A unified diagrammatic formulation of single-reference and multi-reference random phase approximations: the particle-hole and particle-particle channels

Yuqi Wang, Wei-Hai Fang, Zhendong Li · 2025

Read A unified diagrammatic formulation of single-reference and multi-reference random phase approximations: the particle-hole and particle-particle channels by Yuqi Wang, Wei-Hai Fang, Zhendong Li (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-19876.txt.

Introduction

Quantum chemists use the random phase approximation to estimate how electrons correlate, but systems needing several reference states have lacked a unified treatment. Wang, Fang, and Li extend a diagram framework so that single-reference and multi-reference versions of two more variants fall out of one set of equations. The two variants work in the particle-hole channel with exchange and in the particle-particle channel.

Tests on sample systems show a pattern: particle-hole versions overshoot the true correlation energy while the particle-particle version undershoots it. Error cancellation between second and third orders proves key in both. The authors suggest merging the two channels for better accuracy.

Catalog record

CREATORYuqi Wang, Wei-Hai Fang, Zhendong Li
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE92 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-19876

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A unified diagrammatic formulation of single-reference and multi-reference random phase approximations: the particle-hole and particle-particle channels Yuqi Wang, Wei-Hai Fang, Zhendong Li Abstract A diagrammatic multi-reference generalization of many-body perturbation theory was recently introduced [J. Phys. Chem. Lett., 2025, 16, 3047]. This framework allows us to extend single-reference (SR) Green’s function methods defined at the diagrammatic level naturally into multi-reference case, as previously exemplified by the formulation of multi-reference direct random phase approximation (MR-dRPA) and the multi-reference second-order screened exchange approximation (MR-SOSEX). In this work, we further elaborate this framework and use it to develop MR generalizations of two other RPA variants, namely, particle-hole (ph) RPA with exchange (MR-RPAx) and particle-particle RPA (MR-ppRPA). We define these two MR generalizations by infinite order resummations of the generalized ‘ring’ and ‘ladder’ diagrams with antisymmetrized interaction vertices, respectively, which incorporate the contributions from the active-space connected two-body Green’s functions. As for MR-dRPA, we derive unified sets of equations that hold at both SR and MR levels for RPAx and ppRPA, respectively. We perform numerical studies of prototypical systems using the three MR-RPA methods and carry out a perturbative analysis to gain a deeper understanding of their behaviors. We find that error cancellation between the second and third orders is a key factor for both SR-RPA and MR-RPA. In addition, we observe that MR-phRPA (MR-dRPA and MR-RPAx) and MR-ppRPA tend to overestimate and underestimate correlation energies, respectively, suggesting that a better accuracy can be achieved by further combining these two channels in the future. I Introduction Accurate prediction of ground-state energies of strongly correlated electronic systems remains a significant challenge in quantum chemistry and many-body physics. Traditional single-reference (SR) perturbation theory, which employs a quadratic zeroth-order Hamiltonian ( \hat{H}_{0} ) and a single-determinant reference, fails in the presence of strong correlation. Such failure motivates the development of multi-reference perturbation theories (MRPT) with a multi-determinant reference Park et al. 2020 , including the second-order complete active space perturbation theory (CASPT2) Andersson et al. 1992 and second-order N -electron valence state perturbation theory (NEVPT2) Angeli et al. 2001 as two of the most popular methods. Developing nonperturbative methods that include infinite order contributions is highly nontrivial. Traditionally, such methods are mainly developed from a multi-reference coupled cluster (MRCC) perspective using time-independent wavefunction formulation Lyakh et al. 2012 ; Evangelista 2018 ; Adam et al. 2025 . Recently, we tackled this problem from a different perspective by developing a diagrammatic generalization of the traditional many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) based on time-dependent Green’s functions Fetter and Walecka 1971 ; Negele and Orland 1998 ; Martin et al. 2016 for interacting \hat{H}_{0} Wang et al. 2025 . The key idea is to introduce generalized Feynman diagrams, which can involve cumulant (or connected) Green’s functions, derived from the cumulant expansion of time-ordered many-body Green’s functions Negele and Orland 1998 . This development opens up the possibility of developing multi-reference methods beyond the second order by partially resumming certain types of diagrams to infinite order, analogous to the single-reference case Fetter and Walecka 1971 ; Martin et al. 2016 . As a concrete application of this theoretical framework, we formulated a multi-reference generalization of the random phase approximation (RPA) in terms of diagrammatic resummation. In the language of Feynman diagrams, the standard single-reference RPA, which has been successfully applied in both molecular systems Furche 2001 ; Zhu et al. 2010 ; Eshuis and Furche 2011 ; Paier et al. 2012 and condensed-phase systems Harl and Kresse 2008 ; Harl and Kresse 2009 ; Lu et al. 2009 ; Ren et al. 2009 ; Schimka et al. 2010 ; Harl et al. 2010 ; Lebègue et al. 2010 ; Mittendorfer et al. 2011 ; Olsen et al. 2011 ; Casadei et al. 2012 ; Neuhauser et al. 2013 ; Casadei et al. 2016 ; Schäfer et al. 2018 , is formulated by resumming ‘ring’ diagrams to infinite order Pines and Bohm 1952 ; Bohm and Pines 1953 ; Gell-Mann and Brueckner 1957 ; Goldstone 1957 ; McLachlan and Ball 1964 ; Furche 2008 ; Hesselmann and Görling 2011 ; Ren et al. 2012 ; Chen et al. 2017 . Following the same spirit, our multi-reference RPA (MR-RPA) is naturally defined by replacing the standard ring diagrams with the generalized ones Wang et al. 2025 . This distinguishes it from other MR generalizations of RPA from different perspectives, such as the equation of motion (EOM) of excitation operators Chatterjee and Pernal 2012 ; Pernal 2014 ; Pastorczak and Pernal 2018 ; Pernal 2018 ; Guo and Pernal 2024 ; Tucholska et al. 2024 and the ring coupled cluster theory Szabados and Margócsy 2017 ; Margócsy and Szabados 2020 . This MR-RPA method delivers promising results in the description of the bond-breaking processes of prototypical molecules, where single-reference RPA fails miserably. The use of diagrams offers the possibility of systematic improvement by adding more diagrams, which is demonstrated by the multi-reference generalization of the second-order screened exchange (MR-SOSEX) developed in the same work Wang et al. 2025 . The MR-RPA previously developed targets the particle-hole (ph) channel and neglects all the exchange terms, and thus will be referred to more precisely as multi-reference direct RPA (MR-dRPA) in the present work. While it improves single-reference dRPA (SR-dRPA) significantly in the presence of strong correlation, it also inherit drawbacks from SR-dRPA, such as the self-interaction error (SIE) due to the lack of correct fermionic antisymmetry, and too negative correlation energies Mori-Sánchez et al. 2012 . In the single-reference case, efforts have been made to go beyond dRPA by adding corrections containing exchange terms Grüneis et al. 2009 ; Heßelmann 2011 ; Bates and Furche 2013 ; Chen et al. 2018 ; Hummel et al. 2019 , introducing single excitations Ren et al. 2011 , combining with density functional theories Fuchs and Gonze 2002 ; Jiang and Engel 2007 ; Toulouse et al. 2009 ; Hesselmann and Görling 2010 ; Toulouse et al. 2010 ; Paier et al. 2010 ; Heßelmann and Görling 2011 ; Trushin et al. 2021 ; Riemelmoser et al. 2023 , or exploring other RPA variants Klopper et al. 2011 ; Ángyán et al. 2011 ; Heßelmann 2012 ; Eshuis et al. 2012 ; Scuseria et al. 2013 ; van Aggelen et al. 2013 ; van Aggelen et al. 2014 ; Mussard et al. 2015 ; Tahir and Ren 2019 . Specifically, the RPAx method directly includes exchange terms by using antisymmetrizing Coulomb interactions McLachlan and Ball 1964 ; Ángyán et al. 2011 ; Heßelmann 2011 ; Eshuis et al. 2012 ; Heßelmann 2012 , which resolves the SIE in one-electron systems. Unfortunately, RPAx often either suffers from the triplet instability or gives correlation energies even more negative than dRPA, limiting its range of applicability. On the other hand, the particle-particle RPA (ppRPA), which instead targets the particle-particle and hole-hole channels, has been established as a promising alternative to the particle-hole RPA (phRPA) van Aggelen et al. 2013 ; van Aggelen et al. 2014 . In contrast to the phRPA variants, ppRPA preserves the correct antisymmetry, and does not suffer from instability. A series of successful applications of ppRPA has been reported Yang et al. 2013 ; Yang et al. 2015 ; Yang

Read the complete text