Electron-neutrino lepton number crossings: variations with the supernova core physics
Marie Cornelius ID, Irene Tamborra ID, Malte Heinlein ID, Shashank Shalgar ID, Hans-Thomas Janka ID · 2025
Read Electron-neutrino lepton number crossings: variations with the supernova core physics by Marie Cornelius ID, Irene Tamborra ID, Malte Heinlein ID, Shashank Shalgar ID, Hans-Thomas Janka ID (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-13429.txt.
Introduction
Marie Cornelius, Irene Tamborra, Malte Heinlein, Shashank Shalgar, and Hans-Thomas Janka study neutrino flavor clues in exploding stars in a 2025 paper. In a supernova, neutrinos can swap flavors at high speed. A crossing in their count pattern flags good odds for that swap. How core physics shapes those crossings was partly unknown.
The team ran twelve collapse models of one heavy star. Each model varied the nuclear physics, muon use, or core stirring. Crossings moved outward when the young neutron star was stirred. They moved inward when muons formed in the core. The nuclear model choice changed things only a little. The work links core traits to flavor swap chances.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Marie Cornelius ID, Irene Tamborra ID, Malte Heinlein ID, Shashank Shalgar ID, Hans-Thomas Janka ID |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-13429
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Electron-neutrino lepton number crossings: variations with the supernova core physics Marie Cornelius ID, Irene Tamborra ID, Malte Heinlein ID, Shashank Shalgar ID, Hans-Thomas Janka ID Abstract A crucial ingredient affecting fast neutrino flavor conversion in core-collapse supernovae (SNe) is the shape of the angular distribution of the electron-neutrino lepton number (ELN). The presence of an ELN crossing signals favorable conditions for flavor conversion. However, the dependence of ELN crossings on the SN properties is only partially understood. We investigate a suite of 12 spherically symmetric neutrino-hydrodynamics simulations of the core collapse of a SN with a mass of 18.6 M ⊙ 18.6M_{\odot} ; each model employs different microphysics (i.e., three different nuclear equations of state, with and without muon creation) and includes or not a mixing-length treatment for proto-neutron star convection. We solve the Boltzmann equations to compute the neutrino angular distributions relying on static fluid properties extracted from each of the SN simulations in our suite for six selected post-bounce times. We explore the dependence of the ELN distributions on the SN microphysics and proto-neutron star convection. We find that the latter shifts the proto-neutron star radius outwards, favoring the appearance of ELN crossings at larger radii. On the other hand, muon creation causes proto-neutron star contraction, facilitating the occurrence of ELN crossings at smaller radii. These effects mildly depend on the nuclear equation of state. Our findings highlight the subtle impact of the SN microphysics, proto-neutron star convection, and neutrino transport on the ELN angular distributions. I Introduction Core-collapse supernovae (SNe) are among the most energetic transient events that occur in our Universe. Neutrinos are abundantly produced during the core collapse of massive stars and play a key role in the transport of energy and lepton number, as well as in driving the explosion according to the delayed neutrino-driven mechanism, cf. Refs. Burrows and Vartanyan 2021 ; Tamborra 2025 ; Vitagliano et al. 2020 for recent reviews. Multi-dimensional hydrodynamical SN simulations have reached a mature stage, with a wide range of progenitor properties being explored Janka 2025 ; Burrows et al. 2018 . However, due to its complexity, neutrino transport still involves a number of approximations. First, in most state-of-the-art simulations of stellar collapses, the evolution of the neutrino field is tracked relying on the lowest angular moments of the neutrino distribution functions, with closure schemes being employed to minimize the error induced by neglecting the higher angular moments (cf., e.g., Ref. Mezzacappa et al. 2020 and references therein). Second, neutrino flavor conversion is not taken into account in state-of-the-art SN simulations. However, a growing body of work points out that flavor evolution due to neutrino-neutrino refraction should already occur in the proximity of neutrino decoupling Tamborra and Shalgar 2021 ; Volpe 2024 ; Johns et al. 2025 . Recent work, adopting simplified approaches to gauge the impact of flavor conversion in hydrodynamic simulations, points out that the change of flavor of neutrinos can affect the SN explosion mechanism, the multi-messenger observables, and nucleosynthesis Nagakura 2023 ; Ehring et al. 2023a ; Ehring et al. 2023b ; Mori et al. 2025 ; Wang and Burrows 2025 . At high neutrino densities, fast flavor conversion can take place Sawyer 2005 ; Sawyer 2016 ; Chakraborty et al. 2016a ; Chakraborty et al. 2016b , if a crossing occurs between the angular distributions of electron neutrinos and antineutrinos–the electron lepton number (ELN) crossing–under the assumption that the non-electron flavors have identical properties Izaguirre et al. 2017 ; Morinaga 2022 ; Padilla-Gay et al. 2022 ; Fiorillo and Raffelt 2023 . Deep in the SN core, where the electron flavors are in chemical equilibrium with the stellar medium, crossings in the ELN angular distributions may develop in the proximity of the rapid drop of the electron fraction (deleptonization). The latter is responsible for a shift of beta equilibrium towards negative chemical potentials for \nu_{e} ’s. Due to differences in the interaction rates of electron neutrinos and antineutrinos with the stellar medium, \bar{\nu}_{e} ’s decouple from the matter background at smaller radii than \nu_{e} ’s, exhibiting more forward-peaked distributions Tamborra et al. 2017 ; Brandt et al. 2011 ; Shalgar and Tamborra 2019 . The neutrino angular distributions have been computed employing Boltzmann neutrino transport for a small set of SN hydrodynamic simulations, cf. e.g., Refs. Sumiyoshi and Yamada 2012 ; Akaho et al. 2021 ; Nagakura et al. 2018 ; Brandt et al. 2011 ; Fischer et al. 2010 ; Tamborra et al. 2017 . Therefore, in most cases, the neutrino angular distributions are reconstructed employing moment-based schemes to assess the existence of ELN crossings in SN simulations, cf. e.g., Refs. Abbar 2020 ; Abbar et al. 2021 ; Capozzi et al. 2021 ; Dasgupta et al. 2018 ; Glas et al. 2020 ; Nagakura et al. 2021 . Although Refs. Johns and Nagakura 2021 ; Cornelius et al. 2025 have recently questioned the inference of the ELN properties from SN simulations based on moment-based schemes, ELN crossings appear to be a widespread phenomenon in SNe with characteristic features depending on the radial regions where they develop Nagakura et al. 2021 . These findings suggest that ELN crossings may depend on the SN dynamics as well as on the SN microphysics. This paper explores the conditions under which ELN crossings occur in a suite of spherically symmetric SN models. Our goal is to assess how proto-neutron star (PNS) convection and SN microphysics [e.g., the presence of muons and the nuclear equation of state (EoS)] influence the formation and characteristics of these crossings. To this end, we adopt 12 spherically symmetric core-collapse simulations of an 18.6M_{\odot} progenitor, which were performed with and without muons and with and without a mixing-length treatment of PNS convection, and three different nuclear EoSs. For selected post-bounce time snapshots, following the approach presented in Refs. Shalgar and Tamborra 2024a ; Shalgar and Tamborra 2024b ; Shalgar and Tamborra 2025 , we extract static radial profiles of the main fluid properties from the SN simulations (such as the baryon density, medium temperature, electron and neutron fractions, and chemical potentials) to solve the Boltzmann equations in the surroundings of the neutrino decoupling region and compute the neutrino angular distributions. Our work is organized as follows. We introduce the SN models employed in our analysis in Sec. II . Section III outlines the approach adopted to compute the angular distributions for all flavors by solving the Boltzmann equations. We also explore the main features and radial evolution of the neutrino angular distributions. A comparison between the features of the ELN angular distributions and the appearance of ELN crossings across our SN models is presented in Sec. IV . We then discuss our findings and provide an outlook in Sec. V . In addition, in Appendix. A , we compare the first two angular moments extracted from the SN simulations with those computed by solving our Boltzmann equations; we also investigate the impact of the energy resolution on the neutrino angular distributions. II Core-collapse supernova models We adopt a suite of spherically symmetric SN models with a progenitor mass of 18.6M_{\odot} The Garching Core-Collapse Supernova Archive and PNS baryonic mass of 1.6M_{\odot} . These models employ three different nuclear EoSs: