Interactive, Grouped and Non-separable Fixed Effects: A Practitioner’s Guide to the New Panel Data Econometrics

Jan Ditzen, Yiannis Karavias · 2025

Read Interactive, Grouped and Non-separable Fixed Effects: A Practitioner’s Guide to the New Panel Data Econometrics by Jan Ditzen, Yiannis Karavias (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-19099.txt.

Introduction

Jan Ditzen and Yiannis Karavias wrote a practitioner's guide in 2025 to new panel data methods in econometrics. Panel data follow many units over time, and hidden traits of each unit can bias results. The past twenty years brought richer ways to model those traits. Some let hidden traits interact with shared time factors; others group units or allow non-separable effects.

The guide reviews the new estimators and the tests that detect which form fits. Two worked studies show the new forms are common in real data. Results can differ sharply from older fixed-effects methods. The authors aim to help applied researchers pick and check the right tool.

Catalog record

CREATORJan Ditzen, Yiannis Karavias
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE125 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-19099

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Interactive, Grouped and Non-separable Fixed Effects: A Practitioner’s Guide to the New Panel Data Econometrics Note: Acknowledgements: The authors would like to thank Aureo De Paula, Ao Wang, Anindya Banerjee, Marco Barassi, Vasilis Sarafidis, Lorenzo Trapani, Chongxian Zhu, Giovanni Millo participants of the first Midlands Econometrics Conference. They would also like to thank Binzhi Chen for the grouped fixed effects estimations. All remaining errors are ours. Jan Ditzen, Yiannis Karavias Abstract The past 20 years have brought fundamental advances in modeling unobserved heterogeneity in panel data. Interactive Fixed Effects (IFE) proved to be a foundational framework, generalizing the standard one-way and two-way fixed effects models by allowing the unit-specific unobserved heterogeneity to be interacted with unobserved time-varying common factors, allowing for more general forms of omitted variables. The IFE framework laid the theoretical foundations for other forms of heterogeneity, such as grouped fixed effects (GFE) and non-separable two-way fixed effects (NSTW). The existence of IFE, GFE or NSTW has significant implications for identification, estimation, and inference, leading to the development of many new estimators for panel data models. This paper provides an accessible review of the new estimation methods and their associated diagnostic tests, and offers a guide to empirical practice. In two separate empirical investigations we demonstrate that there is empirical support for the new forms of fixed effects and that the results can differ significantly from those obtained using traditional fixed effects estimators. 1 Introduction In the almost 60 years that came after the seminal paper by Balestra and Nerlove 1966 , the merits of panel data sets in dealing with endogeneity due to omitted variables have been well understood, and this has led to the standard practice of consistent repeat observation and measurement of many units over long periods. The availability of large N - large T panel datasets, where N denotes the number of units and T denotes the number of time series observations, is now pervasive in all strands of the economics literature, and beyond. 1 1 1 See Baltagi 2008 and Hsiao 2014 for textbook introductions to the panel data literature. A fundamental assumption in panel data models is that they include individual effects which capture the effect of time-invariant unobserved characteristics which are effectively unobserved omitted variables. Observation over long periods however, possibly over years and decades, put a strain on the sufficiency of time invariance as the omitted variables are more likely to have time-varying effects instead. This argument is conceptually no different to the emergence of the structural breaks literature in time series, where the long time series dimension increased the probability of time-varying parameters as a result of changes in the economic conditions ( Perron 1989 ; Andrews 1993 ) . As such, models and methods for capturing time-varying unobserved heterogeneity became necessary. The two-way fixed effects (TWFE) model, which is the current workhorse in the literature, partly addresses this issue through a time-varying common effect. Still this is not sufficient as it imposes the assumption that time variation affects equally the heterogeneous units. A key modeling innovation, developed for different reasons but nevertheless capable of dealing with time variation, is the introduction of “interactive fixed effects” (IFE) by Holtz-Eakin et al. 1988 ; Robertson and Symons 2000 ; Ahn et al. 2001 , and Coakley et al. 2002 . The IFE represents a significant novelty and generalization compared to the TWFE, in that it allows individual effects to have a time varying and heterogeneous impact on the dependent variable. It is useful to compare TWFE and IFE. Let u_{i,t}=z_{i}+f_{t}+\varepsilon_{i,t} be the TWFE model, where z_{i} is an individual effect and f_{t} is the factor, or time effect. The index i=1,...,N where N is the number of units in the panel and t=1,...,T where T is the number of time series observations. A simple version of the IFE model then is u_{i,t}=z_{i}f_{t}+\varepsilon_{i,t} . The interaction term z_{i}f_{t} is the source of the “interactive” fixed effects nomenclature which is due to Bai 2009 . The IFE allows the z_{i} and f_{t} to be m -dimensional vectors, in which case TWFE can be a part of IFE for z_{i}f_{t}=z_{i,1}+f_{1,t}+z_{i,2}f_{2,t}+...+z_{i,m}f_{m,t} , or even the only part if m=2 . The main motivation behind this paper is to introduce the new estimation methods and to nudge applied panel data research towards the greater use of the IFE, and its extensions, given that to this date, it is somewhat limited. Despite IFE being a key topic in theoretical research, its use is dysanalogous in empirical research. One reason for this could be the lack of understanding of the pervasiveness of this type of endogeneity when T is large, while another one could be the only recent development of many methods that are used to estimate IFE models. In this paper, we review the key contributions in the area in terms of estimation and diagnostic testing, and discuss the basic assumptions and their implications for empirical practice. Our focus lies on estimation methodology and the assumptions that have a direct impact on the choices of the researcher, and not on technical technical regularity conditions, which will be omitted. To further facilitate the use of IFE models, an appendix with a list of references to readily available software is included at the end. As such, this paper complements previous literature reviews such Hsiao 2014 ; Chudik and Pesaran 2015b , Juodis and Reese 2025 and Bonhomme and Denis 2025 . The introduction of IFE is followed by two more new forms of unobserved heterogeneity: group fixed effects (GFE) ( Bonhomme and Manresa 2015 ) and non-separable two-way heterogeneity (NSTW) ( Bonhomme et al. 2022 ) . The GFE model is a special case of IFE where the z_{i} are indicator functions such that each of the m factors is unique for each of the m distinct groups in the data. GFE can be preferable to IFE in smaller datasets as it is a more parsimonious model restricting the z_{i} from varying across the N units to varying only across the m groups. NSTW is a, potentially nonlinear, generalization of IFE and can be written as h(z_{i},f_{t}) , where h(\cdot,\cdot) is a smooth function, unknown to the researcher. It can be shown that h(z_{i},f_{t}) can be approximated by an IFE model with m\to\infty ( Freeman and Weidner 2023 ) . The emergence of GFE and NSTW marks an important shift in methodology and also in the econometric difficulties that have been accompanying TWFE and its extensions. Discretization, inspired by GFE where unobserved heterogeneity is restricted, was introduced in Bonhomme et al. 2022 and involves approximating the unknown function h(z_{,}f_{t}) with clustering. Once the main clusters have been estimated, then the two-way clustered fixed effects estimator can be used. Overall, including IFE, the key issues in the new estimation methods include: i) dealing with the unknown nuisance parameter m , ii) the minimization of appropriate convex objective functions instead of the sum of squared residuals subject to a constraint, and iii) clustering methods and computational difficulty. In a set of two empirical applications we apply a host of the new estimation methodologies and diagnostics that we present, demonstrating their applicability and usefulness. The IFE, GFE and NSTW estimators are

Read the complete text