EMBRACE: Shaping Inclusive Opinion Representation by Aligning Implicit Conversations with Social Norms
Abeer Aldayel, Areej Alokaili · 2025
Read EMBRACE: Shaping Inclusive Opinion Representation by Aligning Implicit Conversations with Social Norms by Abeer Aldayel, Areej Alokaili (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-20264.txt.
Introduction
Abeer Aldayel and Areej Alokaili argue in a 2025 paper that opinion representation in conversation models should take in views that are only hinted at. Their framework is called EMBRACE. Taking in a wide range of voices sits at the core of many conversation-based models. Most current methods, though, rest on surface inclusion, such as naming group traits, and miss views that are expressed only between the lines.
Leaning too hard on plain cues can worsen the mismatch and feed outputs that fall back on stereotypes. The study sets out an evaluation frame for alignment that puts hinted-at conversations first. It weighs views and talk that match shared social norms, and treats the stance of a reply as a stand-in for the opinion under it. That stance is what checks the match with the norms. Readers get a way to audit inclusion past surface mentions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Abeer Aldayel, Areej Alokaili |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-20264
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
EMBRACE: Shaping Inclusive Opinion Representation by Aligning Implicit Conversations with Social Norms Abeer Aldayel, Areej Alokaili Abstract Shaping inclusive representations that embrace diversity and ensure fair participation and reflections of values is at the core of many conversation-based models. However, many existing methods rely on surface inclusion using mention of user demographics or behavioral attributes of social groups. Such methods overlook the nuanced, implicit expression of opinion embedded in conversations. Furthermore, the over-reliance on overt cues can exacerbate misalignment and reinforce harmful or stereotypical representations in model outputs. Thus, we took a step back and recognized that equitable inclusion needs to account for the implicit expression of opinion and use the stance of responses to validate the normative alignment. This study aims to evaluate how opinions are represented in NLP or computational models by introducing an alignment evaluation framework that foregrounds implicit, often overlooked conversations and evaluates the normative social views and discourse. Our approach models the stance of responses as a proxy for the underlying opinion, enabling a considerate and reflective representation of diverse social viewpoints. We evaluate the framework using both (i) positive-unlabeled (PU) online learning with base classifiers, and (ii) instruction-tuned language models to assess post-training alignment. Through this, we provide a lens on how implicit opinions are (mis)represented and offer a pathway toward more inclusive model behavior. Figure 1: EMPRACE framework surfaces the implicit opinion in user opinion statements and assistant response stances, which reflects on its social meaning, and evaluates the model’s normative alignment. 1 Introduction Recent studies have begun to examine the implicit bias behavior of models, particularly in scenarios where bias is conveyed through covert or subtle linguistic cues ( Hofmann et al. 2024 ; Aldayel et al. 2024 ) . Given that social norms are situational and bias remains contextual, this urges a need for a scheme that places these considerations at the core of the process ( Wen et al. 2025 ) . Thus, we take a step back to evaluate how implicit opinions are contextually expressed and interpreted within conversational settings. This aspect is based on the Implicit Attitude Theory, which indicates that individuals hold attitudes that may not be explicitly expressed but are reflected in implicit ways ( Greenwald and Banaji 1995 ) . Following Grice’s Cooperative Principle ( Grice 1975 ) , which explains how meaning is often conveyed through implicature and indirectness, we consider how speakers may express minority or dissenting viewpoints implicitly or indirectly, in ways that adhere to social expectations while avoiding overt conflict. On the light of these theoretical foundations, the EMPRACE framework (Engaging Multiple Beliefs, Reflections, and Contexts Equitably) emphasizes the importance of surfacing and incorporating implicit viewpoints during model training and evaluation. More practically, the inclusion of implicit conversational turns enhances stance norm alignment by allowing models to learn pragmatic inference patterns rather than relying solely on surface-level agreement indicators. This framework can help explain the tendency of LLMs to inadequately represent diverse perspectives and opinions, as their training data often underrepresents implicit or indirect expressions of opinion. Many previous methods on pluralistic opinions ( Feng et al. 2024 ; Sorensen et al. 2024 ) have focused on superficial characteristics, without a careful distinction between related yet distinct concepts, opinion and stance . Opinion refers to individual’s subjective belief or attitude about a topic or entity. It often reflects a speaker’s evaluation, which may be explicit or implied in language ( Oskamp and Schultz 2005 ) . While Stance , in contrast, refers to the speaker’s expressed position or orientation toward a specific proposition or opinion. Stance is often shown through agreement, disagreement, or neutrality in response to another utterance ( Bois 2007 ; ALDayel and Magdy 2021 ) . Therefore, in conversation, a stance is observable alignment that may reflect an opinion, but it can also be situational. In this way, opinions can inform stances, but they remain latent unless made explicit through discourse. To this end, we evaluate how the implicit opinion affects the follow-up stance in this work. We present a framework to assess the impact of implicit opinion in discourse. We examine how stance and certainty cues manifest differently in implicit versus explicit opinionated conversations to uncover subtle patterns of opinion expression. First, we establish the framework to validate normative alignment , in which a unified expectation guides appropriate responses for equitable inclusion. This expectation stems from normative discourse principles ( Habermas and J. 1985 ; Grice 1975 ) , where toxic language (e.g., hate, dehumanization, or extreme ideological views) is not treated neutrally but is instead met with opposition. By aligning stance judgments with this expectation, we can measure whether models reinforce or resist harmful views, especially when they are expressed implicitly. Then, we highlight key turning points in multi-turn dialogues where stance certainty changes, providing insights into how opinions evolve throughout the conversation. Finally, we show that incorporating implicit turns into computational models affects stance classification performance, illustrating how such inclusion can either amplify or mitigate the expression and identification of opinions. 2 Related work Opinion and Bias Representation . Implicit opinion bias has been defined as the use of subtle language, including hedging, implicature, and abstraction, which can preserve or amplify social stereotypes even in the absence of explicit prejudice ( Maass 1999 ; Tannen 1993 ) . Most previous work on opinion and bias has focused on direct, explicit social biases, such as gender disparities in word embeddings ( Cheng et al. 2022 ) or demographic biases in LLMs ( Hedderich et al. 2025 ) . Several studies have also examined the racial aspect of bias ( Hofmann et al. 2024 ; Sun et al. 2025 ) , often operationalized through identity-linked prompts or response disparities on tone or sentiment polarity. For instance, the study by ( Jung and Wang 2024a ) developed fairness-aware methods for online Positive-Unlabeled (PU) learning to address bias and ensure equitable outcomes in machine learning models trained on partially labeled data. Additionally, the study by ( Hedderich et al. 2025 ) employed a human-centered framework, focusing on explicit linguistic cues and extracting token-level patterns that highlight systematic shifts, such as the use of gendered pronouns. More recently, there has been a shift towards addressing the implicit biases, which are not overtly expressed but encoded through subtle cues. Studies such as ( Wen et al. 2025 ; Borah and Mihalcea 2024 ; Kumar et al. 2024 ; Aldayel et al. 2024 ; Tan and Lee 2025 ) analyze the presence of implicit biases in single-turn conversations, revealing that LLMs frequently fail to flag or respond adequately to covertly prejudiced language. Another study by ( Rescala et al. 2024 ) used the 2019 argument dataset to examine the LLMs’ responses (single-turn) and their convincing attributes. A recent study by ( Lake et al. 2025 ) analyzed the post-alignment distributional shift of LLM responses using open-ended QA datasets. The study finds that alignment reduces surface-level diversity while increasing the comprehensiveness of single responses. Thus, they define the stance as the response confirmation of the question-answer as “both”, “yes”, or “no”. Arora et al. Hofmann et al. 2024 frame the implicit racial bias in LLMs by prompting models with identity-linked names and contexts,