Democratizing Game Modding with GenAI: A Case Study of StarCharM, a Stardew Valley Character Maker DOI: 10.1145/3748612 Journal: PACMHCI Volume: 9 6 GAMES017 10 CCS: Applied computing Computer games CCS: Human-centered computing Collaborative and social computing

Hamid Zand Miralvand, Mohammad Ronagh Nikghalb, Mohammad Darandeh, Abidullah Khan, Ian Arawjo, Jinghui Cheng · 2025

Read Democratizing Game Modding with GenAI: A Case Study of StarCharM, a Stardew Valley Character Maker DOI: 10.1145/3748612 Journal: PACMHCI Volume: 9 6 GAMES017 10 CCS: Applied computing Computer games CCS: Human-centered computing Collaborative and social computing by Hamid Zand Miralvand, Mohammad Ronagh Nikghalb, Mohammad Darandeh, Abidullah Khan, Ian Arawjo, Jinghui Cheng (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-13951.txt.

Introduction

Modding a game takes coding skill, so most players never try, even when they dream up characters they would love to meet. Hamid Zand Miralvand and co-authors build StarCharM in this 2025 study, a generative AI tool that lets players of a farming game create new characters through simple, guided steps.

Ten players with mixed modding backgrounds tried the tool. They enjoyed watching their ideas come alive and could fine-tune details, but rich backstories strained the generator. Players welcomed a wider, more diverse modding scene while worrying that easy generation might thin out originality and community spirit. The authors distill design lessons for such tools.

Catalog record

CREATORHamid Zand Miralvand, Mohammad Ronagh Nikghalb, Mohammad Darandeh, Abidullah Khan, Ian Arawjo, Jinghui Cheng
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE113 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-13951

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Democratizing Game Modding with GenAI: A Case Study of StarCharM, a Stardew Valley Character Maker DOI: 10.1145/3748612 Journal: PACMHCI Volume: 9 6 GAMES017 10 CCS: Applied computing Computer games CCS: Human-centered computing Collaborative and social computing Hamid Zand Miralvand, Mohammad Ronagh Nikghalb, Mohammad Darandeh, Abidullah Khan, Ian Arawjo, Jinghui Cheng Abstract . Game modding offers unique and personalized gaming experiences, but the technical complexity of creating mods often limits participation to skilled users. We envision a future where every player can create personalized mods for their games. To explore this space, we designed StarCharM, a GenAI-based non-player character (NPC) creator for Stardew Valley. Our tool enables players to iteratively create new NPC mods, requiring minimal user input while allowing for fine-grained adjustments through user control. We conducted a user study with ten Stardew Valley players who had varied mod usage experiences to understand the impacts of StarCharM and provide insights into how GenAI tools may reshape modding, particularly in NPC creation. Participants expressed excitement in bringing their character ideas to life, although they noted challenges in generating rich content to fulfill complex visions. While they believed GenAI tools like StarCharM can foster a more diverse modding community, some voiced concerns about diminished originality and community engagement that may come with such technology. Our findings provided implications and guidelines for the future of GenAI-powered modding tools and co-creative modding practices. † † cc-license: by-sa 1. Introduction Video game modification, or modding in short, is a hands-on practice carried out by game players or fans (instead of the game developers themselves) to change and enhance the game content ( Poor 2014 ; Scacchi 2010 ) . Nowadays, this practice is popular among gamers and supported by large communities. For instance, Nexus Mods 1 1 1 https://www.nexusmods.com , one of the largest game mod hosting websites, hosts more than 600,000 mods for more than 3,000 games, created by hundreds of thousands of authors and enjoyed by millions of players. There are diverse forms of game modding ( Scacchi 2010 ) , including user interface customization, game conversions (i.e., adding or changing in-game characters, objects, mechanics, etc.), and machinima and art mods. Research shows that modders are driven primarily by a love for the game and desires to enhance their gameplay experience ( Poor 2014 ; Unger 2012 ) , express themselves artistically and creatively, and feel a sense of belonging to a community ( Tancred et al. 2024 ; Sotamaa 2010 ) . In sum, modding gives players and mod creators more ways to experience the game and express themselves. In spite of its popularity and benefits, mod creation, however, is not a practice that is easily attainable for everyone. Creating a mod often requires extensive, game-specific technical skills, such as familiarity with a particular scripting language, graphic design tool, or software development kit, as well as an understanding of community norms, which can pose significant barriers for newcomers ( Postigo 2007 ; Kow and Nardi 2009 ) . Some modding practices also require reverse engineering skills to unravel the game’s design and inner working details, often through hacking-like strategies ( Scacchi 2011 ) . Although some game engines, such as iD Tech and Unreal, actively support modding by providing documentation and infrastructure, learning the necessary workflows and programming languages can still be daunting for novices ( Schreiner and von Mammen 2021 ) . As such, there appears to be a layered hierarchy in modding communities, where at the center are dedicated mod creators, surrounded by players who actively use mods, who are surrounded further by the vast majority of regular players who may have never encountered modding. While mod users and non-modders are not necessarily casual players, they often have limited power to customize their gaming experience and end up becoming the “consumers” of the mod content and the game, relying upon the expertise and creativity of others. As a result, they miss the opportunity to enjoy their favorite games in unique and personalized ways and to showcase their creativity. The advent of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) promises to improve the situation, empowering people with less technical skills to implement software through natural language expressions of their intent ( Panchanadikar and Freeman 2024 ; Nguyen et al. 2024 ; Sweetser 2024 ) . Indeed, previous studies have explored the use of GenAI in game design and development, leveraging its capabilities to generate game content such as narratives ( Steenstra et al. 2024 ) , levels ( Irfan et al. 2019 ) , quests ( Ashby et al. 2023 ; Vartinen et al. 2022 ) , visual assets ( Karp and Swiderska-Chadaj 2021 ) , and game rules ( Torii et al. 2023 ) . However, while GenAI has significant potential to enhance the modding process, there is no empirical research specifically studying this question. One might presume that GenAI can ease the burden of content creation and programming efforts for game modding; however, the usage of GenAI might also raise thorny questions of authenticity, authorship, and ethics ( Bozkurt 2024 ; Sun et al. 2024a ) . In this work, we address this area and aim to explore how players perceive GenAI-empowered tools in transforming the game modding landscape. While modding encompasses a wide range of practices, we focus specifically on non-player character (NPC) creation in the game Stardew Valley and investigated the design and user perception of a tool called StarCharM ( Star dew Valley Cha racter M aker) for adding NPCs in the game. Stardew Valley is a farming simulation role-playing game where players manage an inherited farm. By partaking in a wide range of activities, such as mining, fishing, foraging, and farming, players work to restore the farm and enjoy a country life. As they go about their daily tasks, they can interact with various villagers (NPCs), build relationships, and even marry and start a family. The game places a strong narrative emphasis on NPC interactions, emotional arcs, and social routines. First released in 2016, Stardew Valley is widely considered to be one of the most successful independent games of all time, with continual updates and a large fanbase 2 2 2 https://www.stardewvalley.net/press/ . We chose Stardew Valley both for this popularity and because it has an active modding community ( sta 2024a ) with strong modding support ( sta 2024b ) . Its modding community is exceptionally active, diverse, and welcoming to novice creators (including the authors of this paper), with accessible documentation and widespread use of tools like SMAPI and Content Patcher. Stardew Valley supports a wide range of modding practices, including retexturing visual assets, adding automation tools (e.g., for more efficient farming), redesigning in-game objects to streamline gameplay, and adding new NPCs and narrative arcs. Among these mod types, we focused on NPC modding in this game because of two reasons. First, NPC modding in Stardew Valley provides a rich canvas for personal storytelling, offering the flexibility to cater to different player preferences (as mentioned above and see more in Section 3 ). The NPCs in the game essentially provide a rich setting and lore to the players, offering unique backstories, personalities, and daily routines. As such, a diverse array of players can use NPC modding

Read the complete text