Spin-free Generalised Normal Ordered Coupled Cluster

Nicholas Lee, David P. Tew · 2025

Read Spin-free Generalised Normal Ordered Coupled Cluster by Nicholas Lee, David P. Tew (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-13472.txt.

Introduction

Nicholas Lee and David Tew build a spin free coupled cluster method for hard electron problems, in work from 2025. Coupled cluster is a top tool for molecular energies, but multi reference cases strain it. A generalised normal ordered form can stretch the method to any spin state cleanly.

Their build stays size extensive and size consistent by construction from the start. A spin ensemble route strips spin labels from the working equations fully. Only excitations that reach the first order space survive, cutting redundant terms. Local orbitals let the method split open shell fragments without size errors. Test scores at singles and doubles level rival dedicated multi reference tools.

Catalog record

CREATORNicholas Lee, David P. Tew
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE109 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-13472

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Spin-free Generalised Normal Ordered Coupled Cluster Nicholas Lee, David P. Tew Abstract We present a spin-free, size-extensive, and size-consistent coupled cluster method based on a generalised normal ordered exponential ansatz. This approach is a natural generalisation of single-reference coupled cluster theory for arbitrary spin eigenfunctions. The working equations are size-extensive through the generalised normal order formalism, and made spin-free with the spin-ensemble approach. Redundancies amongst excitations are eliminated by selecting only those excitations that project the reference function onto the first-order interacting space. Furthermore, by utilising localised orbitals, the proposed method describes dissociation into open-shell fragments size-consistently. Numerical results on prototypical multireference systems at the singles and doubles level of theory are competitive with existing multireference approaches, yet with more compact working equations. I Introduction Application of coupled cluster theory to (quasi-)degenerate electronic states where multiple determinants are necessary remains a challenge for electronic structure theory Lyakh et al. 2012 ; Cársky, Paldus, and Pittner ; Köhn et al. 2013 ; Evangelista 2018 . Many early attempts at multireference coupled cluster (MRCC) involve solving for the ground and excited states using an effective Hamiltonian in a model space Shavitt and Bartlett 2009 . These attempts are typically classified either as state-universal Piecuch and Kowalski 2002 ; Paldus and Li 2003 (SU-MRCC) when the determinants making up the model space have the same number of electrons, or valence-universal Haque and Mukherjee 1984 ; Stolarczyk and Monkhorst 1985a ; Stolarczyk and Monkhorst 1985b ; Stolarczyk and Monkhorst 1988a ; Stolarczyk and Monkhorst 1988b ; Lindgren 1985a ; Lindgren and Mukherjee 1987 ; Kaldor 1991 (VU-MRCC) when the determinants can have variable number of electrons. These effective Hamiltonian approaches are usually beset by intruder state problems Hose and Kaldor 1979 ; Hose and Kaldor 1980 ; Hose and Kaldor 1982 ; Kaldor 1988 when model space determinants are strongly coupled to those in the complementary space. The problem of intruder states has led to the development of intermediate Hamiltonian approaches Malrieu, Durand, and Daudey 1985 , where a subset of the effective Hamiltonian eigenstates are targeted. When solving only for one eigenstate, the intermediate Hamiltonian approach is known as state-specific. State-specific approaches in MRCC have been extensively developed over the last few decades Mahapatra et al. 1998 ; Köhn et al. 2013 . In general, these approaches can be broadly divided into two classes (i) Methods which use a wave operator for each determinant in the reference function (Jeziorski-Monkhorst (JM) ansatz Jeziorski and Monkhorst 1981 ) and (ii) A single wave operator is applied onto a given reference function as pioneered by Mukherjee Mukherjee, Moitra, and Mukhopadhyay 1975 . Common to these approaches is that there are usually more excitation operators than there exist excited states Köhn et al. 2013 ; Evangelista 2018 . This leads to a redundancy problem where the number of residual equations, found by projecting the Schrödinger equation onto excited states, is fewer than the number of excitation operators. The corresponding cluster amplitudes are therefore underdetermined. With (i), the JM ansatz, it is typical to employ sufficiency conditions to overcome such redundancies. The different choices of sufficiency conditions employed Kong 2009 ; Lyakh et al. 2012 define the different Hilbert-Space MRCC (HS-MRCC) methods. Hanrath 2005 ; Hanrath 2008a ; Hubac and Wilson 2000 ; Mahapatra et al. 1998 ; Mahapatra, Datta, and Mukherjee 1999 ; Pittner 2003 ; Evangelista, Allen, and Schaefer 2006 ; Sinha, Maitra, and Mukherjee 2012 ; Sen, Shee, and Mukherjee 2012 ; Chakravarti, Sen, and Mukherjee 2023 However, many of these methods do not correspond to solving a projected Schrödinger equation (the proper residual equation condition is not satisfied Kong 2009 ). With (ii), initial attempts by Mukherjee Mukherjee, Moitra, and Mukhopadhyay 1975 ; Mukherjee, , and and Mukhopadhyay 1975 ; Mukherjee, Moitra, and Mukhopadhyay 1977 ; Mukherjee, , and and Mukhopadhyay 1977 and coworkers, as well as Banerjee and Simons Banerjee and Simons 1981 did not explicitly consider the problem of redundancy. A method of handling this redundancy was introduced by Evangelista and Gauss Evangelista and Gauss 2011 involves constructing an overlap metric and removing the null space to identify linearly independent excitation operators. This is known as internally contracted MRCC (ic-MRCC). A correctly scaling implementation of this method and the development of several low-cost approximations were further advanced by Köhn and co-workers Hanauer and Köhn 2011 ; Hanauer and Köhn 2012a ; Hanauer and Köhn 2012b ; Evangelista et al. 2012 ; Samanta et al. 2014 ; Aoto and Köhn 2016 ; Samanta and Köhn 2018 ; Köhn and Bargholz 2019 ; Black and Köhn 2019 ; Köhn et al. 2020 ; Black et al. 2023 ; Zielinski, Black, and Köhn 2023 ; Waigum, Ertürk, and Köhn 2024 ; Adam, Waigum, and Köhn 2025 . Since these redundancy problems arise from trying to solve a series of projective equations, another approach to overcome this difficulty is through constructing a different set of equations. The working equations are found by expanding a similarity transformed Hamiltonian in terms of n -body operators and requiring that those corresponding to the excitations in the cluster operator vanish. Stolarczyk 1994 ; Nooijen and Bartlett 1996 . Formally, this solves the problem of linear dependencies as there are as many residuals as there are cluster amplitudes. This approach is known as the many-body residual method and has been adopted in several formalisms Stolarczyk 1994 ; Nooijen and Lotrich 2001 ; Datta, Kong, and Nooijen 2011 ; Nooijen et al. 2014 ; Feldmann and Reiher 2024 , including partially internally contracted MRCC (pic-MRCC) and multireference equation-of-motion coupled-cluster (MREOM-CC). The aforementioned MRCC methods are known as genuine MRCC methods because they allow for relaxation of the reference function parameters. A different way of circumventing the redundancy problem is to use a fixed reference function, and therefore a fixed set of linearly independent excitation operators. These are known as alt -MRCC methods Oliphant and and Adamowicz 1993 ; Oliphant and and Adamowicz 1993 ; Piecuch, Oliphant, and Adamowicz 1993 ; Lyakh, Ivanov, and Adamowicz 2008 ; Kállay, Szalay, and Surján 2002 . This was pioneered by Oliphant and Adamowicz, who used a complete active space (CAS) reference with single and double excitations from each of the reference determinants Oliphant and and Adamowicz 1993 ; Oliphant and and Adamowicz 1993 . Similar to this are the Nakatsuji’s multireference symmetry-adapted cluster Nakatsuji 1985 (MR-SAC), and Li and Paldus’ unitary group approach coupled cluster Li and Paldus 1993 ; Li and Paldus 1994 ; Li and Paldus 1997 ; Li and Paldus 1998 (UGA-CC), which use multi-configurational references with a fully spin-adapted treatment. While spin-adaptation was performed with spin-projection operators in MR-SAC, spin-free operators were constructed through a unitary group approach in UGA-CC. More recently, the UGA-CC approach has been generalised to arbitrary high-spin open-shell systems by Herrmann and Hanrath Herrmann and Hanrath 2020 ; Herrmann and Hanrath 2022 ; Herrmann and and Hanrath 2022 . Other wavefunction ansätze have also been utilised for multireference coupled cluster methods, including matrix product states (Block-correlated coupled cluster) Li 2004 ; Wang et al. 2020 and generalised valence bond functions (Multireference ring coupled cluster) Szabados and and Margócsy 2017 ; Margócsy and Szabados 2020 . Another challenging issue

Read the complete text