WIP: Turning Fake Chips into Learning Opportunities
Haniye Mehraban, Saad Azmeen-ur-Rahman, John Hu School of Electrical & Computer Engineering , Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, OK 74078, USA · 2025
Read WIP: Turning Fake Chips into Learning Opportunities by Haniye Mehraban, Saad Azmeen-ur-Rahman, John Hu School of Electrical & Computer Engineering , Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, OK 74078, USA (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-13281.txt.
Introduction
Haniye Mehraban and co-authors present a 2025 work-in-progress paper on fake chips in a college lab. Counterfeit amplifier chips turned up in a junior electronics course. Fake parts are a growing risk for teaching labs and industry alike. Rather than swap the parts out quietly, the teachers built a lesson around them. Students diagnosed the fake parts by hand.
Students measured current, read waveforms, and hunted faults in real circuits. The work taught analog basics, supply chain security, and practical repair at once. A fault that could have ruined the course became its richest lab. Engineering teachers get a model for turning supply failures into learning. Students also gain a healthy doubt about parts that look right. The case is small and honest about its work-in-progress status, which suits its teaching aim.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Haniye Mehraban, Saad Azmeen-ur-Rahman, John Hu School of Electrical & Computer Engineering , Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, OK 74078, USA |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 19 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-13281
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
WIP: Turning Fake Chips into Learning Opportunities Thanks: ∗ Indicates authors who contributed equally to this work. Thanks: This work was supported in part by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) under Grant 80NSSC24M0161, awarded to Haniye Mehraban. Haniye Mehraban, Saad Azmeen-ur-Rahman, John Hu School of Electrical & Computer Engineering , Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, OK 74078, USA Abstract This work-in-progress paper presents a case study in which counterfeit TL074 operational amplifiers, discovered in a junior-level electronics course, became the basis for a hands-on learning experience. Counterfeit integrated circuits (IC) are increasingly common, posing a significant threat to the integrity of undergraduate electronics laboratories. Instead of simply replacing the counterfeit components, we turned the issue into a teaching moment. Students engaged in hands-on diagnostics—measuring current, analyzing waveforms, and troubleshooting. By working with fake chip components, they gained deeper insight into analog circuits, supply chain security, and practical engineering. I Introduction Hands-on electronics labs are foundational to undergraduate electrical and computer engineering (ECE) education, providing a critical bridge between abstract theory and real-world application. These lab environments often assume that the components used—especially standard ones like operational amplifiers—behave according to specifications. However, this assumption can break down when counterfeit integrated circuits (ICs) enter the educational supply chain, disrupting both the technical and pedagogical goals of lab-based learning. Counterfeit ICs are a growing concern in hardware security and supply chain integrity. A counterfeit component is typically one that misrepresents its origin, manufacturer, or performance characteristics [ 1 ] . The rise in counterfeit electronics has attracted global attention due to its economic and operational consequences, with losses estimated in the trillions of dollars [ 2 , 3 ] . Although detection and prevention techniques such as watermarking, fingerprinting, split manufacturing [ 4 ] , logic locking [ 5 ] , and EM-based analysis [ 6 , 7 ] exist, they often rely on expensive hardware and proprietary software that are not accessible in consumer or educational settings. Moreover, most are designed to identify specific ICs that the system has been trained to recognize, making them impractical for general-purpose component screening in undergraduate labs. At Oklahoma State University, a counterfeit chip incident became an unexpected pedagogical turning point. During the Fall 2024 semester, nearly every student in a junior-level electronics course received a fake TL074 operational amplifier in their lab kit. As circuits repeatedly failed to perform as expected, students began doubting their understanding, and teaching assistants (TAs) questioned the validity of their instructional materials. The issue was ultimately traced back to counterfeit ICs—a problem that had been growing over several semesters. Rather than shielding students from the issue, we restructured the course to turn the incident into a hands-on learning opportunity. Through measurement, analysis, and comparison, students gained a deeper understanding of component variability, supply chain security, and the essential role of testing in engineering. This paper documents our investigation of counterfeit TL074 op-amps and characterizes their electrical behavior. We also detail the curriculum changes we implemented to turn a hardware failure into a meaningful learning experience. Through targeted lab adjustments and structured support, students were not only able to identify the problem but also learn from it—gaining practical insight into measurement, debugging, and the complexities of real-world circuit behavior. To guide this shift, we focused on two instructional goals: 1. Help students understand the root causes of unexpected circuit behavior. 2. Use the situation to teach key engineering skills: measurement accuracy, component validation, troubleshooting, and critical thinking. II Background II-A TL074CN Opamp The TL07x series of opamps [ 8 , 9 , 10 ] is very popular among hobbyists, researchers, and professionals. It is used, for example, in audio applications [ 11 , 12 ] , prototypes for biomedical research [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ] , didactic platforms for undergraduate teaching [ 18 ] , agricultural research [ 19 ] , and electronics research [ 20 , 21 , 22 ] . However, while its availability and usage have become ubiquitous, so have its counterfeits [ 23 , 11 , 24 , 25 ] . II-B Counterfeits of TL074 Counterfeits of TL074 have been reported by a Canadian company that builds audio synthesizers [ 11 ] . They claim to have bought the ICs from Jameco Electronics, and noticed differences in the appearance of the package compared to a TL074 bought from Mouser. Others have reported purchasing similar counterfeits of TL074 from AliExpress [ 11 , 24 , 25 ] , eBay [ 26 ] , and Tayda [ 24 ] . These fake parts have been reported with logos of, or similar to, Texas Instruments (TI) [ 11 , 24 ] , and ST Microelectronics [ 24 ] , using different typefaces [ 24 ] . Users have suggested checking for “tinning” of IC pins as a sign of being a recycled part [ 24 ] . Using acetone to wipe down the text on the package to check for fading has been proven inconclusive [ 11 , 26 ] . More effective electrical tests include resistance checks, building custom testing platforms, plugging into a system that uses the IC to observe change in operation [ 26 ] , conducting diode tests between each pair of pins, comparing amplifier outputs [ 11 ] , measuring slew rate (SR) [ 11 , 25 ] , and using opamp testers [ 23 ] . One user opined that measuring the quiescent current may be enough to identify the genuine TL074 from the counterfeit [ 24 ] . II-C Use of TL074 in Our Instructional Lab We have used the TL074CN quad opamp, which is a 14-pin PDIP package [ 8 , 9 ] , in our instructional labs at Oklahoma State University for 7+ years to teach undergraduate students in their junior year. Students solder a TL074 and various passive components to build two amplifiers in their non-inverting and inverting configurations, with gains of 10 and 20, respectively. Students solder the TL074 and passive components onto a custom printed circuit boards (PCB) to construct the circuits. The layout of this board is shown in Fig. 1 . With a typical unity-gain bandwidth or gain-bandwidth product (GBWP) of 3 to 4 MHz [ 8 , 9 , 10 ] , the amplifiers should therefore have 3 dB bandwidth ( f_{3dB} ) of 300+ and 150+ kHz, respectively. The experiment requires the frequency of a 1 \mathrm{V_{p-p}} input sinusoidal signal to be swept from 50 Hz to 6 MHz to observe the gains and phases of the two amplifier configurations. Since 2021, we have observed that some students had faulty ICs despite being bought from a reputable vendor. By Fall 2024, every lab section reported failures, which were eventually traced to counterfeit parts—primarily those labeled as TI-manufactured. This situation provided a unique challenge—and an opportunity to redesign the lab experience around real-world component variability, diagnostic methods, and supply chain uncertainty. Fig. 1 : Solder diagram of op-amp circuits on the custom PCB used in the lab. III Pedagogical Redesign and Curriculum Integration After identifying counterfeit TL074 op-amps as the cause of circuit failures, the instructional team redesigned the lab experience to transform the disruption into a structured