EVAluation of the Equivalent Vector Boson Approximation at highest energy colliders Preprint: DESY-25-104 COMETA-2025-29
Benjamin Dahlén, Maximilian Löschner, Krzysztof Mękała, Jürgen Reuter, Panagiotis Stylianou · 2025
Read EVAluation of the Equivalent Vector Boson Approximation at highest energy colliders Preprint: DESY-25-104 COMETA-2025-29 by Benjamin Dahlén, Maximilian Löschner, Krzysztof Mękała, Jürgen Reuter, Panagiotis Stylianou (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-19285.txt.
Introduction
Benjamin Dahlén and co-authors stress-test a favorite shortcut of collider physics at the energies ahead, in a 2025 paper. Above ten trillion electron volts, the W and Z bosons behave almost like light partons inside colliding particles, and the Equivalent Vector boson Approximation replaces hard calculations with their fusion picture. The team ran the approximation, inside a standard event generator, against full matrix-element truth across top, Higgs, neutrino, and boson pair production.
No universal setting tamed the mismatch; each process wanted its own prescription, and discrepancies stayed observable-dependent. Parameter uncertainties could reach a hundred percent. Careful kinematic cuts are the only brake, they conclude. The shortcut survives, but on a short leash.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Benjamin Dahlén, Maximilian Löschner, Krzysztof Mękała, Jürgen Reuter, Panagiotis Stylianou |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-19285
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
EVAluation of the Equivalent Vector Boson Approximation at highest energy colliders Preprint: DESY-25-104 COMETA-2025-29 Benjamin Dahlén, Maximilian Löschner, Krzysztof Mękała, Jürgen Reuter, Panagiotis Stylianou Abstract Collider processes at the highest available partonic center-of-mass energies – 10 TeV and above – exhibit a new regime of electroweak interactions where electroweak gauge bosons mostly act as quasi-massless partons in vector boson fusion processes. We scrutinize these processes using the Equivalent Vector boson Approximation (EVA) based on its implementation in the Monte Carlo generator framework Whizard . Using a variety of important physics processes, including top pairs, Higgs pairs, neutrino pairs, and vector boson pairs, we study the behavior of processes initiated by transverse and longitudinal vector bosons, both W W and Z Z induced. The flexibility of our framework allows to study such processes at different high-energy colliders, such as a muon collider or a high-energy proton collider like FCC-hh. Studying a set of differential distributions, we show which scale choices are the most preferable ones to best approximate results based on full matrix elements. 1 Introduction One of the most important tasks after the current run of the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) and its high-luminosity phase will be to study electroweak (EW) interactions in their high-energy regime, well above the scale where the symmetry is broken, \Lambda\sim 4\pi v\sim 3\,\text{TeV} . Unlike QCD, the EW interactions have never been probed in this energy regime, far above their intrinsic scale. There are also many other reasons for energy-frontier collider-based particle physics, like beyond the Standard Model (BSM) searches or searches for dark matter, that motivate particle collisions at the multi-TeV scale. The US Particle Physics Project Prioritization Panel (P5) report P5:2023wyd , following the Snowmass Community Summer Studies of 2022, has advocated the path towards a 10 TeV (and maybe more) parton-center-of-mass energy collider, for which three technology paths are potentially feasible: as a proton-proton collider synchrotron FCC:2018vvp , as a circular muon collider Accettura:2023ked or as an electron-positron or photon-based plasma wakefield collider Gessner:2025acq . At such a collider, a new regime of EW interactions will enter, more and more resembling the “unbroken” phase of separate (quasi-)massless non-Abelian SU(2)_{L} vector bosons and scalar Goldstone bosons. An important feature of physics predictions at the LHC is the fact that one can decouple different parts of an interaction by finding the energy regime relevant for each of them and applying the concept of factorization . This, among other things, leads to the definition of parton distribution functions (PDFs), which describe the probability of finding a given parton with certain kinematic properties inside of a proton to subsequently participate in a hard interaction. A similar concept can be applied to high-energy lepton colliders. For instance, if a process initiated by a photon emitted collinearly from a charged lepton is considered, one can describe the interaction by convoluting a universal structure function incorporating the probability of the emission with a matrix element for the hard, photon-initiated process. Such an approach, known as the Equivalent Photon Approximation Fermi:1924tc ; vonWeizsacker:1934nji ; Williams:1935dka , has been broadly discussed in the literature (see e.g. Brodsky:1971ud ; Budnev:1975poe ; Frixione:1993yw ; Engel:1995yda ; Vysotskii:2018eic ). The treatment was also later extended to the weak-boson case CAHN1984196 ; DAWSON198542 ; KANE1984367 ; the so-called Equivalent Vector Boson Approximation (EVA) relies on the fact that massive vector bosons can be effectively viewed as massless for collision energies well above the electroweak scale Lindfors:1985yp ; Gunion:1986gm ; Kleiss:1986xp ; Kunszt:1987tk ; Johnson:1987tj ; Abbasabadi:1988ja ; Kuss:1995yv ; Kuss:1996ww ; Accomando:2006mc ; Borel:2012by ; Costantini:2020stv ; Ruiz:2021tdt ; Bigaran:2025rvb ; Frixione:2025guf ; Frixione:2025wsv . The EPA and EVA are mostly based on an identification and separation of regions that lead to logarithmic enhancements due to soft or collinear splittings in the initial state; the corresponding factorized entities are historically called structure functions, motivated from the picture of deep inelastic scattering (DIS). A systematic quantum field theoretic approach leads to a factorization where such logarithms can be systematically resummed by means of a Dokshitzer-Gribov-Lipatov-Altarelli-Parisi (DGLAP) equation Gribov:1972ri ; Altarelli:1977zs ; Dokshitzer:1977sg : it such a case the structure functions become parton distribution functions (PDFs) in a field theoretic embedding. In the past decade, it was demonstrated that this framework can be also applied to the resummation of large initial state EW collinear logarithms, potentially helping to improve the precision of the predictions for multi-TeV interactions Han:2020uid ; Han:2021kes . Moreover, there is very recent work on the formal derivation of electroweak splitting functions without relying on a specific Lorentz frame Dittmaier:2025htf . In this paper, we focus on the EVA and study its potential for simplifying calculations for both future high-energy lepton and hadron colliders with a focus on future muon colliders. Though this approach is equally suited for BSM (cf. the complexity of BSM resonance searches in vector boson scattering Kilian:2014zja ; Fleper:2016frz ; Brass:2018hfw ) and SM processes, for the sake of conciseness, we will focus on standard candle SM processes in this paper. We will start our study with a hypothetical e^{+}\mu^{-} -collider for a theoretically simple setup where most non-vector boson fusion topologies are absent and we, hence, expect the approximation to hold best. Then, we continue with more realistic setups, experimentally viable signatures and cuts to show the regions of phase space of the approach and this quality there. The paper is structured as follows: in sec. 2 we give a brief kinematic derivation of the EVA, discuss its implementation in the Monte Carlo event generator framework Whizard and show semi-numerical convolutions of the EVA structure functions with hard squared matrix elements for simple 2\to 2 processes. In sec. 3 , we compare full matrix elements for many key SM processes with the corresponding vector boson fusion processes using the EVA, and study phase space cuts and scale choices. Finally, we summarize our findings in sec. 4 . In the appendix, we give some practical details on the usage of the EVA within Whizard . 2 Theoretical framework of the EVA In this section, we give a general overview of how the EVA is derived and discuss a few crucial points for our study. For a detailed derivation, we refer the reader e.g. to Appendix B of Ruiz:2021tdt or sec. 4.2.2. of Kilian:2003pc . 2.1 Kinematic derivation of the EVA structure functions The base of the EVA is the collinear emission of EW vector bosons off incoming lepton beams, as depicted in fig. 1 . Figure 1 : Prototype diagram in the EW deep inelastic scattering (DIS) picture as the starting point for the derivation of the EVA. Here, we decompose the intermediate off-shell vector boson propagator into a polarization sum, i.e. \frac{d_{G}^{\mu\nu}(q)}{q^{2}-m_{V}^{2}}=\frac{1}{q^{2}-m_{V}^{2}}\sum_{\lambda}\epsilon_{G}^{\mu}(q,\lambda)^{*}\epsilon_{G}^{\nu}(q,\lambda), (1) where d_{G}^{\mu\nu}(k) is the propagator numerator in a given gauge G ( e.g. R_{\xi} -gauge or axial gauge). The sum goes over transverse ( \lambda=\pm 1 ), longitudinal ( \lambda=0 ) and, depending on the gauge, also unphysical (scalar) polarizations ( \lambda=S ). For explicit expressions of the polarization vectors and propagator numerators in an R_{\xi} -gauge and in an axial gauge, we refer to Bigaran:2025rvb ; Dittmaier:2025htf . Note that similar decompositions are used in the context of vector boson fusion, see e.g. Perez:2018kav