Transverse invariant as Khovanov skein spectrum at its extreme Alexander grading

Nilangshu Bhattacharyya, Adithyan Pandikkadan · 2025

Read Transverse invariant as Khovanov skein spectrum at its extreme Alexander grading by Nilangshu Bhattacharyya, Adithyan Pandikkadan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-12882.txt.

Introduction

Nilangshu Bhattacharyya and Adithyan Pandikkadan build new tools in knot theory in twenty twenty-five. They work at the level of spaces, not just numbers, for Khovanov skein homology. Their setting is annular links, links drawn in a ring-shaped region. They construct a stable homotopy type for such links.

A key step is a cover functor linking two flow categories, which yields the Khovanov skein spectrum. That spectrum extends the older Khovanov spectrum of Lipshitz and Sarkar. The authors also build a map between the two spectra. At extreme gradings, that map recovers a known transverse invariant from Lipshitz, Ng, and Sarkar. Readers get a richer frame for transverse link invariants.

Catalog record

CREATORNilangshu Bhattacharyya, Adithyan Pandikkadan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE77 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-12882

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Transverse invariant as Khovanov skein spectrum at its extreme Alexander grading Nilangshu Bhattacharyya, Adithyan Pandikkadan Abstract . We develop a space-level formulation of Khovanov skein homology by constructing a stable homotopy type for annular links. We explicitly define a cover functor from the skein flow category to the cube flow category, thereby establishing the Khovanov skein spectrum, 𝒳 S ​ k ​ ( L ) \mathcal{X}_{Sk}(L) . This spectrum extends the framework of Lipshitz and Sarkar’s Khovanov spectrum 𝒳 K ​ h ​ ( L ) \mathcal{X}_{Kh}(L) [ LS14 ] and provides new avenues for understanding transverse link invariants in the annular setting. Furthermore, we establish a map from the Khovanov spectrum to the skein spectrum, which, at extreme gradings, recovers the cohomotopy transverse invariant [ LNS15 ] . 1. Introduction Knots and links in contact manifolds play a fundamental role in low-dimensional topology and contact geometry. Understanding their classification and invariants provides deep insights into the structure of contact 3-manifolds. There are two special classes of knots in the standard contact 3-sphere, (S^{3},\xi_{{std}}) —Legendrian and transverse knots. Legendrian knots are everywhere tangent to the contact planes while transverse knots are everywhere transverse to them. We will restrict our attention to transverse links. There are two “classical” invariants for transverse links—the topological link type and the self linking number . While various knot types including the unknot, torus knots, and figure eight are completely classified by these invariants, such a classification is still unknown for most of the knot types. This calls for further introducing more refined invariants. The first candidate for such a non-classical invariant in the context of Khovanov homology called the transverse link invariant was given by Olga Plamevskaya [ Pla06a ] . Given the link diagram, D_{L} of a transverse link, L\subset(S^{3},\xi_{std}) , the invariant is defined as a distinguished element, \psi_{Kh}(L) in the Khovanov Homology [ Kho00 , BN02 ] of the link. While the effectiveness of this invariant remains an open question, other transverse invariants of different flavors have since been developed. Notably, Ozsváth, Szabó, and Thurston [ OST08 ] , along with Lisca, Ozsváth, Stipsicz, and Szabó [ LOSS09 ] , have constructed analogous invariants within the framework of knot Floer homology. Additionally, several refinements of the Plamenevskaya invariant have been developed, which could be more effective than the original invariant. Lipshitz and Sarkar [ LS14 ] recently introduced a space-level version of Khovanov homology, called the Khovanov Spectrum. Later Lipschitz, Ng and Sarkar [ LNS15 ] showed that the transverse link invariant admits a refinement as a stable cohomotopy element of the Khovanov Spectrum which yields several other computable auxiliary invariants. In our work, we consider links which can be represented as a braid closure of a transverse link. These can be naturally considered as embedded inside a thickened annulus, L\subset A\times I\subset S^{3} . M. M. Asaeda, J. H. Przytycki, and A. S. Sikora [ APS04 ] introduced a tri-graded cohomology for annular links, called the Khovanov skein homology. Later, L. Roberts [ Rob13 ] , gave an alternate formulation that directly relates this to Khovanov homology. There is a version of transverse invariant within this framework as well, denoted \psi_{Sk}(L) , which is a distinguished element in the Khovanov skein homology. Roberts also proved the existence of a link surgery spectral sequence from the Skein homology, H^{h,q,f}_{Sk}(L) to knot Floer homology of the double-branched cover. A difference in skein homology is the additional grading, which arises from viewing the knot within the annulus. This grading corresponds to twice the Alexander grading induced by the braid axis in the knot Floer complex - hence the term “extreme Alexander grading” in the title. Furthermore, Lawrence Roberts [ Rob13 ] showed that under the spectral sequence, \psi_{Sk}(L) is sent to a nonzero generator in the knot Floer complex. We aim to further explore this direction in future work. In this paper, we develop a space-level formulation of Khovanov skein homology by explicitly defining a cover functor \mathscr{F} from the skein flow category to the cube flow category, \mathscr{C}_{Sk}(D_{L})\to\mathscr{C}_{C}(n(D_{L})) . A more detailed description of this construction can be found in Section 3 . Utilizing this cover functor, we establish a stable homotopy type for annular links. It is worth noting that the annular Khovanov spectrum can also be constructed via an appropriate functor from the cube category \underline{2}^{n} to the Burnside category \mathscr{B} ; for further details on the Burnside category approach to the annular Khovanov spectrum, see [ AKW21 , AKW22 ] . While our construction utilizing the Cohen-Jones-Segal realization of a framed flow category is initially distinct from the Burnside category approach, the work of Lawson, Lipshitz, and Sarkar [ LLS20 ] establishes that both spectra are, in fact, stably homotopy equivalent. Kauffman, Nikonov, and Ogasa [ KNO21 ] have also defined a stable homotopy for the homotopical Khovanov homology for links in the thickened closed surfaces with genus g>1 . The Khovanov skein spectrum we constructed in this paper is also very similar in spirit. Lipshitz and Sarkar [ LS14 ] constructed a spectrum for links, L\subset S^{3} called the Khovanov Spectrum, \mathcal{X}_{Kh}(L) such that the reduced singular cohomology, \widetilde{H}^{h}(\mathcal{X}_{Kh}^{q}(L)) is isomorphic to the Khovanov Homology, H^{h,q}_{Kh}(L) . Given a link diagram L\subset S^{2} with n crossings, one can associate a combinatorial cube flow category, denoted \mathscr{C}_{C}(n) . The objects of \mathscr{C}_{C}(n) correspond to the 2^{n} possible states obtained by resolving each crossing in one of two ways, labeled as 0 - and 1 -resolutions, see Figure 1 . \displaystyle 0 \displaystyle 1 Figure 1. 0 - and 1 - resolutions Each state x\in\{0,1\}^{n} has a grading given by \text{gr}(x)=\sum\limits_{i=1}^{n}x_{i} . The morphisms are determined by the obvious partial order 1\succ 0 . For two distinct objects x,y in \mathscr{C}_{C}(n) , if x\succ y , we define the set \text{Hom}_{\mathscr{C}_{C}(n)}(x,y) to be a \big(\text{gr}(x)-\text{gr}(y)-1\big) -dimensional permutohedron which is a \langle\text{gr}(x)-\text{gr}(y)-1\rangle -manifold; otherwise, we declare it to be empty; see [ LS14 , Definition 4.1] . We also define \text{Hom}_{\mathscr{C}_{C}(n)}(x,x) to be a singleton consisting of the identity map. The cube flow category \mathscr{C}_{C}(n) naturally arises as a Morse flow category corresponding to the Morse function f_{n}:\mathbb{R}^{n}\to\mathbb{R} , given by f_{n}(x_{1},\dots,x_{n})=(3x_{1}^{2}-2x_{1}^{3})+\cdots+(3x_{n}^{2}-2x_{n}^{3}). Moreover, there exists a neat embedding \imath and coherent framing \psi , which makes \mathscr{C}_{C}(n) a framed flow category; see [ LS14 , Proposition 4.12] . Lipshitz and Sarkar defined Khovanov flow category \mathscr{C}_{Kh}(L) and built a cover functor \mathscr{F}:\mathscr{C}_{Kh}(L)\to\mathscr{C}_{C}(n) for a choice called Ladybug matching; see [ LS14 , Section 5] and also Section 3 . The Khovanov flow category \mathscr{C}_{Kh}(L) is a framed flow category where the framing is induced by the cover functor \mathscr{F} from the framing of the cube flow category \mathscr{C}_{C}(n) . Taking the formal desuspension of Cohen-Jones-Segal realization |\mathscr{C}_{Kh}|_{\widetilde{\imath},\widetilde{d},\widetilde{\psi}} gives a suspension spectrum called the Khovanov spectrum \mathcal{X}_{Kh}(L) . Moreover, the stable homotopy type of \mathcal{X}_{Kh}(L) depends only on the isotopy class of the corresponding link. Figure 2 presents a flowchart summarizing the construction of the stable homotopy type based on Cohen-Jones-Segal realization of a framed flow category. In the Khovanov skein chain complex, the key difference is that resolutions of L include an additional marking that records the braid axis. So we are

Read the complete text