Studying propagating turbulent structures in the near wake of a sphere using Hilbert proper orthogonal decomposition
Shaun Davey, Callum Atkinson and Julio Soria · 2025
Read Studying propagating turbulent structures in the near wake of a sphere using Hilbert proper orthogonal decomposition by Shaun Davey, Callum Atkinson and Julio Soria (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-19167.txt.
Introduction
Shaun Davey, Callum Atkinson, and Julio Soria compare two ways to pull traveling patterns from turbulence in a 2025 paper. Behind a sphere, the wake churns yet hides orderly structures that drift downstream. A classic decomposition finds spatial modes, and a Hilbert-based variant finds moving ones, at the cost of filtering artifacts.
The study ran both methods on the same wake velocity data. Mode pairs from the classic method that match the moving structures were pinpointed. A cheaper shortcut emerged: applying the Hilbert transform to the classic modes alone reproduced the special modes well. That trick avoids the artifacts of transforming the raw data first. The result sharpens how engineers read turbulent wakes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shaun Davey, Callum Atkinson and Julio Soria |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 74 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-19167
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Studying propagating turbulent structures in the near wake of a sphere using Hilbert proper orthogonal decomposition Shaun Davey, Callum Atkinson and Julio Soria Abstract Turbulent flows, despite their apparent randomness, exhibit coherent structures that underpin their dynamics. Proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) has been widely used to extract these structures from experimental data. While periodic features like vortex shedding can be identified using POD mode pairs when periodicity dominates the flow, detecting such structures in complex flows is more challenging. The Hilbert proper orthogonal decomposition (HPOD) addresses this by applying POD to the analytic signal of the turbulent fluctuations, yielding complex modes with a 90 ∘ 90^{\circ} phase shift between the real and imaginary components. These modes capture propagating structures effectively but introduce filtering artefacts from the Hilbert transform that is used to derive the analytic signal. The current work investigates the relationship between the modes of the POD and those of the HPOD on the velocity fluctuations in the wake of a sphere. By comparing their outputs, POD mode pairs that correspond to the same propagating structures revealed by HPOD are identified. Furthermore, this study explored whether computing the analytic signal of the POD modes can replicate the HPOD modes, offering a more computationally efficient method for determining the pairs of POD modes that represent propagating structures. The results show that the pairs of POD modes identified by the HPOD can be more efficiently determined using the Hilbert transform directly on the POD modes. This method enhances the interpretive power of POD, enabling more detailed analysis of turbulent dynamics without introducing the filtering from the Hilbert transform. 1 Introduction While turbulence often appears random, many turbulent flows contain underlying structures, such as eddies and vortices, the scale and nature of which vary depending on the conditions of the flow. Identifying these structures allows for a more detailed description of the flow, as well as the isolation of the dominant structures in the turbulence based on their contribution to the quantity or phenomenon of interest, such as TKE ( TKE ) or mixing. Ranking these structures based on their significance to a given application or study allows the construction of parsimonious reduced-order models, which can be used to reduce the computational intensity of analyses or to reduce noise from experimental data. The complex flow phenomena present in the flow over bluff bodies, even at low Reynolds numbers, develop as the Reynolds number increases, and are a subject of ongoing study. In this respect, the flow over spheres serves as a canonical model for flows over axisymmetric bluff bodies, and is of particular interest for developing a broad understanding of these flow phenomena. The phenomena observed in the wake of a sphere include transition from axisymmetry to planar symmetry to asymmetry, the formation and shedding of vortices, the development of shear layer instabilities, and flow separation. As the flow over a sphere varies significantly with Reynolds number, experimental and numerical investigations have covered a wide range of Reynolds number regimes. In the context of experimental studies of the flow over spheres, one of the main challenges is fixing the sphere in a wind or water tunnel test section with minimal disturbance of the flow, since more often than not, the mounting/support structure of the sphere can have a significant influence on the flow. The supports chosen for an experiment should simultaneously provide rigid and stable positioning of the sphere, and minimise the disturbance to the flow, while also facilitating the placement of probes without obstructing optical measurement access. Some of the supports used in these studies include rigid downstream supports [ 1 ] , honeycomb structures with rigid supports upstream of the sphere [ 2 , 3 ] , and wires placed azimuthally [ 4 , 5 ] . The drag on the spheres has been measured using hot-wire probes [ 1 , 6 ] , with flow visualisations performed using aluminium dust [ 7 ] , smoke [ 8 , 5 ] , and dyes [ 9 , 4 , 10 ] to gain a qualitative understanding of the recirculation region, flow separation, and vortex shedding in the wake. Various forms of PIV ( PIV ), including planar [ 5 ] , stereographic [ 3 ] and tomographic [ 11 ] , have been used to quantitatively measure the flow around spheres. While mounting the sphere is not a concern in numerical studies, simulations are subject to their own set of challenges. The geometry of the problem and the range of scales involved require careful consideration of the mesh and solver to resolve the flow at high Reynolds numbers. Because of this complexity, LES ( LES ) [ 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] and DES ( DES ) [ 14 , 16 ] methods have been favoured over the more computationally expensive DNS ( DNS ) [ 12 , 15 , 17 , 18 ] to resolve the main features of the flow at high Reynolds numbers. In conjunction with the advancement of computational capabilities, these models have extended the feasibility of numerical investigations of the flow over spheres to large Reynolds numbers. Experimental and numerical studies have examined the development of the flow over spheres over a wide range Reynolds number regimes. At low Reynolds number, Re_{D}<20 , the flow in the wake is laminar and axisymmetric, and there is no recirculation [ 7 , 13 ] . A small vortex ring forms near the rear stagnation point around Re_{D}\approx 25 [ 7 ] , and elongates in the streamwise direction with increasing Reynolds number. This vortex ring begins to oscillate around Re_{D}\approx 130 with a long period, which becomes more prominent at higher Reynolds numbers. The recirculation region formed behind the sphere, which exhibits reverse flow in the mean, extends further downstream of the sphere as Reynolds number increases [ 9 ] . The axisymmetry in the wake at low Reynolds number is lost due to the formation of a double-threaded wake around Re_{D}\approx 210 [ 9 , 13 ] , which consists of two streamwise vortices of opposing sign that can be seen as dye threads in the wake of a free-falling sphere [ 19 ] . Single-frequency vortex shedding begins around Re_{D}\approx 300 [ 7 , 4 ] , and hairpin-shaped vortices form at Re_{D}\approx 400 [ 10 ] . The generation of an unsteady random side force, which has been observed in both experimental [ 8 ] and numerical [ 20 ] studies results in the loss of planar symmetry in the wake in the range of 400<Re_{D}<500 [ 7 ] . From Re_{D}=800 , the small-scale Kelvin-Helmholtz instability in the shear layer at the edge of the recirculation region manifests as axisymmetric vortex shedding [ 16 , 21 ] . This is the higher frequency of two instability modes identified in the wake of the sphere by [ 22 ] , with the lower frequency mode arising from large-scale vortex shedding. Small-scale vortical structures are shed from the main vortical structure around Re_{D}\approx 1000 [ 20 ] , and the recirculation region behind the sphere begins to shrink with increasing Reynolds number. Periodic fluctuations are present in the wake for much higher