A combination theorem for the twist conjecture for Artin groups

Oli Jones, Giorgio Mangioni, Giovanni Sartori · 2025

Read A combination theorem for the twist conjecture for Artin groups by Oli Jones, Giorgio Mangioni, Giovanni Sartori (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-13971.txt.

Introduction

Oli Jones, Giorgio Mangioni, and Giovanni Sartori prove a combination result in 2025 for a conjecture about Artin groups, a family of groups defined by graph shaped rules. The twist conjecture, in a strong form, ties the symmetries of such a group to twists in its graph. The team reduces that strong form to the case where the graph has no vertex whose removal splits it.

That reduction yields new examples of groups that meet the conjecture. It also adds light to the wider problem of telling when two such groups are the same. On the way, they prove a combination result for a ribbon trait of vertices. Grouping hard cases down to simpler graphs is a classic move, and this paper gives the field a fresh one for a central open problem.

Catalog record

CREATOROli Jones, Giorgio Mangioni, Giovanni Sartori
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE88 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-13971

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A combination theorem for the twist conjecture for Artin groups Oli Jones, Giorgio Mangioni, Giovanni Sartori Abstract . We reduce a strong version of the twist conjecture for Artin groups to Artin groups whose defining graphs have no separating vertices. This produces new examples of Artin groups satisfying the conjecture, and sheds more light on the isomorphism problem for Artin groups. Along the way we also prove a combination result for the ribbon property for vertices. 2020 Mathematics subject classification. 20F36, 20E08, 20F65 Key words. Artin groups, Bass-Serre theory, isomorphism problem, twist conjecture, ribbons. Introduction Artin groups are a rich class of groups generalising braid groups and with strong connections to Coxeter groups. They are defined via the following presentation: given a finite simplicial graph \Gamma with vertices \operatorname{V}(\Gamma) , edges \operatorname{E}(\Gamma) , and for each edge \{a,b\}\in\operatorname{E}(\Gamma) a label m_{ab}\in\mathbb{N}_{\geq 2} , the associated Artin group A_{\Gamma} is \langle\operatorname{V}(\Gamma)\ |\ \mathrm{prod}(a,b,m_{ab})=\mathrm{prod}(b,a,m_{ab})\,\forall\{a,b\}\in\operatorname{E}(\Gamma)\rangle, where \mathrm{prod}(u,v,n) denotes the prefix of length n of the infinite alternating word uvuvuv\dots . When a and b do not span an edge, we abuse notation and set m_{ab}=\infty . One of the most prominent open questions for Artin groups is the isomorphism problem , which specialises Dehn’s isomorphism problem [ Deh12 ] , and asks for an algorithm that, given two labelled graphs, determines if they give rise to isomorphic Artin groups. The question is completely open in general, with some results when one or both graphs are restricted to some subclasses [ Bau81 , Dro87 , Par04 , Vas22 ] . In this paper we are concerned with the twist conjecture, which can be seen as a first step towards the isomorphism problem. Before giving more details, we need some terminology. An Artin system is a pair (A,S) where A is a group isomorphic to some A_{\Gamma} , and the isomorphism maps S\subseteq A bijectively onto the vertices of \Gamma (see Definition 2.1 ). The set S is called an Artin generating set for A , and the graph \Gamma , which we also denote by \Gamma_{S} , is its defining graph . A standard parabolic subgroup of (A,S) is the subgroup A_{Y} generated by some Y\subseteq S ; by a result of van der Lek, (A_{Y},Y) is itself an Artin system [ VdL83 ] . Two Artin generating sets for the same Artin group are twist equivalent if they are related by a sequence of elementary twists , whose definition we briefly recall (we postpone all details to Definition 3.2 ). Given an Artin generating set S , let Y\subseteq S be a subset which separates \Gamma_{S} . Suppose that the Artin system (A_{Y},Y) is spherical (meaning the corresponding Coxeter group is finite) and does not decompose as a direct product. Performing an elementary twist of S along Y roughly amounts to conjugating one of the connected components of \Gamma_{S}-\Gamma_{Y} by the Garside element of (A_{Y},Y) (this is a distinguished element corresponding to the longest element in the associated Coxeter group, see [ BS72 ] ). Two graphs \Gamma and \Gamma^{\prime} are then said be twist equivalent if \Gamma\cong\Gamma_{S} and \Gamma^{\prime}\cong\Gamma_{U} for some twist equivalent Artin generating sets S and U of an Artin group A . In all the solved cases of the isomorphism problem, two graphs give rise to isomorphic Artin groups if and only if they are twist equivalent, so it is natural to ask if this is always the case: Question A ( [ Cha16 , Problem 28] ) . If two labelled graphs \Gamma and \Delta give rise to isomorphic Artin groups, are they necessarily twist equivalent? As a first step in this direction, Brady, McCammond, Mühlherr, and Neumann conjectured the following: Conjecture B (Weak twist conjecture, [ BMMN02 , Conjecture 8.2] ) . Let (A,S) be an Artin system. If U\subseteq A is an Artin generating set with R_{S}=R_{U} , then \Gamma_{S} and \Gamma_{U} are twist equivalent. Here R_{S} , called the reflection set of (A,S) , is the union of the conjugacy classes of S in A , and similarly for R_{U} . The corresponding conjecture for Coxeter groups, which is [ BMMN02 , Conjecture 8.1] , has been proven to be false in [ RT08 ] ; however, Artin groups are believed to be more rigid than their Coxeter counterparts. In this paper we consider the following stronger version of the twist conjecture: Conjecture C (Strong twist conjecture) . Let (A,S) be an Artin system. If U\subseteq A is an Artin generating set with R_{S}=R_{U} , then S and U are twist equivalent. The analogue of the strong twist conjecture for Coxeter groups (with the appropriate extra conditions to avoid the known counter examples) was already considered by Mühlherr in [ Müh06 , Conjecture 2] . A combination theorem for the strong twist conjecture. A big chunk of a simplicial graph is a connected induced subgraph without separating vertices which is maximal with these properties. Given an Artin system (A,S) , a big chunk parabolic is a subgroup conjugated to some A_{X} , where X\subseteq S spans a big chunk in \Gamma_{S} . In our previous work, we proved that every isomorphism between two Artin systems induces a bijection between the sets of big chunks, which preserves the isomorphism type [ JMS25 ] . In light of this, one might hope to recover the strong twist conjecture for an Artin system from the twist conjecture for its big chunk parabolics. We prove just that in our first main result, under a further mild hypothesis: Theorem D (see Theorem 4.11 ) . Let (A,S) be an Artin system, with \Gamma_{S} connected. Suppose that the following holds: • For every X\subseteq S spanning a big chunk, (A_{X},X) satisfies the strong twist conjecture; • For every Y\subseteq S spanning a clique, (A_{Y},Y) satisfies the vertex ribbon property. Then (A,S) satisfies the strong twist conjecture. First introduced by Paris [ Par97 ] , a ribbon can be intuitively thought of as a minimal element that conjugates two standard parabolic subgroups of an Artin system (see Definition 4.1 , which for our purposes only describes ribbons between standard generators). The vertex ribbon property states that any element that conjugates two standard generators decomposes as a product of ribbons, and is conjectured to hold for all Artin systems. In the course of proving Theorem D , we also obtain a combination result for the vertex ribbon property, see Theorem G below. As an application of Theorem D , we exhibit new families of Artin systems satisfying the strong twist conjecture. Our result covers Artin systems for which even the weak twist conjecture was not previously known (see Figure 1 for an example). Corollary E (see Corollary 4.16 ) . Let (A,S) be an Artin system, with \Gamma_{S} connected. Suppose that, for every X\subseteq S spanning a big chunk, the corresponding parabolic (A_{X},X) is of one of the following types: (1) (A_{X},X) is right-angled (i.e. all edge labels are 2 ); (2) (A_{X},X) is of large-type (i.e. all edge labels are at least 3 ) and triangle-free (i.e. no induced subgraph of \Gamma_{X} is a triangle); (3) (A_{X},X) is of large-type and free-of-infinity (i.e. \Gamma_{X} is a complete graph); (4) (A_{X},X) is of

Read the complete text