Energy exchange between electrons and ions driven by ITG-TEM turbulence

T. Kato, H. Sugama, T.-H. Watanabe · 2025

Read Energy exchange between electrons and ions driven by ITG-TEM turbulence by T. Kato, H. Sugama, T.-H. Watanabe (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-13692.txt.

Introduction

Kato, Sugama, and Watanabe study energy exchange in plasma turbulence in a paper from two thousand twenty-five. In fusion plasmas, two kinds of turbulence, called ITG and TEM, move heat and particles. The authors ask how energy passes between electrons and ions inside that turbulence, using gyrokinetic simulations.

In TEM turbulence, electrons cool through one drift motion while ions heat along the field lines, so energy flows from electrons to ions. ITG turbulence shows the opposite direction. In mixed turbulence, the balance of the two effects sets the net flow. The authors confirm the flow runs from the species that produces more entropy to the other. They also test a simpler predictive model and propose a new method.

Catalog record

CREATORT. Kato, H. Sugama, T.-H. Watanabe
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-13692

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Energy exchange between electrons and ions driven by ITG-TEM turbulence Preprint: AIP/123-QED T. Kato, H. Sugama, T.-H. Watanabe Abstract In this study, the energy exchange between electrons and ions in trapped-electron-mode (TEM) and mixed ion-temperature-gradient (ITG) – TEM turbulence is investigated using gyrokinetic simulations. The energy exchange in TEM turbulence is primarily composed of the cooling of electrons associated with perpendicular ∇ B \nabla B -curvature drift and the heating of ions moving parallel to magnetic field lines. TEM turbulence facilitates energy transfer from electrons to ions, which is opposite to the direction observed in ITG turbulence. In mixed ITG-TEM turbulence, the relative magnitudes of parallel heating and perpendicular cooling for each species determine the overall direction and magnitude of energy exchange. From the viewpoint of entropy balance, it is further confirmed that energy flows from the species with larger entropy production, caused by particle and heat fluxes, to the other species in ITG-TEM turbulence. The predictability of turbulent energy exchange in ITG-TEM turbulence by the quasilinear model is examined. In addition, an alternative method based on the correlation between energy flux and energy exchange is developed, and its validity is demonstrated. I Introduction Turbulence in magnetically confined plasmas induces particle flux, heat flux, and energy exchange between electrons and ions Kato2024 ; Sugama1996 ; Sugama2009 ; Waltz ; Waltz1997 ; Candy ; Manheimer . Gyrokinetic theory provides a robust framework for understanding turbulence in magnetized plasmas, and gyrokinetic simulations are widely used to analyse the turbulent transports Antonsen ; CTB ; F-C ; Pueschel ; Dimits ; Krommes2012 ; Garbet2010 ; Idomura2006 ; Horton . The prediction of turbulent effects is necessary for simulations of global density and temperature profiles. The quasilinear model is useful for estimating the nonlinear simulation results by linear simulations, which require relatively low computational costs Casati ; Citrin ; Citrin2017 ; Bourdelle ; Staebler2021 ; Staebler2024 ; Merz ; Narita ; Toda ; Parker ; Barnes . It is well established that the turbulent fluxes significantly contribute to the global profiles. However, the effect of turbulent energy exchange had been considered negligible Waltz ; Waltz1997 ; Candy ; Manheimer . As a result, while turbulent transport fluxes are commonly incorporated into transport simulations for predicting density and temperature profiles, the contribution of turbulent energy exchange is typically omitted. Our previous work Kato2024 , which investigates energy exchange caused by pure ITG turbulence in tokamak plasmas, has reported that in high temperature or low collisional plasmas, such as those handled in future fusion reactors, turbulent energy exchange could exceed collisional one. Furthermore, it is found that turbulent energy exchange in ITG turbulence can transfer energy from ions to electrons regardless of whether electrons or ions are hotter. This is significantly different from the collisional energy exchange, which transfers energy from the hotter particle species to the cooler species. This implies that the ITG turbulence should be suppressed from the viewpoint of sustaining the high ion temperature required for fusion reactions since it prevents energy transfer from alpha-heated electrons to ions. Thus, transport simulations predicting global temperature profiles should include the effect of turbulent energy exchange for future fusion reactors. To support this, the feasibility of the quasilinear model for energy exchange due to ITG turbulence in tokamak plasmas has also been demonstrated. Other previous studies Manheimer ; Waltz1997 ; Waltz have examined energy exchange driven by TEM and mixed ITG–TEM turbulence. In this study, we analyze the entropy balance and energy fluxes as well as the wavenumber spectrum of energy exchange, which have not been addressed in the previous studies, to clarify the physical mechanism of energy exchange in ITG-TEM turbulence. We also extend our previous work to examine the applicability of the quasilinear model to energy exchange in TEM and mixed ITG–TEM turbulence, by varying the most unstable mode from TEM to ITG. In addition, we propose an alternative approach that combines the quasilinear model with the correlation between energy fluxes and energy exchange, and demonstrate its effectiveness. It should be noted that the saturation rule, which is essential for the practical application of quasilinear models, is not addressed here. Instead, this study focuses on evaluating the validity of a fundamental assumption of the quasilinear model that the ratios of turbulent fluxes and energy exchange to the amplitude of turbulent fluctuations can be approximated by those obtained from linear calculations. The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II , the entropy balance equation for the turbulent fluctuation and components of turbulent energy transfer are introduced. In Sec. III , simulation results of pure TEM and mixed ITG-TEM turbulence by the GKV code GKV , which uses a flux tube domain Beer , are shown. Simulation settings and results of linear simulations are shown in Sec. III.1 . The nonlinear simulation results for pure TEM and mixed ITG-TEM turbulence are presented in Secs. III.2 and III.3 , respectively, and the entropy balance, energy transfer and the feasibility of the quasilinear model for energy transfer are discussed. Finally, conclusions and discussion are given in Sec. IV . II Entropy balance equation and turbulent energy transfers We here introduce the balance equation for the entropy associated with the perturbed distribution function and the components of turbulent energy transfers for electrons and ions. In this study, the background radial electric field E_{r} is set to zero, since its effect appears only in the Doppler shift in the local gyrokinetic theory and does not fundamentally affect the turbulent transport fluxes and energy exchange. The background E\times B flow shear effect is also neglected here since it is regarded as smaller by an order of the gyrokinetic expansion parameter \delta than the terms included in the gyrokinetic equation introduced in Ref. Kato2024 . The detailed derivation is explained in Refs. Kato2024 ; Sugama1996 ; Sugama2009 . The entropy balance equation in the perpendicular wavenumber space for particle species a=e,i is described as, \frac{\partial}{\partial t}\left(\delta S_{ha\bm{k}}\right)=\frac{\Gamma^{\rm turb}_{a\bm{k}}}{L_{pa}}+\frac{q^{\rm turb}_{a\bm{k}}}{T_{a}L_{Ta}}+\frac{Q^{\rm turb}_{a\bm{k}}}{T_{a}}+D_{a\bm{k}}+N_{a\bm{k}}, (1) where the perturbed entropy for nonadiabatic distrbution function \delta S_{ha\bm{k}} , particle flux \Gamma_{a\bm{k}}^{\rm turb} , heat flux q^{\rm turb}_{a\bm{k}} , energy transfer from the perturbed field to particles Q^{\rm turb}_{a\bm{k}} , collisional dissipation D_{a\bm{k}} , and entropy transfer by nonlinear interaction N_{a\bm{k}} , pressure and temperature gradient scale lengths L_{pa} , L_{Ta} are described as, \displaystyle\delta S_{ha\bm{k}}=\Big\langle\Big\langle\int d^{3}v\frac{\left|h_{a\bm{k}}\right|^{2}}{2f_{Ma}}\Big\rangle\Big\rangle, (2) \displaystyle\left[\Gamma^{\rm turb}_{a\bm{k}},q^{\rm turb}_{a\bm{k}}\right]=\operatorname{\rm{Re}}\Bigg\langle\Bigg\langle\int d^{3}v\left[1,\frac{m_{a}v^{2}}{2}-\frac{5T_{a}}{2}\right] \displaystyle\hskip 71.13188pt\times h_{a\bm{k}}^{*}\left(-i\frac{c}{B}\psi_{a\bm{k}}\bm{k}\times\bm{b}\right)\cdot\nabla r\Bigg\rangle\Bigg\rangle, (3) \displaystyle Q^{\rm turb}_{a\bm{k}}=\operatorname{\rm{Re}}\Bigg\langle\Bigg\langle\int d^{3}ve_{a}h_{a\bm{k}}^{*}\frac{\partial\psi_{a\bm{k}}}{\partial t}\Bigg\rangle\Bigg\rangle, (4) \displaystyle D_{a\bm{k}}=\operatorname{\rm{Re}}\Big\langle\Big\langle\int d^{3}v\frac{h_{a\bm{k}}^{*}}{f_{Ma}}C^{GK}_{a}\Big\rangle\Big\rangle, (5) \displaystyle N_{a\bm{k}}= \displaystyle\operatorname{\rm{Re}}\Bigg\langle\Bigg\langle\int d^{3}v\frac{c}{Bf_{Ma}}\sum_{\bm{k}^{\prime}+\bm{k}^{\prime\prime}=\bm{k}}\left[\bm{b}\cdot\left(\bm{k}^{\prime}\times\bm{k}^{\prime\prime}\right)\right]\psi_{a\bm{k}^{\prime}}h_{a\bm{k}^{\prime\prime}}h_{a\bm{k}}^{*}\Bigg\rangle\Bigg\rangle, (6) \displaystyle\left[L_{pa}^{-1},L_{Ta}^{-1}\right]=\left[-\frac{\partial\ln p_{a}}{\partial r},-\frac{\partial\ln T_{a}}{\partial r}\right], (7) respectively. The superscript * and " \rm Re " denote the complex conjugate and real parts, respectively, and c , e_{a} , m_{a} , T_{a} , p_{a} , f_{Ma} , and C^{GK}_{a} are the speed of light, charge, mass, temperature, pressure, local Maxwellian, and gyrokinetic collision operator, respectively. The perturbed nonadiabatic distribution function with a perpendicular wavenumber \bm{k} , denoted as h_{a\bm{k}} , is related to the perturbed distribution function f_{a\bm{k}} by the following relation: f_{a\bm{k}}=-\frac{e_{a}f_{Ma}}{T_{a}}\phi_{\bm{k}}+h_{a\bm{k}}e^{-i\bm{k}\cdot\bm{\rho}_{a}}, (8) where \bm{\rho}_{a}=\bm{b}\times\bm{v}/\Omega_{a} , \Omega_{a}=e_{a}B/(m_{a}c) and \bm{b}=\bm{B}/B . The double angle bracket \langle\langle\cdots\rangle\rangle denotes the double average over the ensemble and flux surface, and v and B are the absolute values of the velocity \bm{v} and background magnetic field \bm{B} ,

Read the complete text