Reassessing the gallium anomaly using exact electron wave functions

M. Cadeddu, N. Cargioli, G. Carotenuto, F. Dordei, L. Ferro, C. Giunti · 2025

Read Reassessing the gallium anomaly using exact electron wave functions by M. Cadeddu, N. Cargioli, G. Carotenuto, F. Dordei, L. Ferro, C. Giunti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-13103.txt.

Introduction

M Cadeddu, N Cargioli, and their co-authors revisit the gallium anomaly, a long standing mismatch in neutrino physics. Their 2025 paper concerns experiments that counted neutrinos from radioactive sources using gallium. For over thirty years, the counts in the GALLEX, SAGE, and BEST experiments have fallen short of forecasts by a wide margin.

The usual shortcut treats the electron waves in the capture process with a rough first order formula. The team instead solved the full Dirac Coulomb equation for the electron states, both bound and free, with a self consistent method. With that sharper cross section, they recalculated how strong the anomaly is worldwide. They also give the current standing of the idea that a hidden, sterile kind of neutrino explains the gap.

Catalog record

CREATORM. Cadeddu, N. Cargioli, G. Carotenuto, F. Dordei, L. Ferro, C. Giunti
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-13103

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Reassessing the gallium anomaly using exact electron wave functions M. Cadeddu, N. Cargioli, G. Carotenuto, F. Dordei, L. Ferro, C. Giunti Abstract The gallium anomaly, a persistent discrepancy exceeding 4 ​ σ 4\sigma in the 71 Ga neutrino capture rates from 51 Cr and 37 Ar calibration sources by the GALLEX, SAGE, and recently BEST experiments, has challenged particle physics and nuclear theory for over three decades. We present a new calculation for the neutrino capture cross-section, abandoning the conventional leading-order approximation for electronic wave functions by numerically solving the Dirac-Coulomb equation for both bound and continuum electron states. Finally, we re-evaluate the gallium anomaly, updating its global significance and presenting the most up-to-date status of its interpretation in terms of sterile neutrinos. I Introduction The study of neutrino interactions with matter has provided profound insights into both the properties of neutrinos and the dynamics of weak interactions. In this field, a particularly intriguing and long-standing puzzle is the so-called gallium anomaly Elliott et al. 2024 ; Giunti and Laveder 2011 , observed in experiments involving gallium-71 ( {}^{71}{\textrm{Ga}} ) as a neutrino target. This anomaly, identified at the GALLEX Anselmann et al. 1992 ; Hampel et al. 1999 ; Kaether et al. 2010 ; Altmann et al. 2005 and SAGE Abdurashitov et al. 2009 ; Gavrin experiments, which reported a measured neutrino-induced inverse beta decay (IBD) rate from 51 Cr and 37 Ar calibration sources systematically lower than predictions, has raised questions about the robustness of the theoretical cross-section calculations. Moreover, when considered alongside other anomalies Mention et al. 2011 ; Abratenko et al. 2023 ; Giunti et al. 2022a ; Berryman and Huber 2020 , it has strengthened the case for potential implications beyond the Standard Model (SM) Giunti and Laveder 2007 ; Giunti and Lasserre 2019 ; Gariazzo et al. 2016 ; Gonzalez-Garcia et al. 2016 ; Diaz et al. 2020 ; Böser et al. 2020 ; Dasgupta and Kopp 2021 ; Giunti and Ternes 2024 ; Abazajian et al. 2012 ; Acero et al. 2024 ; Farzan and Schwetz 2023 . The anomaly arises in the charge current \nu_{e}+^{71}{\textrm{Ga}}\to\,^{71}{\textrm{Ge}}+e^{-} reaction, a process historically used to detect neutrinos from solar and artificial sources. While the theoretical predictions for the cross section have provided critical benchmarks for interpreting experimental results, the persistent deficit in the observed rates, now exceeding 4\sigma thanks to the recent short-baseline BEST experiment Barinov et al. 2022a ; Barinov et al. 2022b , demands a closer examination of the underlying assumptions and parameters in the theoretical models. An early theoretical work by Bahcall Bahcall 1997 established the foundation for these predictions. However, the persistence of this anomaly has later prompted other theoretical investigations Elliott et al. 2023 ; Haxton and Rule 2025 ; Kostensalo et al. 2019 ; Brdar et al. 2023 ; Giunti et al. 2023 ; Huber 2023 , that employed more recent experimental inputs, the inclusion of radiative terms, additional corrections and an updated evaluation of excited-state contributions, among others. Our analysis builds on and updates these previous works. In this paper, we undertake a comprehensive revision of the theoretical cross section for neutrino interactions with {}^{71}{\textrm{Ga}} . The widely employed theoretical approach relies on the detailed balance (db) principle Williams 1971 ; Blatt and Weisskopf 1952 ; Bahcall 1989 ; Alvarez 1949 between neutrino-induced IBD and electron capture (EC) rates, factorizing nuclear and leptonic matrix elements, and utilizing leading-order (LO) approximations for the lepton wave functions Bambynek et al. 1977 ; Behrens and Jänecke 1969 . Here, we abandon the conventional LO approximation for electronic wave functions by numerically solving the Dirac-Coulomb equation for both bound and continuum electron states, using the same underlying assumptions and software. The latter is used to obtain an accurate determination of the Fermi function Fermi 1933 , a correction for the Coulomb distortion of the outgoing electron in the field of the associated nucleus. While doing so, we incorporate recent developments in the evaluation of the electron-capture lifetime of {}^{71}{\textrm{Ge}} Hampel and Remsberg 1985 ; Collar and Yoon 2023 ; Norman et al. 2024 ; Derbin et al. 2025 and the first determination of the nuclear charge radius of {}^{71}{\textrm{Ge}} Wang et al. 2024 , the use of a more accurate Q -value Singh and Chen 2023 as well as updated electron-capture probability ratios Collar and Yoon 2023 ; Arnaud et al. 2020 ; Bambynek et al. 1977 . These updates aim to provide a more accurate and self-consistent theoretical framework for interpreting gallium-based neutrino experiments. Moreover, we update the status of the allowed parameter space for the interpretation of such an anomaly in terms of sterile neutrinos Elliott et al. 2024 ; Giunti and Lasserre 2019 ; Giunti and Laveder 2007 ; Böser et al. 2020 whose presence would result in a reduction of the observed IBD event rate. II Determination of the neutrino capture cross section The ground-state neutrino-induced IBD cross section of the process \nu_{e}+^{71}\textrm{Ga}\to\,^{71}{\textrm{Ge}}+e^{-} can be written as 1 1 1 Natural units with \hbar=c=1 are used throughout. Bahcall 1978 ; Bahcall 1997 ; Bahcall 1989 ; Bahcall 1964 \sigma_{\text{gs}}=\frac{G_{F}^{2}\,|V_{ud}|^{2}\,g^{2}_{A}\,\Omega_{e}\Omega_{\nu}}{\pi(2J_{\text{Ga}}+1)}\sum_{j}{{p^{j}_{e}E^{j}_{e}}\,\left|\mathcal{H}_{j}^{\rm IBD}\right|^{2}\,\mathcal{B}(E^{j}_{e})}, (1) where G_{F} is the Fermi constant, V_{ud} is the CKM matrix element Navas et al. 2024 , g_{A}=1.2764 is the axial-vector coupling constant Märkisch et al. 2019 , \Omega_{e} and \Omega_{\nu} are normalization volumes and J_{\text{Ga}}=3/2 is the nuclear spin of gallium. The momentum of the electron is indicated by p_{e} , while E_{e} is the energy of the emitted electron, which is related to the Q -value of the process, Q_{\text{EC}} , and to the energy of the absorbed neutrinos by E_{e}=E_{\nu}-Q_{\text{EC}}+m_{e}-0.09\,\text{keV} . 2 2 2 Following Ref. Bahcall 1997 , we consider a small correction of 0.09 keV representing the energy lost during the electronic rearrangement. Finally, the sum runs over the different possible electron energies, E_{e}^{j} , weighted by the corresponding branching ratio, \mathcal{B}(E^{j}_{e}) , of the neutrino source employed in gallium experiments. The term \mathcal{H}_{j}^{\rm IBD} represents the matrix element of the transition and incorporates the involved lepton, \psi , and nuclear, \Psi , wave functions, and the Gamow-Teller Hamiltonian, \hat{H}_{\text{GT}} . In the literature, it is common practice to assume that the neutrino can be considered to be a plane wave normalized in such a way to cancel \Omega_{\nu} in Eq. ( 1 ), and that the electron wave functions vary slowly within the nuclear volume. Therefore, the latter can be factored out by considering its value at a specific distance r_{0} , usually chosen to be r_{0}=0 or r_{0}=R_{\rm box} , where R_{\rm box} represents the equivalent box density radius, namely R_{\rm box}=\sqrt{5/3}\,R_{\rm ch} , with R_{\rm ch} the nuclear charge radius. In this way, one can isolate the IBD nuclear matrix element, \mathcal{M}^{\rm IBD}_{\rm nuc} , 3 3 3 In the literature, the nuclear matrix element is often referred to in terms of the Gamow-Teller strength B_{\rm GT}=|\mathcal{M}_{\rm nuc}|^{2}/(2J+1) . \mathcal{H}^{\rm IBD}_{j}\simeq\psi^{j\,*}_{e}(r_{0})\,\mathcal{M^{\rm IBD}_{\rm nuc}}\,, (2) where \mathcal{M^{\rm IBD}_{\rm nuc}}=\int\Psi^{*}_{{}^{71}\text{Ge}}(\mathbf{r})\,\hat{H}_{\text{GT}}\,\Psi_{{}^{71}\text{Ga}}(\mathbf{r})\,\text{d}\mathbf{r}\,. (3) This permits to use the detailed balance principle, according to which the nuclear matrix element in Eq. ( 3 ) can be extracted from the inverse process, e^{-}_{\text{bound}}+{}^{71}\text{Ge}\rightarrow{}^{71}\text{Ga}+\nu_{e} , thus from the measurement of the electron-capture lifetime of {}^{71}{\textrm{Ge}} , referred

Read the complete text