What Does ‘Human-Centred AI’ Mean?
Olivia Guest · 2025
Read What Does ‘Human-Centred AI’ Mean? by Olivia Guest (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-19960.txt.
Introduction
Olivia Guest asked in a 2025 essay what the popular slogan human-centred AI could mean. Centring human behaviour and experience sounds obvious, she argues. Because AI is never anything else: it is a relationship between method and people in which artifacts appear to perform human mental labour. She lines up pairs to make the point, the abacus against mental number work, the alarm clock against the knocker-upper who once woke workers in person, the camera against vision.
Guest sorts these sociotechnical relationships into three kinds: harmful displacement of mental labour, beneficial enhancement, and neutral replacement. Every AI system implicates human cognition somewhere, she contends. Hiding that cognition, whether in a clock or a neural network, distorts debate, slows key engagement, and undermines mental science itself. Truly centring humans starts with refusing to fetishize the machine.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Olivia Guest |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 60 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-19960
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
What Does ‘Human-Centred AI’ Mean? Olivia Guest Abstract While it seems sensible that human-centred artificial intelligence (AI) means centring “human behaviour and experience,” it cannot be any other way. AI, I argue, is usefully seen as a relationship between technology and humans where it appears that artifacts can perform, to a greater or lesser extent, human cognitive labour. This is evinced using examples that juxtapose technology with cognition, inter alia: abacus versus mental arithmetic; alarm clock versus knocker-upper; camera versus vision; and sweatshop versus tailor. Using novel definitions and analyses, sociotechnical relationships can be analysed into varying types of: displacement (harmful), enhancement (beneficial), and/or replacement (neutral) of human cognitive labour. Ultimately, all AI implicates human cognition; no matter what. Obfuscation of cognition in the AI context — from clocks to artificial neural networks — results in distortion, in slowing critical engagement, perverting cognitive science, and indeed in limiting our ability to truly centre humans and humanity in the engineering of AI systems. To even begin to de-fetishise AI, we must look the human-in-the-loop in the eyes. Keywords: artificial intelligence; cognitive science; sociotechnical relationship; cognitive labour; artificial neural network; technology; cognition; human-centred AI 1 Introduction [M]odels have to be used before they will give up their secrets. In this sense, they have the quality of a technology — the power of the model only becomes apparent in the context of its use. ( Morrison & Morgan 1999a , p. 12) We are experiencing a point in history that considers itself separate, unique, a zenith of human civilisation, presented as disconnected from the past through a series of technological sea changes. In extreme cases, we are detached from even the last few months: the newest version of a piece of artificial intelligence (AI) software is the definitive one, everything else is irrelevant. And so findings in AI are held to expire. Our AI students describe their own knowledge and skills — even their whole degree itself — as having upcoming sell-by dates. Research in AI is thus often framed as unmoored from historical, ethical, social, and legal precedents. The speed of the “ultra rapid computing machine,” as Wiener 1948a ; Wiener 1950a describes computers, becomes a metaphor for the speed of change and of technological progress. This notion of condensed time operates as a further discursive regularity in two ways. First, it forms an overall temporal backdrop against which various cybernetic dramas are played out. Second, condensed time becomes a measure of the performance of humans and machines. Hughes 1985a offers a telling example of the first manifestation of condensed time: In the scant two hundred years since the early Industrial Revolution, Western man has totally rescaled and changed the face and fabric of his environment. Indeed, the changes have proceeded at such an accelerated pace that we might use the word “old” or “outmoded” to refer to last month’s computer model. (p. 205) This sense of condensing time—of speed, of rapid change—imbues virtually all the popular literature examined. It becomes a contextual operator, stated but not questioned. ( Hamilton 1998a , p. 193) What Sheryl N. Hamilton describes above is more than seven decades old. But if this has been going for decades, two-thirds of a century or longer still, does this not undermine its very premise? How can we both be at a unique point in history, and trapped in an endless cycle that began with the paralleling of humans and clockwork? The process of uncondensing time indubitably requires slowing down ( Stengers 2018a ) and radically centring the human and decentring the “ultra rapid computing machine.” ( Hamilton 1998a ) To do this, some propose to (conceptually) reengineer ( Nado 2021a ; Guest 2024a ) or reimagine these machines and our relationships to them inter alia through a subfield known as human-centred AI. For a pertinent example, Andy J. Wills 2025a , in the call for this special issue, describes human-centred artificial intelligence (HCAI) as placing “human behaviour and experience at the heart of [AI] research.” An example of this, he says, could be cases wherein it is “claimed that artificial neural networks (ANNs) now perform at human levels in a variety of tasks”. He goes on to ask: Can ANNs effectively and safely be used to support the work of highly trained professionals—for example, radiologists, therapists, legal advisors, or researchers? Can we effectively adapt the skills and techniques of behavioural research, previously applied to humans and other animals, to better understand the ‘psychology’ of complex black-box ANNs? Relatedly, Yvonne Rogers 2022a states the goal of HCAI as “designing AI systems that enhance human capacities and improve their experiences rather than replacing them through automation[, along with the aspiration of] reimagining human-machine interaction in all its guises[, while negotiating] the creeping creepiness of AI” (p. 255). Industry players, such as IBM, make a different but not entirely incompatible conceptualisation: Human-Centered AI (HCAI) is an emerging discipline intent on creating AI systems that amplify and augment rather than displace human abilities. HCAI seeks to preserve human control in a way that ensures artificial intelligence meets our needs while also operating transparently, delivering equitable outcomes, and respecting privacy. ( Geyer et al. 2022a , n.p.) Regulatory bodies, like the European Union, also have a perspective: The human-centric approach to AI strives to ensure that human values are central to the way in which AI systems are developed, deployed, used and monitored, by ensuring respect for fundamental rights, […] which are united by reference to a common foundation rooted in respect for human dignity, in which the human being enjoys a unique and inalienable moral status. ( Tambiama 2019a , p. 3) Overall we see that HCAI — as a specialisation for students (e.g. 8 ; 10 ) , as a subfield for scholars (e.g. Wills 2025a ; Holzinger 2025a ; Rogers 2022a ; 9 ; 6 ; Stanford Institute for Human-Centered AI 2019a ) or technology industry workers (e.g. Geyer et al. 2022a ) alike, and as a concern and mission for regulators (e.g. Pirozzoli 2024a ; Tambiama 2019a ) — interweaves four related themes: 1. supporting or enhancing human skills, both without displacement of said skills and without violation of fundamental human rights; 2. imbuing systems with various so-called human-aligned values, including those of explainability and transparency; 3. focussing on human behaviour as a benchmark, i.e. the idea of human-like or -level performance; 4. implicating behavioural, or otherwise psychological, methods in the study of these systems as if on equal epistemic footing with humans. In this paper, I turn this frame on its head (cf. Bannon 2011a ; Rogers 2022a ; Ryan 2024a ; Schmager et al. 2025a ; Nick-Witheford 2019a ; Walton & Nayak 2021a ; Andersen et al. 2023a ; Shneiderman 2022a ; Bishop 2021a ; Steinhoff 2021a ) . Using a unique (re)definition of AI that releases us from a correlationist 1 1 1 The idea that it is correlations with a given target, like human data derived benchmarks ( Schrimpf et al. 2020a ; Pasquinelli 2017a ; cf. Rooij et al. 2024a ), that validate the safety ( El-Mhamdi et al. 2022a ) , appropriateness, or other desirable properties of a model or system. In general,