On the interplay between plasma triangularity and micro-tearing turbulence
A. Balestri 1,∗ , J. Ball 1 , S. Coda 1 · 2025
Read On the interplay between plasma triangularity and micro-tearing turbulence by A. Balestri 1,∗ , J. Ball 1 , S. Coda 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-20244.txt.
Introduction
Alessandro Balestri, Justin Ball, and Stefano Coda study how plasma shape affects a kind of turbulence in fusion devices, in a 2025 paper. The plasma cross-section can lean in or out, a trait called triangularity. Small tearing modes in the magnetic field can stir strong turbulence. The team asked when those modes take over.
They ran linear and full simulations with a known code. Shapes came from five real machines, present and planned. Plasma that leans out was prone to tearing modes, which worsened transport. Plasma that leans in stayed calmer, ruled by a milder turbulence. At high pressure ratios, the split grew stark. The work informs shape choices for future fusion reactors.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | A. Balestri 1,∗ , J. Ball 1 , S. Coda 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 59 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-20244
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the interplay between plasma triangularity and micro-tearing turbulence Preprint: APS/123-QED A. Balestri 1,∗ , J. Ball 1 , S. Coda 1 Abstract In this work, we study the interplay between triangularity and micro-tearing turbulence using linear and nonlinear flux tube GENE simulations. We consider scenarios with negative and positive triangularity plasma shaping taken from existing tokamaks (TCV, DIII-D, MAST-U and SMART) and EU-DEMO. The study of all these tokamaks reveals a coherent picture. Negative triangularity geometry is more susceptible to micro-tearing modes (MTM), which, when present, make transport much worse than in positive triangularity. At sufficiently large β \beta (the ratio of plasma pressure over magnetic pressure), magnetic shear and ratio of electron to ion temperature gradient, all the scenarios with negative triangularity are dominated by MTM turbulence. In contrast, the corresponding scenarios with positive triangularity remain dominated by electrostatic turbulence and MTMs are subdominant or stable. We observe that conventional tokamaks usually operate in a parameter space far away from the onset of this MTM-dominated regime in negative triangularity, thus preserving the beneficial effect of negative triangularity on turbulent transport. In contrast, spherical tokamaks operate close to this regime and may ultimately exhibit worse transport at negative triangularity than positive triangularity. We find that lowering the magnetic shear in spherical tokamaks can preserve the beneficial effect of negative triangularity on electrostatic turbulence and prevent strong MTM transport. Finally, linear and nonlinear simulations reveal the reason for stronger MTMs: the magnetic drifts are faster in the negative triangularity geometry. I Introduction Since the first experiments on the TCV tokamak Weisen et al. 1997 , many advances have been made in the study of Negative Triangularity (NT) plasma shaping. It is now well established that NT closes the access to H-mode Merle et al. 2017 ; Nelson et al. 2024 , creating the most robust ELM-free scenario, while reducing turbulent transport sufficiently to achieve H-mode-like performance Fontana et al. 2017 ; Marinoni et al. 2019 ; Austin et al. 2019 ; Paz-Soldan and the DIII-D Team 2021 ; Coda et al. 2021 ; Happel et al. 2022 ; Nelson et al. 2023 ; Balestri et al. 2024a ; Aucone et al. 2024 ; Mariani et al. 2024 ; Thome et al. 2024 ; Paz-Soldan et al. 2024 . These properties make NT a viable alternative to Fusion Power Plant (FPP) concepts based on the more common Positive Triangularity (PT) H-mode scenario. However, the conceptualization of an NT-FPP remains in its early stages The MANTA Collaboration et al. 2024 ; Wilson et al. 2024 and some important questions remain unanswered. In particular, the observed reduction in turbulent transport has been primarily observed and studied in the electrostatic limit, or in regimes dominated by electrostatic turbulence, e.g Trapped Electron Mode (TEM) turbulence Marinoni et al. 2009 ; Merlo et al. 2019 ; Balestri et al. 2024a ; Balestri et al. 2024b ; Giannatale et al. 2024 ; Hoffmann et al. 2024 ; Merlo and Jenko 2023 and Ion Temperature Gradient (ITG) turbulence Merlo and Jenko 2023 ; Balestri et al. 2024b ; Merlo et al. 2023 ; Hoffmann et al. 2024 ; Giannatale et al. 2024 . However, in comparison to most current experiments, reactor-relevant plasmas are expected to have large values of \beta , making electromagnetic turbulence more significant. The most important electromagnetic instabilities are Micro-Tearing Modes (MTM) and Kinetic Ballooning Modes (KBM). To date, only Pueschel et al. 2025 has analyzed the interplay between MTM and triangularity. The limited amount of work on this topic and its importance in view of an NT power plant motivates this study. We highlight the fact that reliable saturated MTM-dominated nonlinear simulations have been obtained throughout this work, thus adding to the relatively small number reported in literature Guttenfelder et al. 2011 ; Doerk et al. 2011 ; Doerk et al. 2012 ; Maeyama et al. 2017 ; Hamed et al. 2023 . The reminder of the paper is structured as follows. Section II provides a brief overview of the theory behind MTM turbulence and summarizes key findings from recent years. Section III introduces the GENE code and the numerical methodology that has been used in the rest of the paper. Section IV presents the results of linear simulations, where key parameters affecting MTM turbulence are scanned to compare behaviour in NT and PT. Section V shows nonlinear simulations results to verify and expand the picture that emerged from linear simulations. Analogously to Balestri et al. 2024b , section VI presents linear and nonlinear simulations to develop a simple physical picture for why MTMs are destabilized in NT. Finally, section VII provides conclusions and a summary. II Overview of micro-tearing turbulence theory A micro-tearing mode is an electromagnetic micro-instability that has been known in the plasma physics community for more than four decades Hazeltine et al. 1975 . However, despite its long history, it remains understudied and has received more attention only in recent years thanks to its strong relation with H-mode. Since many readers may not be familiar with MTM turbulence, we will provide a brief overview. MTMs rely on fluctuations of the radial magnetic field to create small-scale magnetic islands that increase the stochasticity of the magnetic field itself, enabling the motion of electrons along these perturbed field lines to result in radial transport. Because of their nature, MTMs can be considered as the gyroradius-scale counterpart of large-scale MHD tearing modes. However, contrary to their MHD counterparts, MTMs do not drain free energy from the relaxation of magnetic field lines after a reconnection event. Rather, their source of free energy comes from the electron temperature gradient \mathbf{\nabla}T_{e} , which couples with perturbations in the magnetic field, resulting in perturbations in the drag force R_{\parallel}\propto\mathbf{B}\cdot\mathbf{\nabla}T_{e} . This fundamental destabilizing mechanism was proposed for the first time by Hazeltine et al. Hazeltine et al. 1975 in slab geometry. It was subsequently extended by Gladd et al. 1980 with a more sophisticated linear theory that highlights the importance of magnetic shear in destabilizing MTMs and then adapted by Drake and Lee 1977 to cylindrical geometry. These three analytical works found that collisions play a fundamental role and predicted that MTMs can be unstable only at finite collisionality. Indeed, the parallel drag force caused by collisions is made inhomogeneous by the presence of fluctuations in \nabla_{\parallel}T_{e} , which creates a parallel current that is able to reinforce the original radial perturbation of the magnetic field. Catto and Rosenbluth Catto and Rosenbluth 1981 then showed that collisions are not strictly necessary to destabilize MTMs, which can be unstable also in a collisionless regime. Finally, Garbet et al. 1990 showed analytically that MTMs can be unstable nonlinearly and lead to strong heat transport. In more recent years, MTMs have been investigated by means of gyrokinetic simulations. Ref. Applegate et al. 2007 showed with linear gyrokinetic simulations that MTMs can be dominant in MAST discharges and are destabilized by \beta , collisionality and electron temperature gradient. In Guttenfelder et al. 2011 ; Doerk et al. 2011 , some of the first nonlinear gyrokinetic simulations with dominant MTMs were performed, showing that MTMs break magnetic field lines, which leads to a stochastization of the magnetic field and an associated increase