Existence of a fourth Airy elephant in the nuclear rainbows for 12 C+ 12 C scattering
S. Ohkubo, Y. Hirabayashi · 2025
Read Existence of a fourth Airy elephant in the nuclear rainbows for 12 C+ 12 C scattering by S. Ohkubo, Y. Hirabayashi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-19923.txt.
Introduction
Ohkubo and Hirabayashi report that a long-missing fourth broad hump exists in the scattering pattern of two carbon nuclei. Their 2025 paper deals with rainbows in nuclear physics, where a beam bends much like light in a rain shower. The humps, nicknamed Airy elephants, are split by dips and reveal the force between the two nuclei.
A puzzle had stood for years: one key dip crossed a right angle at a far lower energy for carbon on carbon than for kindred systems. A second rainbow, found later, held the clue. The team shows that the second rainbow's dip crosses the right angle near the expected energy, which proves a fourth hump sits between the two dips and closes the old question.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | S. Ohkubo, Y. Hirabayashi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-19923
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Existence of a fourth Airy elephant in the nuclear rainbows for 12 C+ 12 C scattering S. Ohkubo, Y. Hirabayashi Abstract The number of gross structures in the 90 ∘ excitation function for 12 C+ 12 C elastic scattering—often called ”Airy elephants”—has been of great interest. These structures are caused by refractive scattering and are separated by Airy minima. Their importance stems from their close relationship to the interaction potential between two 12 C nuclei, which also describes the molecular resonances of the compound system at lower energies. Although a unique deep potential was usually determined from rainbow scattering at higher energies, a puzzling discrepancy persisted: the energy at which the Airy minimum A 1 A1 crosses 90 ∘ was E c . m . ≈ E_{c.m.}\approx 67 MeV for 12 C+ 12 C. This is remarkably low compared to approximately 100 MeV for both the 16 O+ 12 C and 16 O+ 16 O systems. This question remained unanswered until the discovery of the secondary rainbow in the 12 C+ 12 C system. We report for the first time that the highest energy at which the dynamically generated Airy minimum of the secondary rainbow crosses 90 ∘ is about 100 MeV. This demonstrates that the fourth Airy elephant exists between the Airy minimum A 1 A1 of the primary nuclear rainbow and that, A 1 ( S ) A1^{(S)} , of the secondary rainbow. The long-standing problem concerning the Airy minima and Airy elephants has finally been resolved after decades of concern by recognizing the existence of a dynamically generated secondary rainbow in 12 C+ 12 C scattering. keywords 12 C+ 12 C, nuclear rainbow, refractive scattering, secondary bow, Airy elephant, double folding model, coupled channel method 1 Introduction Gross structures observed in excitation functions provide important information about the structure of the nucleus. The famous structure observed by Bromley et al. Bromley1960 in 12 C+ 12 C elastic scattering at E_{L} =6 - 29 MeV opened the field of molecular structure in heavy-ion systems. Quasi-molecular structures for the typical 12 C+ 12 C system, as well as 16 O+ 16 O, were extensively studied Bromley1984 ; Betts1997 . The measurement of the 90 ∘ excitation function in 12 C+ 12 C scattering was extended to E_{L} =27 - 75 MeV by Reilly et al. Reilly1973 . Stokstad et al. Stokstad1975 further extended the measurement of angular distributions to E_{L} =75-130 MeV systematically and observed the development of gross structure in the 90 ∘ excitation function, which is not related to the resonances of the compound 12 C+ 12 C system. Brandan et al. Brandan1990 were able to describe the evolution of the angular distributions with energy by using a global deep real potential. On the other hand, Morsad et al. Morsad1991 , measuring the excitation functions at E_{L} =60-120 MeV, found that the intermediate structure resonances disappear above E_{L} = 70 MeV, while the broad and irregular structure becomes a general feature of the interaction at higher energies. Figure 1: The familiar elephant interpretation Raman1974 ; McVoy1992 of the shape of the experimental 90 ∘ excitation function (points) in refractive 12 C+ 12 C scattering. The line (elephant) is to guide the eye. The minima separating the elephants correspond to the Airy minima. This figure is reproduced from Ref. McVoy1992 under STM permission from Elsevier publisher. McVoy and Brandan McVoy1992 analyzed the angular distributions of Ref. Stokstad1975 and discussed the structure of the 90 ∘ excitation function from viewpoint of refractive scattering, see Fig. 1 , using a unique deep potential in Ref. Brandan1990 determined from the analysis of rainbow scattering above E_{L} =150 MeV and concluded that the most prominent minimum is unquestionably due to Airy minimum A2 that crosses 90 ∘ at 102 MeV. They expected a minimum due to A3 at near E_{L} =55 MeV. They confidently predicted the existence of the Airy minimum A1 at about E_{L} = 130 MeV as a final minimum. Michel and Ohkubo Michel2004 systematically studied the energy evolution of the Airy minima in 12 C+ 12 C scattering extensively at E_{L} =70-130 MeV by decomposing the farside scattering amplitude into the internal wave and barrier wave components using the prescription in Refs. Fuller1975 ; Brink1985 ; Brink1977 ; Albinski82 and showed that the so-called Airy minima in this energy region are, strictly speaking, the interference minima of the prerainbows proposed in Ref. Michel2002 . They also showed that the Airy minimum A3 crosses 90 ∘ at around E_{L} =75 MeV. Demyanova et al. Demyanova2010A ; Demyanova2010B , by measuring the rainbow scattering at 240 MeV up to large angles toward 90 ∘ , concluded that there is no Airy minimum that crosses 90 ∘ above E_{L} = 130 MeV. Thus, the number of Airy minima that cross 90 ∘ seems to have been solved to be four ( A1 - A4 ) decades after the humorous ”Airy elephants”. However, there remained a puzzle that the energy E_{c.m.}\approx 67 MeV that the A1 crosses 90 ∘ for 12 C+ 12 C is remarkably smaller compared with about E_{c.m.} =100 MeV for 16 O+ 12 C and 95 MeV for 16 O+ 16 O. It may be difficult to believe that the refractive scattering due to the mean-field potential changes so drastically among the neighbouring three systems. Although since the first experimental observation in Refs. Brandan1982 ; Bohlen1982 ; Buenerd1982 tremendous studies Buenerd1982 ; Bohlen1982 ; Bohlen1985 ; Brandan1982 ; Brandan1988 ; Brandan1990 ; McVoy1992 ; Khoa1994 ; Brandan1997 ; Hassanain2008 ; Demyanova2010A ; Demyanova2010B ; Furumoto2012 ; Khoa2016 ; Hemmdan2021 ; Phuc2021 have been devoted to nuclear rainbow scattering for 12 C+ 12 C and the interaction potential that describes the rainbow scattering, this seeming puzzle has not been answered in the last decades. Thus the number of the gross structures in the 90 ∘ excitation function separated by the Airy minima, which evokes of the shape of an elephant and have been called Airy elephant humorously Raman1974 ; McVoy1992 , remained as a puzzle concerning the number of the Airy elephants. The purpose of this paper is to report, for the first time, the existence of an Airy elephant above E_{L} = 130 MeV. We demonstrate this by showing that the highest energy at which the Airy minimum crosses 90 ∘ is E_{L}\approx 210 MeV ( E_{c.m.} =105 MeV). This corresponds to the Airy minimum A1 of the dynamically generated secondary bow, not the primary nuclear rainbow. This finding resolves the puzzle concerning the number of Airy minima in the 90 ∘ excitation function, the number of Airy elephants, and the previously reported, remarkably lower energy of the A1 minimum crossing 90 ∘ for 12 C + 12 C compared with 16 O+ 12 C and 16 O+ 16 O. 2 The extended double folding model We use an extended double folding (EDF) model, which is given by \displaystyle V_{ij,kl}({\bf R})=\int\rho_{ij}^{\rm(^{12}C)}({\bf r}_{1})\;\rho_{kl}^{\rm(^{12}C)}({\bf r}_{2}) (1) \displaystyle\times v_{\it NN}(E,\rho,{\bf r}_{1}+{\bf R}-{\bf r}_{2})\;{\it d}{\bf r}_{1}{\it d}{\bf r}_{2}, where \rho_{ij}^{\rm(^{12}C)}({\bf r}) represents the diagonal ( i=j ) or transition ( i\neq j ) nucleon density of 12 C which is calculated using the microscopic three \alpha cluster model in the