Fermi liquid and isotropic superconductivity of Hund scenario for bilayer nickelates

Jiangfan Wang, Yi-feng Yang · 2025

Read Fermi liquid and isotropic superconductivity of Hund scenario for bilayer nickelates by Jiangfan Wang, Yi-feng Yang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-19301.txt.

Introduction

Jiangfan Wang and Yi-feng Yang wrote this 2025 physics paper on why layered nickel compounds superconduct at high temperatures. Two stories compete. In one, the link between two kinds of electron orbits drives the pairing. In the other, a magnetic rule called Hund's coupling does the work. The team tests the second story with the same math tool used for the first.

Their counts give the Hund-driven state a smooth, even gap, a lower top temperature, and a normal state that behaves like a standard metal. Those traits clash with what the rival story gives. Set against fresh lab results on bulk and thin-film samples, the Hund story alone falls short. The authors conclude that the truth must draw on more than this one mechanism.

Catalog record

CREATORJiangfan Wang, Yi-feng Yang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-19301

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Fermi liquid and isotropic superconductivity of Hund scenario for bilayer nickelates Jiangfan Wang, Yi-feng Yang Abstract Recent experiments on bulk and thin film bilayer nickelate high- T c T_{c} superconductors urge for clarification of their pairing mechanism. Debates exist on whether the hybridization or the Hund’s coupling between the nickel d x 2 − y 2 d_{x^{2}-y^{2}} and d z 2 d_{z^{2}} orbitals plays a primary role in driving the superconductivity. Here, we study the Hund scenario and make comparisons with the hybridization scenario using the same dynamic Schwinger boson approach. Our calculations reveal several key features of the Hund-driven superconductivity, including an isotropic s s -wave gap, a lower maximum T c T_{c} , and Fermi liquid normal states, that differ from the hybridization-driven mechanism. We attribute these differences to their distinct low-energy dynamics. Comparison with recent experiments suggests that the Hund scenario alone is not enough to explain the bilayer nickelate superconductivity in both bulk and thin films. The discovery of bilayer Ruddlesden-Popper nickelate superconductor La 3 Ni 2 O 7 with a transition temperature T_{c}\approx 80 K under pressure has garnered significant attention MWang2023Nature ; JGCheng2023 ; HQYuan2024 ; ZChen2024 ; JGCheng2024Nature ; HHWen2024 ; XJZhou2024 ; LShu2024 ; DLFeng2024 ; MWang2024 ; MWang2024b ; LYang2024 ; Shen2025 . More recently, superconductivity with T_{c}\approx 40 K was discovered in the compressively strained (La,Pr) 3 Ni 2 O 7 Hwang2025 ; Chen2025 ; Hwang2025b ; QKXue2025 ; ZXShen2025 ; Hwang2025FL ; He2025pseudogap ; HHWen2025 ; ZYChen2025 and (La,Sr) 3 Ni 2 O 7 Nie2025 thin films at ambient pressure. Both host dominant nickel 3d_{z^{2}} and 3d_{x^{2}-y^{2}} bands near the Fermi level DXYao2023 ; Dagotto2023 ; Werner2023 ; Leonov2023 ; Eremin2023 ; YYCao2024 ; Eremin2024 ; MWang2023Nature ; QKXue2025 ; ZXShen2025 ; DXYao2025film ; WQChen2025 ; HHWen2024 ; XJZhou2024 , but exhibit significantly different T_{c} and normal state properties: the bulk La 3 Ni 2 O 7 displays linear-in- T resistivity above the superconducting dome under high pressure HQYuan2024 ; Shen2025 , while the thin films show Fermi liquid (FL) transport at ambient pressure Hwang2025FL . While density functional theory calculations predict d_{z^{2}} hole pockets for the high pressure phase of La 3 Ni 2 O 7 MWang2023Nature ; DXYao2023 , angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) measurements of (La,Pr) 3 Ni 2 O 7 thin films show contradictory d_{z^{2}} band position relative to the Fermi level QKXue2025 ; ZXShen2025 . These experimental facts provide important clues to clarify the true pairing mechanism among all different proposals. Theoretically, most studies are based on certain types of bilayer two-orbital Hubbard model or t - J model, and employ either weakly or strongly correlated approaches WQChen2025 ; JPHu2025 ; QHWang2025 ; JPHu2025PRL ; FYang2023 ; QHWang2023 ; YFYang2023 ; Wang2025 ; QQin2023 ; GMZhang2023 ; WWu2025 ; CJWu2024PRL ; CJWu2024 ; CJWu2025 ; GSu2024 ; GSu2025 ; YHZhang2023 ; Bohrdt2024 ; DXYao2023tJ ; YZYou2023 ; ZYWeng2024 ; ZYLu2024 ; Kuroki2024 ; WLi2024 ; KJiang2024 ; WKu2024 ; TXiang2024 . The weak-correlation theories treat the Fermi surface nesting and its associated spin density wave fluctuations as the origin of the pairing glue, but remain debated on whether it is sufficient to explain the high T_{c} without resorting to electron-phonon interaction QHWang2025 ; JPHu2025PRL . By contrast, the strong-correlation theories regard the interlayer superexchange interaction of the (nearly) half-filled d_{z^{2}} electrons as the primary interaction for the pairing, but are divided as to whether the hybridization YFYang2023 ; Wang2025 ; QQin2023 ; GMZhang2023 ; WWu2025 or the Hund’s coupling CJWu2024PRL ; CJWu2024 ; CJWu2025 ; GSu2024 ; GSu2025 ; YHZhang2023 ; Bohrdt2024 play a key role in transmitting the pairing interaction to itinerant d_{x^{2}-y^{2}} electrons for the superconducting phase coherence. In the hybridization scenario described by a bilayer two-orbital t - V - J model YFYang2023 ; Wang2025 ; QQin2023 , where t , V , J represents the intralayer d_{x^{2}-y^{2}} hopping, hybridization, and d_{z^{2}} interlayer superexchange, respectively, previous Schwinger boson calculations in the large U limit have predicted a highly asymmetric superconducting dome upon d_{z^{2}} hole doping, and a non-Fermi liquid (NFL) normal state around optimal J (for maximum T_{c} ) Wang2025 , in agreement with experiments of pressurized La 3 Ni 2 O 7 MWang2024b ; HQYuan2024 ; Shen2025 . The maximum T_{c}^{\text{max}} is found to be about 0.17J from mean-field type Schwinger boson calculations Wang2025 , and 0.05J from auxiliary-field Monte Carlo simulations where superconducting phase fluctuations are included QQin2023 ; QQin2025 . It has anisotropic s^{\pm} -wave gaps with nodes or minima along the zone diagonal on the d_{x^{2}-y^{2}} Fermi surfaces ( \alpha and \beta ) and an isotropic s -wave gap on the d_{z^{2}} Fermi surface ( \gamma ), consistent with recent experiments of La 2 PrNi 2 O 7 HHWen2025 and (La,Pr,Sm) 3 Ni 2 O 7 thin films ZYChen2025 . On the other hand, the Hund scenario is often studied based on some type of effective single-band t - J model of d_{x^{2}-y^{2}} electrons in the infinite Hund’s coupling limit CJWu2024PRL ; GSu2024 ; YHZhang2023 ; Bohrdt2024 . Despite of some recent work focusing on finite Hund’s coupling CJWu2025 ; GSu2025 , a comprehensive study of its phase diagram, T_{c}^{\text{max}} , superconducting and normal state properties based on a bilayer two-orbital model is highly demanded for a faithful comparison with recent experiments and other theories. In this work, we study a bilayer two-orbital t - J_{H} - J model using the dynamic Schwinger boson approach and focusing on the interplay between the inter-orbital Hund’s coupling ( J_{H} ) and the d_{z^{2}} interlayer superexchange ( J ). We found several important differences of the Hund scenario as summarized in Table 1 : 1) Its pairing vertex of d_{x^{2}-y^{2}} electrons exhibits no momentum dependence, suggesting a fully isotropic s -wave gap; 2) Its T_{c}^{\text{max}}/J is about 40% lower than the hybridization scenario; 3) Its T_{c} is monotonically suppressed by the d_{z^{2}} hole doping; 4) Its normal state is always a Fermi liquid irrespective of the Hund’s coupling strength. Comparison of these results with recent experiments suggests that the Hund scenario alone is not enough to explain the superconductivity in both bulk and thin film bilayer nickelates. Table 1: Comparison between the Schwinger boson results of the t - V - J model (hybridization scenario) in the large U limit studied in Ref. Wang2025 and the t - J_{H} - J model (Hund scenario) studied in this work. A factor of 0.3 is introduced for the T_{c}^{\text{max}} to account for the phase fluctuations. t - V - J t - J_{H} - J Gap structure Anisotropic s^{\pm} Isotropic s^{\pm} 0.3T_{c}^{\text{max}}/J \approx 0.05 \approx 0.03 d_{z^{2}} metallization Promotes SC Suppresses SC Normal state NFL around optimal J FL for all J Model— We consider the effective t - J_{H} - J model defined on a bilayer square lattice, \displaystyle H \displaystyle= \displaystyle-\sum_{lijs}(t_{ij}+\mu\delta_{ij})c_{lis}^{\dagger}c_{ljs}-J_{H}\sum_{li}\bm{S}_{li}\cdot\bm{s}_{li} (1) \displaystyle+J\sum_{i}\bm{S}_{1i}\cdot\bm{S}_{2i}, where c_{lis}^{\dagger} creates a d_{x^{2}-y^{2}} electron on site i of the l -th ( l=1,2 ) layer with spin s=\pm 1 , \bm{s}_{li}=\frac{1}{2}\sum_{ss^{\prime}}c_{lis}^{\dagger}\bm{\sigma}_{ss^{\prime}}c_{lis^{\prime}} is its spin density operator, \bm{S}_{li} denotes the local d_{z^{2}} spin, t_{ij}=t is the in-plane nearest neighbor hopping amplitude, and \mu is the chemical potential of d_{x^{2}-y^{2}} electrons. The above Hamiltonian is schematically represented in

Read the complete text