Effects of Ill-Defined Domain of Definitions of the Parameter Operator on Berry Curvature and the Adiabatic Theorem

Georgios Konstantinou, Konstantinos Moulopoulos · 2025

Read Effects of Ill-Defined Domain of Definitions of the Parameter Operator on Berry Curvature and the Adiabatic Theorem by Georgios Konstantinou, Konstantinos Moulopoulos (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-20679.txt.

Introduction

Georgios Konstantinou and Konstantinos Moulopoulos wrote a paper from 2025 on a subtle flaw in a standard tool of quantum physics. The tool, called Berry curvature, tracks how a system's states twist as its settings change. It is drawn from the states themselves by a set recipe. The pair show that the recipe can go wrong where the operator for a setting is not well defined across its whole range.

Handled with care, those problem zones can change the curvature a great deal. Even a system whose core rule shows no link to the setting can end up with a nonzero twist. The lesson is that the curvature lives in the states, not in the core rule as such. The team works the point from first steps in the standard frame for crystals, where settings are wave-like. They close by weighing what the shift may mean for solid materials.

Catalog record

CREATORGeorgios Konstantinou, Konstantinos Moulopoulos
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE46 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-20679

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Effects of Ill-Defined Domain of Definitions of the Parameter Operator on Berry Curvature and the Adiabatic Theorem Georgios Konstantinou, Konstantinos Moulopoulos Abstract We present a comprehensive analytical study that extends the conventional formulation of Berry curvature, highlighting its derivation in the context of problematic domains of definition of the operators. Our analysis reveals that handling these domains carefully can have a substantial impact on Berry curvature, demonstrating that even Hamiltonians without explicit parameter dependence may exhibit nonzero Berry curvature. This finding emphasizes that Berry curvature is intrinsically related to the eigenvectors rather than the Hamiltonian itself. Our approach utilizes the standard Bloch ( k → \vec{k} -space) framework for spatially periodic systems, illustrating these effects from first principles and discussing potential implications for solid-state systems. 1 Introduction In time-dependent quantum systems, the adiabatic theorem asserts that adiabaticity is preserved if no inter-level transitions occur. Specifically, if a system is initially in a single eigenstate, it will remain in that eigenstate throughout the parameter evolution until the final time T (which in the literature corresponds to a cyclic process). Each eigenstate |n(\vec{R})\rangle , assumed single-valued in parameter space, is defined by the eigenvalue equation: H(\vec{R})|n(\vec{R})\rangle=\epsilon_{n}(\vec{R})|n(\vec{R})\rangle (1) where \vec{R}=\vec{R}(t) is a collective time-dependent parameter vector, valid for all times t\in[0,T] . The adiabaticity condition (no transitions to other states n+1,n-1,\ldots ) holds due to the vanishing of the rightmost term in the following equation, derived from substituting |\Psi\rangle=\sum_{n}c_{n}(t)|n\rangle into the Schrödinger equation: \dot{c}_{m}(t)=c_{m}(t)\left(-i\frac{\epsilon_{m}}{\hbar}-\langle m|\dot{m}\rangle\right)-i\hbar\sum_{n\neq m}c_{n}(t)\langle m|\dot{n}\rangle (2) Here, \langle m|\dot{n}\rangle\ll 1 is the standard condition for adiabaticity. Several studies have attempted to quantify ’how small’, with results often being contradictory [ 3 ] . By manipulating this term, one incorporates the time derivative of the Hamiltonian into the adiabaticity condition: \dot{H}|n\rangle+H|\dot{n}\rangle=\dot{\epsilon}_{n}|n\rangle+\epsilon_{n}|\dot{n}\rangle (3) Taking the inner product with \langle m| , with m\neq n , and using orthonormality, we find: \langle m|\dot{H}|n\rangle+\langle m|H|\dot{n}\rangle=\epsilon_{n}\langle m|\dot{n}\rangle (4) For a Hermitian Hamiltonian H=H^{\dagger} , we have: \langle m|H|\dot{n}\rangle=\epsilon_{m}\langle m|\dot{n}\rangle (5) so the adiabatic transition matrix element becomes: \langle m|\dot{n}\rangle=\frac{\langle m|\dot{H}|n\rangle}{\epsilon_{n}-\epsilon_{m}} (6) When time dependence arises only through parameters, the derivative becomes: \langle m|\nabla_{\vec{R}}|n\rangle=\frac{\langle m|\nabla_{\vec{R}}H|n\rangle}{\epsilon_{n}-\epsilon_{m}} (7) The Berry connection and curvature are then defined as [ 1 ] : \vec{A}=i\langle n|\nabla_{\vec{R}}|n\rangle (8) \vec{\Omega}=\nabla_{\vec{R}}\times\vec{A} (9) An alternative expression for Berry curvature is: \vec{\Omega}=i\sum_{m\neq n}\langle\nabla_{\vec{R}}n|m\rangle\times\langle m|\nabla_{\vec{R}}n\rangle (10) Using Eq. (7), we obtain: \vec{\Omega}=i\sum_{m\neq n}\frac{\langle n|\nabla_{\vec{R}}H|m\rangle\times\langle m|\nabla_{\vec{R}}H|n\rangle}{(\epsilon_{n}-\epsilon_{m})^{2}} (11) This standard form suggests that Berry curvature depends on the Hamiltonian and its derivatives. However, in cases where H is parameter-independent (as in the standard Bloch Hamiltonian in solids), the right-hand side of Eq. (11) is zero. This contradicts the fact that Berry curvature is often non-zero in such systems. To resolve this, we revisit the derivation and note subtleties arising from the domain of definition of the operators involved. Specifically, the conventional assumption that all operators act on a common, well-defined domain can break down in parameter-dependent systems. In particular, while the Hamiltonian H remains Hermitian throughout, the parameter-derivative operator \nabla_{\vec{R}} may act on eigenstates |n(\vec{R})\rangle that lie outside the domain of H . This mismatch leads to nontrivial corrections when evaluating matrix elements involving \nabla_{\vec{R}} . To account for these domain-related subtleties, we define a correction term: \vec{\Delta}_{m,n}=\langle m|H|\nabla_{\vec{R}}n\rangle-\langle Hm|\nabla_{\vec{R}}n\rangle (12) This term vanishes only when the action of H on |m\rangle and its adjoint action on |\nabla_{\vec{R}}n\rangle are both well-defined and compatible—i.e., when the relevant wavefunctions and their parameter derivatives all reside within the domain of H . Therefore, \vec{\Delta}_{m,n} does not signal any failure of Hermiticity of the Hamiltonian itself, but rather exposes an inconsistency in the domain of the parameter derivative operator. A physically important and illustrative example is when the parameter \vec{R} is the crystal momentum \vec{k} in a periodic solid. The standard Bloch Hamiltonian H(\vec{k}) , often written in the form: H(\vec{k})=\frac{1}{2m}\left(-i\hbar\nabla+\hbar\vec{k}\right)^{2}+V(\vec{r}) is commonly treated as Hermitian for each \vec{k} . However, the operation \nabla_{\vec{k}}|u_{n,\vec{k}}\rangle , where |u_{n,\vec{k}}\rangle is the periodic part of the Bloch function, can produce a vector that lies outside the domain of H , particularly due to boundary or gauge ambiguities associated with the Bloch wavefunctions. In this case, even though H(\vec{k}) itself has no explicit \vec{k} -derivative terms and thus \nabla_{\vec{k}}H=0 , the Berry curvature \vec{\Omega}_{n}(\vec{k}) can be nonzero due to nonvanishing surface or boundary-like contributions encapsulated by \vec{\Delta}_{m,n} . These terms reflect how parameter variations affect the structure of the eigenstates, even when the Hamiltonian is independent of the parameter in a formal sense. This analysis demonstrates that Berry curvature is fundamentally an eigenstate property, and its nontrivial structure can originate from subtle domain issues in the differentiation with respect to parameters—especially in systems with periodicity, boundary constraints, or gauge freedoms. This can be expressed using wavefunctions f_{n} in position representation as: \vec{\Delta}_{m,n}=\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2m}\int\nabla\left(\nabla f^{*}_{m}\nabla_{\vec{R}}f_{n}-f^{*}_{m}\nabla\nabla_{\vec{R}}f_{n}-2i\frac{e}{\hbar c}f^{*}_{m}\vec{A}\nabla_{\vec{R}}f_{n}\right)d^{3}r (13) The quantity in parentheses is a generalized current density: \vec{J}_{m,n}=\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2m}\left(\nabla f^{*}_{m}\nabla_{\vec{R}}f_{n}-f^{*}_{m}\nabla\nabla_{\vec{R}}f_{n}-2i\frac{e}{\hbar c}f^{*}_{m}\vec{A}\nabla_{\vec{R}}f_{n}\right) (14) Thus, the correction becomes a surface term: \vec{\Delta}_{m,n}=\oint\vec{J}_{m,n}\cdot d\vec{S} (15) Incorporating this correction modifies the matrix element: \langle m|\nabla_{\vec{R}}|n\rangle=\frac{\langle m|\nabla_{\vec{R}}H|n\rangle+\vec{\Delta}_{m,n}}{\epsilon_{n}-\epsilon_{m}} (16) and the Berry curvature becomes: \vec{\Omega}^{n}=i\sum_{m\neq n}\frac{(\langle n|\nabla_{\vec{R}}H|m\rangle+\vec{\Delta}_{n,m})\times(\langle m|\nabla_{\vec{R}}H|n\rangle+\vec{\Delta}_{m,n})}{(\epsilon_{n}-\epsilon_{m})^{2}} (17) This expression restores nonzero Berry curvature even in the absence of explicit parameter dependence in H , thus resolving the inconsistency. It confirms that Berry curvature fundamentally arises from the eigenvectors and their boundary behaviors, and not just from explicit parametric dependence in the Hamiltonian. 2 Revised Adiabatic Theorem Referring to Equation (2) for the adiabatic theorem, and exploring the generalized adiabaticity conditions as previously mentioned, we note that the following relation is also valid: \langle m|\dot{n}\rangle=\frac{\langle m|\dot{H}|n\rangle+\Delta_{m,n}}{\epsilon_{n}-\epsilon_{m}} (18) Thus, the extended version of the ordinary adiabaticity condition must be: \left|\frac{\langle m|\dot{H}|n\rangle+\Delta_{m,n}}{\epsilon_{n}-\epsilon_{m}}\right|\ll 1 (19) This highlights the necessity of incorporating the corrective term \Delta_{m,n} , which originates not from any non-Hermitian behavior of H , but rather from subtleties in the domain of definition of the operator \nabla_{\vec{R}} , or more generally, of the parameter-derivative operator acting on the eigenstates. This is especially critical in systems where \dot{H} vanishes — such as the Bloch problem — and yet adiabatic transport still occurs. For illustration, consider the standard Bloch problem with the Hamiltonian: H=\frac{p^{2}}{2m}+V(\vec{r}) (20) where V(\vec{r}) is the periodic potential of the crystal. The eigenfunctions of this Hamiltonian are the well-known Bloch states: f_{n,\vec{k}}(\vec{r})=u_{n,\vec{k}}(\vec{r})\exp(i\vec{k}\cdot\vec{r}) , with u_{n,\vec{k}} being the cell-periodic functions. Importantly, the Hamiltonian H does not explicitly depend on the crystal momentum \vec{k} ; rather, the \vec{k} -dependence appears entirely in the eigenfunctions. If one were to compute adiabaticity conditions using only \langle m|\dot{H}|n\rangle , the result would be zero, incorrectly suggesting a lack of dynamical response to changes in \vec{k}(t) . However, using the corrected Equation (18), which includes \Delta_{m,n} , yields a meaningful, non-zero result even in the absence of explicit time-dependence in H . This correction captures the nontrivial role played by the domains of the derivative operator \nabla_{\vec{k}} , which acts on wavefunctions that may lie outside the strict domain of H . For simplicity, considering a one-dimensional Bloch solid, the following explicit result is obtained (see Appendix A for the derivation): \Delta_{n^{\prime}k^{\prime},nk}=\frac{\hbar}{m}\left[\langle p\rangle_{n^{\prime}k^{\prime},nk}+\frac{im}{\hbar}(\epsilon_{nk}-\epsilon_{n^{\prime}k^{\prime}})\langle x\rangle_{n^{\prime}k^{\prime},nk}\right] (21) where \langle p\rangle_{n^{\prime}k^{\prime},nk} and \langle x\rangle_{n^{\prime}k^{\prime},nk} are the off-diagonal elements of the momentum and position operators, respectively. It is noteworthy that when using the explicitly \vec{k} -dependent Hamiltonian H(k) instead, the correction term \Delta vanishes. This is due

Read the complete text