Impact of particle-size polydispersity on the quality of thin-film colloidal crystals
Mariam Arif, Andrew B. Schofield, Fraser H. J. Laidlaw, Wilson C. K. Poon, Job H. J. Thijssen · 2025
Read Impact of particle-size polydispersity on the quality of thin-film colloidal crystals by Mariam Arif, Andrew B. Schofield, Fraser H. J. Laidlaw, Wilson C. K. Poon, Job H. J. Thijssen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-13258.txt.
Introduction
Mariam Arif and co-authors test how spread in particle size harms the order of thin colloidal crystals in 2025. Colloids are tiny spheres that can self assemble into crystals. Uneven sizes can break that order and stop crystal growth. Most past work was by computer. This team runs lab tests with a controlled range of size spread.
Films were dried from drops with set spread levels. As spread rose, order fell as expected. Sharp drops in local order marks came at two spread levels. The pattern fits a model of layer by layer growth like that of crystal films on a base. The results set limits for making crystals from cheaper, less even batches.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mariam Arif, Andrew B. Schofield, Fraser H. J. Laidlaw, Wilson C. K. Poon, Job H. J. Thijssen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-13258
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Impact of particle-size polydispersity on the quality of thin-film colloidal crystals Preprint: APS/123-QED Mariam Arif, Andrew B. Schofield, Fraser H. J. Laidlaw, Wilson C. K. Poon, Job H. J. Thijssen Abstract Size polydispersity in colloidal particles can disrupt order in their self-assembly, ultimately leading to a complete suppression of crystallization. In contrast to various computational studies, few experimental studies systematically address the effects of size polydispersity on the quality of colloidal crystals. We present an experimental study of structural order in thin films of crystals vertically dried from colloidal dispersions with a systematically varying polydispersity. As expected, an increase in polydispersity leads to a deterioration in order with significant drops in the local bond-orientational order at 8% and 12% polydispersity. Our results align with previously suggested models of epitaxial-like growth of 2D layers during convective assembly. Our results can offer critical insights into the permissible limits for achieving colloidal crystals from more polydisperse systems such as those synthesized through more sustainable methods. I Introduction Colloidal crystals have attracted significant interest due to their ease of preparation and range of applications. Conventionally, they have been used as photonic nanocrystals Kim et al. 2011 , for which the photonic bandgaps of these materials are crucial Rengarajan et al. 2005 and so necessitating high crystallinity Ye et al. 2001 ; Li et al. 2019 . Other applications, which do not utilize the optical properties of these crystals, such as their use as templates for microbatteries Sorensen et al. 2006 ; Pikul et al. 2013 , may allow greater flexibility in crystal preparation and particle synthesis techniques as the requirements for crystal quality might be less demanding. To optimize colloidal crystal quality, model systems of particles with low polydispersity are often employed. One of the most popular colloid synthesis techniques is the Stöber synthesis, as it provides good control of particle size Bourebrab et al. 2018 ; Fernandes et al. 2019 and the resulting batches can have polydispersity as low as 4-5% Giesche 1994 . In this method, a silica precursor undergoes hydrolysis in a water-alcohol mixture catalysed by ammonia which is followed by condensation of silanol groups to form siloxane networks. With recent attempts to make the Stöber synthesis sustainable by using water as the primary solvent Wang et al. 2023 ; Furlan et al. 2019 , it is a challenge to control the reaction and uniformity of the resulting particles Wang et al. 2023 . The non-uniformity in particle size disrupts regularity in the arrangement of colloidal crystals Topçu et al. 2018 , which can be a significant impediment to maintaining their quality. This deterioration in crystal quality, however, is yet to be studied quantitatively over a range of particle size polydispersities to better identify and understand critical thresholds. Such a study can also give more insight into the assembly processes. Previous experimental work on the drop in crystal quality with increasing polydispersity has focused on relatively low polydispersities Rengarajan et al. 2005 and on the variation of optical behaviour of crystals Harun-Ur-Rashid et al. 2010 . The long-range structural order, up to an upper limit of 10% polydispersity, was investigated by Rengaranjan et al. in Rengarajan et al. 2005 . In another study, this variation was characterised in Fourier space for two silica batches, with narrow and wide particle size distributions Jiang et al. 1999 . The limited scope of systematic previous experimental work could stem from the challenging nature of synthesizing a finely spaced range of polydispersities without significantly altering the average particle diameter. Such a challenge need not be met in non-experimental studies, so that the impact of polydispersity on crystal quality for hard sphere colloids has been studied theoretically Pusey 1987 and through computer simulations Auer and Frenkel 2001 ; Phan et al. 1998 , with crystallization suppression reported at polydispersity levels between 6-12%. To the best of our knowledge, there has been no accurate determination of this limit using experiments, but only reports that crystallization is not observed at particular polydispersities. The variation of local order as polydispersity is increased towards this limit also does not appear to have been systematically investigated in experiments. Here we systematically investigate structural order variation in thin films of colloidal crystals fabricated by vertical drying using silica particles with polydispersities ranging from 6% to 15%; this range aligns with previous reports of significant shifts in ordering behaviour Pusey 1987 ; Auer and Frenkel 2001 ; van der Linden et al. 2013 . The colloidal dispersions are characterised using electron microscopy and light scattering, while the resulting (crystalline) assemblies are characterised in 2D and 3D using electron microscopy and UV-Vis spectroscopy. As expected, both long-range and local order decrease with increasing polydispersity. Notably, we observe two significant drops in local order around 8% and 12% polydispersity. In addition, we observe that the local order is higher in crystal layers further from the substrate. We also measure the polydispersity of particles in the (crystalline) assembly, and in the dispersion before and after crystal growth, and do not find significant size-fractionation. We discuss these results in the context of existing literature, arguing that they can be explained by known polydispersity limits for 2D and 3D crystallization Kawasaki et al. 2008 ; Pusey 1987 , operating in the context of a model for convective assembly of epitaxial-like growth of 2D crystalline layers to form 3D thin-film colloidal crystals Wang et al. 2025 . II Experimental Methods II.1 Synthesis of silica particles Silica nanoparticles were synthesized following the Stöber-Fink-Bohn method Stöber et al. 1968 . Ethanol (Sigma Aldrich, \geq 99.8%), distilled water, tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS, Sigma Aldrich, \geq 99%) and ammonia solution (Fisher Chemical, 35% in H 2 O) were mixed and left for 48 hours to react at room temperature and pressure. A systematic variation of reactant volumes, as discussed in references Fernandes et al. 2019 and Ghimire and Jaroniec 2021 , enabled the production of low (6.3-7.5%) and high (11.9%, 14.6%) polydispersity silica batches within a consistent particle diameter range of 200-400 nm. Two ‘intermediate’ polydispersity batches (8.5% and 10.8%) were made by mixing (almost) equal number concentrations of batches for which the average diameters lay within 2 standard deviations of each other. The 9.1% polydisperse silica were made following the low polydispersity silica synthesis recipe but by a batch-wise addtion of TEOS over a period of 5 hours. All dispersions were cleaned by performing 7 successive cycles of centrifugation (using Thermo Scientific Sorvall ST 40), supernatant removal and ethanol addition. The recipes for all batches can be found in the Supplementary Information. II.2 Characterization of particles The average hydrodynamic radii of our silica particles were measured by Anton Paar Litesizer DLS 500 using Kalliope software. The particle size distributions were determined by Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) using JEOL JSM-6010PLUS/LV. An SEM sample was prepared by drying a droplet of dispersion (10-12% volume in ethanol) on a silicon wafer substrate stuck to a metal stub with carbon tape. The top surface of the dried sample was sputter coated with a 20 nm layer of gold using a Denton Vacuum Desk III sputter coater. The surface was imaged using the SEM (Figure 1 (a), (b)) at different locations across the sample and particle sizes for