Undulating patterns of Hysteresis loops in diurnal seasonality of air temperature in Urban Heat Island effect: Insights from Paris and Madrid

Suman Dharmasthala, Vittal Hari, Rohini Kumar · 2025

Read Undulating patterns of Hysteresis loops in diurnal seasonality of air temperature in Urban Heat Island effect: Insights from Paris and Madrid by Suman Dharmasthala, Vittal Hari, Rohini Kumar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-13075.txt.

Introduction

Suman Dharmasthala, Vittal Hari, and Rohini Kumar compare how Paris and Madrid heat up and cool down each day, in a 2025 study. Cities run hotter than their countryside, the urban heat island effect. Plotting city warmth against the hour draws loops whose shape betrays how heat is stored and shed.

The team used fine modeled temperature data at three-hour steps from 2008 to 2017. Paris sits in a mild oceanic climate, Madrid in a dry semi-arid one, and their heat island strength and seasons differ a lot. Yet the loops in both cities run the same direction with like slopes. Sun input and heat storage seem to steer the daily cycle everywhere. Planners may group cities by loop shape when sharing cooling plans.

Catalog record

CREATORSuman Dharmasthala, Vittal Hari, Rohini Kumar
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-13075

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Undulating patterns of Hysteresis loops in diurnal seasonality of air temperature in Urban Heat Island effect: Insights from Paris and Madrid Suman Dharmasthala, Vittal Hari, Rohini Kumar Abstract This study examines the dynamics of the urban heat island (UHI) effect by conducting a comparative analysis of air temperature hysteresis patterns in Paris and Madrid, two major European cities with distinct climatic and urban characteristics. Utilizing high-resolution modelled air temperature data aggregated at a fine temporal resolution of three-hour intervals from 2008 to 2017, we investigate how diurnal and seasonal hysteresis loops reveal both unique and universal aspects of UHI variability. Paris, located in a temperate oceanic climate, and Madrid, situated in a cold semi-arid zone, display pronounced differences in UHI intensity, seasonal distribution, and diurnal patterns. Despite these contrasts, both cities exhibit remarkably similar hysteresis loop directions and slopes, suggesting that time-dependent mechanisms such as solar radiation and heat storage fundamentally govern air temperature UHI across diverse urban contexts. Our findings underscore the importance of considering both local climate and universal physical processes in developing targeted, climate-resilient urban strategies. The results pave the way for group-based interventions and classification of cities by hysteresis patterns to inform urban planning and heat mitigation efforts. 1 Introduction The urban heat island effect (UHI) refers to the phenomenon in which urban areas experience higher temperatures than their surrounding rural or background (non-urban) regions, resulting in island-like isotherms in air and surface temperature patterns [ 1 ] . This effect is a well-documented consequence of urbanisation, driven by increased built surfaces, reduced vegetation, and anthropogenic heat emissions [ 2 , 3 ] . The effect of UHI is not just a climatic anomaly [ 4 ] ; It poses significant risks to human health, including increased morbidity and mortality related to heat [ 5 , 6 ] , and exacerbates energy consumption and environmental degradation [ 7 , 6 , 8 ] . Given its detrimental impacts [ 9 ] , extensive research has been devoted to understanding the effect of UHI to develop effective mitigation and adaptation strategies at urban scales [ 10 , 11 ] . Despite the wealth of studies on UHI, a universal mitigation strategy remains obscure [ 12 ] , generally due to its dependence on a multitude of factors, including local climatic zones, latitude, elevation, city size, land cover, and urban morphology [ 13 , 14 , 10 ] . For instance, the magnitude and pattern of UHI can vary significantly between cities in temperate and tropical climates [ 12 ] , underscoring the need for comparative studies. Furthermore, while numerous studies have proposed mitigation measures at the local or individual city level, there is a lack of consensus on scalable and transferable solutions [ 12 ] . This gap highlights the importance of understanding the underlying factors driving UHI variability across different urban contexts. Most studies investigating the UHI effect focus on temperature differences between urban and non-urban (rural or background) areas, although the definitions of ’urban’ and ’non-urban’ vary widely across the literature [ 15 ] . These studies typically employ either surface temperature measurements, derived from remote sensing, or air temperature measurements, obtained from weather stations [ 1 , 16 ] . Each approach has its limitations: surface temperature studies often analyse distinct time periods (day and night) but lack temporal resolution, while air temperature studies, though temporally rich, are spatially sparse and often rely on short-term observational data [ 9 , 17 ] . In cases where finer temporal resolutions are considered, hysteresis analysis - a critical tool for understanding the lagged response of UHI to ambient temperature changes - is rarely performed [ 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] . This limitation stems from the trade-off between spatial and temporal resolution in UHI data: remotely sensed surface temperature data offers high spatial resolution but limited temporal coverage, whereas air temperature data from weather stations provides continuous temporal coverage, but with poor spatial coverage [ 23 ] . Studying the UHI effect at finer spatial and temporal resolutions, though computationally demanding, can reveal one of its most intriguing signatures: seasonal hysteresis loops. These loops, generated by plotting the case of surface UHI against rural or background temperature, exhibit rate-dependent seasonality that is closely tied to local climatic conditions [ 24 , 25 ] . Interestingly, while surface UHI hysteresis is influenced by factors such as land cover and urban morphology, air temperature hysteresis appears to be primarily a function of time of the day [ 26 ] . Despite this distinction, research on hysteresis loops has predominantly focused on surface UHI, with limited attention given to air temperature hysteresis [ 26 , 27 , 28 ] . This gap in the literature is significant, as air temperature hysteresis, studied at a fine temporal resolution, provides critical insights into the diurnal and seasonal dynamics of UHI, which are essential for developing effective mitigation strategies, which this study seeks to address. Comparative studies of UHI dynamics across cities with differing climatic and urban contexts have provided valuable insights into factors driving UHI variability. For example, [ 24 ] examined the hysteresis pattern in cities across Koppen climate classification [ 29 ] , highlighting how variations in local climatic conditions influence UHI hysteresis patterns for surface temperature. Such studies underscore the importance of context-specific approaches to UHI mitigation, as strategies effective in one climatic zone may not translate well to another. In this study, we focus on a comparative study of air temperature hysteresis effect for Paris and Madrid, two cities with well-documented UHI characteristics but distinct climate and urban contexts. Paris, located in a Temperate, CfB Koppen climate classification, exhibits surface UHI patterns looping in an upward direction, while Madrid, situated in an Arid BsK classification [Fig. 1], experiences a similar clockwise, but downward sloping hysteresis loop, attributing this distinction of hysteresis patterns among the two cities to time lags between temperature and rainfall [ 25 ] . While the study looked at surface temperature UHI (SUHI), we aim to look at fine resolution air temperature UHI (termed as UHI throughout the paper) as a comparative study to enhance our understanding of the hysteresis pattern, which is limited in air temperature data. To address these limitations, this study leverages modelled fine temporal resolution hourly air temperature data (aggregated at three-hour intervals for clarity while preserving the patterns) for the two cities: Paris and Madrid. These cities were selected due to their UHI research history, enabling meaningful comparisons with existing studies. By focusing on two cities, we also mitigate the computational challenges associated with acquiring and processing high-resolution temporal data while providing a detailed analysis of diurnal and seasonal hysteresis patterns. Our findings contribute to a deeper understanding of UHI dynamics and offer insights into the factors driving hysteresis variability across different urban contexts for air temperature data. 2 Data and Methodology 2.1 Study Area Paris and Madrid, two of Europe’s most prominent metropolitan areas, were selected for this study because of their contrasting climatic and urban characteristics, which provide a robust framework for investigating Urban Heat Island (UHI) dynamics and hysteresis patterns. Paris, the capital of France, is located in the northern part

Read the complete text