Challenges in the nonlinear evolution of unequal mass binaries in sGB gravity
Llibert Aresté Saló, Daniela D. Doneva, Katy Clough, Pau Figueras, Stoytcho S. Yazadjiev · 2025
Read Challenges in the nonlinear evolution of unequal mass binaries in sGB gravity by Llibert Aresté Saló, Daniela D. Doneva, Katy Clough, Pau Figueras, Stoytcho S. Yazadjiev (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-13046.txt.
Introduction
Llibert Aresté Saló and colleagues report the first full merger simulations of unequal black hole pairs in an alternative gravity theory. Scalar-Gauss-Bonnet gravity adds a scalar field to Einstein's picture. Simulating its full nonlinear dynamics only recently became possible. Unequal pairs, with mass ratios of two or three to one, kept breaking before merger.
The team follows both ratios through merger and inspects what the waveforms claim. The key worry is dephasing, the drift from Einstein's prediction, which fakes can imitate. Weak couplings matched the expected post-Newtonian dephasing. Stronger couplings instead picked up false deviations from wobbles in the starting data. The authors pinpoint which setup choices corrupt the signal. Their lesson: better initial data methods are the bottleneck for trustworthy beyond-Einstein waveforms.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Llibert Aresté Saló, Daniela D. Doneva, Katy Clough, Pau Figueras, Stoytcho S. Yazadjiev |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-13046
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Challenges in the nonlinear evolution of unequal mass binaries in sGB gravity Llibert Aresté Saló, Daniela D. Doneva, Katy Clough, Pau Figueras, Stoytcho S. Yazadjiev Abstract It has only recently become possible to simulate the full nonlinear dynamics of binary black holes in scalar-Gauss-Bonnet theories of gravity. The simulations remain technically challenging and evolutions of unequal mass binaries in particular have been difficult to follow through the merger. Even when the merger is successful, accurately quantifying the physical dephasing, as opposed to contributions from transients in the initial data and gauge adjustments, remains difficult. We show the first full simulations of 2:1 and 3:1 binaries through merger, and we discuss how specific choices in the setup affect the dephasing observed and our ability to obtain reliable results. In cases with weaker couplings, we match the expected PN value for the dephasing, whereas for larger couplings, eccentricity introduced by the initial data transients can lead to artificial deviations. Our work highlights the need for improvements in the initial data methods used, to ensure reliable waveforms are obtained for data analysis in beyond-GR models. I Introduction Since the first direct detection of gravitational waves Abbott et al. 2016 , observations of merging black holes have been used to test aspects of fundamental physics, putting constraints on deviations from General Relativity (GR) and the presence of new fields beyond the Standard Model Abbott et al. 2019 ; Abbott et al. 2021a ; Abbott et al. 2021b . Proposed future detectors, such as LISA Amaro-Seoane et al. 2017 , the Einstein Telescope Punturo et al. 2010 , and Cosmic Explorer Maggiore et al. 2020 ; Reitze et al. 2019 , will have unprecedented accuracy, allowing us to detect tens of thousands of gravitational wave events to higher redshifts and with a higher signal to noise ratio, and so further probe fundamental physics Arun et al. 2022 ; Perkins et al. 2021 ; Barausse et al. 2020 ; Gnocchi et al. 2019 ; Barack et al. 2019 ; Baker et al. 2015 . Model-independent tests of gravity look for parameterised deviations in the signals from those of GR Maggio et al. 2023 ; Pompili et al. 2025 ; Krishnendu and Ohme 2021 ; Abbott et al. 2021b ; Carson and Yagi 2020 ; Cornish et al. 2011 , for example, by looking at changes in the coefficients of the Post-Newtonian expansion. These methods have the advantage of being fully general. However, it is not yet clear how well they would successfully capture the potential novel phenomena or correlated deviations that occur in specific theories beyond GR. Fully nonlinear modeling of the waveforms generated in such theories, using numerical relativity (NR) simulations, can help us to understand to what extent the parameterised models do a good job of capturing and identifying the new physics, and to what extent the effects may generate a systematic bias in the inferred binary parameters during data analysis. Even within GR, binary modeling is a complex problem. Post-Newtonian, post-Minkowskian, NR and self-force approaches are still working to cover the wide range of parameter space, including effects like precession, eccentricity and higher mass ratios (e.g. some recent advances Thompson et al. 2024 ; Ghosh et al. 2024 ; Wardell et al. 2023 ; Blanchet et al. 2023 ; Dhani et al. 2024 ; Wittek et al. 2025 ). In modified theories of gravity, we are still at the beginning of developing accurate simulations in NR. Part of the problem is the large possible theory space for modifications, and to date, there has been a focus on theories with one extra scalar degree of freedom, mainly due to the availability of well-posed formulations in such cases Kovács and Reall 2020a ; Kovács and Reall 2020b ; Aresté Saló et al. 2022 ; Aresté Saló et al. 2023 . The simplest scalar-tensor theories do not generically source the scalar degree of freedom and so would not be expected to lead to deviations Healy et al. 2012 . Higher order corrections change this picture and may lead to scalarised solutions Kanti et al. 1996 ; Torii et al. 1997 ; Sotiriou and Zhou 2014 ; Doneva and Yazadjiev 2018 ; Silva et al. 2018 ; Antoniou et al. 2018 ; Kleihaus et al. 2016 ; Kleihaus et al. 2011 ; Cunha et al. 2019 ; Collodel et al. 2020 ; Herdeiro et al. 2021 ; Berti et al. 2021 . Beyond initial studies in spherical symmetry Ripley and Pretorius 2020 , fully consistent simulations including the leading parity invariant 4th order derivative corrections in an EFT framework with second order equations of motion, of which scalar-Gauss-Bonnet (sGB) is a well known example, were performed only a few years ago, first in East and Ripley 2021a , and then in other works Doneva et al. 2024 ; Doneva et al. 2023 ; Thaalba et al. 2025a ; Thaalba et al. 2025b ; Thaalba et al. 2024 ; Franchini et al. 2022 ; East and Ripley 2021b ; Corman and East 2024 ; East and Pretorius 2022 ; Corman et al. 2023 ; Corman et al. 2024 ; Aresté Saló et al. 2022 ; Aresté Saló et al. 2023 ; R et al. 2023 ; Corman and East 2024 . This work built on earlier studies that worked in the decoupling limit in which the scalar evolves nonlinearly but does not backreact onto the metric Okounkova et al. 2017 ; Silva et al. 2021 ; Elley et al. 2022 ; Doneva et al. 2022 ; Evstafyeva et al. 2023 , which gives qualitative results but has been shown to suffer from the accumulation of secular errors Corman et al. 2024 . Results so far have shown a good order of magnitude agreement with the post-Newtonian expansion estimations Corman et al. 2023 ; Shiralilou et al. 2021 ; Shiralilou et al. 2022 ; Julié and Berti 2019 ; Yagi et al. 2012 ; Lyu et al. 2022 and although studies are at an early stage, some novel signatures have already been found Lara et al. 2025 . However, the effects are generally small in the regime of validity of the effective theory, and their exact quantification is still not at the required level of performance for data analysis, with one of the main challenges being the construction of self-consistent initial data. In Brady et al. 2023 , constraint satisfying solutions were found for binaries with an arbitrary scalar profile, but this does not lead to a state of quasistationary equilibrium. This was rectified in Nee et al. 2025 in which quasistationary solutions were found, but this work only solved for the scalar profile in the decoupling limit. A full solution should therefore be achievable by combining the two approaches, and in this work we find evidence that such solutions are needed to enable the construction of reliable and accurate waveforms. More ad hoc methods, like a slow turn-on of the coupling between the scalar field and the Gauss-Bonnet invariant, whilst performing better in some cases compared to an immediate coupling turn-on, do not consistently improve the quality of the results and in large couplings can lead to eccentricity change. Another area where more work is needed is on