Adaptive Proximal Causal Inference with Some Invalid Proxies

Prabrisha Rakshit, Xu Shi, Eric Tchetgen Tchetgen · 2025

Read Adaptive Proximal Causal Inference with Some Invalid Proxies by Prabrisha Rakshit, Xu Shi, Eric Tchetgen Tchetgen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-19623.txt.

Introduction

Prabrisha Rakshit, Xu Shi, and Eric Tchetgen Tchetgen rescue causal estimates when some stand-in variables lie. Hidden confounding blocks many treatment studies, so researchers use proxies, observed variables tied to the hidden ones. Valid proxies must obey strict exclusion rules. With many proxies in play, some surely break the rules and bias the answer.

The team derives exact conditions for identification when an unknown subset of proxies is invalid. In a standard linear model, a penalized median estimator picks the valid proxies while estimating the effect. A flaw in that selector's consistency prompts an adaptive version with uneven penalties. The adaptive estimator converges at the standard rate and yields valid intervals when a sound outcome proxy exists. Extensions cover invalid outcome proxies too. Simulations and a real application support the theory.

Catalog record

CREATORPrabrisha Rakshit, Xu Shi, Eric Tchetgen Tchetgen
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE89 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-19623

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Adaptive Proximal Causal Inference with Some Invalid Proxies Prabrisha Rakshit, Xu Shi, Eric Tchetgen Tchetgen Abstract Proximal causal inference (PCI) is a recently proposed framework to identify and estimate the causal effect of an exposure on a given outcome, in the presence of hidden confounders for which proxies are available. Specifically, PCI relies on having observed two valid types of proxies; a treatment-inducing confounding proxy related to the outcome only to the extent that it is associated with an unmeasured confounder conditional on the primary treatment and measured covariates, and an outcome-inducing confounding proxy related to the treatment only through its association with an unmeasured confounder conditional on measured covariates. Therefore, valid proxies must satisfy stringent exclusion restrictions; mainly, a treatment-inducing confounding proxy must not cause the outcome, while an outcome-inducing confounding proxy must not be caused by the treatment. In order to improve the prospects for identification and possibly the efficiency of the approach, multiple proxies will often be used, raising concerns about bias due to a possible violation of the required exclusion restrictions. To address this concern, we introduce necessary and sufficient conditions for identifying causal effects in the presence of many confounding proxies, some of which may be invalid. Specifically, under a canonical proximal linear structural equations model, we propose a LASSO-based median estimator of the causal effect of primary interest, which simultaneously selects valid proxies and estimates the causal effect with corresponding theoretical performance guarantees. Despite its strengths, the LASSO-based approach can under certain conditions lead to inconsistent treatment proxy selection. To overcome this limitation, we introduce an adaptive LASSO-based proximal estimator, which incorporates adaptive weights to differentially penalize separate treatment proxy coefficients with respect to the ℓ 1 \ell_{1} penalty. We formally establish that the adaptive estimator is n \sqrt{n} -consistent for the causal effect, and when a valid outcome-confounding proxy is available, we construct corresponding asymptotically valid confidence intervals for the causal effect. We also extend the approach to the many outcome-confounding proxies setting, some of which may be invalid. All theoretical results are supported by extensive simulation studies. We apply the proposed methods to assess the impact of right heart catheterization on 30-day survival outcomes for critically ill ICU patients, utilizing data from the SUPPORT study. 1 Introduction Causal inference from observational data has historically primarily relied on the key untestable assumption that one has accurately measured all relevant confounding variables, such that units are exchangeable across treatment arms, conditional on measured covariates, so-called conditional exchangeability. However, even in well-designed observational studies where all important sources of confounding might be known, it may be unrealistic to assume that relevant confounders can be measured perfectly. In such settings, measured variables may at best be viewed as confounding proxies, which, although are associated with hidden confounding factors, do not suffice to ensure conditional exchangeability. Proximal causal inference was recently proposed ( Tchetgen et al. 2024 ; Miao et al. 2018 ) as a formal framework to identify and estimate causal effects in the presence of hidden confounders for which valid proxies are available. The approach technically relies on having two types of proxies of hidden confounders available in the observed sample: treatment-inducing confounding proxies (TCP), and outcome-inducing confounding proxies (OCP) , which meet certain stringent exclusion restriction conditions. Basically, a valid TCP must not have a direct effect on the primary outcome, and therefore must be associated with the latter only to the extent that it is associated with an unmeasured confounder conditional on the treatment and measured confounders; while an OCP must not directly be causally impacted by the primary treatment, and therefore be associated with the latter only to the extent that it is associated with a hidden confounder to the outcome solely through an unmeasured common cause for which the variable acts as a proxy, conditional on measured confounders. Furthermore, TCP and OCP variables must be conditionally independent given the primary treatment of interest, measured, and unmeasured confounders. Statistical methods for proximal causal inference with valid proxies are now well developed, in both parametric and semiparametric/nonparametric settings ( Cui et al. 2023 ; Ghassami et al. 2022 ; Deaner 2021 ; Liu et al. 2024 ) . To ground ideas, we briefly describe a standard PCI approach with valid confounding proxies, under a pair of linear structural equations for the primary outcome Y and OCP W , in terms of the primary treatment D , TCP Z and hidden confounder U : \displaystyle\mathbb{E}(Y\mid D,Z,U) \displaystyle=\beta D+\beta_{u}U, (1) \displaystyle\mathbb{E}(W\mid D,Z,U) \displaystyle=\eta_{u}U. where as a valid TCP Z appears in the conditioning event of both equations but not on their right-hand side; while as a valid OCP, the conditional mean of W also does not depend on A conditional on U . Assuming W is U -relevant, that is \eta_{u}\neq 0 , we have that: \mathbb{E}(Y\mid D,Z)=\beta D+\frac{\beta_{u}}{\eta_{u}}\mathbb{E}(W\mid D,Z). (2) Thus, given a consistent estimator \widehat{W} of \mathbb{E}(W\mid D,Z) , a least-squares regression of Y on D and \widehat{W} should recover a consistent estimator of \beta , the causal parameter of interest. This so-called “proximal two-stage least squares” (P2SLS) method is analogous to the 2SLS approach used in instrumental variable (IV) settings, allowing existing instrumental variable software to be re-purposed for P2SLS by treating W as the endogenous variable, Z as the instrument, and D as a covariate. Figure 1(a) illustrates the conditional independencies that valid TCP and OCP variables must satisfy to formally justify PCI. In an effort to improve the prospects for identification and potentially improve efficiency, multiple TCPs and OCPs are often considered in practical applications of proximal causal inference, raising concerns about bias due to a possible violation of the required exclusion restrictions. Specifically, existing PCI methods with multiple proxies require all proxies to be valid and may be severely biased even if a single candidate proxy does not fulfill the required exclusion identifying conditions, that is, say, if a TCP causally impacts the primary outcome of interest, or if the primary treatment has a direct causal effect on an OCP. Figure 1(b) illustrates potential violations of proxy conditions that would in principle invalidate the above P2SLS approach. To address this concern, in this paper, we derive the necessary and sufficient conditions for identifying causal effects in the presence of many confounding proxies, some of which may not be valid. Our main contributions are outlined in the following Section. U Z_{1} W_{1} D Y Z_{2} W_{2} (a) Z_{1},Z2 and W_{1},W_{2} are valid TCP and OCP respectively. U Z_{1} W_{1} D Y Z_{2} W_{2} (b) Z_{2} and W_{2} are invalid proxies, indicated by the presence of the red arrows in the DAG. Figure 1 : Comparison of two DAGs with different proxy validity. 2 Main Contributions and Related Works Proximal causal inference has recently emerged as a formal framework to leverage proxy variables to account for hidden confounders for which they are relevant. Originally proposed to address unmeasured confounding in a point exposure setting ( Miao et al. 2018 ; Tchetgen et al. 2024 ), the framework has since been extended in multiple directions, including mediation analysis subject to unmeasured confounding ( Dukes et al. 2023 ) , mediation analysis with a hidden mediator ( Ghassami et al. 2024 ) ,

Read the complete text