The carbon cost of materials discovery: Can machine learning really accelerate the discovery of new photovoltaics?

Matthew Walker, Keith T. Butler · 2025

Read The carbon cost of materials discovery: Can machine learning really accelerate the discovery of new photovoltaics? by Matthew Walker, Keith T. Butler (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-13246.txt.

Introduction

Matthew Walker and Keith T. Butler wrote a research paper in 2025 about the hidden climate cost of searching for new solar cell materials. Computer screening is now a common way to hunt for such materials. Most searches use a heavy physics method to estimate how well a material might turn sunlight into power. Machine learning models can stand in for that method and use far less energy.

The authors rerun a standard search and swap in learning models step by step. They track the carbon cost of each mix of the two methods. Some mixed plans match the old accuracy while cutting emissions a lot. They also find that guessing a single score, such as top efficiency, works better than guessing a full spectrum first. The study gives labs a clear way to weigh speed, accuracy, and climate cost.

Catalog record

CREATORMatthew Walker, Keith T. Butler
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-13246

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The carbon cost of materials discovery: Can machine learning really accelerate the discovery of new photovoltaics? Preprint: APS/123-QED Matthew Walker, Keith T. Butler Abstract Computational screening has become a powerful complement to experimental efforts in the discovery of high-performance photovoltaic (PV) materials. Most workflows rely on density functional theory (DFT) to estimate electronic and optical properties relevant to solar energy conversion. Although more efficient than laboratory-based methods, DFT calculations still entail substantial computational and environmental costs. Machine learning (ML) models have recently gained attention as surrogates for DFT, offering drastic reductions in resource use with competitive predictive performance. In this study, we reproduce a canonical DFT-based workflow to estimate the maximum efficiency limit and progressively replace its components with ML surrogates. By quantifying the CO 2 \text{CO}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{2}}} emissions associated with each computational strategy, we evaluate the trade-offs between predictive efficacy and environmental cost. Our results reveal multiple hybrid ML/DFT strategies that optimize different points along the accuracy–emissions front. We find that direct prediction of scalar quantities, such as maximum efficiency, is significantly more tractable than using predicted absorption spectra as an intermediate step. Interestingly, ML models trained on DFT data can outperform DFT workflows using alternative exchange–correlation functionals in screening applications, highlighting the consistency and utility of data-driven approaches. We also assess strategies to improve ML-driven screening through expanded datasets and improved model architectures tailored to PV-relevant features. This work provides a quantitative framework for building low-emission, high-throughput discovery pipelines. I INTRODUCTION The development of new material functionalities has historically been a time-consuming process, with new materials or materials’ applications often discovered serendipitously or taking many decades of careful synthesis and characterization before realizing a real-world application Cheetham et al. 2022 . In recent years, with the increase in computing power and the sophistication of materials modelling software, computational chemistry has promised to accelerate this process by providing qualitative insight and design rules as well as quantitative predictions allowing virtual screening of new materials for given applications. However, atomistic modelling has known limitations for the discovery of new materials. In recent years, the emergence of data-driven approaches, notably machine learning (ML), and the availability of large, high-quality annotated datasets of material properties have been predicted to be a route to accelerate computational materials design. But there are many open questions for applying ML to PV discovery: Are these methods really reliable? Which methods are best suited to the task? How does the quality of the underlying data affect model performance? Finally, what should we actually model? In this paper, we set out to address some of these questions in the context of photovoltaic (PV) materials discovery. and provide some concrete guidelines on how effective ML is for PV discovery currently by estimating the carbon cost of both ML-based and density functional theory (DFT)-based materials discovery. We also provide suggestions on how to advance in the future. Global PV capacity reached approximately 1.6 TW in 2023 Masson et al. 2024 , and a future push toward 30–70 TW by 2050 could see PVs meeting most of the world’s energy requirements Haegel et al. 2019 . Achieving this target requires the development of new materials as well as the optimization of existing ones Blakesley et al. 2024 . While crystalline and multi-crystalline Si modules remain the industrial standard Battaglia et al. 2016 , alternative materials such as amorphous Si Sayed et al. 2025 , CIGS Ramanujam and Singh 2017 , CdTe Scarpulla et al. 2023 , organic photovoltaics Solak and Irmak 2023 , and dye-sensitized solar cells O’Regan and Grätzel 1991 have been commercialized to varying degrees of success. A number of perovskites have also emerged as promising candidates in the last decade Green et al. 2014 . However, established technologies often rely on critical raw materials, toxic elements, or suffer from long-term stability issues, conversion efficiency limitations, or low technological flexibility; overcoming these challenges is essential for reaching TW-level production of PV energy Zakutayev et al. 2021 . New inorganic materials offer significant promise as future PV absorbers due to their potential for low-cost fabrication, defect tolerance, earth abundance, and facile synthesis via various techniques such as sol-gel processing or sputtering Needleman et al. 2016 ; Yang et al. 2010 ; Wu and Yang 2022 ; Welch et al. 2017 . These materials exhibit stability across a wide range of thermal, chemical, and mechanical conditions and are compatible with device architectures that may offer lower capital costs, enabling rapid scale-up Needleman et al. 2016 . Computational modelling has played an important role in the development of new inorganic photovoltaic materials such as CZTS Yadav et al. 2025 ; Ahmad et al. 2022 , SnS Vidal et al. 2012 , BiSI M. Ganose et al. 2016 , Sb 2 Se 3 Wang et al. 2024 , CdTe Yang et al. 2016 and many others. Typically, these studies have been DFT calculations allowing accurate estimation of optical absorption, carrier transport and defect properties Yuan et al. 2024 . Although these DFT calculations are more efficient than experimental synthesis and characterisaton, they nonetheless have a non-negligible energy cost. In recent years there has been a trend to replace some of the costly DFT calculations with ML surrogate models. However, the questions previously raised about the veracity of these models remain largely unanswered. To address these questions, we have developed a framework that enables the joint assessment of both predictive accuracy and carbon emissions associated with different computational approaches for estimating PV performance in novel inorganic crystalline materials. These approaches span from hybrid-functional DFT (the most computationally expensive) to direct ML estimation of maximum PV efficiency (the least expensive), and include intermediate strategies such as predicting optical absorption profiles or applying corrections to low-fidelity DFT calculations based on the generalized gradient approximation (GGA) Perdew et al. 1996 . The paper begins with a detailed outline of our evaluation methodology, covering both PV property estimation and carbon emission quantification. We then compare these approaches in terms of predictive efficacy and environmental cost. Our analysis allows us to propose optimal trade-offs, highlight important limitations, and suggest promising directions for future research aimed at improving the effectiveness and sustainability of computational PV screening. More broadly, our framework offers a template for evaluating computational discovery pipelines in which resource intensity is considered alongside predictive performance—a consideration we believe will be increasingly important across many areas of energy research. II Evaluation methodology We provide details of the different design choices in our evaluation protocol. Covering approaches to obtain the carbon emissions of calculations, the optical absorption spectra and the maximum PV efficiency. II.1 The Carbon Cost of Discovery Ultimately, we are interested in developing new photovoltaic materials as a renewable energy technology. Therefore, it is important to consider the energy cost of a discovery campaign. While computational discovery is less resource intensive than experimental programmes, it is not carbon neutral. One promise of ML is that it can reduce the computational cost and ultimately the resource required for discovery. To assess the trade-off between prediction accuracy and carbon cost of the calculations involved, we have used the CodeCarbon package Courty et al. 2024 , which integrates into computational workflows to estimate the \text{CO}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{2}}} emissions associated with running a given job

Read the complete text