Navigating the Lobbying Landscape: Insights from Opinion Dynamics Models
Daniele Giachini, Leonardo Ciambezi, Verdiana Del Rosso, Fabrizio Fornari, Valentina Pansanella, Lilit Popoyan, Alina Sîrbu · 2025
Read Navigating the Lobbying Landscape: Insights from Opinion Dynamics Models by Daniele Giachini, Leonardo Ciambezi, Verdiana Del Rosso, Fabrizio Fornari, Valentina Pansanella, Lilit Popoyan, Alina Sîrbu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-13767.txt.
Introduction
Daniele Giachini and six co-authors add lobbying to models of how opinions form, in a research paper from 2025. Lobbyists plainly shape public opinion and policy, yet standard opinion models leave them out. In the new model, lobbyists have limited budgets and can plan complex campaigns.
People in the model update their views from signals sent by others, filtered through habits like under-reacting and favoring what they already think. Computer runs show two regimes. In one, lobbyists can sway the whole network. In the other, peer pressure splits the public into camps. When rival lobbyists compete, spending early wins in one regime and spending late wins in the other.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniele Giachini, Leonardo Ciambezi, Verdiana Del Rosso, Fabrizio Fornari, Valentina Pansanella, Lilit Popoyan, Alina Sîrbu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 51 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-13767
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Navigating the Lobbying Landscape: Insights from Opinion Dynamics Models Daniele Giachini, Leonardo Ciambezi, Verdiana Del Rosso, Fabrizio Fornari, Valentina Pansanella, Lilit Popoyan, Alina Sîrbu Abstract While lobbying has been demonstrated to have an important effect on public opinion and policy making, existing models of opinion formation do not specifically include its effect. In this work we introduce a new model of opinion dynamics where lobbyists can implement complex strategies and are characterised by a finite budget. Individuals update their opinions through a learning process resembling Bayesian learning, but influenced by cognitive biases such as under-reaction and confirmation bias. We study the model numerically and demonstrate rich dynamics both with and without lobbyists. In the presence of lobbying, we observe two regimes: one in which lobbyists can have full influence on the agent network, and another where the peer-effect generates polarisation. When symmetric lobbyists are present, the lobbyist influence regime is characterised by long opinion oscillations, while in the transition area between the two regimes we observe convergence to the optimistic model when the lobbying influence is long enough. These rich dynamics pave the way for studying real lobbying strategies to validate the model in practice. keywords Opinion dynamics, Social networks, Agent-based modelling, Bayesian learning and behavioural bias, Lobbying, Climate change Introduction Lobbying is a pervasive feature of modern policymaking, shaping decisions across virtually all domains of public life, from environmental regulation and healthcare to financial oversight and digital governance. Beyond direct engagement with policymakers, lobbying strategies increasingly aim to influence public opinion, leveraging social networks and mass communication to create political momentum, reduce resistance to controversial policies, or shift the Overton window on key issues. Lobbyists, whether representing corporate interests, civil society, or ideological coalitions, act strategically to influence not only policymakers, but also public perception and discourse. A large body of empirical literature has demonstrated the effectiveness of lobbying in shaping policy outcomes [ 1 , 2 ] , with recent work underscoring the growing sophistication of lobbying strategies in networked political and media environments [ 3 , 4 ] . This broader landscape of influence highlights the need to understand lobbying not only as a transactional activity, but also as a dynamic process of belief formation and diffusion in complex social systems. Among the various mechanisms through which lobbying exerts influence, opinion formation within the public sphere plays a critical role. Lobbyists increasingly target public attitudes to create political pressure or legitimacy for specific policy choices [ 5 , 6 ] . The advent of digital platforms has magnified these efforts, enabling tailored messaging and decentralized opinion shaping. This makes the diffusion of opinions across social networks, where individuals interact, update beliefs, and potentially become advocates themselves, a crucial site for understanding lobbying efficacy. To study this complex landscape, opinion dynamics models offer powerful tools. Opinion dynamics models are mathematical representations utilized to elucidate the intricate mechanisms underlying the dissemination and evolution of opinions or beliefs across heterogeneous populations [ 7 , 8 ] . These models, rooted in theories of social influence and information diffusion, and also inspired by models from statistical physics, have garnered substantial attention and application across diverse disciplines, including sociology [ 9 ] , political science [ 10 ] , marketing [ 11 ] and economics [ 12 ] . They offer valuable insights into the emergence of collective behaviors, the formation of consensus, and the dynamics of information propagation within social networks [ 13 , 14 , 15 ] . Recently, they have also been used to model opinion formation in settings mediated by technology, for example through a bounded confidence model with algorithmic bias [ 16 , 17 ] , which demonstrated how interaction through online social media that promotes information exchange with similar peers can cause fragmentation and polarization of opinions. In economic modelling and political science, opinion dynamics models have increasingly intersected with agent-based modeling approaches [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] , allowing for the incorporation of bounded rationality, motivated reasoning, and strategic behavior. Despite their extensive utilization in numerous domains, the application of opinion dynamics models within the lobbying realm remains a nascent and underexplored area of inquiry. While existing research has shed light on the role of social networks and public discourse in shaping climate attitudes and policy preferences [ 21 ] , the integration of formalized mathematical frameworks to analyze and forecast lobbying dynamics represents a promising frontier for advancing our understanding of the complex interplay between public opinion, lobbying discourse, and policy outcomes. However, relatively few models explicitly integrate lobbying agents into these frameworks. Many studies consider mass media influence in opinion dynamics, typically modelled as external field that can influence all agents with a certain probability [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 22 , 17 ] . The effects observed depend on the structure of the population and model parameters: while in some situations mass media can stimulate consensus or speedup convergence, in other cases, especially when promoting extreme messages, it can facilitate polarisation. Alternatively, models can include zealots or stubborn agents [ 23 , 15 ] , with similar effects. While some similarities exist, these approaches do not fully encompass the concept of lobbying, which can implement different dynamic strategies and typically have a cost. Furthermore, the modelling of opinions in these examples is very simplified, sometimes including bounded confidence or disagreement, but not taking into account more complex mechanisms such as confirmation bias or motivated reasoning. Therefore, the endogenous modeling of lobbying strategies aimed at belief manipulation within a dynamic opinion formation process remains underdeveloped. This paper contributes to this growing interdisciplinary literature by introducing a novel model of lobbying influence over opinion dynamics in a boundedly rational social network. In our framework, a population of agents interacts repeatedly to update their subjective beliefs about the likelihood of an uncertain future event, for example, a damaging climate event. Each agent weighs two competing probabilistic models—one “optimistic” and one “pessimistic”—and updates their beliefs through Bayesian-like learning, modulated by under-reaction [ 24 , 25 , 26 ] and confirmation bias (a form of directional motivated reasoning) [ 27 ] . Agents are embedded in a directed network and interact through sequential signal exchanges that propagate beliefs over time. We then endogenize lobbying by introducing external agents — lobbyists — who strategically send costly signals to influence the population’s belief distribution by the end of a finite time horizon. Lobbyists differ in the model they support and are subject to a resource constraint (budget). Their objective is to minimize the distance between the final average belief and their preferred model. Lobbyists select randomized strategies from a constrained set of signaling paths, and their interventions shape both the speed and direction of belief evolution in the network. Our numerical results reveal rich dynamics. In the absence of lobbying, the network tends to converge toward consensus or, under high confirmation bias, become polarized. A single lobbyist with sufficient resources can dominate belief formation and steer the network toward its preferred model, especially when agents are relatively open to new information. However, when two lobbyists with opposing goals act simultaneously, the system often fails to converge within the active time horizon, resulting in persistent instability