Impact of homophily in adherence to anti-epidemic measures on the spread of infectious diseases in social networks
Piotr Bentkowski, Tomasz Gubiec · 2025
Read Impact of homophily in adherence to anti-epidemic measures on the spread of infectious diseases in social networks by Piotr Bentkowski, Tomasz Gubiec (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-13848.txt.
Introduction
Piotr Bentkowski and Tomasz Gubiec model how like-minded clustering of health behaviour can backfire in epidemics, in work from twenty twenty-five. People split into those who follow anti-epidemic steps and those who do not. Spread rates depend on the behaviour of both the sick and the healthy person. The team runs a standard spread model on two kinds of fake social networks. One kind tunes how often the two groups mix, with little clustering.
The second kind adds triadic closure, so friends of friends link up often. When sick followers cut spread a lot, more group split can raise infections among followers. That paradox appears only in the clustered networks, not the plain ones. Local clumps let behaviour amplify spread inside the follower group itself. More social distance thus fails to protect when clustering runs high. Network shape must enter plans for behaviour-based controls.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Piotr Bentkowski, Tomasz Gubiec |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-13848
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Impact of homophily in adherence to anti-epidemic measures on the spread of infectious diseases in social networks Piotr Bentkowski, Tomasz Gubiec Abstract We investigate how homophily in adherence to anti-epidemic measures affects the final size of epidemics in social networks. Using a modified SIR model, we divide agents into two behavioral groups—compliant and non-compliant—and introduce transmission probabilities that depend asymmetrically on the behavior of both the infected and susceptible individuals. We simulate epidemic dynamics on two types of synthetic networks with tunable inter-group connection probability: stochastic block models (SBM) and networks with triadic closure (TC) that better capture local clustering. Our main result reveals a counterintuitive effect: under conditions where compliant infected agents significantly reduce transmission, increasing the separation between groups may lead to a higher fraction of infections in the compliant population. This paradoxical outcome emerges only in networks with clustering (TC), not in SBM, suggesting that local network structure plays a crucial role. These findings highlight that increasing group separation does not always confer protection, especially when behavioral traits amplify within-group transmission. 1 Introduction 1.1 Motivation The COVID-19 pandemic has sparked renewed interest in understanding how behavioural and structural heterogeneity affect the spread of infectious diseases in social systems. Although classical compartmental models in epidemiology treat the population as homogeneous, real-world societies are composed of individuals with diverse behavioural responses, including varying levels of adherence to public health interventions such as mask wearing, vaccination, and social distancing. Recent empirical studies have shown that people tend to cluster in social and spatial proximity based on their health behaviours and beliefs [ 14 , 15 , 4 ] , a phenomenon known as homophily. Such clustering can have profound implications for epidemic dynamics, particularly when individuals who neglect anti-epidemic measures form tightly connected subgroups. These clusters can serve as reservoirs for sustained transmission, reducing the overall effectiveness of interventions aimed at the population level. Our study focusses on understanding how homophily in adherence to antiepidemic measures affects the final size of an epidemic in a population composed of two behavioural groups. We distinguish between compliant individuals who follow preventive measures, and noncompliant individuals who do not. By embedding these groups into synthetic networks with tunable levels of intergroup connectivity, we explore whether increasing separation between behavioural groups protects compliant individuals or, paradoxically, makes them more vulnerable. We show that under certain conditions, separating groups may inadvertently amplify transmission within the non-compliant cluster, increasing secondary exposure for the compliant group. This finding underscores the importance of considering network structure and asymmetric behavioural effects in the design and evaluation of epidemic control strategies. 1.2 Related Work The role of behavioural clustering in epidemic dynamics has been studied in multiple disciplines, including epidemiology, network science, and computational social science. Early work by May and Silverman [ 14 ] highlighted the potential threat posed by spatial clusters of individuals who refuse vaccination, showing that such clustering can lower herd immunity thresholds. Omer et al. [ 15 ] extended this observation by identifying geographic clustering of non-medical exemptions and its association with pertussis outbreaks. From a network-theoretic perspective, Salathé and Bonhoeffer [ 17 ] showed that opinion clustering can dramatically affect outbreak size, even when the overall fraction of protected individuals remains constant. More recent studies have investigated the dual role of social influence and selection in producing clusters of vaccine hesitancy [ 2 ] , and how assortative mixing based on behaviors such as mask-wearing [ 18 ] or vaccination [ 11 , 8 , 3 ] alters epidemic thresholds and dynamics. In particular, [ 3 ] show that vaccine status homophily can amplify infection risk among the unvaccinated, even when overall coverage is high. The interaction between homophily and the effectiveness of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) has recently been linked to paradoxical phenomena. Klimek et al. [ 12 ] demonstrate that, under specific behavioral correlations, low mask coverage can be more protective for mask wearers than medium coverage—a result attributed to network-level feedbacks and assortativity. These findings resonate with our observation that increased separation between compliant and non-compliant individuals can elevate risk for the compliant group, depending on which aspect of transmission is modulated by interventions. From a modelling perspective, our use of networks with controlled clustering and modularity builds on recent advances in network generation. In particular, the STC model proposed in [ 9 ] enables explicit control of triadic closure while preserving degree distributions. The importance of higher-order motifs has been emphasized in studies of complex contagion [ 7 , 13 ] , showing that clustering and triangle overlap influence both outbreak thresholds and final epidemic size. Bizzarri et al. [ 6 ] theoretically predict that homophily may first amplify and then suppress infections as it increases, depending on epidemic regime. These studies collectively suggest that homophily in protective behavior is not merely a passive reflection of social preferences but an active driver of epidemic risk. Our work contributes to this literature by demonstrating that, under realistic constraints on transmission asymmetry, increased homophily can produce counterintuitive outcomes. Unlike most prior models, we examine this effect in networks with controlled modularity and clustering, and we isolate the conditions under which increased separation between compliant and non-compliant individuals harms rather than protects the compliant population. 1.3 Research Questions and Contribution This work addresses the following research question: under what conditions does increasing behavioral homophily—interpreted as the separation between compliant and non-compliant individuals—lead to reduced epidemic impact in the compliant group? More specifically, we aim to understand how network structure and asymmetric transmission dynamics influence the final size of the epidemic within each behavioral group. To answer this question, we develop a modified SIR model in which the probability of transmission depends asymmetrically on the behaviors of both the infected and susceptible individuals. We embed the population into synthetic networks generated by two models which allows control over inter-group connection probabilities: the stochastic block model (SBM) and a triadic closure (TC) model, which captures clustering typical of real-world social networks. The key contributions of this study are: • We introduce a variant of the SIR model with behavior-dependent transmission asymmetries, distinguishing between the infectiousness of non-compliant individuals and the susceptibility of compliant individuals. • We systematically explore epidemic dynamics across a range of homophily levels and model parameters on both SBM and TC networks, ensuring constant network density for fair comparison (mean degree \langle k\rangle=4 ) • We identify a counterintuitive effect: in clustered networks (TC), increasing the separation between groups can increase the fraction of recovered nodes in the compliant group, due to intensified intra-group transmission among non-compliant individuals. • We show that this effect does not appear in SBM networks, underscoring the role of local clustering in mediating epidemic outcomes. By isolating the conditions under which homophily exacerbates risk rather than mitigates it, our findings contribute to the theoretical understanding of behavioral-epidemic interactions and offer cautionary insight into the design of intervention strategies. 2 Model and Methods 2.1 Epidemic Dynamics with Behavior-Based Transmission We use a discrete-time SIR (Susceptible–Infected–Recovered) model implemented on a static undirected network. Each node represents an individual and can be in one of three epidemiological states: susceptible (S), infected (I), or recovered (R). At each time step, infected individuals