Sequence-Aware Inline Measurement Attribution for Good-Bad Wafer Diagnosis DM: Big Data Management and Machine Learning

Kohei Miyaguchi ∗, Masao Joko, Rebekah Sheraw, Tsuyoshi Idé · 2025

Read Sequence-Aware Inline Measurement Attribution for Good-Bad Wafer Diagnosis DM: Big Data Management and Machine Learning by Kohei Miyaguchi ∗, Masao Joko, Rebekah Sheraw, Tsuyoshi Idé (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-20364.txt.

Introduction

Kohei Miyaguchi and co-authors hunted defect causes in chip factories in two thousand twenty-five. A wafer defect at inspection raises a hard question. Which upstream step, among thousands, went wrong? Their framework extends Shapley attribution to sequences. Standard attribution ignores step order entirely. It also leans on an arbitrary reference wafer.

Trajectory Shapley Attribution fixes both flaws. It credits measurements while respecting process sequence. The team tested it at an Albany research fab. Front-end processes supplied the experimental data. Suspect measurement items were ranked per defect type. Engineers can aim fixes at the true step. Yield losses shrink when root causes surface fast.

Catalog record

CREATORKohei Miyaguchi ∗, Masao Joko, Rebekah Sheraw, Tsuyoshi Idé
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-20364

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Sequence-Aware Inline Measurement Attribution for Good-Bad Wafer Diagnosis DM: Big Data Management and Machine Learning Kohei Miyaguchi ∗, Masao Joko, Rebekah Sheraw, Tsuyoshi Idé Abstract How can we identify problematic upstream processes when a certain type of wafer defect starts appearing at a quality checkpoint? Given the complexity of modern semiconductor manufacturing, which involves thousands of process steps, cross-process root cause analysis for wafer defects has been considered highly challenging. This paper proposes a novel framework called Trajectory Shapley Attribution (TSA), an extension of Shapley values (SV), a widely used attribution algorithm in explainable artificial intelligence research. TSA overcomes key limitations of standard SV, including its disregard for the sequential nature of manufacturing processes and its reliance on an arbitrarily chosen reference point. We applied TSA to a good-bad wafer diagnosis task in experimental front-end-of-line processes at the NY CREATES Albany NanoTech fab, aiming to identify measurement items (serving as proxies for process parameters) most relevant to abnormal defect occurrence. I Introduction Root cause analysis (RCA) of wafer defects is a key challenge throughout all stages of semiconductor manufacturing, from process integration to high-volume production. Performing RCA across multiple process steps is particularly difficult due to the complex sequence and combination of physically and chemically diverse processes, which are carried out using various equipment across hierarchical levels such as wafer, lot, and batch. RCA is often approached as a by-product of virtual metrology (VM) modeling, which aims to predict a quality metric as a function of process variables. Typically, VM is formulated as a regression or classification problem. However, existing approaches still face challenges that hinder their practicality. Regularized linear regression combined with variable selection techniques, a commonly adopted VM approach (e.g., [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] ), essentially performs variable-wise correlation analysis for attribution, disregarding the sequential nature of the processing route. While recurrent neural networks (RNNs) and Transformers can capture complex nonlinear dependencies in sequential processes (e.g., [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] ), they operate as black boxes, making input attribution a non-trivial task. Fig. 1: Defect attribution. Given a defect flag y and a set of observed in-line measurements \bm{x} , compute the responsibility score s_{i}(\bm{x}) for each measurement item as a proxy for the underlying process. To address the interpretability challenges of deep-learning-based models and facilitate actionable insights, techniques developed in the explainable artificial intelligence (XAI) research community are gaining increasing attention in semiconductor data analytics. One key approach is Shapley values (SV) [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] , which compute attribution scores for each input variable in a prediction model, given an observed input-output pair. When applied to a VM model, SV can provide valuable insights into which input variables are most responsible for an observed process quality metric. However, for cross-process defect attribution, existing approaches (e.g., [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] ) have two main limitations: they fail to respect the sequential nature of semiconductor processes and rely on an arbitrarily chosen baseline (or reference) point. These issues stem from the original modeling assumptions of SV. In this paper, we propose a model-agnostic input attribution algorithm called Trajectory Shapley Attribution (TSA) , a novel extension of SV designed for scenarios where input variables form a trajectory. As discussed later, TSA eliminates dependency on an arbitrary baseline point by incorporating a data imputation algorithm that leverages the lot-wafer hierarchy in semiconductor manufacturing. We apply our methodology to in-line measurements from a state-of-the-art front-end-of-line (FEOL) process at the Albany NanoTech fab to demonstrate the utility of our approach. II Related Work The overall framework of in-line measurement attribution aligns with advanced process control (APC), which encompasses virtual metrology (VM), variable attribution, and recipe tuning as key sub-tasks. For a recent and comprehensive review of APC, VM, and related tasks, see [ 16 ] . However, most existing studies focus on specific processes. While cross-process dependency analysis and attribution of wafer quality issues are crucial for accelerating yield improvement [ 17 ] , the vision of digital twins—namely, data-driven, semi-automated yield control—remains far from reality. In many mass production fabs, yield ramp-up still requires significant manual effort. The integration of model-agnostic XAI techniques with advanced quality prediction models is a major research trend in semiconductor analytics. This approach aims to strike an optimal balance between predictive power and interpretability. Among various XAI methods (see, e.g., [ 18 ] for a general overview), the Shapley value (SV) is the most widely used in semiconductor analytics. Torres et al. [ 12 ] and Stoner et al. [ 13 ] were among the first to leverage SV for fab-wide yield control. Lee et al. [ 14 ] applied SV to ten different regression models for yield prediction and attribution, demonstrating its model-agnostic nature. Guo et al. [ 15 ] further utilized SV for chip probing yield in a good-bad classification setting. Ironically, despite its widespread adoption, most studies treat SV as a black-box software tool, paying little attention to the validity of its modeling assumptions. We argue that the original definition of SV may not be fully appropriate for semiconductor manufacturing due to two key issues: 1) variable coalitions include physically inadmissible process routes, and 2) the default baseline value in SHAP, a popular Python implementation [ 11 ] , disregards the wafer-lot hierarchy. The proposed Trajectory Shapley Attribution (TSA) addresses these limitations. Finally, the Transformer architecture has recently gained attention in semiconductor analytics [ 4 , 5 ] due to its ability to directly model dependencies between sequential input variables via the self-attention mechanism [ 19 ] . However, Transformers are known to be even more data-hungry than RNNs. It remains an open question whether Transformers provide reliable predictive performance in semiconductor applications, given the challenge of extremely low effective sample sizes, as discussed in Sec. III-B . For instance, Han et al. [ 5 ] evaluated their proposed Transformer-based VM model using only 344 training samples and 36 validation samples—orders of magnitude smaller than the “internet-scale” datasets used in text, speech, and vision domains, where RNN and Transformer architectures have demonstrated remarkable success [ 20 , 21 ] . Moreover, in the VM setting, Transformer input ‘tokens’ are aggregated in some manner to predict the target variable, introducing an additional explainability challenge. III Problem Setting This section outlines the machine learning tasks we address and the key modeling assumptions. III-A Attribution vs. Prediction The attribution task considered in this paper is defined as follows: Definition III.1 (In-line measurement attribution) . Given a binary wafer quality label y\in\{0,1\} and a set of in-line measurements \bm{x}\in\mathbb{R}^{D} (i.e., a D -dimensional real-valued vector), compute the attribution score s_{i}(\bm{x}) that quantifies the contribution of each measurement item i=1,\ldots,D to the outcome y , serving as a proxy for the underlying process. Here, the binary label is defined as 1 for bad wafers and 0 for good wafers. As illustrated in Fig. 1 , each measurement tool is associated with a specific processing tool and acts as its proxy. Some measurements may be performed multiple times on the same wafer due to reentrant processes. In such cases, only the latest observations are retained, allowing the in-line measurement history to

Read the complete text