size method is frequently utilized to examine the low-energy interaction between two hadrons. Detailed information of the low-energy interaction is represented by the lower partial-wave phase shifts at low energies. After original proposals given by Lüscher Luscher:1986pf ; Luscher:1990ux , many extensions have been developed in various ways. In particular, this formalism was first extended to moving frames with nonzero total momentum of scattered particles of equal mass Rummukainen:1995vs . A further extension is elaborated in Refs. Fu:2011xz ; Doring:2012eu ; Leskovec:2012gb ; Gockeler:2012yj for the

Read the complete text