A Blockchain-Based Quality Control Model for Online Collaboration Systems
Sadegh Sohani, Maliheh Shahryari, Salar Ghazi, Mohammad Allahbakhsh, Haleh Amintoosi, Boualem Benatallah · 2025
Read A Blockchain-Based Quality Control Model for Online Collaboration Systems by Sadegh Sohani, Maliheh Shahryari, Salar Ghazi, Mohammad Allahbakhsh, Haleh Amintoosi, Boualem Benatallah (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-20265.txt.
Introduction
Sadegh Sohani and co-authors put quality control for group writing on a blockchain, in this 2025 paper. Teams now write papers and documents together online, and judging the quality of the result matters. Most judging systems run from one center, which raises worries about tampering, privacy, and downtime. A blockchain's shared, sealed ledger offers another base.
Their model scores each artifact's quality and each contributor's reputation together, each feeding the other in rounds. It targets known academic headaches such as gamed citations and murky credit. Against two classic ranking methods the scores held up comparably, and extra tests covered speed, delay handling, and resistance to bad actors. The authors argue the design is ready for real scholarly use.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sadegh Sohani, Maliheh Shahryari, Salar Ghazi, Mohammad Allahbakhsh, Haleh Amintoosi, Boualem Benatallah |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-20265
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Blockchain-Based Quality Control Model for Online Collaboration Systems Sadegh Sohani, Maliheh Shahryari, Salar Ghazi, Mohammad Allahbakhsh, Haleh Amintoosi, Boualem Benatallah Abstract Collaborative content generation (CCG) enables collective creation of artifacts like scientific articles. Quality is a paramount concern in CCG, and a multitude of methods have been proposed to evaluate the quality of artifacts. Nevertheless, the majority of these methods are reliant on centralized architectures, which present challenges pertaining to security, privacy, and availability. Blockchain technology proffers a potential resolution to these challenges, by furnishing a decentralized and immutable ledger of quality scores. In this manuscript, we introduce a blockchain-based quality control model for CCG that uses a semi-iterative algorithm to interdependently compute quality scores of artifacts and reputation of nodes. Our model addresses critical challenges in academic informetrics, such as citation manipulation, transparency in collaborative scholarship, and decentralized trust in metric computation. Our model also exhibits sensitivity to processing latency, rendering it more agile in the presence of delays. Our model’s quality scores, evaluated against PageRank and HITS baselines, show comparable performance, with additional assessments of throughput, latency, and robustness against malicious nodes confirming its reliability. A theoretical comparison with recent studies validates its feasibility for real-world informetric application. keywords Quality Control, Online Collaboration, Blockchain, Consensus Algorithm 1 Introduction Collaborative problem-solving and decision-making is known as ”Collective Intelligence (CI)” 1 . This concept has been applied to various research domains, such as sociology, psychology, biology, tourism, management, economics, computer science, game theory, and more 2 ; 3 ; 4 ; 5 . The development of information and communication technologies, such as Web 2.0, semantic web, and crowdsourcing, has enabled large-scale collaborations in the online space. These technologies allow individual users and groups to share knowledge, solve problems, and make decisions through web-based interactions and collaborations. In a specific form of such collaborations, collaborative content generation (CCG), a group of contributors work together to create content 1 ; 5 ; 6 . We refer to such collaboratively created content as artifacts. Some examples of CCG are scientific articles, Wikipedia, and Github. In CCG systems, there are two forms of collaborations: synchronous and asynchronous 7 . In synchronous collaboration, contributors collaborate intentionally and simultaneously in the content creation process. Writing research articles is an example of synchronous collaboration, where researchers work together on the same document. In asynchronous collaboration, an artifact is created by one contributor, and then modified by other contributors over time, without explicit coordination. These artifacts can be original or derived from existing ones, creating parent-child relationships among them. Wikipedia and Github are examples of asynchronous collaborative systems 7 ; 8 ; 9 . Blockchain technology provides a decentralized, tamper-proof framework for managing data through a distributed ledger, where transactions are recorded immutably across a network of nodes. Various ledger structures, such as linear blockchains and Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs), enable flexible data management tailored to specific application needs. Consensus algorithms ensure agreement among nodes on the ledger’s state, enabling trustless collaboration without a central authority bcsurvey ; sciot2024cons . One of the main challenges of CCG systems is how to ensure the quality of the content 10 ; 11 . Quality control is difficult in CCG systems, as the contributors may have different backgrounds, expertise, motivations, and incentives. Moreover, the content may be complex, dynamic, and interrelated, requiring constant evaluation and revision. The proliferation of preprint repositories, open peer review platforms, and collaborative authorship tools underscores the need for decentralized, tamper-proof quality assessment, a gap our blockchain-based model seeks to fill. Various techniques and methods have been proposed to address this challenge, by leveraging human feedback, content, the network structure and the relationships between entities to calculate dependable quality metrics. The earlier approaches, simple aggregations, weighted aggregations, and heuristics attempted to aggregate direct or indirect human feedback to compute quality scores QQ ; AQA ; wikitrust . However, these techniques have several limitations. Mainly, they are prone to manipulation. To overcome this problem, iterative techniques are proposed, in which network structure and the relationships between entities are employed to calculate interdependent quality metrics, making them more resistant to manipulation than simple or weighted aggregations. Some examples of such systems are PageRank pagerank , RTV RTV1 , Dekerchove Dekerchove , Laureti laureti , and SciMet 7 . However, these systems are mostly designed with centralized architectures, which result in problems such as single point of failure, lack of transparency, and high computational overhead. Systems based on blockchain technology present a promising solution to address these challenges. These systems are devoid of a singular central node, implying that even in the event of failure of one or multiple computational nodes or servers, the remaining nodes retain the ability to compute metrics and disseminate scores. Furthermore, blockchain technology facilitates collaboration among individuals lacking mutual trust, eliminating the necessity for a central and impartial authority bcsurvey . Owing to the distributed architecture of blockchain, any modifications to the data necessitate network consensus, thereby bolstering security against attacks and attempts at data alteration. These attributes render blockchain a unique technology with particular relevance in CCG systems. Nevertheless, systems based on blockchain technology are not without their challenges. Primarily, iterative techniques are computationally intensive and time-consuming, making their execution on blockchain nodes challenging. Managing a consensus on their results also proves to be a time-consuming task. In addition, the consensus techniques currently employed in scoring systems do not adapt well to processing latency. As delay escalates, these techniques encounter difficulties and fail to reach a consensus. In addition to these challenges, CCG systems face a major obstacle concerning content quality control on a public blockchain. Sharing raw content in a completely decentralized environment can be problematic, as untrusted nodes would gain access to sensitive or confidential information. Consequently, previous approaches have often relied on private blockchains or centralized methods to ensure data confidentiality. In contrast, our model leverages a public blockchain by employing a PageRank-like mechanism that uses citation relationships among artifacts, thus avoiding the direct sharing of full content. Each artifact’s score is calculated using this citation-based approach, combined with a specialized consensus protocol. This protocol applies a genetic algorithm to select a committee of nodes, ensuring that the evaluation process remains robust, decentralized, and resistant to manipulation while still maintaining the privacy of raw data. This manuscript presents our model for quality control in CCG systems, designed to address the aforementioned issues. We propose an innovative data model that encapsulates and simplifies the comprehension of the research problem and our suggested solution. The data model is composed of a directed acyclic graph, which represents the contents and their interrelationships, and a blockchain that functions as the consensus infrastructure. We formulate an adaptive semi-iterative algorithm that operates on each node independently, calculating scores. This algorithm incorporates a convergence threshold that dictates the termination of the algorithm. This threshold is adapted to the process latency, while ensuring the system accuracy remains above a predefined acceptable threshold. Subsequently, the computed scores are dispatched to a committee of selected nodes as proposals, to be aggregated and reach a consensus. We propose a committee-based consensus algorithm that aggregates the scores received from committee nodes and generates a quality score for each content. These scores are