A Protocol to Address Ecological Redirection for Digital Practices in Organizations Conference: 11th Workshop on Computing within Limits; June 26–27, 2025; Online
Valentin Girard, Antoine Martin, Maud Rio, Romain Couillet · 2025
Read A Protocol to Address Ecological Redirection for Digital Practices in Organizations Conference: 11th Workshop on Computing within Limits; June 26–27, 2025; Online by Valentin Girard, Antoine Martin, Maud Rio, Romain Couillet (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-19078.txt.
Introduction
Digital tools carry an ecological cost that organizations rarely question. Valentin Girard, Antoine Martin, Maud Rio, and Romain Couillet propose a protocol for ecological redirection of digital practice. Rather than chasing efficiency, the approach asks which uses to give up. First, a survey maps how attached staff are to their tools. Next, training builds the knowledge needed for a real debate. A structured discussion then arbitrates which practices to close or transform.
The protocol will be tested in live organizations. The planned study measures how smoothly participants run it and whether it meets its redirection goal. Social and technical barriers are part of the scorecard.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Valentin Girard, Antoine Martin, Maud Rio, Romain Couillet |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-19078
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Protocol to Address Ecological Redirection for Digital Practices in Organizations Conference: 11th Workshop on Computing within Limits; June 26–27, 2025; Online Valentin Girard, Antoine Martin, Maud Rio, Romain Couillet Abstract . The digitalization of societies raises questions about its sustainability and the socio-technical impacts it generates. Ecological redirection applied to organizations is a field of research aiming for achieving sustainability as a direction, rather than for technical means. Arbitration and renunciation to some digital usage and technologies are investigated. Ecological redirection is, however, not yet addressing concrete methodologies for its implementation in organizations. This paper therefore proposes a protocol to support stakeholders in the ecological redirection of their digital practices. This protocol is based on mapping attachments to digital tools through a multi-disciplinary survey. It then proposes increasing stakeholders’ knowledge and skills to prepare a debate on the arbitration of renunciations, and finally, to operationalize the closure/transformation of targeted digital practices. This protocol will be tested in real conditions in different contexts. An empirical study is proposed to measure 1) the fluidity with which participants carry out the protocol, 2) the effectiveness of the protocol in terms of the redirection objective, 3) the socio-technical barriers to the redirection process. The paper concludes on the potential benefits for organizations to better understand both the barriers related to its ecological redirection and the transformative aim of such protocols. This will help them trigger large and radical policies towards a desirable and sustainable society. 1. Introduction In response to the transgression of planetary boundaries on a global scale ( Richardson et al. 2023 ) , various actors within the techno-industrial society are advocating for a digital transition (e.g. ( Joint Research Centre et al.(2022) European Commission ) ). This solution is often proposed in pairs with the energy transition ( Garin 2023 ) . However, according to a report by the think-tank The Shift Project, ‘The digital transition as it is currently being implemented contributes more to climate disruption than it helps to prevent it’, notably because of indirect effects such as the rebound effect, induction, moral compensation and so on ( Roussilhe 2022 ) . The report further notes that ‘[these] global systemic effects […] remain highly uncertain, despite often being considered positive a priori’ ( Ferreboeuf 2018 ) . Indeed, the share of emissions from the digital sector – which encompasses the entire life cycle of devices, network infrastructures, and data centers – is estimated to account for between 2.1% and 3.9% of total global greenhouse gas emissions ( Freitag et al. 2021 ) , with an annual growth rate of 8% in 2018 ( Ferreboeuf 2018 ) . Besides these emissions, the sector requires a significant amount of metal resources, severely impacting the health of the ecosystems and the communities most exposed to its industry ( Izoard 2024 ) . The entire infrastructure manufacturing process is highly energy-intensive and demands large quantities of drinking water ( Bordage 2019 ) . Furthermore, this industry, which is based on short-lived devices, is responsible for several tens of millions of tons of electronic waste each year: 62 million tons in 2022 1 1 1 With major regional disparities : 17.6 kg per capita per year in Europe, 14.1 in America, 6.4 in Asia and 2.5 in Africa. , of which only 22% were documented as formally collected for recycling in an environmentally sound manner ( Baldé et al. 2024 ) . Beyond the environmental and social impacts generated by the digital sector, studies suggest that this sector is condemned in the long term ( Tomlinson and Aubert 2017 ) . This vulnerability can be explained by the destruction of ecosystems essential to its existence, the complexity of the value chains underlying the infrastructure, the societal instability it generates, and the limited availability of mineral and energy resources ( Girard et al. 2024 ) . Despite these findings, the expansion of digitalization is rarely questioned and continues to progress at an exponential rate 2 2 2 +8% annual increase in greenhouse gas emissions, +9% annual increase in energy consumption, +40% annual increase in data storage, +25% increase in data flow ( Ferreboeuf 2018 ) . Given the urgency and the insufficient impact of current transition policies, the framework of ecological redirection proposes a change in perspective: rather than considering that we are facing an ecological crisis that requires technical solutions, it suggests that we are dealing with a new socio-climatic regime (the Anthropocene 3 3 3 This controversial concept developed in 2000 by J Crutzen ( Steffen et al. 2011 ) , highlights the significant impact of the human species on geology and ecosystems on the scale of the Earth’s history ( Steffen et al. 2015 ) . ), which raises primarily a question of direction 4 4 4 The concept of direction can be compared to Donella Meadows’ third leverage point: the goals of the system ( Meadows 1999 ) . . This new regime necessitates both renunciations and closures of certain activities to reorganize our conditions of subsistence. Of course, not all activities should be closed, and stakeholders should be able to suggest certain arbitrations in the process of renunciation, based on criteria of (un)sustainability and vulnerability. The field of ecological redirection is particularly developed in France 5 5 5 Open and lead at first by Alexandre Monnin, Emmanuel Bonnet and Diego Landivar after their original publication Héritage et Fermeture ( Bonnet et al. 2021 ) , inspired by theories of Tony Fry and Bruno Latour. . Its approach is currently mainly theoretical and requires further specification, especially within the context of the digital sector: ‘[…] This situation, experienced by generations endogenous to the digital age, dramatizes the questions we can ask about the conditions for achieving sobriety, or even implementing active processes of detachment or renunciation. This question seems to us to open a considerable and urgently needed area of research’ ( Allard Laurence et al. 2022 ) . Organizations, however concerned about the environmental impact of their digital tools, usually find it difficult to make a real ecological redirection due to a lack of efficient methodology. This article thus proposes a protocol for the ecological redirection of digital tools and practices for organizations. It can be applied to any organization, whatever its size and scope, strategy, governance structure, incorporation structure or relationship to profit (these five dimensions of business have been theorized by Jennifer Hinton ( Hinton 2021 ) ). The protocol can be applied, for example, by publicly-traded shareholder corporations, producer cooperatives, worker cooperatives, dual purpose companies or not-for-profit structures. Section 2 presents the framework of ecological redirection. Section 3 is a proposition for a protocol for the ecological redirection of digital tools and practices for organizations. Section 4 explores the application of this protocol to case studies, and outlines objectives for evaluating and improving the protocol. Section 5 concludes on a perspective regarding the challenges related to the ecological redirection of the digital sector. 2. The Ecological Redirection Framework 2.1. Theoretical framework Ecological redirection is a political framework that has been developed in France, notably through the work of researchers Alexandre Monin, Emmanuel Bonnet, and Diego Landivar ( Bonnet et al. 2021 ) . This conceptual framework