Comment to “The asymptotically-free gauge theories”
Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Aldo Deandrea, Francesco Sannino · 2025
Read Comment to “The asymptotically-free gauge theories” by Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Aldo Deandrea, Francesco Sannino (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-14037.txt.
Introduction
Cacciapaglia, Deandrea, and Sannino comment on a recent paper that proposed a classification of gauge theories that stay asymptotically free down to very short scales. They argue that several statements in that paper may mislead readers. Their note works through the points that need correction or added care. It also places the proposal beside earlier literature and existing classifications of such theories. The goal is to keep the record straight on what is new and what was already known.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Aldo Deandrea, Francesco Sannino |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 5 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-14037
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comment to “The asymptotically-free gauge theories”
Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Aldo Deandrea, Francesco Sannino
Abstract
The recent paper ” The asymptotically-free gauge theories ” by Ben Gripaios and Khoi Le Nguyen Nguyen Gripaios and Le Nguyen Nguyen 2025 presents a proposed classification of gauge theories valid down to arbitrarily short scales. In this comment, we aim to clarify several points and address some statements that may be misleading. We also provide additional context by discussing relevant prior literature and existing classifications.
I
Gauge anomaly cancellation
The cancellation of gauge anomalies is essential in defining a consistent gauge theory. Hence, imposing the absence of ABJ anomalies
Adler 1969
;
Bell and Jackiw 1969
and topological anomalies
Witten 1982
;
Wang et al. 2019
is a central ingredient in any classification attempt. The former are relevant for
\mathrm{SU}(N)
theories with complex representations, while the latter for
\mathrm{Sp}(2N)
theories with pseudo-real irreducible representations (irreps). This analysis has been performed in
Cacciapaglia et al. 2025
to classify asymptotic-free (AF) gauge theories, showing that crucial restrictions are imposed on the available irreps. For instance, the three-index symmetric of
\mathrm{SU}(N)
,
(3,0,\dots)
in dynkin representation, cannot be used to define a chiral AF theory
Cacciapaglia et al. 2025
for all
N
, while a one-family vector-like theory exists only for
N=2,3,4
. For the
(1,0,1,0,0)
of
\mathrm{SU}(6)
, neither chiral nor vector-like theories can be defined. Furthermore, the well known Witten anomalies forbid the presence of an odd number of certain representations of
\mathrm{Sp}(2N)
(a discussion of the Witten anomalies for general pseudo-real representations of
\mathrm{Sp}(2N)
is present in the supplementary material of
Cacciapaglia et al. 2025
).
The above constraints were not taken into account in
Gripaios and Le Nguyen Nguyen 2025
, where anomalies are only briefly mentioned as reducing the number of viable theories for
\mathrm{SU}(5)
(Lie algebra
A_{4}
). In fact, Ref.
Cacciapaglia et al. 2025
provides a ‘basis’ of chiral families, which can be used to construct the whole class of AF anomaly-free
\mathrm{SU}(N)
theories, when supplemented with vector-like fermions.
II
Classifications present in the literature
The statement “
here we provide a first classification of such theories, focussing on the case in which any matter is fermionic; the generalization to theories with scalar particles or supersymmetry will become obvious
” is incorrect. For instance, vector-like AF theories based on
\mathrm{SU}(N)
have been classified in
Dietrich and Sannino 2007
. The chiral case has been classified in
Cacciapaglia et al. 2025
by providing a basis of chiral families for all
\mathrm{SU}(N)
and anomaly-free AF representations for
\mathrm{Sp}(2N)
. The classification of AF irreps of
\mathrm{SU}(N)
has been pioneered by E.Eichten and F.Feinberg: Ref.
Eichten and Feinberg 1982
contains a more complete list than the one in Ref.
Eichten et al. 1982
(the latter cited in
Gripaios and Le Nguyen Nguyen 2025
).
Studying AF in the presence of scalars is not a mere generalization of the fermionic case (see next paragraph).
III
Complete freedom with scalars
Achieving AF in gauge theories with scalars is far from obvious. This is due to the presence of additional marginal operators, namely quartic couplings and Yukawas (with fermions). A simple analysis of the one-loop gauge beta function, as stated in
Gripaios and Le Nguyen Nguyen 2025
, is far from enough: in fact, the sensitivity to the Yukawa couplings enters at two loops while that to the quartics at three loops. This order is dictated by the need to respect the Weyl consistency conditions
Antipin et al. 2013
;
Osborn 1989
;
Jack and Osborn 1990
;
Osborn 1991
. Complete asymptotic freedom, therefore, requires that all the couplings run free
Callaway 1988
;
Holdom et al. 2015
;
Giudice et al. 2015
;
Pica et al. 2017
.
IV
You can be safe rather than free
The naive statement that “
asymptotically-free gauge theories provide the only known examples of interacting quantum field theories in four spacetime dimensions that are valid down to arbitrarily short scales
” is challenged by the discovery of interactive four-dimensional gauge-Yukawa asymptotically safe theories
Litim and Sannino 2014
.