Ribbon knots and iterated cables of fibered knots

Jennifer Hom, JungHwan Park · 2025

Read Ribbon knots and iterated cables of fibered knots by Jennifer Hom, JungHwan Park (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-20455.txt.

Introduction

Jennifer Hom and JungHwan Park present a 2025 math paper on knots, closed loops studied up to smooth bending. They work with fibered knots and with ribbon knots, and they define a new sharpness test based on a known knot measure and a genus value.

Their main result links sums of such knots to a simple paired form. From that link they draw a sharp choice for the field. Either repeated cable knots built from tight fibered knots stay distinct in the smooth concordance group, or a long open guess about slice and ribbon knots fails. The paper gives knot theory a clean test case.

Catalog record

CREATORJennifer Hom, JungHwan Park
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-20455

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Ribbon knots and iterated cables of fibered knots Jennifer Hom, JungHwan Park Abstract . We define a knot to be γ 0 \gamma_{0} -sharp if its Seifert genus is detected by the concordance invariant γ 0 \gamma_{0} , which arises from the immersed curve formalism in bordered Heegaard Floer homology. We show that a connected sum of γ 0 \gamma_{0} -sharp fibered knots is ribbon exactly when it is of the form K # − K K\mathbin{\#}-K . Consequently, either iterated cables of tight fibered knots are linearly independent in the smooth concordance group, or the slice–ribbon conjecture fails. 1. Introduction A knot in the three-sphere S^{3} is called slice if it bounds a smoothly embedded disk in the four-ball B^{4} , and ribbon if it bounds an immersed disk in S^{3} with only ribbon singularities. Since resolving the ribbon singularities naturally yields a smooth slicing disk, every ribbon knot is necessarily slice. One of the most significant open problems in low-dimensional topology, originally posed by Fox [ 14 , Problem 25] , asks whether the converse is also true. This question is known as the slice-ribbon conjecture . By applying the celebrated theorem of Casson and Gordon [ 8 ] , which states that a fibered knot in a homology sphere is homotopically ribbon 1 1 1 A knot in a homology sphere is called homotopically ribbon if it bounds a smooth disk in a homology four-ball, where the inclusion of the knot complement into the disk complement induces a surjective map on the fundamental group. Note that every ribbon knot in the three-sphere is homotopically ribbon. if and only if its closed monodromy extends over a handlebody, many interesting non-ribbon knots have been constructed. For a large number of them, the sliceness problem remains unresolved to this day. For instance, Miyazaki [ 40 ] proved that a connected sum of iterated cables of torus knots is not ribbon unless it is of the form K\mathbin{\#}-K , where K is a knot and -K denotes its mirror image with reversed orientation. In contrast, the sliceness problem for connected sums of iterated cables of torus knots remains widely open. In particular, a well-known and long-standing conjecture of Rudolph [ 58 ] states that the set of algebraic knots, which are in particular iterated cables of torus knots, is linearly independent in the smooth knot concordance group. About ten years ago, Miyazaki’s result was strengthened by Baker [ 3 ] , who proved that the same holds for connected sums of fibered knots supporting the tight contact structure. For simplicity, we will refer to such knots as tight fibered knots throughout this article. This led to a stronger version of Rudolph’s conjecture, which states that prime tight fibered knots are linearly independent in the smooth knot concordance group (see [ 3 , Corollary 5] and [ 1 , Lemma 3.1] ). In this article, we provide additional examples of fibered knots that are not ribbon, using the results of Casson and Gordon [ 8 ] and Miyazaki [ 40 ] , combined with the concordance invariant \gamma_{0} , which arises from the interpretation of bordered Floer homology [ 36 ] via immersed curves by Hanselman, Rasmussen, and Watson [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] . We define a knot K to be \gamma_{0} -sharp if its Seifert genus agrees with the maximal Alexander grading of the summand of the knot Floer complex associated to \gamma_{0}(K) ; that is, the Seifert genus is determined by \gamma_{0} . In particular, every tight fibered knot is \gamma_{0} -sharp (see Remark 2.2 ). Theorem 1.1 . A connected sum of \gamma_{0} -sharp fibered knots is ribbon if and only if it is of the form K\mathbin{\#}-K . For the proof, we revisit a key step in [ 3 , Lemma 2] , where Baker establishes the minimality of tight fibered knots with respect to homotopy ribbon concordance among all fibered knots in S^{3} , and we extend this result to \gamma_{0} -sharp knots. Here, given two knots K_{0}\subset Y_{0} and K_{1}\subset Y_{1} , where Y_{0} and Y_{1} are homology spheres, we say that K_{1} is homotopy ribbon concordant to K_{0} if there exists a smooth annulus A in a homology cobordism X from Y_{0} to Y_{1} such that (\partial X,A\cap\partial X)=(Y_{1},K_{1})\sqcup-(Y_{0},K_{0}), and the inclusion-induced maps \pi_{1}(Y_{0}\smallsetminus K_{0})\hookrightarrow\pi_{1}(X\smallsetminus A)\qquad\text{and}\qquad\pi_{1}(Y_{1}\smallsetminus K_{1})\twoheadrightarrow\pi_{1}(X\smallsetminus A) are injective and surjective, respectively. Note that homotopy ribbon concordance generalizes the notion of ribbon concordance , introduced by Gordon [ 17 , Lemma 3.1] , which was later shown by Agol [ 2 , Theorem 1.1] to define a partial order. Furthermore, we prove that \gamma_{0} -sharpness is preserved under satelliting by 1-bridge braided patterns, which include cabling (see Proposition 2.6 ). In particular, iterated cables of tight fibered knots remain \gamma_{0} -sharp, even though they are no longer tight fibered when the cabling parameter is negative. As a consequence, combining this fact with the main theorem yields a new family of non-ribbon knots: Corollary 1.2 . Either distinct iterated cables of tight fibered knots are linearly independent in the smooth knot concordance group, or the slice-ribbon conjecture is false. In the following corollary, we present a special case of Corollary 1.2 , which provides many simple and interesting new examples of non-ribbon knots whose sliceness is not easily detected. Notably, all of these knots are algebraically slice. Throughout this article, we use the notation K_{p,q} to denote the (p,q) -cable of a knot K , where p indicates the longitudinal winding. We assume p>1 , since K_{p,q} is isotopic to K_{-p,-q} and K_{1,q} is isotopic to K . Corollary 1.3 . Let K and J be distinct iterated cables of tight fibered knots. Then, for each pair of distinct integers q_{1} and q_{2} that are relatively prime to p , the knot P(K,J,p,q_{1},q_{2}):=K_{p,q_{1}}\mathbin{\#}-K_{p,q_{2}}\mathbin{\#}J_{p,q_{2}}\mathbin{\#}-J_{p,q_{1}} is algebraically slice but not ribbon. We make two remarks on the corollary. First, we discuss the algebraic sliceness and non-ribbonness of the knots in question. The fact that the knot is algebraically slice follows from work of Livingston and Melvin [ 37 ] (see also [ 34 ] ), and holds for any choice of knots K and J and any integers p , q_{1} and q_{2} with q_{1} and q_{2} relatively prime to p . The non-ribbonness of P(K,J,p,q_{1},q_{2}) follows from work of Miyazaki [ 40 ] in the case where K and J are distinct iterated cables of torus knots, and from work of Baker [ 3 ] when K and J are distinct tight fibered knots and q_{1},q_{2}>0 , as each cable remains a tight fibered knot under these conditions. As mentioned earlier, our contribution lies in extending these results to the case where K and J are arbitrary iterated cables of tight fibered knots, and in particular, the parameters q_{1} and q_{2} are allowed to be negative integers. Secondly, while the slice–ribbon conjecture predicts that each knot from Corollary 1.3 is not slice, proving this remains challenging in general with current techniques in knot concordance. Nonetheless, notable results by Hedden, Kirk, and Livingston [ 21 ] , Conway, Kim, and Politarczyk [ 11 ] , and Zhang [ 64 ] prove that certain families

Read the complete text