Comments on “Exploring Quantum Statistics for Dirac and Majorana Neutrinos using Spinor-Helicity techniques” (arXiv:2507.07180 [hep-ph])

C. S. Kim, M. V. N. Murthy, Dibyakrupa Sahoo · 2025

Read Comments on “Exploring Quantum Statistics for Dirac and Majorana Neutrinos using Spinor-Helicity techniques” (arXiv:2507.07180 [hep-ph]) by C. S. Kim, M. V. N. Murthy, Dibyakrupa Sahoo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-14463.txt.

Introduction

Kim, Murthy, and Sahoo published a comment in twenty twenty-five defending their idea for telling two kinds of neutrinos apart. Neutrinos may be Dirac particles, distinct from their antiparticles, or Majorana particles, their own antiparticles. The authors had proposed using quantum statistics to distinguish the two cases. Another paper had criticized that proposal.

The comment answers the critique head-on. It says the rival paper's fix, a symmetrization of the Dirac case added by hand, has no physical basis. Worse, the comment argues, that fix would break lepton number conservation for Dirac neutrinos within the Standard Model. On those grounds the authors call the symmetrization wrong in principle. The piece is a short, pointed reply in an ongoing technical dispute.

Catalog record

CREATORC. S. Kim, M. V. N. Murthy, Dibyakrupa Sahoo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-14463

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comments on “Exploring Quantum Statistics for Dirac and Majorana Neutrinos using Spinor-Helicity techniques” (arXiv:2507.07180 [hep-ph]) C. S. Kim, M. V. N. Murthy, Dibyakrupa Sahoo Abstract We give our comments on Ref. Bigaran:2025kod which critiques our idea of exploring quantum statistics to distinguish between Dirac and Majorana neutrinos proposed in some of our earlier works. We show that the ad-hoc symmetrization of the Dirac case amplitude square advocated in Eqs. (16) and (35) of Bigaran:2025kod , have no physical basis and it leads to violation of lepton number in the the standard model. Therefore, we consider this symmetrization ‘by hand’ as incorrect and misleading. Moreover, we show that it is even unnecessary for the proof of pDMCT in context of final states containing a neutrino and antineutrino pair. I What is the primary issue and where does it appear in Bigaran:2025kod ? In Ref. Bigaran:2025kod the authors aim to provide a critique of our papers Kim:2021dyj ; Kim:2023iwz ; Kim:2024tsm where we have explored the possibility whether quantum statistics could help in distinguishing Dirac and Majorana neutrinos. We note that in Ref. Bigaran:2025kod the authors have tried to force agreement with the practical Dirac Majorana confusion theorem (pDMCT), while in our works Kim:2021dyj ; Kim:2023iwz ; Kim:2024tsm we have explored the domain of applicability of pDMCT in addition to providing a general proof of it in context of final states having neutrino antineutrino pair. We have used the standard quantum field theory in our papers Kim:2021dyj ; Kim:2023iwz ; Kim:2024tsm and our approach very well accommodates the previously existing literature. The underlying basis of the main claim of Ref. Bigaran:2025kod where they disagree with our papers, is contained within their Eqs. (33)-(38) of Sec. IV. While discussing the case of Dirac neutrinos, the authors of Bigaran:2025kod contend that for the unobserved final states of neutrino and antineutrino one should symmetrize the amplitude squared with respect to the 4-momenta of the neutrino and antineutrino. Just below Eq. (34) of Bigaran:2025kod they state that “To make a fair comparison with the Majorana case, as the neutrinos are not observed, it is imperative that both momentum assignments be the anti-neutrino are summed to construct the Dirac matrix-element squared”. This notion of symmetrizing at the probability level for Dirac neutrinos affects the inferences made in Ref. Bigaran:2025kod . As explained below, we find such symmetrization “by hand” to be incorrect and misleading. Our comments below exclusively discuss all aspects of this particular issue found in Ref. Bigaran:2025kod . It should be mentioned that although we primarily focus on their Sec. IV where they have critiqued our work on the decay B^{0}\to\mu^{-}\mu^{+}\nu_{\mu}\overline{\nu}_{\mu} Kim:2021dyj , the above mentioned issue can also be found in Sec. III of Bigaran:2025kod around Eqs. (14)-(16). Finally, we also point out the misinterpretation of the helicity amplitudes given in Eq. (28) of Kim:2023iwz by the authors of Bigaran:2025kod in their Eqs. (39)-(43). We clarify these aspects as well. II Our comments Our comments are as follows. 1. There is no fundamental principle or law of physics which requires that the amplitude square for a process having two distinguishable particles in the final state ought to be symmetrized with respect to the exchange of the 4-momenta of the concerned particles, when the two particles are not detected in the detector 1 1 1 We note that with advancement of technology, particle detection and identification also improves, and even with the best of detector technology some particles might not get detected by the detector either due to limited spatial coverage of the detector or due to the finite time needed for triggering events in a detector. . A Dirac neutrino is distinguishable from the corresponding antineutrino. Therefore, for a final state containing a pair of Dirac neutrino and antineutrino there is no need to do any symmetrization with respect to their momentum exchange. Detection and identification of a particle in a detector does not affect the amplitude square which is a purely theoretical computation where one assumes that all the 4-momenta of all the particles are well known. The quantity which gets affected by experimental detection or observation or measurement is the “observable” (such as some asymmetry, or distribution, or differential decay rate, or scattering cross-section etc.) which involves both the amplitude square as well as the phase space considerations. Non-observation of any final particle is well taken care of by suitably performing corresponding phase space integration. We will later show how such phase space integration for invisible neutrinos, without any ‘by hand’ symmetrization of the Dirac amplitude square, directly leads to pDMCT which we have already provided in Kim:2021dyj . But before that we point out how such symmetrization is incorrect and misleading. 2. In the standard model (SM) the Dirac neutrino ( \nu ) and antineutrino ( \overline{\nu} ) carry lepton numbers as they are produced via different weak charged currents (CCs) W^{+}\to\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} and W^{-}\to\ell^{-}\overline{\nu}_{\ell} for \ell=e,\mu,\tau , to ensure lepton number conservation within the SM. When considering Dirac neutrino antineutrino pair production via two CCs, as it happens in the decays considered in Ref. Bigaran:2025kod as well as in our work Kim:2021dyj , the neutrino and antineutrino 4-momenta are paired with the corresponding charged lepton so that lepton number is conserved. This is not required for Majorana neutrinos, in which \nu=\overline{\nu} and the lepton number is not a good (conserved) quantum number. However, adding a term to the Dirac case amplitude square where the neutrino and antineutrino 4-momenta have been exchanged, as done in the right sides of Eqs. (16) and (35) of Ref. Bigaran:2025kod , amounts to considering W^{+}\to\ell^{+}\overline{\nu}_{\ell}~(\Delta L=-2) and W^{-}\to\ell^{-}\nu_{\ell}~(\Delta L=+2) both of which violate lepton number. When working with Dirac neutrinos in the framework of the SM alone without consideration of any new physics contributions, as is the case in decay B^{0}\to\mu^{-}\mu^{+}\nu_{\mu}\overline{\nu}_{\mu} considered in both Bigaran:2025kod and Kim:2021dyj , one should avoid considering lepton number violation effects. 3. The authors of Ref. Bigaran:2025kod state in the paragraph containing Eq. (32) that we have not been explicit about how we construct the Dirac as well as Majorana amplitudes in Kim:2021dyj . We note that we have explicitly and fully mentioned construction of our Dirac case and Majorana case amplitudes in Sec. IV, sub-sections A, B, C and D of Kim:2021dyj . As far as the spin or helicity of the neutrinos are concerned, they are automatically taken care of by the V-A nature of the CC vertices. To elaborate slightly more on this let us first focus on the Dirac case, the 4-momenta of antineutrino and neutrino in Kim:2021dyj are denoted by p_{1} and p_{2} respectively. The amplitude in our case is denoted by \mathscr{M}^{D}\equiv\mathscr{M}(p_{1},p_{2}) and given by Eq. (15a) in Kim:2021dyj . 2 2 2 The momentum-exchanged amplitude \mathscr{M}(p_{2},p_{1}) , is not at all required in the Dirac case. There is no underlying symmetry principle that connects the two amplitudes, \mathscr{M}(p_{1},p_{2}) and \mathscr{M}(p_{2},p_{1}) , in the general case . We then follow the standard procedure in any QFT calculation to evaluate the amplitude square in such a case, i.e. we take the modulus square of the amplitude, sum over final spins, average over initial spins 3 3 3 Since B^{0} is a pseudo-scalar meson its spin is

Read the complete text