Analytic structure of stress-energy response functions and new Kubo formulae
Sangyong Jeon, Alina Czajka, Juhee Hong · 2025
Read Analytic structure of stress-energy response functions and new Kubo formulae by Sangyong Jeon, Alina Czajka, Juhee Hong (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-20302.txt.
Introduction
Sangyong Jeon, Alina Czajka, and Juhee Hong study the math behind how a hot, dense form of matter flows, in a 2025 paper. The matter forms when heavy atomic nuclei crash at high speed. Its flow traits, such as thickness under shear, are found through formulas that need response functions for stress and energy. Knowing the exact shape of those functions is a must before the formulas can be trusted.
Using energy-saving laws and results from gravity-based models, the team pins down the shape of all such functions at low rates and long waves. They match those shapes against flow models of second and third order. That match yields new versions of the classic formulas for the case where the rate limit is taken first. The authors also show how the sense of some formulas can shift when higher-order terms enter the flow model.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sangyong Jeon, Alina Czajka, Juhee Hong |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-20302
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Analytic structure of stress-energy response functions and new Kubo formulae Sangyong Jeon, Alina Czajka, Juhee Hong Abstract Determining the transport properties of Quark-Gluon Plasma is one of the most important aspects of relativistic heavy ion collision studies. Field-theoretical calculations of the transport coefficients such as the shear and bulk viscosities require Kubo formulae which in turn require real-time correlation functions of stress-energy tensors. Consequently, knowing the analytic structure of these correlation functions is essential in any such studies. Using the energy-conservation laws and the results from the gravity-hydrodynamics analysis, we determine the low-frequency and low-wavenumber analytic structures of all stress-energy correlation functions in the rest frame of the medium. By comparing with the diffusion and sound spectra from the second-order and the third-order relativistic hydrodynamics, various new Kubo formulae are derived in the limit where the zero-frequency limit is taken first. We also show that the meaning of the Kubo formulae for relaxation times can change when higher-order terms are added to hydrodynamics. A subtle issue of taking the zero frequency and zero wavenumber limits when using skeleton diagrams is addressed as well. I Introduction The main purpose of studying relativistic heavy ion collisions is to determine the properties of Quark-Gluon Plasma (QGP). Among the QGP properties, the equation of state and the transport coefficients are the most studied in relativistic heavy ion collisions. The QGP equation of state can be reliably calculated on the lattice up to the electroweak scale as it only involves the calculation of the stress-energy tensor average Borsanyi et al. 2014 ; Bazavov et al. 2014 ; Bazavov et al. 2018 ; Bresciani et al. 2025 . Field theoretical calculations of transport coefficients, however, are more complex as they need to use the Kubo formulae involving real-time correlation functions. Kubo formulae have been a staple of theoretical physics ever since it was first derived Kubo et al. 1957 ; Kubo 1957 ; Kadanoff and Martin 1963 . Relativistic field theory calculations of viscosities using the Kubo formulae have a correspondingly long history Hosoya et al. 1984 ; Hosoya and Kajantie 1985 ; Karsch and Wyld 1987 ; Jeon 1995 ; Jeon and Yaffe 1996 ; Wang and Heinz 1999 ; Carrington et al. 2000 ; Wang and Heinz 2003 ; Arnold et al. 2000 ; Arnold et al. 2003 ; Nakamura and Sakai 2005 ; Arnold et al. 2006 ; Huot et al. 2007 ; Meyer 2008 ; Meyer 2007 ; Meyer 2011 ; Gagnon and Jeon 2007 ; Liu et al. 2008 ; Carrington and Kovalchuk 2009 ; Carrington and Kovalchuk 2010 ; Lu and Moore 2011 ; Chen et al. 2013 ; Lang and Weise 2014 ; Christiansen et al. 2015 ; Jeon and Heinz 2015 ; Francis et al. 2015 ; Czajka and Jeon 2017 ; Czajka et al. 2018 ; Harutyunyan et al. 2017 ; Harutyunyan and Sedrakian 2017 ; Astrakhantsev et al. 2017 ; Czajka et al. 2019 ; Czajka et al. 2020 ; Ghiglieri et al. 2018 ; Astrakhantsev et al. 2018 ; Romatschke 2021 ; Altenkort et al. 2023 ; Danhoni and Moore 2024 ; Pavan et al. 2025 ; Kovtun et al. 2005 ; Buchel 2008 . The standard Kubo formulae for the shear and the bulk viscosities can be derived by considering the analytic structure of stress-energy tensor correlation functions in the the small-wavenumber ( \displaystyle k=|{\bf k}| ) and small-frequency ( \displaystyle\omega ) limit. Such derivations so far (for instance, see Jeon 1995 ; Jeon and Heinz 2015 ) have used a limited amount of information on how the correlation functions depend on the transport coefficients. Recently, more information on the structure of the correlation functions became available due to the new developments in the gravity-hydrodynamic analysis Baier et al. 2008 ; York and Moore 2009 ; Hong and Teaney 2010 ; Moore and Sohrabi 2011 ; Moore and Sohrabi 2012 ; Romatschke 2016 ; Kleinert and Probst 2016 ; Romatschke and Romatschke 2019 ; Romatschke 2019 ; Weiner and Romatschke 2023 as well as the third order relativistic hydrodynamics de Brito and Denicol 2023 ; Brito and Denicol 2022 ; Jaiswal 2013 ; Panday et al. 2024 ; El et al. 2010 ; Ye et al. 2024 ; Younus and Muronga 2020 ; Chattopadhyay et al. 2015 ; Diles et al. 2020 ; Diles et al. 2024 ; Grozdanov and Kaplis 2016 . To take advantage of the new information, one needs to understand the analytic structure of the stress-energy tensor correlation functions more thoroughly. The main purpose of this work is to determine the general analytic structure of the correlation functions that are compatible with the new information from the gravity-hydrodynamics and the third-order hydrodynamics. By doing so, we are able to derive a number of new Kubo-formulae for the viscosities as we will show below. Interestingly, in most of the new formulae, the order of the limits is reversed. That is, the zero \displaystyle\omega limit is taken first instead of the zero \displaystyle k limit. Schematically, the usual Kubo formula takes the following form \displaystyle\displaystyle\gamma_{A} \displaystyle\displaystyle=iC_{A}\lim_{\omega\to 0}\lim_{k\to 0}\partial_{\omega}G_{R}^{\hat{A}\hat{A}}(\omega,{\bf k}) (1) where \displaystyle\hat{A} is the operator that is coupled to an external force that introduces a perturbation to the underlying equilibrium system. The retarded correlation function \displaystyle G_{R}^{\hat{A}\hat{A}}(\omega,{\bf k}) is calculated in equilibrium, and \displaystyle\gamma_{A} is the transport coefficient that controls the speed of dissipation of the perturbation. The coefficient \displaystyle C_{A} is an \displaystyle O(1) constant. The \displaystyle\omega -derivative is present because the Kubo formula above is actually about the small \displaystyle\omega behaviour of the spectral density defined as twice the imaginary part of the retarded correlation function. The order of the limits in Eq.( 1 ) corresponds to the thermodynamic limit where the zero \displaystyle k limit (equivalently, the infinite volume limit) is taken before the zero \displaystyle\omega limit. The two limits usually do not commute. There was, however, an exception. In Ref. Baier et al. 2008 and many subsequent papers Romatschke 2016 ; Romatschke 2019 ; Weiner and Romatschke 2023 ; Romatschke and Romatschke 2019 ; Moore and Sohrabi 2012 one finds the following expansion of a retarded correlation function of the stress-energy tensor component \displaystyle\hat{T}^{xy} \displaystyle\displaystyle G_{R}^{xy,xy}(\omega,k_{z})=-i\eta\omega+\eta\tau_{\pi}\omega^{2}-\left({\kappa\over 2}-\kappa^{*}\right)\omega^{2}-{\kappa\over 2}k_{z}^{2} (2) where \displaystyle\eta is the shear viscosity, \displaystyle\tau_{\pi} is the corresponding relaxation time, and \displaystyle\kappa and \displaystyle\kappa^{*} are additional transport coefficients, and we have omitted the higher order terms. 1 1 1 We follow the convention where only the non-zero components of the arguments are displayed in a function of a 4-vector. Thus, \displaystyle G_{R}^{xy,xy}(\omega,k_{z}) means that \displaystyle k^{\mu}=(\omega,0,0,k_{z}) . At first glance, this looks like a reasonable representation of the shear response function in the small \displaystyle\omega and small \displaystyle k limit. However, if the two limits do not commute, one must specify whether this expansion assumes \displaystyle k>\omega or \displaystyle k<\omega . Careful inspection of the derivation of Eq.( 2 ) reveals that the expansion above is perfectly valid, which seems to indicate that the two limits do commute, at least for this specific case. Hence, the following alternate form of the Kubo formula should work \displaystyle\displaystyle\eta \displaystyle\displaystyle=i\lim_{k_{z}\to 0}\lim_{\omega\to 0}\partial_{\omega}G_{R}^{xy,xy}(\omega,k_{z}) (3) as well as the usual one with the \displaystyle k_{z}\to 0 limit taken first. Eq.( 3 )