Contact point geometry governs structural build-up at rest in Portland cement-limestone blends

Luca Michel, Antoine Sanner, Franco Zunino, Robert J. Flatt, David S. Kammer · 2025

Read Contact point geometry governs structural build-up at rest in Portland cement-limestone blends by Luca Michel, Antoine Sanner, Franco Zunino, Robert J. Flatt, David S. Kammer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-14029.txt.

Introduction

Luca Michel and co-authors show that the shape of contact points between grains governs how fast fresh cement stiffens at rest, in a paper from 2025. Early stiffness matters for casting and for printing concrete. A mineral glue that grows between grains is known to stiffen contacts.

Blending in limestone of varied fineness and shape changed the stiffening rate but not the glue mechanism. Heat and flow tests tied stiffness gains to the amount of glue formed. Rates lined up with a length scale that captures grain size and shape together. The authors conclude that contact geometry, not just chemistry, sets early build up, which gives a design rule for blended cements.

Catalog record

CREATORLuca Michel, Antoine Sanner, Franco Zunino, Robert J. Flatt, David S. Kammer
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-14029

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Contact point geometry governs structural build-up at rest in Portland cement-limestone blends Luca Michel, Antoine Sanner, Franco Zunino, Robert J. Flatt, David S. Kammer Abstract Abstract The early stiffening of fresh cement paste plays a key role in shaping and stability during casting and 3D printing. In Portland cement systems, this phenomenon arises from the formation of calcium–silicate–hydrate ( {}{}{}\mathrm{C}{-}\mathrm{S}{-}\mathrm{H} ), which stiffens grain-to-grain contacts. However, the role of powder characteristics such as particle size and morphology remains poorly understood. Here, we vary fineness and grain shape by blending Portland cement with either coarse or fine limestone, leveraging the affinity of {}{}{}\mathrm{C}{-}\mathrm{S}{-}\mathrm{H} to nucleate on limestone surfaces. By coupling calorimetry and rheometry, we relate the amount of formed hydration products to the increase in stiffness, and show that the mechanism of contact stiffening through {}{}{}\mathrm{C}{-}\mathrm{S}{-}\mathrm{H} formation remains unchanged with limestone addition. Nevertheless, the rate of stiffening varies across blends. We find that these rates correlate with a characteristic length scale that captures particle size and shape. These results demonstrate that early stiffening depends not only on the amount of hydration products formed, but also on the geometry of the contacts where these products form, offering a framework for understanding more complex systems such as limestone–calcined clay cements. 1 Introduction On the microscopic level, fresh cement paste forms a dense, flocculated network of grains suspended in water. This network arises from attractive interactions between cement particles [ 1 , 2 ] and is progressively reinforced by the formation of hydration products [ 3 , 4 ] . The combined effect of these interparticle forces and hydration-induced strengthening leads to a gradual increase in macroscopic mechanical properties over time, a phenomenon commonly known as structural build-up or structuration [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] . Experimentally, structural build-up is characterized by evolutions of storage modulus or yield stress [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] . In the past years, time evolutions have been widely used for structural build-up investigations. While such approaches are insightful for practical applications, such as 3D printing with concrete [ 11 , 12 ] , they do not directly link hydration reactions to changes in macroscopic mechanical properties. Moreover, time-resolved data are influenced by hydration kinetics, limiting their ability to provide fundamental insights [ 13 ] . A recent approach combining rheometry and calorimetry has addressed this limitation by directly correlating hydration reactions with the evolution of storage modulus [ 4 ] . However, it has so far been applied only to Portland cement paste with a fixed particle size distribution and specific surface area. The impact of variations in these powder characteristics on build-up at rest remains unknown, yet it can be expected to play a significant role in practical systems, such as blended cements. Blending Portland cement with other mineral powders is a well-established strategy to reduce the clinker content in cementitious materials, thus lowering their carbon footprint [ 14 , 15 ] . Among various formulations, Limestone Calcined Clay Cement (LC3) stands out, allowing up to 50% clinker replacement [ 16 ] . LC3 includes Portland cement, limestone, and calcined clay, creating a complex system in which drastic changes in structural build-up and workability have been observed [ 17 , 18 ] . These effects are often attributed to calcined clay, but the combined addition of limestone and clay makes it difficult to isolate the influence of powder fineness and grain morphology. In this context, Portland cement-limestone blends offer a simpler, canonical model for understanding how variations in particle size distribution, specific surface area, and grain geometry affect structural build-up at rest. Since these factors are also present in LC3, studying cement-limestone systems provides a controlled framework that captures key physical aspects of more complex blends, while excluding potential chemical effects introduced by reactive clays. This lays a foundation for systematically investigating the role of powder morphology in the early mechanical evolution of multi-component systems, like LC3. In this work, we investigate how adding limestone to Portland cement impacts structural build-up at rest, focusing on variations in powder fineness and grain geometry. Coupled calorimetry and rheometry measurements allow us to express the evolution of storage modulus as a function of the average thickness of hydration products forming on grain surfaces. Based on these results, we find that the general build-up mechanism remains unchanged compared to plain Portland cement, namely that contact points are strengthened by {}{}{}\mathrm{C}{-}\mathrm{S}{-}\mathrm{H} formation. We observe that finer powders lead to a faster increase in storage modulus for a given hydration product thickness. These differences are canceled out when accounting for grain morphology, whereby data collapse onto a single master curve when plotting the normalized storage modulus against a normalized thickness of products. Hence, this suggests that the geometry of grain-to-grain contacts plays a key role in structural build-up at rest. Our findings indicate that structural build-up at rest is governed not only by “how much” hydration products form, but also “into what geometry” these products form. This highlights the critical role that contact point geometry plays in structural build-up at rest. 2 Materials 2.1 Raw powders In this work, we investigate the effect of limestone addition and powder fineness on structural build-up in fresh Portland cement paste at rest. The cement used is a Portland cement CEM I 52.5R (Holcim Normo 5R), blended with either a coarse limestone (Sigma-Aldrich Calcium Carbonate, 99.95% dry basis) or a fine limestone (Omya Betocarb UF, high-purity calcium carbonate). The specific surface area ( \mathrm{SSA} ) of the Portland cement, coarse limestone, and fine limestone is 1.1, 0.56, and 5.53 m 2 /g, respectively. \mathrm{SSA} measurements were performed using a BET multi-point nitrogen physisorption apparatus (Micromeritics Tristar II 3020). Particle size distributions ( \mathrm{PSD} ) were determined via laser diffraction using a HORIBA Partica LA-950 Laser Scattering Particle Size Distribution Analyzer. Before measuring the final size distribution, the particles were dispersed by ultrasound three times to ensure proper dispersion. The particles are dispersed in isopropanol without use of dispersant. The coarse limestone has a particle size distribution comparable to that of Portland cement, whereas the fine limestone exhibits a distribution shifted toward smaller diameters, as shown in Fig. 1 . Figure 1: Particle size distributions of the raw powders measured by laser diffraction. a) Portland cement. b) Coarse limestone. c) Fine limestone. The solid lines represent the differential size distributions (left axes), and the dashed lines display the cumulative size distributions (right axes). 2.2 Blends investigated We add Limestone (both coarse and fine) to Portland cement in fractions of 15% and 45% by mass. The selected water-to-binder (w/b) ratios ensure that the pastes are homogeneously mixed while avoiding stability issues such as sedimentation and bleeding. An overview of the blends investigated is given in Table 1 . The particle size distributions of the blends are reported in Fig. 2 , where, compared to Portland cement, the addition of coarse limestone shifts the size distributions towards larger diameters, and the addition of fine limestone results in distributions containing larger fractions of fine particles. Table 1: Compositions and w/b ratios of the investigated blends. The system ID is used to label the different mixes throughout the manuscript. PC = Portland cement. LS

Read the complete text