Anomalous superconductivity and unusual normal state properties of bilayer and twisted graphene (Brief review)

M. Yu. Kagan, M. M. Korovushkin, V. A. Mitskan, K. I. Kugel, A. L. Rakhmanov, A. V. Rozhkov, A. O. Sboychakov · 2025

Read Anomalous superconductivity and unusual normal state properties of bilayer and twisted graphene (Brief review) by M. Yu. Kagan, M. M. Korovushkin, V. A. Mitskan, K. I. Kugel, A. L. Rakhmanov, A. V. Rozhkov, A. O. Sboychakov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-19903.txt.

Introduction

Kagan and six co-authors reviewed odd superconductivity in graphene layers for this paper from twenty twenty-five. Twisting or stacking two graphene sheets creates states unlike either sheet alone. One route to superconductivity there is the Kohn-Luttinger mechanism, where repulsion itself pairs electrons. The review gathers the team's earlier results on this pairing.

Pairing shapes covered include p-, d-, and f-wave forms in single and stacked sheets. Later sections weigh how superconductivity competes with spin density waves in real samples. Twisted bilayers also show nematic order, a directional twist on the paired state. Odd normal-state properties round out the survey. The authors map a crowded phase landscape.

Catalog record

CREATORM. Yu. Kagan, M. M. Korovushkin, V. A. Mitskan, K. I. Kugel, A. L. Rakhmanov, A. V. Rozhkov, A. O. Sboychakov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-19903

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Anomalous superconductivity and unusual normal state properties of bilayer and twisted graphene (Brief review) M. Yu. Kagan, M. M. Korovushkin, V. A. Mitskan, K. I. Kugel, A. L. Rakhmanov, A. V. Rozhkov, A. O. Sboychakov Abstract It has been shown that the Kohn–Luttinger superconductivity mechanism interplaying with other types of ordering can be implemented in systems with a hexagonal lattice. A number of unusual properties of such systems in the normal phase have also been considered. Our previous results on Kohn–Luttinger superconductivity with p p -, d d -, and f f -wave pairing in monolayer and AB bilayer graphene, obtained disregarding the effect of substrate potential and impurities, have been presented in the first part. Then, the interplay of the superconducting Kohn–Luttinger state with the spin density wave state in actual AB, AA, and twisted bilayer graphene has been discussed in detail. In the last parts, a number of anomalous properties in the normal phase and the appearance of nematic superconductivity alongside with the spin density wave in the twisted bilayer graphene have been presented. I Introduction Since its discovery, graphene is attracting a widespread attention due to its unusual electronic characteristics NovoselovSci2004 ; KatsnelsonNatPh2006 ; KotovRMP2012 ; NetoRMP2009 ; RozhkovPhRep2016 ; SboychakovPRB2015 ; KaganKugRakhPhRep2021 ; BookPS . Experimental studies of bilayer graphene and the discovery of superconductivity in magic angle twisted bilayer graphene in 2018 CaoNat2018 stimulated an advent of numerous theoretical works on anomalous (non-phonon) mechanisms of superconductivity in graphene and related compounds (see review KaganUFN2015 and references therein), including the Kohn–Luttinger mechanism KohnLuttPRL1965 ; FayPRL1968 ; KaganPZhETF1988 ; KaganPZhETF1989 ; ChubukovJPCM1989 ; KaganPhLA1991 . The possibility of implementing anomalous mechanisms of superconductivity in graphene is primarily related to strong electron correlations in this system and is largely due to the existence of Dirac points in the spectrum of graphene. Near these points, the energy spectrum is linear and electrons can be described by the Dirac equation for massless charged quasiparticles. This results in a pronounced electron-polaron effects KaganKugRakhPhRep2021 ; BookPS , which strongly enhances electron correlations. Such fact gives hope for implementing in graphene superconductivity mechanisms based on the electron–electron interaction. Note that the Kohn–Luttinger mechanism is the basic one for the non-phonon superconductivity in strongly correlated electron systems with repulsion, and it competes with the Fröhlich plasmon mechanism FrohlichJPhC1968 in the systems with low electron density. For the Kohn–Luttinger superconductivity mechanism, the frequency effects associated with the retardation do not play a dominant role, while the presence of the Kohn anomaly KohnPRL1959 (Friedel oscillations FriedelNuCim1958 ) in the effective interaction between two electrons of the Cooper pair via the polarization of the Fermi background plays a crucial role (see Fig. 1 ). In fact, the Kohn–Luttinger mechanism involves the transformation of the bare repulsive interaction between two particles in vacuum in the presence of a Fermi background (a filled Fermi sphere) into an effective attraction in the material within a channel characterized by a nonzero orbital moment of the Cooper pair. Figure 1: Friedel oscillations in the effective interaction between two particles due to the polarization of the Fermi background, where \xi_{0} is the coherence length of a Cooper pair KaganUFN2015 ; BaranovIJMPB1992 ; KaganBookSpringer . Our previous results on the Kohn–Luttinger mechanism BaranovIJMPB1992 ; BaranovZsPhB1992 ; BaranovPhC1993 ; ChubukovPRB1993 ; KaganUFN1994 ; BaranovPZhETF1996 ; BaranovZhETF1991 ; BaranovZhETF1992 ; KaganPZhETF1995 ; BaranovPZhETF1993 are presented in the review KaganUFN2015 on anomalous superconductivity in electron systems with repulsion. They are dealing primarily with low-density electron systems described by the Hubbard model or by the Fermi gas model with the purely repulsive bare interaction. In the effective interaction of two particles mediated by the polarization of the Fermi background in all channels with nonzero momenta of the Cooper pair, the attraction arises, and the most attractive harmonic corresponds to the triplet p -wave pairing FayPRL1968 ; KaganPZhETF1988 . Moreover, the critical temperature corresponding to the p -wave pairing can be significantly enhanced in the spin-polarized Fermi gas or in the two-band situation, leading to reasonable values of T_{c}=1-5 K KaganPZhETF1989 ; KaganPhLA1991 ; BaranovIJMPB1992 ; BaranovPhC1993 ; KaganUFN1994 . In doing so, there appears a possibility to enhance the Kohn anomaly in the three-dimensional case. However, it is more important that in the case when the energy band becomes almost flat, it is possible to make the strong but one-sided (square-root type) Kohn anomaly efficient for the superconductivity problem already in the second order of perturbation theory. Note that, according to the results reported in KaganUFN2015 ; BaranovIJMPB1992 ; KaganBookSpringer , the Kohn anomaly plays an important but not dominant role in the implementation of the p -wave pairing. In a more general case, it is sufficient for the effective (or screened) interaction to increase only in the range from 0 to 2 p_{F} . Note also that in repulsive models on a two-dimensional square lattice, such as the Hubbard model with repulsion, the d_{xy} -wave pairing naturally arises in a wide electron density range, whereas at high electron densities (closer to half-filling), the d_{x^{2}-y^{2}} -wave pairing, relevant for cuprate superconductors, takes place BaranovIJMPB1992 ; KaganBookSpringer ; BaranovZsPhB1992 . II Superconductivity in monolayer graphene and in idealized bilayer graphene More recent results of our group on the Kohn–Luttinger mechanism on the lattice KaganKugRakhPhRep2021 ; BookPS ; KaganUFN2015 ; KaganZhETF2011 ; KaganPZhETF2011 ; KaganPZhETF2013 ; KaganZhETF2013 ; KaganZhETF2014 ; KaganSSC2014 ; KaganZhETF2014a ; KaganEPJB2015 ; KaganPZhETF2016 in cuprate and iron-based superconductors, as well as in the monolayer and idealized AB bilayer graphene pertain to the period of 2011‒2016 (see also the results reported in NandkishoreNatPh2012 ; NandkishorePRL2012 ; NandkishorePRB2012 ; NandkishorePRB2014 ; DongPRB2023 ). In these works, phase diagrams of the superconducting state for cuprate and iron-based superconductors were constructed within the framework of the most repulsive basic Shubin–Vonsovsky model ShubVonsPrRoySoc1934 (or extended Hubbard model) taking into account the onsite Hubbard repulsion U and the additional Coulomb repulsion between electrons at different sites of the square lattice, as well as the long-range intersite hopping, generalizing our previous results on p - and d -wave pairing in the Hubbard model KaganPZhETF2013 ; KaganZhETF2013 (see Fig. 2 ). Figure 2: (Color online) n-V_{1} phase diagram of the Shubin–Vonsovsky model on the square lattice at t_{2}=t_{3}=0 , U=|t_{1}| and V_{2}/V_{1}=0.5 . Thin lines correspond to fixed values of the coupling constant |\lambda| KaganZhETF2013 . Figure 3: n-V_{1} phase diagram for the superconducting state of the graphene monolayer at U=2 and V_{2}=0.6V_{1} (all parameter are given in units of |t| ) KaganUFN2015 ; KaganZhETF2014 ; KaganSSC2014 . The results of the studies on the Kohn–Luttinger mechanism on a square lattice were also generalized by us to the hexagonal lattice of graphene. In KaganZhETF2014 ; KaganSSC2014 , in the framework of the Shubin–Vonsovsky model, we constructed a phase diagram for an idealized graphene monolayer containing, at different electron densities, the regions of triplet pairing with p_{x}+ip_{y} - and f -wave symmetries, as well as small regions of the singlet d_{x^{2}-y^{2}}+id_{xy} -pairing KaganUFN2015 ; KaganZhETF2014 ; KaganSSC2014 (see Fig. 3 ). Then, our studies on the Kohn–Luttinger superconductivity mechanism and its possible enhancement in AB bilayer graphene appeared (see Fig. 4 ) KaganUFN2015 ; KaganZhETF2014a ; KaganEPJB2015 . We have also demonstrated the enhancement of

Read the complete text