Photon condensation from thermal sources and the limits of heat engines

Luísa Toledo Tude, Emily Haughton, Paul R. Eastham · 2025

Read Photon condensation from thermal sources and the limits of heat engines by Luísa Toledo Tude, Emily Haughton, Paul R. Eastham (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-19128.txt.

Introduction

Luisa Toledo Tude, Emily Haughton, and Paul Eastham ask when light trapped in a dye-filled microcavity condenses, and what heat engines have to do with it, in a paper from 2025. Photon gases cooled in such cavities can form Bose-Einstein condensates, a quantum state of light. The photons can be pumped by driving the dye, or fed by a warm source like sunlight.

The team finds that the threshold pump temperature for condensation is set by the second law of thermodynamics. The lowest possible threshold matches that of a reversible three-level heat engine. Dye pumping and a two-level cavity both reach that ideal; a many-level cavity needs slightly more heat. The result means even incoherent warm light can, in principle, seed a condensate.

Catalog record

CREATORLuísa Toledo Tude, Emily Haughton, Paul R. Eastham
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE23 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-19128

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Photon condensation from thermal sources and the limits of heat engines Luísa Toledo Tude, Emily Haughton, Paul R. Eastham Abstract The trapping and cooling of photon gases in microcavities has been used to create Bose-Einstein condensates. We investigate the conditions required for condensation in dye-filled microcavities, with photon populations created either by driving a transition of the dye or by coupling to an external thermal photon reservoir such as sunlight. We show that the threshold pump temperature, above which condensation appears, is determined by the second law of thermodynamics. The minimum achievable threshold is that of a reversible three-level heat engine, which we show arises in the dye-pumped case, and for the external pumping of a two-level cavity. For a many-level cavity condensation occurs at a similar but higher temperature. The increase is attributed to irreversible heat transfers and the associated entropy production. The thermalization of cavity photons by inelastic scattering can be used to produce equilibrated photon gases, at densities and temperatures sufficient to achieve Bose-Einstein condensates. Such condensates have been observed in dye-filled microcavities Klaers et al. 2010 ; Marelic and Nyman 2015 ; Greveling et al. 2018 , plasmonic lattices Hakala et al. 2018 , doped fibers, Weill et al. 2019 ; Weill et al. 2021 and semiconductor microcavities Schofield et al. 2024 ; Pieczarka et al. 2024 ; Barland et al. 2021 . In these systems photons are rapidly absorbed and re-emitted by the medium, allowing the gas to cool without significant loss of photons. The resulting condensates have been used to explore the physics of near-ideal Bose gases, including grand-canonical fluctuations Schmitt et al. 2016 ; Klaers et al. 2012 , fluctuation-dissipation theorems Öztürk et al. 2023 , heat capacity Damm et al. 2016 , equations-of-state Busley et al. 2022 , and the approach to the continuum limit Erglis et al. 2024 . Non-equilibrium effects have also been studied, including the breakdown of thermalization Kirton and Keeling 2015 ; Kirton and Keeling 2013 and coherence Tang et al. 2024 and non-equilibrium phase transitions Öztürk et al. 2021 ; Erglis et al. 2024 . An important feature of these systems is that the photon distribution functions are close to thermal, due to the fast inelastic scattering. This distinguishes photon condensates from typical lasers Schmitt et al. 2015 or exciton-polariton condensates Gomez-Dominguez et al. 2025 . Nonetheless, there is a loss of condensate photons through the cavity mirrors, which is offset by an external pump. The condensation is therefore occurring not in equilibrium, but in a nonequilibrium steady state with energy and particle flow. The properties of such a steady state are not completely captured by an equilibrium description: in particular, whether it is condensed or not depends on the density, and therefore on the kinetics and the strength and form of pumping Marelic and Nyman 2015 . Figure 1: Photon condensation in a dye-filled cavity as a heat engine. The cavity photons which condense originate from an external source, corresponding to the hot bath of the engine, while excess energy is dissipated into the cold bath, provided by the solvent. The work output corresponds to the coherent emission from the condensate. Here we show that there are straightforward and universal criteria for photon condensation. We focus on dye-filled cavities and investigate, in addition to the typical situation where the dye is pumped with a laser Klaers et al. 2010 ; Kirton and Keeling 2013 ; Kirton and Keeling 2015 , one where the cavity modes are pumped with a thermal source such as sunlight. We point out that photon condensates, similarly to lasers Scovil and Schulz-DuBois 1959 , fluorescent concentrators Smestad et al. 1990 and polariton condensates Toledo Tude and Eastham 2024 , are forms of heat engine, which convert energy from a hot reservoir, corresponding to the pump, into work, corresponding to the coherent emission (see Fig. 1). We analyze the kinetic equations and show that the pumping strength required for condensation, encoded in the temperature of the hot reservoir T_{h} , is given by the requirement of positive entropy production. In certain limits the threshold is at zero entropy production, and corresponds to the condition for operation of a reversible (Carnot) three-level heat engine Scovil and Schulz-DuBois 1959 ; Geusic et al. 1967 ; Toledo Tude and Eastham 2024 ; Kosloff and Levy 2014 , Eq. ( 9 ). This occurs for fast thermalization, compared with the particle gain/loss, and reservoirs which couple at a single frequency. We extend our analysis to consider external pumping at multiple frequencies, which leads to an increase in threshold due to entropy production and irreversibility Landi and Paternostro 2021 . The increases are relatively small, however, and this disadvantage can be offset by a larger condensate and output power. Our results expose the thermodynamic principles of steady-state condensation and establish the general conditions under which it can be achieved. Although photon condensates have great potential as light emitters and in energy harvesting and studies of quantum thermodynamics, this has been limited by the requirements of laser pumping. Our results show how this long-standing challenge could be overcome, and condensation achieved using low-temperature thermal sources such as sunlight. For definiteness we consider a dye-filled microcavity with harmonic in-plane confinement Klaers et al. 2010 , as shown in Fig. 1 . In such a structure there are transverse modes m=0,1,\ldots,m_{\text{max}} with photon occupations n_{m} , frequencies \omega_{m}=\omega_{0}+m\epsilon , and degeneracies g_{m}=m+1 , where \omega_{0} is the transverse ground-state frequency, and \epsilon the trapping frequency. Our analysis is based on a generalization of the kinetic equations used in Kirton and Keeling 2015 ; Kirton and Keeling 2013 : \displaystyle\dot{n}_{m}(t)= \displaystyle N_{d}\left[\Gamma^{e}_{m}(n_{m}+1)p_{e}-\Gamma^{a}_{m}n_{m}p_{g}\right] \displaystyle+\kappa_{m}\left[n^{h}_{m}(n_{m}+1)-(n^{h}_{m}+1)n_{m}\right]. (1) The first line of Eq. ( 1 ) describes the emission and absorption of photons from N_{d} dye molecules. Each is modeled as a two-state electronic system, with excited and ground state populations p_{e} and p_{g}=1-p_{e} , respectively, coupled to molecular vibrations. \Gamma_{m}^{e} and \Gamma_{m}^{a} are the emission and absorption rates. These can be computed from microscopic models. However, for our purposes it suffices that they satisfy the Kennard-Stepanov relation Kennard 1918 \Gamma_{m}^{e}=\Gamma_{m}^{a}e^{-(\omega_{m}-\omega_{d})/T_{c}} , where \omega_{d} is the zero-phonon transition frequency, and T_{c} the temperature of the solvent ( \hbar=k=1 ). The electronic population obeys \dot{p}_{e}(t)=-({\Gamma}_{\downarrow}^{\rm tot}+\Gamma_{\downarrow})p_{e}+({\Gamma}_{\uparrow}^{\rm tot}+\Gamma_{\uparrow})p_{g}.\ (2) Here \Gamma_{\downarrow}^{\rm tot}=\sum_{m}g_{m}\Gamma^{e}_{m}(n_{m}+1) and \Gamma_{\uparrow}^{\rm tot}=\sum_{m}g_{m}\Gamma^{a}_{m}n_{m} are transition rates due to the emission and absorption of cavity photons, respectively, while \Gamma_{\downarrow} and \Gamma_{\uparrow} describe other processes. Figure 2: Computed photon occupations as functions of the pump strength expressed as a temperature T_{h} . Black curves: occupations of the lowest energy mode with pumping of the dye (solid), or external photons (dashed), the latter considering only two harmonic-oscillator levels (see text). The thresholds agree with Eq. ( 9 ) (black arrow). The dashed curve shows a smoother threshold due to the smaller photon numbers. Blue curves: total occupation (dotted) and ground-state occupation (dot-dashed), for pumping with external photons, including all harmonic-oscillator levels. The threshold agrees with Eq. ( 10 ) (blue arrow). We consider two different ways in which system can be pumped. In the first scenario, considered previously Kirton and Keeling 2015 ; Kirton and Keeling 2013 , the dye is pumped and fluoresces into the cavity modes, creating

Read the complete text