Preliminary orbits with over-determined systems of Keplerian conservation laws

C. Grassi, G. F. Gronchi · 2025

Read Preliminary orbits with over-determined systems of Keplerian conservation laws by C. Grassi, G. F. Gronchi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-20709.txt.

Introduction

Clara Grassi and Giovanni Federico Gronchi test which sets of orbit rules can pin a first orbit from two short arcs of sky reads. Their paper is from two thousand twenty-five, in the math of orbits.

The full set holds seven rules in four unknowns. With two help terms, it forms a nine-rule system with, in most cases, no answer at all. Past work found one part-set that is sound, and leads to a ninth-degree rule in one range. The team tries all the rest. They find two more sound part-sets, each with an eighteenth-degree rule in the same range. The rest clash. They give a way to tell the cases apart.

Catalog record

CREATORC. Grassi, G. F. Gronchi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-20709

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Preliminary orbits with over-determined systems of Keplerian conservation laws C. Grassi, G. F. Gronchi Abstract We consider different choices of Keplerian conservation laws for the computation of preliminary orbits with two very short arcs (VSAs) of astrometric observations. In total we have 7 equations in 4 unknowns. Adding two auxiliary variables we can embed the full set of conservation laws into a polynomial system of 9 equations. This complete system generically has no solutions. However, combining these equations, in [ 10 ] the authors found an over-determined polynomial system that is consistent, and leads by variable elimination to a univariate polynomial 𝗉 9 \mathsf{p}_{9} of degree 9 in one radial distance. In [ 9 ] the authors showed that this corresponds to taking a subsystem with 7 equations of the complete system. In this paper we consider all the other possibilities and we find two additional over-determined cases which are consistent and lead to a univariate polynomial 𝗉 18 \mathsf{p}_{18} of degree 18 in the same variable as 𝗉 9 \mathsf{p}_{9} . In the other over-determined cases the corresponding system is inconsistent. We also present a method to compute an approximate gcd of 𝗉 9 \mathsf{p}_{9} and 𝗉 18 \mathsf{p}_{18} , that can allow us to find preliminary orbits that approximately satisfy inconsistent systems of conservation laws, or to discard incompatible pairs of VSAs. We show this through some numerical tests with real asteroid data. 1 Introduction The modern asteroid surveys are producing very large databases of optical observations. Linking very short arcs (VSAs) of these observations collected in different nights we can compute asteroid orbits. The search for efficient linkage algorithms is an interesting mathematical problem: we show how it can be faced using the first integrals of Kepler’s problem. The use of the Keplerian integrals (KI) for this purpose goes back to the 70s, see [ 18 ] , where the authors proposed to employ conservation of angular momentum and energy to compute preliminary orbits for artificial Earth satellites. A Newton-Raphson method was applied to compute the solutions but, according to [ 17 ] , the algorithm is extremely sensitive to the errors. Later this algorithm was improved, however the results were not satisfactory yet, see [ 19 ] . More recently, in [ 11 ] , [ 12 ] the authors employed the Keplerian integrals to write polynomial equations for the problem: in [ 11 ] the same conservation laws as in [ 18 ] were used, leading to a univariate polynomial equation of degree 48, while in [ 12 ] the projection of the Laplace-Lenz vector onto a suitable direction was used in place of the energy, leading to a polynomial of degree 20. These methods can be applied also to compute preliminary orbits of satellites and space debris, and allow to include the J_{2} effect [ 7 ] . A comparison between the two KI methods can be found in [ 6 ] , where these methods were successfully applied to a large scale simulation of space debris observations in the upper part of the LEO region. In these methods the number of equations is equal to the number of unknowns. In [ 10 ] a combination of the Keplerian conservation laws was used to obtain an over-determined polynomial system which is consistent, that is it always admits solutions, at least in the complex field. This system leads to a univariate polynomial equation of degree 9. In [ 9 ] , using Gröbner basis theory, the authors gave an interpretation of the equations considered in [ 10 ] . Recently, the KI method introduced in [ 10 ] was successfully used in [ 15 ] as the first step of a complete orbit determination pipeline, that has been applied to the observations of the isolated tracklet file. 1 1 1 https://minorplanetcenter.net/iau/ITF/itf.txt.gz The authors were able to link several VSAs and compute a few thousand orbits. In Section 2 we introduce the mathematical setting for this work and describe the results that we obtained in the attempt of using as many Keplerian conservation laws as possible for the computation of preliminary orbits. 2 Preliminaries and description of the results Let us consider a reference frame with origin at the center of the Sun. Denote by \bm{q},\dot{\bm{q}} the position and velocity vectors of the observer and by \bm{r},\dot{\bm{r}} the position and velocity vectors of the observed body at time t . We can write \displaystyle\bm{r} \displaystyle=\bm{q}+\rho\bm{e}^{\rho}, \displaystyle\dot{\bm{r}} \displaystyle=\dot{\bm{q}}+\dot{\rho}\bm{e}^{\rho}+\rho\bm{e}^{\perp}, where \rho,\dot{\rho} are the topocentric radial distance and velocity of the observed body, \bm{e}^{\rho} is the line of sight unit vector and \bm{e}^{\perp}=\frac{d\bm{e}^{\rho}}{dt} . Using angular coordinates (\alpha,\delta)\in[-\pi,\pi)\times[-\pi/2,\pi/2] , which are usually right ascension and declination, we have \bm{e}^{\rho}=(\cos\alpha\cos\delta,\sin\alpha\cos\delta,\sin\delta). In this frame the Keplerian energy of the observed object is {\cal E}=\frac{1}{2}|\dot{\bm{r}}|^{2}-\frac{\mu}{|\bm{r}|}, while the angular momentum \bm{c} and the Laplace-Lenz vector \bm{L} are given by \displaystyle\bm{c} \displaystyle=\bm{r}\times\dot{\bm{r}}, \displaystyle\mu\bm{L} \displaystyle=\dot{\bm{r}}\times\bm{c}-\frac{\mu}{|\bm{r}|}\bm{r}=\left(|\dot{\bm{r}}|^{2}-\frac{\mu}{|\bm{r}|}\right)\bm{r}-(\dot{\bm{r}}\cdot\bm{r})\dot{\bm{r}}. Given two VSAs of optical observations of a celestial body we can compute two attributables {\cal A}_{1}=(\alpha_{1},\delta_{1},\dot{\alpha}_{1},\dot{\delta}_{1}),\qquad{\cal A}_{2}=(\alpha_{2},\delta_{2},\dot{\alpha}_{2},\dot{\delta}_{2}) at epochs t_{1},t_{2} , see [ 14 ] . Assuming that \bm{q}_{j},\dot{\bm{q}}_{j} for j=1,2 are known, we try to determine an initial orbit using the Keplerian conservation laws \bm{c}_{1}-\bm{c}_{2}={\bf 0},\qquad\mu(\bm{L}_{1}-\bm{L}_{2})={\bf 0},\qquad{\cal E}_{1}-{\cal E}_{2}=0 (1) in the unknowns \rho_{1},\rho_{2},\dot{\rho}_{1},\dot{\rho}_{2} . Introducing the auxiliary variables z_{j}=\frac{\mu}{|\bm{r}_{j}|},\qquad j=1,2 and the polynomials \begin{split}&\mu\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{j}=(|\dot{\bm{r}}_{j}|^{2}-z_{j})\bm{r}_{j}-(\dot{\bm{r}}_{j}\cdot\bm{r}_{j})\dot{\bm{r}}_{j},\cr&\widetilde{\cal E}_{j}=\frac{1}{2}|\dot{\bm{r}}_{j}|^{2}-z_{j}\cr&\zeta_{j}=z_{j}^{2}|\bm{r}_{j}|^{2}-\mu^{2},\cr\end{split} we embed ( 1 ) into the polynomial system \bm{c}_{1}-\bm{c}_{2}={\bf 0},\quad\mu(\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{1}-\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{2})={\bf 0},\quad\widetilde{\cal E}_{1}-\widetilde{\cal E}_{2}=0,\quad\zeta_{1}=0,\quad\zeta_{2}=0 (2) where the unknowns are \rho_{1},\rho_{2},\dot{\rho}_{1},\dot{\rho}_{2},z_{1},z_{2} . However, system ( 2 ) is over-determined (9 equations and 6 unknowns) and inconsistent, that is it generically does not admit solutions, not even in the complex field, not even when {\cal A}_{1},{\cal A}_{2} belong to the same observed body, see Table 1 in Section 3 . In Appendix A we define more precisely what we mean when we claim that some property holds generically. Let \bm{D}_{j}=\bm{q}_{j}\times\bm{e}^{\rho}_{j},\qquad j=1,2 and assume \bm{D}_{1}\times\bm{D}_{2}\cdot\bm{e}^{\rho}_{1}\times\bm{e}^{\rho}_{2}\neq 0, which generically holds. In [ 9 ] the authors showed that the system \bm{c}_{1}-\bm{c}_{2}={\bf 0},\quad\mu(\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{1}-\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{2})={\bf 0},\quad\widetilde{\cal E}_{1}-\widetilde{\cal E}_{2}=0, (3) obtained from ( 2 ) neglecting the last two equations, is still over-determined but nevertheless consistent, i.e. it generically admits solutions in the complex field, even when the two VSAs do not belong to the same celestial body. The proof has been conducted by computing a Gröbner basis of the ideal I generated by the polynomials \displaystyle\mathfrak{q}_{1} \displaystyle= \displaystyle(\bm{c}_{1}-\bm{c}_{2})\cdot\bm{D}_{1}\times\bm{D}_{2}, (4) \displaystyle\mathfrak{q}_{2} \displaystyle= \displaystyle(\bm{c}_{1}-\bm{c}_{2})\cdot\bm{D}_{1}\times(\bm{D}_{1}\times\bm{D}_{2}), (5) \displaystyle\mathfrak{q}_{3} \displaystyle= \displaystyle(\bm{c}_{1}-\bm{c}_{2})\cdot\bm{D}_{2}\times(\bm{D}_{1}\times\bm{D}_{2}), (6) \displaystyle\mathfrak{q}_{4} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\mu(\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{1}-\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{2})\cdot\bm{e}^{\rho}_{1}\times\bm{e}^{\rho}_{2}, (7) \displaystyle\mathfrak{q}_{5} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\mu(\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{1}-\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{2})\cdot\bm{D}_{2}, (8) \displaystyle\mathfrak{q}_{6} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\mu(\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{1}-\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{2})\cdot\bm{D}_{1}, (9) \displaystyle\mathfrak{q}_{7} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\widetilde{{\cal E}}_{1}-\widetilde{{\cal E}}_{2} (10) for the lexicographic (for short, lex) ordering with \dot{\rho}_{1}\succ\dot{\rho}_{2}\succ z_{1}\succ z_{2}\succ\rho_{1}\succ\rho_{2}. (11) The selected projections of \bm{c}_{1}-\bm{c}_{2} and \mu(\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{1}-\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{2}) have the purpose of simplifying the polynomials in the system, in fact \displaystyle\mathfrak{q}_{1} \displaystyle= \displaystyle q(\rho_{1},\rho_{2}), (12) \displaystyle\mathfrak{q}_{2} \displaystyle= \displaystyle|\bm{D}_{1}\times\bm{D}_{2}|^{2}\dot{\rho}_{1}-\bm{J}(\rho_{1},\rho_{2})\cdot\bm{D}_{1}\times(\bm{D}_{1}\times\bm{D}_{2}), (13) \displaystyle\mathfrak{q}_{3} \displaystyle= \displaystyle|\bm{D}_{1}\times\bm{D}_{2}|^{2}\dot{\rho}_{2}-\bm{J}(\rho_{1},\rho_{2})\cdot\bm{D}_{2}\times(\bm{D}_{1}\times\bm{D}_{2}), (14) where q and \bm{J} are defined as in [ 10 ] and are reported in Appendix B for completeness. Both q and the three components of \bm{J} are quadratic forms in the variables \rho_{1},\rho_{2} , without the mixed monomial \rho_{1}\rho_{2} . The projections of \mu(\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{1}-\widetilde{\bm{L}}_{2}) can be written as follows: \displaystyle\mathfrak{q}_{4} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-(\bm{D}_{1}\cdot\bm{e}^{\rho}_{2})z_{1}-(\bm{D}_{2}\cdot\bm{e}^{\rho}_{1})z_{2}+\mathfrak{f}_{4}, \displaystyle\mathfrak{q}_{5} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-(\bm{D}_{2}\cdot\bm{r}_{1})z_{1}+\mathfrak{f}_{5}, \displaystyle\mathfrak{q}_{6} \displaystyle= \displaystyle(\bm{D}_{1}\cdot\bm{r}_{2})z_{2}+\mathfrak{f}_{6}, for three polynomials \mathfrak{f}_{4} , \mathfrak{f}_{5} , \mathfrak{f}_{6} in the variables \rho_{1},\rho_{2},\dot{\rho}_{1},\dot{\rho}_{2} defined by \begin{split}\mathfrak{f}_{4}&=\left[|\dot{\bm{r}}_{1}|^{2}\bm{r}_{1}-(\dot{\bm{r}}_{1}\cdot\bm{r}_{1})\dot{\bm{r}}_{1}-|\dot{\bm{r}}_{2}|^{2}\bm{r}_{2}+(\dot{\bm{r}}_{2}\cdot\bm{r}_{2})\dot{\bm{r}}_{2}\right]\cdot\bm{e}^{\rho}_{1}\times\bm{e}^{\rho}_{2},\cr\mathfrak{f}_{5}&=\left[|\dot{\bm{r}}_{1}|^{2}\bm{r}_{1}-(\dot{\bm{r}}_{1}\cdot\bm{r}_{1})\dot{\bm{r}}_{1}+(\dot{\bm{r}}_{2}\cdot\bm{r}_{2})\dot{\bm{r}}_{2}\right]\cdot\bm{D}_{2},\cr\mathfrak{f}_{6}&=[-(\dot{\bm{r}}_{1}\cdot\bm{r}_{1})\dot{\bm{r}}_{1}-|\dot{\bm{r}}_{2}|^{2}\bm{r}_{2}+(\dot{\bm{r}}_{2}\cdot\bm{r}_{2})\dot{\bm{r}}_{2}]\cdot\bm{D}_{1}.\cr\end{split} We can obtain a Gröbner basis

Read the complete text