A Computational Framework to Identify Self-Aspects in Text
Jaya Caporusso, Matthew Purver, Senja Pollak · 2025
Read A Computational Framework to Identify Self-Aspects in Text by Jaya Caporusso, Matthew Purver, Senja Pollak (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-13115.txt.
Introduction
Jaya Caporusso, Matthew Purver, and Senja Pollak set out a doctoral research plan for finding aspects of the Self in text, in a 2025 proposal. The Self is a rich idea across psychology and philosophy, and language reflects it. Language technology has barely studied it in a systematic way.
The plan builds an ontology of Self-aspects and a hand-labeled gold dataset. Three model families will be compared: classic classifiers, large generative models, and embedding-based retrieval. Judging covers clarity, faithfulness to labels, accuracy, and computing cost. The best models will then be applied in case studies on mental health and lived experience research.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jaya Caporusso, Matthew Purver, Senja Pollak |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-13115
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Computational Framework to Identify Self-Aspects in Text Jaya Caporusso, Matthew Purver, Senja Pollak Abstract This Ph.D. proposal introduces a plan to develop a computational framework to identify Self-aspects in text. The Self is a multifaceted construct and it is reflected in language. While it is described across disciplines like cognitive science and phenomenology, it remains underexplored in natural language processing (NLP). Many of the aspects of the Self align with psychological and other well-researched phenomena (e.g., those related to mental health), highlighting the need for systematic NLP-based analysis. In line with this, we plan to introduce an ontology of Self-aspects and a gold-standard annotated dataset. Using this foundation, we will develop and evaluate conventional discriminative models, generative large language models, and embedding-based retrieval approaches against four main criteria: interpretability, ground-truth adherence, accuracy, and computational efficiency. Top-performing models will be applied in case studies in mental health and empirical phenomenology. 1 Introduction The Self, superficially experienced as “the (perhaps sometimes elusive) feeling of being the particular person one is” Siderits et al. 2013 , is a complex phenomenon, amply discussed in philosophy and cognitive science ( Zahavi 2008 , e.g.,) .While there exist different views about the metaphysical nature of the Self Siderits et al. 2013 , in this work, we build on its phenomenological and behavioural manifestations. In everyday experience, the Self is characterised by multiple phenomenological and psychological aspects, including the experience of one’s own body Bermúdez 2018 and a sense of agency Gallagher 2000 , among others Caporusso 2022 . These Self-aspects are conceptually and empirically related to other well-established constructs—such as personality traits or experiential modes. For example, their relevance to contexts such as mental health research is supported in related work, which highlights the central role of Self-related processes in well-being and psychopathology, as well as in empirical phenomenology ( Aspers 2009 , i.e., the empirical investigation of experience;) , where they are key to understanding altered states of consciousness (see Section 2 ). Importantly, the specific ways in which Self-aspects are experienced by a person in a given moment are reflected in the language they use ( Pennebaker et al. 2003 , e.g., see Section 2 and) . The found correlations between textual features and Self-aspects can be further employed in downstream NLP tasks, for instance to detect psychological states Caporusso et al. 2023 ; Du and Sun 2022 ; Kolenik et al. 2024 . However, the connections between textual features and many Self-aspects important for the identification of, e.g., mental health conditions and phenomenological states, are underexplored. To address this shortcoming, we propose a computational framework capable of automatically detecting the presence and mode of Self-aspects in text. Existing tools such as LIWC ( Boyd et al. 2022 , Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count;) and VADER ( Hutto and Gilbert 2014 , Valence Aware Dictionary and sEntiment Reasoner;) have shown that psychologically meaningful patterns can be computationally extracted from text using lexicons and interpretable features. Building on this tradition, our framework aims to go further: to detect nuanced, theoretically grounded aspects of Self-experience—such as agency, embodiment, or narrative coherence—through a combination of ontology design, annotated data, and a range of modelling approaches. The resulting method can be applied to tasks in domains such as mental health research and empirical phenomenology. 2 Related Work 2.1 Textual Features and Self-Aspects Correlations This subsection surveys studies mapping text features to aspects of the Self. Self-Aspects Most research focuses on I-talk , i.e., the use of first-person pronouns as indicators of Self-focus Pennebaker et al. 2003 , which correlates with emotional pain, trauma, and depression Tausczik and Pennebaker 2010 . Furthermore, pronoun usage hints at specific understandings of the Self vs others distinction Na and Choi 2009 ; Sharpless 1985 . The usage of active vs passive voice can shed light on the sense of agency of the author of a text Simchon et al. 2023 , while the Narrative Self ( Caporusso et al. 2024 , NS; i.e., “the narrative someone has of themselves, comprising their autobiographical memories and stories of who they are”) is reflected in the structure and coherence of one’s autobiographical accounts Habermas and Köber 2015 ; Holm et al. 2016 ; Jaeger et al. 2014 ; Waters and Fivush 2015 . In this context, Author profiling (AP) refers to the task of inferring personal characteristics of an author based on their writing, which has applications in, e.g., sociolinguistics and mental health analytics Eke et al. 2019 ; Ouni et al. 2023b . The correlation of text features with other aspects of the Self, such as the Minimal Self ( Caporusso et al. 2024 , MS; “the fact that experiences are presented to us in a fundamentally personal and subjective way”) , are less explored Uno and Imaizumi 2025 . Caporusso et al. 2024 investigated the LIWC categories associated with different aspects of the Self: MS, NS, Self as Agent (AS; “the experience of being an agent, i.e., in control, active”), Bodily Self (BS; “the experience of owning, controlling, and/or identifying with someone’s own body (or parts of it)”), and Social Self (SS; “the self as it is shaped and/or perceived when in an interaction or relationship of sorts with other people or entities to whom we attribute qualities of an inner life”). Specifically, utilising a mixed approach to annotate the data, the authors classified text instances as presenting or not each of the mentioned Self-aspects, and they analysed the obtained splits with LIWC. Methods The methodological approaches utilised to detect correlations between textual features and Self-aspects can be broadly grouped into three main types: • Approaches based on stylistic features such as punctuation, syntactic patterns, part-of-speech (POS) tags, sentence length, character/word n-grams, and structural features (e.g., number of paragraphs or capitalised words)—see Ouni et al. 2021 ; Vijayan and Govilkar 2019 . • Content-based approaches, relying on subject matter and vocabulary; features include term frequency-inverse document frequency (TF-IDF), topic models, and domain-specific keywords—see Ch and Cheema 2018 ; Ouni et al. 2023b . • Hybrid approaches, where both stylistic and content-based features are analysed—see Fatima et al. 2017 ; Ouni et al. 2021 ; Ouni et al. 2023b . The use of LIWC or other lexicon-based techniques is the most common approach to investigate correlations between Self-aspects and textual features Boyd and Schwartz 2021 ; Pennebaker et al. 2003 . More recently, however, NLP research has increasingly adopted machine learning (ML) methods—such as topic modelling and supervised classification—to analyse language patterns in a data-driven way Eichstaedt et al. 2018 ; Ouni et al. 2021 . Many studies used classical supervised learning methods, like support vector machines ( Chinea-Rios et al. 2022 ; HaCohen-Kerner 2022 ; Vijayan and Govilkar 2019 , SVMs;) , random forests ( Fatima et al. 2017 ; Ouni et al. 2021 , RFs;) , decision trees Vijayan and Govilkar 2019 , and Naïve Bayes ( Mechti et al. 2020 , NB;) . Feature extraction in AP is critical: common strategies include Bag-of-Words (BoW) and TF-IDF Ouni et al. 2023b , character and word n-grams HaCohen-Kerner 2022 , POS and syntactic feature vectors Mechti et al. 2020 ; Vijayan and Govilkar 2019 , word embeddings Chinea-Rios et al. 2022 ;