Flexible estimation of skill formation models
1 · 2025
Read Flexible estimation of skill formation models by 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-18995.txt.
Introduction
How skills build in childhood shapes adult outcomes, and economists model that building with latent traits that no test sees directly. Antonia Antweiler and Joachim Freyberger present a flexible way to fit such models in this 2025 paper. Older methods either work only in narrow settings or guess the shape of the hidden traits. A guessed shape that clashes with the model can skew the results.
Their method estimates the hidden trait spread freely, step by step, while folding in the model's rules across ages. That cuts computing cost and allows curved production rules and curved test rules. A shortcut makes statistical inference cheap, since the model need not be refit for each test sample. Fake-data trials and a real case showed less bias and noise than older methods.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 87 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-18995
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Flexible estimation of skill formation models 1 Abstract Abstract This paper examines estimation of skill formation models, a critical component in understanding human capital development and its effects on individual outcomes. Existing estimators are either based on moment conditions and only applicable in specific settings or rely on distributional approximations that often do not align with the model. Our method employs an iterative likelihood-based procedure, which flexibly estimates latent variable distributions and recursively incorporates model restrictions across time periods. This approach reduces computational complexity while accommodating nonlinear production functions and measurement systems. Inference can be based on a bootstrap procedure that does not require re-estimating the model for bootstrap samples. Monte Carlo simulations and an empirical application demonstrate that our estimator outperforms existing methods, whose estimators can be substantially biased or noisy. 1 Introduction The study of skill formation is central to understanding human capital development and its impact on individual outcomes. The seminal work of ? ) and ? ) provides a foundational framework for analyzing skill formation as a dynamic, multidimensional process. Building on these papers, a large literature has emerged that explores various aspects of skill formation mechanisms, including persistence, dynamic complementarities, and the optimal timing of investments. 1 1 1 For example, ? ) study the interaction of children’s cognition and health using data from India, ? ) evaluate the impact of parental investment on socio-emotional and cognitive skills using an RCT in Columbia. ? ) evaluate the effect of math and verbal skills on educational attainment using data from England. For further references, see ? ), ? ), ? ), ? ), ? ), ? ) and references therein. Depending on the specification of the production function, estimation in this context can be challenging because the data only contains noisy measures of the latent variables. With the exception of ? ), early work has therefore primarily employed the Cobb-Douglas production function, which allows parameter estimation using first and second moments of the measures. A more flexible moments-based approach has recently been proposed by ? ), who use a multi-step instrumental variable (IV) strategy to estimate trans-log production functions. In this iterative procedure, measures replace latent variables in the production function, while other measures serve as instruments. Recent applications of this method include ? ) and ? ). For general nonlinear production functions, such as the CES production function in ? ), identification and estimation require the joint distribution of the measures. However, maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) for these models is typically computational prohibitive because the likelihood involves high-dimensional integrals. The dimension of the integral is the product of the number of latent variables and the number of time periods, which results from the need to integrate out latent variables (see Section A5 in their supplement). To reduce the computational burden, ? ) employ nonlinear filtering techniques, which rely on the crucial assumption that the latent variables are (approximately) distributed as mixtures of normals conditional on the measures. A computationally much simpler and more accessible approach has been suggested by ? ), who build on similar approximations but simplify the implementation. To do so, they assume that the joint distribution of all latent variables across time periods is a mixture of normals, which allows estimating the model with a combination of the EM algorithm and nonlinear least squares. Unlike ? ), whose approach has seen very limited adoption, the method by ? ) has been widely applied, including in studies by ? ), ? ), ? ), ? ), and ? ). 2 2 2 A Python implementation of the estimator of ? ) has been provided by Janos Gabler: https://skillmodels.readthedocs.io/ . While very efficient for the class of models considered, it is difficult to adapt to general cases, and it is not directly applicable in the setups of our simulations and our application. However, both methods rely on assumptions that may not align with the model. For instance, even if initial skills are normally distributed, nonlinear transformations through CES or trans-log production functions generally result in non-normal distributions in subsequent periods. Motivated by Monte Carlo simulations, which suggest that the mixture normal approximations of the measures may be poor in some settings, we propose a new estimator of skill formation models. Our approach is based on a likelihood, but uses an iterative procedure to reduce the dimensions of the integrals and thereby the computational complexity. That is, we first flexibly estimate the distribution of the latent variables in the initial period. Subsequently, we proceed recursively: given the distribution of the latent variables in period t , we use measures from periods t and t+1 to estimate the parameters in period t and the distribution of the latent variables in period t+1 . While less efficient than full MLE, our method is computationally attractive because each step only estimates parameters of one time period and we integrate out latent variables whose distribution has been estimated in a previous step, which greatly facilitates numerical approximations of the integrals. Inspired by the iterative estimator of ? ), our procedure generalizes their approach by leveraging all model restrictions across two periods, and it can therefore be used with various flexible specifications of the model, such as different production functions or binary measures. We also provide a bootstrap-based inference method that avoids re-estimating the model for bootstrap samples, enhancing computational efficiency. We evaluate the properties of our estimator in Monte Carlo simulations and an empirical application. We compare our results with the popular estimators of ? ) (for both the CES and the trans-log production function) and ? ) (for the trans-log production function). We find that the performance of the estimator of ? ) depends heavily on the true values of the parameters. In some settings, the bias from the mixture normal approximation is minimal, but in other cases the estimators of the parameters and counterfactuals are severely biased. Increasing the number of mixture components can mitigate the bias, but it may lead to numerical instabilities and larger standard errors. Since our approach is consistent with the specification of the model, it performs well across all scenarios. Compared to ? ), our estimator not only applies to different specifications of the model, but it is also generally more precise, as their method uses only a subset of available moment conditions. Additionally, we demonstrate in the empirical application that their results may depend on which measures are used to replace the latent variables in the production function and which measures are used as instruments. Structure: Section 2 presents the model of skill formation. In Section 3 , we briefly review existing estimators. Section 4 contains our estimation procedure and the score-based bootstrap. Sections 5 and 6 contain the Monte Carlo simulations and the empirical application, respectively. Finally, Section 7 provides practical recommendations. 2 Model The description of the model largely follows ? ). Let \theta_{t} and I_{t} denote skills and investment at time t , respectively. Neither skills nor investment are directly observed and we denote the observed measurements by Z_{\theta,t,m} and Z_{I,t,m} , respectively. We consider a model based on (1) \displaystyle\ln\theta_{t+1} \displaystyle= \displaystyle f(\ln\theta_{t},\ln I_{t},\delta_{t})+\eta_{\theta,t}\hskip 96.73936ptt=0,\ldots,T-1 (2) \displaystyle Z_{\theta,t,m} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\mu_{\theta,t,m}+\lambda_{\theta,t,m}\ln\theta_{t}+\varepsilon_{\theta,t,m}\hskip 73.97716ptt=0,\ldots,T,m=1,2,3 (3) \displaystyle Z_{I,t,m} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\mu_{I,t,m}+\lambda_{I,t,m}\ln I_{t}+\varepsilon_{I,t,m}\hskip