Note on Euler class 0 0 taut foliation on the Whitehead link exterior
Yao Fan, Zhentao Lai and Bin Yu · 2025
Read Note on Euler class 0 0 taut foliation on the Whitehead link exterior by Yao Fan, Zhentao Lai and Bin Yu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-14461.txt.
Introduction
Yao Fan, Zhentao Lai, and Bin Yu study whether layered surfaces can fill a classic knot-theory space: the outside of the Whitehead link. Such fillings, called taut foliations, come with a numerical tag, their Euler class, and the question is which tags can occur. The contrast case, the figure-eight knot's outside, allows far more freedom.
The trio proves that most points in the natural measuring ball for this space cannot be realized as tags of the wanted foliations, with only a few exceptions. Their proofs mix filling constructions and index formulas with blockages drawn from surgery on the space. The methods, they note, extend to other cusped hyperbolic spaces.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yao Fan, Zhentao Lai and Bin Yu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-14461
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Note on Euler class 0 0 taut foliation on the Whitehead link exterior Yao Fan, Zhentao Lai and Bin Yu Abstract . This paper studies the existence of co-orientable taut foliations on 3-manifolds, particularly focusing on the Whitehead link exterior. We demonstrate fundamental obstructions to the existence of such foliations with certain Euler class properties, contrasting with the more permissive case of the figure-eight knot exterior. Our analysis reveals that most lattice points in the dual unit Thurston ball of the Whitehead link exterior cannot be realized as Euler classes of co-orientable taut foliations, with only limited exceptional cases. The proofs combine techniques from foliation theory, including saddle fillings and index formulas, with topological obstructions derived from Dehn surgery. These results yield general methods for studying foliations on cusped hyperbolic 3-manifolds. These techniques applied to broader classes of manifolds beyond the specific examples considered here. 1. Introduction Let W be a compact orientable 3 -manifold such that \partial W is either empty or consists of finitely many tori. Let \mathcal{F} be a co-orientable taut foliation on W that is transverse to \partial W , and let T\mathcal{F} denote the tangent bundle of the foliation \mathcal{F} . According to Thurston [ Thu ] , the dual Thurston norm x^{*}(e(T\mathcal{F})) lies in the dual unit ball B^{*}(W) , meaning that x^{*}(e(T\mathcal{F}))\leq 1 . Thurston’s Euler class-one conjecture states that when W is closed, for every integral class a\in H^{2}(W;\mathbb{Z}) with x^{*}(a)=1 , there exists a taut foliation \mathcal{F} on W whose Euler class equals a . In [ Ya ] , Yazdi provided the first class of counterexamples to this conjecture. He constructed infinitely many hyperbolic 3-manifolds for which an even lattice point on the boundary of the dual unit ball does not correspond to any co-orientable taut foliation 1 1 1 Recently, Yi Liu proved that every oriented closed hyperbolic 3-manifold admits some finite cover that serves as a counterexample [ Liu ] . . Yazdi subsequently posed two natural questions: Question 1.1 . Which points in the dual unit ball can be realized as the Euler class of some taut foliation on W ? Question 1.2 . Which 3 -manifolds with positive first Betti number admit a taut foliation with trivial Euler class? Certainly, Question 1.2 represents a special case of Question 1.1 , but it carries particular significance: the existence of a taut foliation \mathcal{F} on W with e(T\mathcal{F})=0 implies the existence of a non-singular vector field X on W that is tangent to \mathcal{F} . Moreover, when \partial W\neq\emptyset , we additionally require that X is transverse to \partial W . As a concrete example addressing Question 1.2 , Yazdi proposed investigating the case where W is the Whitehead link exterior. The Whitehead link L consists of two components L_{1} and L_{2} (see Figure 1 ). Through an isotopy, one can observe that L_{1} and L_{2} are interchangeable. For the Whitehead link exterior W , its boundary \partial W comprises two tori T_{1} and T_{2} , corresponding to L_{1} and L_{2} respectively. We establish a coordinate system on each torus boundary using the standard meridian-longitude coordinates, where the meridian is assigned slope \infty and the longitude is assigned slope 0 . Under this convention, any simple closed curve on a torus boundary can be assigned a rational slope p/q\in\mathbb{Q}\cup\{\infty\} , representing a curve that winds p times around the meridian and q times around the longitude. Figure 1. The Whitehead link L and the surface S_{1} Our results provide a direct answer to Question 1.2 for this specific case: Theorem 1.3 . The Whitehead link exterior W admits no co-orientable taut foliation \mathcal{F} that is transverse to \partial W and satisfies e(T\mathcal{F})=0 in H^{2}(W,\partial W;\mathbb{Z}) . This non-existence result for co-orientable taut foliations with vanishing Euler class on the Whitehead link exterior demonstrates that the origin of the dual unit ball B_{x^{*}}(W) does not correspond to any such foliation. According to Thurston [ Thu ] , the dual unit ball B_{x^{*}}(W) forms a square containing nine lattice points, as illustrated in Figure 2 . The x -axis represents the component L_{1} of the Whitehead link L , while the y -axis corresponds to L_{2} . Regarding the boundary points of B_{x^{*}}(W) , Gabai established that the four vertices correspond to co-orientable taut foliations [ Ga1 ] . For the intermediate points \{(\pm 1,0),(0,\pm 1)\} , we demonstrate the following: Theorem 1.4 . Let W be the Whitehead link exterior. There exists no co-orientable taut foliation \mathcal{F} transverse to \partial W with Euler class e(T\mathcal{F})=(\pm 1,0) or (0,\pm 1) in H^{2}(W,\partial W;\mathbb{Z}) , except possibly when: • The restriction \mathcal{F}|_{T_{1}} (respectively \mathcal{F}|_{T_{2}} ) forms a suspension foliation, and • The restriction \mathcal{F}|_{T_{2}} (respectively \mathcal{F}|_{T_{1}} ) is non-suspension (containing Reeb annuli) with all Reeb annuli cores having slope \infty . We present the proof of Theorem 1.4 in Section 4 . This brings us close to a complete understanding of Question 1.1 for the Whitehead link exterior, as summarized below: • Gabai’s work [ Ga1 ] establishes that the four vertices of the dual unit ball B_{x^{*}}(W) correspond to co-orientable taut foliations, represented by solid round dots in Figure 2 . • Theorem 1.3 shows that the origin has no corresponding co-orientable taut foliations, indicated by a hollow round dot in Figure 2 . • Theorem 1.4 demonstrates that the lattice points \{(\pm 1,0),(0,\pm 1)\} generally lack corresponding co-orientable taut foliations, except for the potential special case described in the theorem. These points are marked by hollow square dots in Figure 2 . Figure 2. The four vertices of the square can be realized by taut foliations for the Whitehead link exterior W . This situation contrasts sharply with the case of the figure-eight knot exterior N , where every lattice point on the dual unit ball B_{x^{*}}(N) corresponds to a taut foliation: • Following Thurston [ Thu ] , one can readily verify that the dual unit ball B_{x^{*}}(N) forms a line segment containing exactly three lattice points, as depicted in Figure 3 . • Gabai’s results [ Ga1 ] establish that the two vertices of B_{x^{*}}(N) correspond to co-orientable taut foliations. These foliations arise naturally from the fiber bundle structure of N , with each leaf being a once-punctured torus. • For the origin, we construct the corresponding foliation as follows: Consider the natural suspension Anosov flow X_{t} in the Sol manifold \bar{N}=\text{Map}\left(\mathbb{T}^{2},\begin{pmatrix}2&1\\ 1&1\end{pmatrix}\right). Let \mathcal{F}^{s} denote the weak stable foliation of X_{t} , and let \gamma_{O} be the periodic orbit corresponding to the origin O\in\mathbb{T}^{2} . By removing a small standard neighborhood of \gamma_{O} , we obtain an induced foliation \mathcal{F} on N derived from \mathcal{F}^{s} on \bar{N} . This construction yields: – \mathcal{F} is transverse to \partial N – \mathcal{F}\cap\partial N consists of two Reeb annuli [ FW ] – There exists a vector field X tangent to \mathcal{F} and transverse to \partial N [ FW ] Consequently, we have e(T\mathcal{F})=0 . Figure 3. All three integer points can be realized by taut foliations for the figure-eight knot exterior N . We outline the proof strategy for Theorem 1.3 at the beginning of Section 5 . The key observation is that when sufficient topological information is